This restaurant does not have any images
American
Tipsy Mermaid
135 S. MAIN ST
Zionsville, IN 46077
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Dinner Menu
Tonight's Special
Oysters
Party Starters

4 Wives of Hemingway Ceviche
Ceviche with shrimp, conch, scallop, mahi. Mango sweet & habanero spicy. Gluten Free blue corn tortilla chips.$23.00
Bahamian Baked Goat Cheese Dip
tropical rum chutney, spiced pecans, plantains$19.00
Beach Style chip 'n dips
house made plantain chips, blue corn tortilla chips, guacamole & pico de gallo$12.00
Bikini Lettuce Wraps
Gulf shrimp & grilled pineapple salsa, island slaw, toasted coconut, pickled onions.$23.00
Buffalo Shrimp
1/2 pound beer battered Gulf shrimp bites with Spicy Bird Pepper Buffalo sauce, Gorgonzola crème$18.00
Caprese Flatbread
burrata cheese, nut free pesto, roasted tomatoes, Parmesan, Romano, Asiago cheeses, balsamic reduction$19.00
Coconut Crack Conch
A Caribbean delicacy, habanero guava dipping sauce with island slaw$21.00
Coconut Shrimp
Island slaw, habanero guava marmalade dipping sauce$21.00
Conch & Shrimp Fritters
Habanero guava marmalade & key lime mustard$21.00
Cuban Cigars
3 flour tortillas filled with Mojo pork, honey ham, Swiss cheese, crispy pickles, flash-fried with Key Lime mustard$18.00
Duval Disco Fries
Mojo Cuban pork, burrata cheese, queso fresco, pickled onions, house horseradish dipping sauce.$19.00
Goat Cheese & Asparagus Quesadilla
fire roasted tomatoes, caramelized onions, white cheddar, queso fresco, fig balsamic reduction, pico de gallo$19.00
Havana Pork Empanadas
stuffed with Mojo pork, peppers, onions & Gruyère, rum chutney & chimichurri for dipping$18.00
Marky Mark
Cuban bread crostini with Mojo steak, horseradish crème, scallions, and balsamic reduction$19.00
Miss Key West Drunken Shrimp
Beer steamed Key West Peel 'n Eat shrimp, tequila lime cocktail sauce, Cuban bread for dipping. Caught from the only shrimp boat in Key West's Marina, the 'Miss Key West'$23.00
Off the Hook Pickles
Beer battered, Key Lime mustard & secret Frita sauce$11.00
Rooster Wings
6 grilled wings with your choice of bird pepper buffalo sauce, Lemon Garlic or tamarind jerk BBQ, with shishito peppers$15.00
Southernmost Smoked Fish Dip
Cool & creamy smoked white fish & Gulf shrimp dip topped with pickled onions, red peppers, fried jalapeños, and Gluten Free blue corn tortilla chips$14.00
Steak Carpaccio
Thinly sliced RARE steak, Parmesan, Romano & Asiago, fried capers, arugula, horseradish crème, and Truffle oil$18.00
The Dock's Lobster & Shrimp Dip
hot & creamy, a bit of heat, GF blue corn tortilla chips $26.00
Salad & Soup

Burrata Panzanella
Cuban bread croutons, mixed greens, grape tomatoes, crushed pistachios, white balsamic dressing, creamy burrata cheese & balsamic reduction$16.00
Casa's Backyard
Watch Us Farm romaine, gorgonzola, spiced pecans, Granny Smith apples, blueberries, white balsamic vinaigrette$16.00
Conch Chowder
Key West style with conch, tomatoes, potatoes, and pork$11.00
Gnocchi French Onion Soup
caramelized onions, Cuban bread croutons, Swiss & Gruyère cheese.$12.00
Hemingway House
Chopped Romaine, fried avocado, red pepper, applewood smoked bacon, queso fresco, Cuban bread croutons, toasted coconut, and pineapple mojito dressing$16.00
Louie's Caesar
Chopped Romaine, creamy Caesars dressing, Parmesan, Romano & Asiago, Cuban bread croutons$14.00
New Town Wedge
Iceberg wedge, grape tomatoes, applewood smoked bacon, Gorgonzola, pickled onions, balsamic reduction, Gorgonzola dressing$14.00
Party Time

