Skip to Main content
  • Benji and Jake’s

    • Home
    • /
    • White Lake
    • /
    • Benji and Jakes
    Restaurant banner image
    Italian

    Benji and Jakes

    5 Horseshoe Lake Rd

    White Lake, NY 12786


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Benji & Jake's
    Beverages

    Benji & Jake's

    Specials

    • Carrot Soup

      A vegan (GF) carrot soup made with coconut milk, ginger with a curry kick! Topped with shredded carrots and chives
      $10.00
    • Aviv *Seasonal Pizza Special*

      a white pie on white dough with mozzarella, ricotta, grilled leeks, cremini mushrooms, asparagus and truffle oil
      $24.00+
    • Risotto Balls

      these cheese filled rice balls are mixed with Italian herbs and coated in a crispy breading and served with a side of marinara. The ultimate Italian comfort food!
      OUT OF STOCK
      $13.00
    • Pickle Fries

      Battered fried pickles served with a side of ranch
      $12.00
    • Sadies's Smokestack - Smoked Mozz Sticks

      $12.00
    • Catskill Cold Press - Cold Pressed Juice - 16oz

      $12.00
    • Extra Sauce

    • Gelato

      Please ask your server for this weeks flavors
      $8.00
    • Tropic Like It's Hot **Pizza Special**

      marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, smoked mozzarella, pineapple, pickled jalapenos, red onion, with a hot honey drizzle
      $24.00+
    • Tropic Like It’s Hot - Burger Edition

      8oz angus beef chuck, brisket, sirloin burger upgraded with smoked mozzarella, pickled jalapeños, juicy pineapple, and a spicy-sweet pineapple tequila spread that’ll send your taste buds straight on vacation
      $18.00

    Appetizers & Salads

    • Mixed Green Salad

      Local organic baby greens served with shredded cabbage, carrots, cucumber and grape tomatoes with a choice of dressing
      $16.00
    • Ceaser Salad

      Served with croutons and parmesan
      $15.00
    • Caprese Salad

      Local mozzarella, plum tomato and basil with a balsamic reduction and porcini oil
      $16.00
    • Mediterranean Salad

      Romaine topped with chickpeas, kalamata olives, roasted tomato peices, cucumber, feta cheese artichokes, oregano and served with a red wine and olive oil or tahini dressing
      $20.00
    • French Onion Soup

      A vegetarian version of the classic served with french bread and gruyere cheese
      $12.00
    • Murray's Brick Oven Chicken Wings

      served five per order with a side of bbq and jalapeno sauce
      $16.00
    • Murray's BBQ Chicken Skewers

      Murray's Chicken breast skewers seasoned and grilled or grilled coated in BBQ sauce - your choice - served 2 per order
      OUT OF STOCK
      $12.00
    • Chicken Tenders

      Served 5 per order with a side of BBQ sauce, housemade maple mustard and waffle fries
      $16.00
    • Gardein Plant Based Chicken Tenders

      Plant based chicken tenders served with a side of BBQ, housemade maple mustard and waffle fries
      $16.00
    • Meatball Appetizer

      Three all beef meatballs served in a cast iron skillet with marinara and topped with parmesan and basil
      $16.00
    • Mozarella Sticks

      served six per order with a side of marinara sauce
      $10.00
    • Firecracker Sticks

      Golden mozzarella sticks with a spicy twist—tossed in Buffalo sauce and drizzled with cool ranch. Crispy, cheesy, zesty, and totally addictive. For drizzle my rizzle!
      $11.00
    • Golden Triangles

      SoyBoy organic non GMO Tofu (Rochester, NY) lightly coated in cornmeal, fried and served with housemade chipotle mayo
      $12.00
    • Hummus and pita

      $12.00
    • Corn Ribs

      grilled and fried corn "ribs" seasoned with lime juice and truffle oil for a fiesta in your mouth!
      $12.00
    • Waffle Fries

      Waffle Fries
      $8.00
    • Truffle Parmesan Fries

      Our waffle fries tossed in truffle parmesean cheese and white truffle oil
      $12.00
    • Garlic Knots

      served in a cast iron with a side of marinara
      $10.00

    PIZZAS

    • Angry Bird - Buffalo Chicken Pie

      White dough, mozzarella, breaded chicken pieces, hot wing sauce, blue cheese crumble, scallions
      $24.00+
    • Aviv *Seasonal Pizza Special*

      a white pie on white dough with mozzarella, ricotta, grilled leeks, cremini mushrooms, asparagus and truffle oil
      $24.00+
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

