Sandwiches
Tony & Pete's
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items
TURKEY PESTO
TURKEY, MOZZARELLA, HOUSE PESTO, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, ARUGULA, BALSAMIC. THIS SANDWICH CANNOT BE MADE GLUTEN FREE.$14.00
DELIVERY BOY
Really good Pepperoni from Ezzo Sausage Co, House made Red Sauce, Melty Mozzarella, Banana Peppers, Chopped Calabrian’s, plenty of Oregano & good Olive Oil. If you’re really tryna get wild, add some Calabrian Honey. Served hot & fresh with a side of house made ranch CUZ WE IN THE MIDWEST BABY!$15.00
PASTA SALAD
$5.00
Food
SANDWICHES
FRESH LOCALLY BAKED BREAD, HIGH QUALITY MEATS & CHEESES, SCRATCH MADE INGREDIENTS ALWAYS.
COLD CUT TRIO
SALAMI, CAPICOLA, BOLOGNA, PROVOLONE, SHREDDUCE, TOMATO, ROASTED RED PEP, T&P VINAIGRETTE$14.00
TONY
ROAST BEEF, TURKEY, DUKE'S MAYO, ROASTED RED PEP, AMERICAN CHEESE, SHREDDUCE, T&P VINAIGRETTE$14.00
PETE
SOPPRESSATA, PROVOLONE, ARUGULA, TOMATO JAM, CHILI OIL, RED ONION$14.00
HAM SANDWICH
COUNTRY HAM, PIMENTO CHEESE, HOUSE BREAD & BUTTER PICKLES, SHREDDUCE, SPREAD, OLIVE OIL.$14.00
STRETTO'S SPICY SALAMI
SALAMI, SPICY SPREAD, CALABRIAN HONEY, ARUGULA, PARMESAN$14.00
AFTER SCHOOL SPECIAL
TURKEY, AMERICAN CHEESE, SHREDDUCE, TOMATO, SPREAD, OLIVE OIL$14.00
VEGAN COLD CUT
MARINATED TOFU, HERBED VEGAN SPREAD, SHREDDUCE, TOMATO, RED ONION, CALABRIAN CHILI OIL, GIARDINIERA, T&P VINAIGRETTE THIS SANDWICH CONTAINS SOY$14.00
GABAGOOL
CAPICOLA, PROVOLONE, PESTO AIOLI, PICKLED RED ONION, SHREDDUCE, CHILI OIL, T&P VINAIGRETTE THIS SANDWICH CANNOT BE MADE GLUTEN FREE$14.00
WHITE COLLAR
MORTADELLA*, ARUGULA, PICKLED RED ONION, SHAVED PARMESAN, SPREAD, T&P VINAIGRETTE *THIS ITEM CONTAINS NUTS (PISTACHIO)$14.00
HALF SANDWICH & SIDE
HALF OF ANY COLD CUT SANDWICH AND ONE OF OUR HOUSE MADE SIDES, OR A CUP OF SOUP. SOUP ROTATES FREQUENTLY. *HOT SANDWICHES NOT AVAILABLE AS A COMBO* *GLUTEN FREE SANDWICHES NOT AVAILABLE AS A COMBO*$14.00
BLUE COLLAR
BOLOGNA, PROVOLONE, SHREDDUCE, SPICY MUSTARD, GIARDINIERA$14.00
Z93
SALAMI, BOLOGNA, AMERICAN, SPREAD, SHREDDUCE, OLIVE OIL, GRIPPOS POTATO CHIPS$14.00TURKEY PESTO
TURKEY, MOZZARELLA, HOUSE PESTO, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, ARUGULA, BALSAMIC. THIS SANDWICH CANNOT BE MADE GLUTEN FREE.$14.00
MIDWEST ITALIAN
CAPICOLA, SALAMI, PEPPERONI, PROVOLONE, PEPPERONCINI MAYO, BANANA PEPPERS, SHREDDUCE, TOMATO, ONION, OREGANO$14.00
KIDZ SANDWICH
THIS IS FOR KIDS ONLY! SMALL SANDWICH WITH YOUR CHOICE OF MEAT, CHEESE, MAYO/MUSTARD, LETTUCE/TOMATO. NO SURPRISES HERE! AGAIN- THIS IS FOR KIDS ONLY!$7.00
VEGAN MUSHROOM SANDWICH
PAN ROASTED MUSHROOMS, CARAMELIZED ONIONS, HORSERADISH SPREAD, HERBS.$15.00OUT OF STOCK
ITALIAN BEEF
A CHICAGO CLASSIC. THINLY SLICED ROAST BEEF DUNKED IN A HOMEMADE BEEF STOCK, PILED ONTO A FRESH BAKED ROLL, AND THEN THE WHOLE THING IS DUNKED (AGAIN) IN BEEF STOCK. FINISHED WITH HOT GIARDINIERA FROM JP GRAZIANO'S.$15.00DELIVERY BOY
Really good Pepperoni from Ezzo Sausage Co, House made Red Sauce, Melty Mozzarella, Banana Peppers, Chopped Calabrian’s, plenty of Oregano & good Olive Oil. If you’re really tryna get wild, add some Calabrian Honey. Served hot & fresh with a side of house made ranch CUZ WE IN THE MIDWEST BABY!$15.00
SALADS
SIDES
PIMENTO CHEESE
CREAMY, SPREADABLE, FULL OF FLAVOR WITH SUBTLE HEAT$5.00PASTA SALAD
$5.00
CHIPS AND CARAMELIZED ONION DIP
$5.00
VEGAN CHICKPEA SALAD
$5.00
CUP OF MIDWEST CHILI
$5.00
CHIPS
$2.25
TODAY'S COOKIES
BAKED FRESH BY OUR FRIENDS AT GRIST PROVISIONS$3.50
2OZ GIARDINIERA
CHICAGO-STYLE, SEASONED PICKLED CARROTS, CAULIFLOWER, & CELERY WITH A LITTLE JALAPEÑO$1.50
2OZ SPICY SPREAD
$1.50
2OZ SIDE T&P VIN
$0.75
2OZ SIDE SPREAD
$0.75
2OZ SIDE OF MAYO
$0.502OZ SIDE OF PESTO AIOLI
$0.752OZ SIDE OF PEPPEROCINI MAYO
$0.75
2OZ SIDE OF RANCH
$0.50
Beverages
NA Beverages
Rain Bottled Water
$3.00
Mineragua
$3.50OUT OF STOCK
Mexican Coke, 355 mL
$3.50
Sprite
$3.50OUT OF STOCK
Diet Coke
$3.50
Root Beer
$3.00
Cherry Vanilla Soda
$3.00
Ginger Beer
$3.00
Orange Cream Soda
$3.00
Fanta Orange
$3.50
LA Croix Lime 12oz Can
$3.00
LA Croix Pamplemousse 12oz Can
$3.00
Natalie's Lemonade
$4.00
Natalie's Strawberry Lemonade
$4.00OUT OF STOCK
Warped Wing Ginger Beer 6pk
$8.00
Warped Wing Root Beer 6pks
$8.00
Warped Wing Orange Cream Soda 6pk
$8.00
Warped Wing Cherry Vanilla 6pk
$8.00
Dark Matter Coffee Chocolate City
$5.00
Dark Matter Coffee Vanilla Suburbs
$6.00
Franklin's Coconut Cold Brew
$5.00
Joe's Peach Tea
$3.75
Joe's 50/50 Lemonade Iced Tea
$3.75
HAM SANDWICH
$14.00
COUNTRY HAM, PIMENTO CHEESE, HOUSE BREAD & BUTTER PICKLES, SHREDDUCE, SPREAD, OLIVE OIL.
Customize your item
Optional
Optional
Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutions or add-ons. EXTRA CHARGES MAY APPLY UPON PICKUP.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 6:30 pm |
| Monday | 11:00 am - 6:30 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 6:30 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 6:30 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 6:30 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 6:30 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 6:30 pm |
Restaurant info
NEIGHBORHOOD MARKET AND SANDWICH SHOP
Location
129 East 3rd Street, Dayton, OH 45402
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