305 Seafood Pasta
Squid Ink pasta, Gulf shrimp, Bay scallops, fire-roasted tomatoes, burrata cheese, Parmesan, Romano & Asiago, white wine garlic pesto sauce$35.00
A Moveable Feast Bowl
Cuban black beans & rice, Mojo pork, pickled onions, guacamole, mango & jicama escabeche, fried jalapeños, grilled pineapple salsa, tamarind Jerk BBQ, queso fresco$26.00
Bahama Mama Chicken
chicken kabobs with grilled pineapple & red peppers, tamarind jerk BBQ, sweet roasted maduros, Cuban black beans & rice, guacamole, pickled onions$26.00
Blackened Mahi Mahi
Blackened mahi mahi served over carrot & fire roasted tomato purée, grilled asparagus, nut free pesto & Heirloom tomatoes$33.00
Calvin Coolidge Steak & Frites
Grilled & sliced 9 oz Certified Angus Beef Mojo center-cut Sirloin steak, chimichurri, crispy fries, Gruyère fondue, mini Caesar salad$35.00
Caprese Gnocchi
fire roasted tomatoes, creamy nut-free pesto cream sauce, burrata, Parmesan, Romano, Asiago cheeses, balsamic reduction$27.00
Coconut Crusted Mahi Mahi
Coconut Crusted mahi mahi topped with mango escabeche & served with Cuban black beans & rice$33.00
Coconut Curry Seafood
Mahi mahi, Gulf shrimp, wild mix mushrooms, coconut rice, and red peppers topped with cilantro served with crostinis$31.00
Cuban Nachos
house cut plantain chips, blue corn tortilla chips, Cuban Ropa Vieja, queso fresco, pickled onions, guacamole, garlic aioli$28.00
Fish 'N Chips
Beer battered Pacific Cod, Island slaw, key lime tartar sauce$28.00
Havana Ropa Vieja
Mojo marinated shredded short ribs over Cuban black beans & rice, sweet roasted maduros, Cuban sautéed peppers & onions, queso fresco & pickled onions$28.00
Mushroom & Truffle Ragu Pappardelle
Wild mixed mushrooms in light white wine garlic sauce, Parmesan, Asiago, Ramano cheese and truffle oil$26.00
Poppin' Bottles Pappardelle
Key West Spiny Lobster & Shrimp, pappardelle pasta, heirloom tomatoes, Champagne cream sauce$35.00
Seafood & Grits
Gulf shrimp, Maine scallops, creamy Gruyère grits, bacon & wild mix mushrooms, Coconut Rum glaze or Southern Caribbean style$33.00
Sandwiches & Tacos

Ana's Cuban
Mojo pork, honey ham, crispy pickles, Swiss cheese, house mustards, Cuban bread$19.00
Bodega Burger
½ # burger, sautéed mushrooms & onions, basted in house-made lemon BBQ, red onion jam, Swiss cheese, crispy shoestring potatoes, brioche bun, fries$18.00
Crispy Chicken Sliders
3 crispy chicken sliders on Hawaiian slider rolls with bacon, ranch, crispy pickles, fried jalapeño with small Cuban black beans & rice$18.00
Lobster & Shrimp Roll
Juicy Key West Spiny lobster & shrimp served on a sweet Hawaiian roll with a side of salt & vinegar seasoned fries Your choice of Maine or Key West Style$31.00
Island Life Tacos
Beer battered, blackened or sautéed Gulf shrimp, grilled pineapple salsa, island slaw, guacamole, pickled onions, sriracha honey, queso fresco, with Cuban black beans & rice, gluten free blue corn chips & salsa$23.00
Last Flight Out Caesar Wrap
Blackened Key West shrimp, romaine, cherry tomatoes, house made Caesar dressing, Cuban bread croutons.$18.00
Mahi Mahi Philly
blackened or battered Mahi Mahi, sautéed peppers & onions, Swiss cheese, red onion jam, garlic aioli. Cuban black beans & rice.$26.00
Medianoche Sliders
3 Cubano sliders on Hawaiian rolls with Mojo pork, honey ham, crispy pickles, Swiss cheese, house mustards with Cuban black beans & rice$18.00
Papa's Steak Sandwich
Mojo steak, sriracha honey, caramelized bacon & onions, fried jalapeños, shredded lettuce, horseradish crème, Cuban bread$28.00
Ropa Vieja Sliders
shredded Cuban Mojo Ropa Viejo, red onion jam, crispy shoestring potatoes$18.00
Steak Sliders
3 Certified Angus Beef steak sliders on grilled Hawaiian rolls with horseradish sauce, caramelized onions with french fries.$22.00
Surf 'N Turf Tacos
2 soft flour tortillas with a layer of cheese filled with Certified Angus Beef steak tossed in chimichurri and blackened Gulf shrimp served with a side of Cuban black beans and rice with Gluten Free blue corn chips and salsa$26.00
Truman Po' Boy
Beer battered Gulf shrimp, Cajun remoulade, lettuce, tomatoes, crispy pickles, Cuban bread$21.00
The After Party

Key Lime Pie
House made graham cracker crust, sweet & tart pie topped with whip cream & toasted coconut & fresh strawberries$12.00
Piña Colada Bread Pudding
House made bread pudding topped with Coconut Rum glaze, whipped cream & fresh strawberries, toasted coconut$11.00
Sweet Rum Maduros
$10.00
Whole Key Lime Pie
PLEASE ALLOW 24 HOURS FOR PICK UP$80.00
Brunch Menu
Chowder, Salads & Appetizers

4 Wives of Hemingway Ceviche
Ceviche with shrimp, conch, scallop, mahi. Mango sweet & habanero spicy. Gluten Free blue corn tortilla chips.$23.00
Bahama Village Conch Chowder
Key West style with conch, tomatoes, potatoes, pork$11.00
Burrata Panzanella
Cuban bread croutons, arugula, grape tomatoes, crushed pistachios tossed in white balsamic dressing, topped with creamy burrata cheese & balsamic reduction$16.00
Caprese Flatbread
House made nut-free pesto, burrata cheese, roasted tomatoes, Parmesan, Romano & Asiago cheeses, balsamic reduction$19.00
Captain Tim's Conch & Shrimp Fritters
Key West shrimp & Bahamian conch with habanero guava marmalade & Key Lime mustard$21.00
Cuban Cigars
3 flour tortillas filled with Mojo pork, honey ham, Swiss cheese, crispy pickles, flash-fried with Key Lime mustard$18.00
Hemingway House
Chopped Romaine, fried avocado, red pepper, applewood smoked bacon, queso fresco, Cuban bread croutons, toasted coconut, pineapple mojito dressing$16.00
Louie's Ceasar Salad
Chopped Romaine, Caesar dressing, Parmesan, Romano & Asiago, Cuban bread croutons Make It BLT style- add applewood smoked bacon pieces & grape tomatoes $3 Calvin style- add Mojo steak & shoestring potatoes $12$14.00
Miss Key West Drunken Shrimp
Beer steamed Key West peel 'n eat shrimp, Tequila Lime cocktail sauce, Cuban bread for dipping. Caught from the ONLY shrimp boat in Key West's Marina, the "Miss Key West"$23.00
New Town Wedge
Iceberg wedge, grape tomatoes, applewood smoked bacon, Gorgonzola, pickled onions, balsamic reduction, Gorgonzola dressing$14.00
Off the Hook Pickles
Beer battered, Key Lime mustard & secret Frita sauce$11.00
Southernmost Fish Dip
Cool & creamy smoked white fish & shrimp dip topped with pickled onions, red peppers, fried jalapeños. Served with Gluten Free blue corn tortilla chips$14.00
Casa's Backyard
Watch Us Farm romaine, gorgonzola, spiced pecans, Granny Smith apples, blueberries, white balsamic vinaigrette$16.00
Lobster & Shrimp Dip
hot & creamy, a bit of heat, GF blue corn tortilla chips $26.00
Brunchy

Avocado Toast
Open-faced sour dough, guacamole, creamy burrata cheese, queso fresco, crushed pistachios, pickled onions, balsamic reduction, arugula salad$18.00
B Cafe Steak & Eggs
4 oz sliced Certified Angus Beef Mojo center cut Sirloin steak topped with 2 sunny side up eggs on Cuban bread crostinis, chimichurri, Pesto potatoes, and mushroom crème sauce$21.00
Chicken 'n Waffle
Crispy chicken tenders, savory bacon waffle, sunny side up egg, candied bacon crumbles, blueberries Choice of: coconut rum glaze, mushroom gorgonzola crème or sriracha honey$18.00
Fantasy Fest Bowl
Pesto potatoes, white cheddar, your choice of egg, applewood smoked bacon crumbles, fried jalapeños, scallions, pickled onions, queso fresco, guacamole, fire roasted salsa. Also available as a wrap.$19.00
French Toast
Hawaiian rolls stuffed with strawberry & guava cream cheese topped with whip cream, toasted coconut, coconut rum glaze$16.00
Key Lime Pie Cinnamon Roll
Zionsville's Local Baker's House graham cracker cinnamon roll topped with house key lime icing.$11.00
Key Westerner
2 eggs, honey ham or bacon, bacon waffle, pesto potatoes$18.00
Lobster & Shrimp Roll
Juicy Key West Spiny lobster & shrimp served on a sweet Hawaiian roll with a side of salt & vinegar seasoned fries Your choice of Maine or Key West Style$31.00
Shrimp & Grits
Parmesan & bacon grits, 3 large Key West pink shrimp, house made nut-free pesto$18.00
Ultimate Croque Madame
Open-faced Cuban bread, house mustards, honey ham, applewood smoked bacon, white cheddar, Guyère fondue, sunny side up egg, arugula salad$18.00
Duval Disco Fries
Mojo Cuban pork, burrata cheese, queso fresco, pickled onions, house horseradish dipping sauce.$19.00
Crêpes