      White dough, mozzarella, breaded chicken & bacon pieces, finished with a ranch drizzle
      $24.00+
    • Chicken Parmesan Pie

      White dough topped with breaded chicken pieces, fresh mozzarella, basil
      $24.00+
    • Dolce Diavolo

      white dough pie topped with marinara, fresh mozzarella, roasted tomato pieces, Calabrian peppers and finished with truffle honey
      $24.00+
    • Don Mateo

      marinara, mozzarella, pepper jack cheese, Peppadews, habanero
      $23.00+
    • Drunken Chef

      vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, parmesan, zucchini, yellow squash, crimini mushrooms
      $24.00+
    • Eggplant Parm

      marinara sauce, fire-roasted eggplant sauce, fresh mozzarella, parmesan cheese, breaded fried eggplant
      $24.00+
    • Fungus Amongus

      marinara sauce, mozzarella, cheddar cheese, goat cheese, crimini mushrooms, shiitake mushrooms, fresh black cracked pepper
      $24.00+
    • Gringo Disco

      vodka sauce, mozarella, ricotta, artichoke, crimini mushroom, broccoli
      $24.00+
    • Holy Jalapeno

      spicy tomato sauce, cheddar cheese, mozzarella, cilantro pesto, raw & housemade fried jalapeno rings
      OUT OF STOCK
      $24.00+
    • I Dream of Genie

      aubergine sauce, mozzarella, black olives, mushrooms, pesto drops, sun-dried tomatoes
      $24.00+
    • Itallian Stallion

      marinara sauce on top of fresh mozzarella, olive oil, fresh basil & fresh oregano
      $20.00+
    • Jackson Pollock

      marinara, vodka, fire-roasted eggplant and pesto sauces, smoked mozzarella, crimini mushrooms
      $23.00+
    • Laughing Goat

      vodka sauce, mozzarella, goat cheese, shitake mushrooms, caramelized onions
      $24.00+
    • Margarita

      marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, plum tomato slices, fresh basil
      $20.00+
    • Pizza Bernadette

      pesto sauce, fresh mozzarella, Murray's roasted pulled chicken, broccoli
      $24.00+
    • Plain Jane

      marinara sauce, mozzarella
      $18.00+
    • Pua Hula

      marinara, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, pineapple, bacon
      $24.00+
    • Saucy Bird - BBQ Chicken Pie

      White dough, mozzarella, chicken pieces, bbq sauce, red onion
      $24.00+
    • Smokey Mozz

      marinara sauce, smoked mozzarella, roasted red peppers
      $22.00+
    • Sweetie Pie

      balsamic reduction, fresh mozzarella, tomato, fresh oregano & fresh basil
      $20.00+
    • The Big Poppy

      Large Pie - A regular and local legend Harvey Rosenberg's favorite pie (Sid Rosenberg's loving father, may his memory be a blessing). So good we had to offer it to you. Half T-Rex (Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella, Pepperoni, Roasted Pulled Murray's Chicken, Ground Beef, Bacon) Half Margarita (Marinara Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Plum Tomato Slices, Fresh Basil)
      $25.00+
    • Vampire Slayer

      marinara, mozzarella, garlic confit, cherry peppers, finished with chili garlic crisp oil
      $24.00+
    • T-Rex

      marinara sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, Murray's roasted pulled chicken, ground beef, & bacon
      $26.00+
    • Pesto La Vista

      a rich basil pesto base, roasted tomatoes and fresh mozzarella, then finished off with a balsamic glaze drizzle and plenty of fresh basil It’s bold. It’s bright. It’s basically summer on a slice.
      $24.00+
    • Aubergine

      fire-roasted eggplant sauce, mozzarella, romano, sun-dried tomatoes
      $23.00+
    • Rampway To Heaven * Seasonal Pizza Special*

      marinara, mozzarella, cheddar cheese, shallots, local ramps, fresh cracked black pepper *seasonal - limited time only
      $24.00+
    • Supreme

      marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage crumble, green peppers, onion, black olive & Cremini mushrooms
      $26.00+
    • Pepperoni & Hot Honey

      marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni, finished with a hot honey drizzle
      $22.00+