La G-Foolio Crêpe
applewood smoked bacon, scrambled eggs, pesto potatoes, fried jalapeños, guacamole, sriracha honey, blue corn chips & salsa$16.00
La Layton Crêpe
Nutella meringue, strawberries, whip cream$13.00
La Lenny Crêpe
Strawberry guava cream cheese, strawberries, whip cream$11.00
La Li-Li Crêpe
blueberry cream cheese, blueberry reduction, whip cream$11.00
La Lynn-O Crêpe
Honey ham, Swiss, caramelized onions & mushrooms, gruyère fondue, arugula salad$16.00
La Volkswagen
asparagus, goat cheese, caramelized onions & mushrooms, fire roasted tomatoes, homemade, nut-free pesto, chives$16.00
Hand Helds

Breakfast Club BLT
Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, Key Lime tartar, fried or over easy egg, guacamole, crispy shoestring potatoes, sour dough, crispy fries$18.00
Caesar Wrap
Blackened Key West shrimp, Romaine lettuce, cherry tomatoes, house made Caesar dressing, Cuban bread croutons, crispy fries$18.00
Crispy Chicken Sliders
3 crispy chicken sliders on Hawaiian slider rolls with bacon, ranch, crispy pickles, fried jalapeño with small Cuban black beans & rice$18.00
Ella's Late Night Burrito
honey ham, candied bacon, pesto potatoes, caramelized onions, white cheddar, scrambled eggs, sriracha honey or tamarind jerk BBQ$18.00
Lobster & Shrimp Roll
Juicy Key West Spiny lobster & shrimp served on a sweet Hawaiian roll with a side of salt & vinegar seasoned fries Your choice of Maine or Key West Style$31.00
Hangover Tacos
Pesto potatoes, applewood smoked bacon, fried eggs, sriracha honey, guacamole, pickled onions, queso fresco on 2 flour tortillas, side of Cuban black beans & rice, Gluten Free blue corn chips & salsa$18.00
Havana OHH-LA-LA
Mojo pork, honey ham, applewood smoked bacon, fried egg, white cheddar, crispy shoestring potatoes, garlic cilantro aioli, Cuban bread, fries$19.00
Lost Boy Waffle Grilled Cheese
Savory bacon waffle, white cheddar, applewood smoked bacon, tomatoes, guacamole, garlic cilantro aioli, crispy fries$18.00
Mahi Mahi Philly
blackened or battered Mahi Mahi, sautéed peppers & onions, Swiss cheese, red onion jam, garlic aioli. Cuban black beans & rice.$26.00
WAKE 'N STEAK TACOS
2 cheesy tortillas, chimichurri steak, 2 eggs your choice, queso fresco, guacamole with Cuban black beans & rice, chips & salsa$22.00
Breakfast Sides
Add 1 Egg
$3.00Crostinis(4)
$3.00Cuban Black Beans & Rice
$3.00Fries
$7.00fruit cup
$5.00Grilled Chicken
$10.00Plain Bacon Waffle
$5.00Salt n Vinegar Fries
$8.00Side 4Pcs Applewood Smoked Bacon
$6.00Side Arugula Salad
$6.00Side Candied Bacon
$5.00Side Caesar Salad
$6.00Grilled Sourdough
$4.00Side Guacamole
$3.50Side Pesto Potatoes
$4.00Side Two Eggs
$6.00Sliced Avocado
$4.00Truffle Fries
$10.00Side Parm Grits
$10.00chips and salsa
$6.006 Grilled Shrimp KW Pinks
$15.00Side of 6 Maduros
$8.00Side Mixed Green Salad
$6.00Side Caesar Salad
$6.00Add Egg White
$3.00Ramekin of Nutella
$1.00Ramekin of Strawberries
$1.00
Sweet Finishes

Key Lime Pie
House made graham cracker crust, sweet & tart pie topped with whip cream & toasted coconut & fresh strawberries$12.00
Piña Colada Bread Pudding
House made bread pudding topped with Coconut Rum glaze, whipped cream & fresh strawberries, toasted coconut$11.00
Whole Key Lime Pie
PLEASE ALLOW 24 HOURS FOR PICK UP$80.00
Sweet Rum Maduros
$10.00
Key Lime Pie Cinnamon Roll
Zionsville's Local Baker's House graham cracker cinnamon roll topped with house key lime icing.$11.00
Cheese Flatbread
$15.00
1
All hours
| Sunday | 10:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Thursday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Friday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Saturday | 10:00 am - 1:00 pm, 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
Restaurant info
BRINGING KEY WEST TO ZIONSVILLE, IN
Location
135 S. MAIN ST, Zionsville, IN 46077
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.