    Entrees

    • Murray’s Free Range Brick Oven Roasted Half Chicken

      seasoned with fresh herbs and spices, served with roasted potatoes, roasted carrots and sautéed broccoli
      $38.00
    • Grilled Yellow Fin Tuna

      *available as a steak or served cubed on rosemary skewers* marinated in white wine, chili, garlic, and basil. seared and served with quinoa, roasted carrots and sautéed broccoli- accompanied with a chipotle lime vin
      $38.00
    • Ravioli Burrata

      Burrata cheese stuffed ravioli - 5 piece dish served with marinara sauce and topped with Pecorino and basil
      $25.00
    • Angus Beef Burger - Chuck, Brisket & Sirloin

      8 OZ served on a Broiche bun with lettuce, tomato, red onion and a pickle Add Toppings as desired (additional charge)
      $16.00
    • Beyond Burger

      vegan/soy free/gluten free patty by Beyond Meat served on a Brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, red onion and a pickle Add toppings to your liking (additional charge)
      $15.00

    Desserts

    • Mini Housemade Zeppoles

      sprinkled with cinnamon and sugar served with chocolate sauce
      $12.00
    • Churros

      Two large churros dusted with locally made maple sugar and a carnal and chocolate drizzle
      $10.00
    • Gelato

      $8.00

    Merchandise

    • Gift Certificate

      Please add email address or post office address in notes
      $25.00
    • Gift Certificate

      Please add email address or post office address in notes
      $50.00
    • Gift Certificate

      Please add email address or post office address in notes
      $75.00
    • Gift Certificate

      Please add email address or post office address in notes
      $100.00
    • Sid Rosenberg Signed Book

      $28.00

    Beverages

    N/A Beverages

    • Boylen's Birch

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Black Cherry

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Cream Soda

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Creamy Red

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Ginger Ale

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Grape

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Orange

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Root Beer

      $6.00
    • Club Soda

      $2.00+
    • Coffee

      $4.00
    • Cranberry Juice

      $3.00
    • Diet Pepsi

      $3.00+
    • Dirty Coke - Non Alcholic

      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.00
    • Dr. Pepper

      $3.00+
    • Ginger Ale - Schweppes

      $3.00+
    • Ginger Beer

      $5.00
    • Milk

      $2.50
    • Mocktail

      OUT OF STOCK
      $8.00
    • Orange Juice

      $3.00
    • Peach Iced Tea

      $6.00
    • Pepsi

      $3.00+
    • Pepsi - Glass Bottle

      $5.00
    • pineapple juice

      $3.00
    • Pink Lemonade

      $3.00+
    • Pitcher of Soda

      $12.00
    • Saratoga Water - Flat

      $10.00
    • Saratoga Water - Sparkling

      $10.00
    • Seltzer

      $2.00+
    • Shirley Temple

      $5.00
    • Shirley Temple

      $5.00
    • Starry

      $3.00+
    • Tea

      $3.00
    • Topo Chico

      $5.00
    • Unsweet Iced Tea

      $4.00
    • Water (tap)

    • Wild Bills Soda

      $5.00
    • Guava Juice

      $3.00
    • Mango Juice

      $3.00

    Gift Certificate

    $75.00

    Please add email address or post office address in notes

    Request advisory
    We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
    1

    All hours
    Sunday4:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    MondayClosed
    TuesdayClosed
    Wednesday4:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Thursday4:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Friday4:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Saturday4:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Restaurant info

    #Catskillspizza

    Location

    5 Horseshoe Lake Rd, White Lake, NY 12786

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Liberty Pizza - Bowling + Arcade Broadway Bowling 498 Broadway
    View restaurantnext
    Liberty Pizza 2 512 Broadway
    View restaurantnext
    Liberty Pizza | Liberty, NY
    View restaurantnext
    Kartrite Surfside Surfside
    View restaurantnext
    Bridge & Main 251 Bridge Street
    View restaurantnext
    Forest Edge 1441 Route 590
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook