Skip to Main content
  • Benji and Jake’s

    • Home
    • /
    • White Lake
    • /
    • Benji and Jakes
    Restaurant banner image
    Italian

    Benji and Jakes

    5 Horseshoe Lake Rd

    White Lake, NY 12786


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    Benji & Jake's
    Beverages

    Benji & Jake's

    Specials

    • Carrot Soup

      A vegan (GF) carrot soup made with coconut milk, ginger with a curry kick! Topped with shredded carrots and chives
      $10.00
    • Aviv *Seasonal Pizza Special*

      a white pie on white dough with mozzarella, ricotta, grilled leeks, cremini mushrooms, asparagus and truffle oil
      $24.00+
    • Risotto Balls

      these cheese filled rice balls are mixed with Italian herbs and coated in a crispy breading and served with a side of marinara. The ultimate Italian comfort food!
      OUT OF STOCK
      $13.00
    • Pickle Fries

      Battered fried pickles served with a side of ranch
      $12.00
    • Sadies's Smokestack - Smoked Mozz Sticks

      $12.00
    • Catskill Cold Press - Cold Pressed Juice - 16oz

      $12.00
    • Extra Sauce

    • Gelato

      Please ask your server for this weeks flavors
      $8.00
    • Tropic Like It's Hot **Pizza Special**

      marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, smoked mozzarella, pineapple, pickled jalapenos, red onion, with a hot honey drizzle
      $24.00+
    • Tropic Like It’s Hot - Burger Edition

      8oz angus beef chuck, brisket, sirloin burger upgraded with smoked mozzarella, pickled jalapeños, juicy pineapple, and a spicy-sweet pineapple tequila spread that’ll send your taste buds straight on vacation
      $18.00

    Appetizers & Salads

    • Mixed Green Salad

      Local organic baby greens served with shredded cabbage, carrots, cucumber and grape tomatoes with a choice of dressing
      $16.00
    • Ceaser Salad

      Served with croutons and parmesan
      $15.00
    • Caprese Salad

      Local mozzarella, plum tomato and basil with a balsamic reduction and porcini oil
      $16.00
    • Mediterranean Salad

      Romaine topped with chickpeas, kalamata olives, roasted tomato peices, cucumber, feta cheese artichokes, oregano and served with a red wine and olive oil or tahini dressing
      $20.00
    • French Onion Soup

      A vegetarian version of the classic served with french bread and gruyere cheese
      $12.00
    • Murray's Brick Oven Chicken Wings

      served five per order with a side of bbq and jalapeno sauce
      $16.00
    • Murray's BBQ Chicken Skewers

      Murray's Chicken breast skewers seasoned and grilled or grilled coated in BBQ sauce - your choice - served 2 per order
      OUT OF STOCK
      $12.00
    • Chicken Tenders

      Served 5 per order with a side of BBQ sauce, housemade maple mustard and waffle fries
      $16.00
    • Gardein Plant Based Chicken Tenders

      Plant based chicken tenders served with a side of BBQ, housemade maple mustard and waffle fries
      $16.00
    • Meatball Appetizer

      Three all beef meatballs served in a cast iron skillet with marinara and topped with parmesan and basil
      $16.00
    • Mozarella Sticks

      served six per order with a side of marinara sauce
      $10.00
    • Firecracker Sticks

      Golden mozzarella sticks with a spicy twist—tossed in Buffalo sauce and drizzled with cool ranch. Crispy, cheesy, zesty, and totally addictive. For drizzle my rizzle!
      $11.00
    • Golden Triangles

      SoyBoy organic non GMO Tofu (Rochester, NY) lightly coated in cornmeal, fried and served with housemade chipotle mayo
      $12.00
    • Hummus and pita

      $12.00
    • Corn Ribs

      grilled and fried corn "ribs" seasoned with lime juice and truffle oil for a fiesta in your mouth!
      $12.00
    • Waffle Fries

      Waffle Fries
      $8.00
    • Truffle Parmesan Fries

      Our waffle fries tossed in truffle parmesean cheese and white truffle oil
      $12.00
    • Garlic Knots

      served in a cast iron with a side of marinara
      $10.00

    PIZZAS

    • Angry Bird - Buffalo Chicken Pie

      White dough, mozzarella, breaded chicken pieces, hot wing sauce, blue cheese crumble, scallions
      $24.00+
    • Aviv *Seasonal Pizza Special*

      a white pie on white dough with mozzarella, ricotta, grilled leeks, cremini mushrooms, asparagus and truffle oil
      $24.00+
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

      White dough, mozzarella, breaded chicken & bacon pieces, finished with a ranch drizzle
      $24.00+
    • Chicken Parmesan Pie

      White dough topped with breaded chicken pieces, fresh mozzarella, basil
      $24.00+
    • Dolce Diavolo

      white dough pie topped with marinara, fresh mozzarella, roasted tomato pieces, Calabrian peppers and finished with truffle honey
      $24.00+
    • Don Mateo

      marinara, mozzarella, pepper jack cheese, Peppadews, habanero
      $23.00+
    • Drunken Chef

      vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, parmesan, zucchini, yellow squash, crimini mushrooms
      $24.00+
    • Eggplant Parm

      marinara sauce, fire-roasted eggplant sauce, fresh mozzarella, parmesan cheese, breaded fried eggplant
      $24.00+
    • Fungus Amongus

      marinara sauce, mozzarella, cheddar cheese, goat cheese, crimini mushrooms, shiitake mushrooms, fresh black cracked pepper
      $24.00+
    • Gringo Disco

      vodka sauce, mozarella, ricotta, artichoke, crimini mushroom, broccoli
      $24.00+
    • Holy Jalapeno

      spicy tomato sauce, cheddar cheese, mozzarella, cilantro pesto, raw & housemade fried jalapeno rings
      OUT OF STOCK
      $24.00+
    • I Dream of Genie

      aubergine sauce, mozzarella, black olives, mushrooms, pesto drops, sun-dried tomatoes
      $24.00+
    • Itallian Stallion

      marinara sauce on top of fresh mozzarella, olive oil, fresh basil & fresh oregano
      $20.00+
    • Jackson Pollock

      marinara, vodka, fire-roasted eggplant and pesto sauces, smoked mozzarella, crimini mushrooms
      $23.00+
    • Laughing Goat

      vodka sauce, mozzarella, goat cheese, shitake mushrooms, caramelized onions
      $24.00+
    • Margarita

      marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, plum tomato slices, fresh basil
      $20.00+
    • Pizza Bernadette

      pesto sauce, fresh mozzarella, Murray's roasted pulled chicken, broccoli
      $24.00+
    • Plain Jane

      marinara sauce, mozzarella
      $18.00+
    • Pua Hula

      marinara, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, pineapple, bacon
      $24.00+
    • Saucy Bird - BBQ Chicken Pie

      White dough, mozzarella, chicken pieces, bbq sauce, red onion
      $24.00+
    • Smokey Mozz

      marinara sauce, smoked mozzarella, roasted red peppers
      $22.00+
    • Sweetie Pie

      balsamic reduction, fresh mozzarella, tomato, fresh oregano & fresh basil
      $20.00+
    • The Big Poppy

      Large Pie - A regular and local legend Harvey Rosenberg's favorite pie (Sid Rosenberg's loving father, may his memory be a blessing). So good we had to offer it to you. Half T-Rex (Marinara Sauce, Mozzarella, Pepperoni, Roasted Pulled Murray's Chicken, Ground Beef, Bacon) Half Margarita (Marinara Sauce, Fresh Mozzarella, Plum Tomato Slices, Fresh Basil)
      $25.00+
    • Vampire Slayer

      marinara, mozzarella, garlic confit, cherry peppers, finished with chili garlic crisp oil
      $24.00+
    • T-Rex

      marinara sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, Murray's roasted pulled chicken, ground beef, & bacon
      $26.00+
    • Pesto La Vista

      a rich basil pesto base, roasted tomatoes and fresh mozzarella, then finished off with a balsamic glaze drizzle and plenty of fresh basil It’s bold. It’s bright. It’s basically summer on a slice.
      $24.00+
    • Aubergine

      fire-roasted eggplant sauce, mozzarella, romano, sun-dried tomatoes
      $23.00+
    • Rampway To Heaven * Seasonal Pizza Special*

      marinara, mozzarella, cheddar cheese, shallots, local ramps, fresh cracked black pepper *seasonal - limited time only
      $24.00+
    • Supreme

      marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage crumble, green peppers, onion, black olive & Cremini mushrooms
      $26.00+
    • Pepperoni & Hot Honey

      marinara, mozzarella, pepperoni, finished with a hot honey drizzle
      $22.00+

    Entrees

    • Murray’s Free Range Brick Oven Roasted Half Chicken

      seasoned with fresh herbs and spices, served with roasted potatoes, roasted carrots and sautéed broccoli
      $38.00
    • Grilled Yellow Fin Tuna

      *available as a steak or served cubed on rosemary skewers* marinated in white wine, chili, garlic, and basil. seared and served with quinoa, roasted carrots and sautéed broccoli- accompanied with a chipotle lime vin
      $38.00
    • Ravioli Burrata

      Burrata cheese stuffed ravioli - 5 piece dish served with marinara sauce and topped with Pecorino and basil
      $25.00
    • Angus Beef Burger - Chuck, Brisket & Sirloin

      8 OZ served on a Broiche bun with lettuce, tomato, red onion and a pickle Add Toppings as desired (additional charge)
      $16.00
    • Beyond Burger

      vegan/soy free/gluten free patty by Beyond Meat served on a Brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, red onion and a pickle Add toppings to your liking (additional charge)
      $15.00

    Desserts

    • Mini Housemade Zeppoles

      sprinkled with cinnamon and sugar served with chocolate sauce
      $12.00
    • Churros

      Two large churros dusted with locally made maple sugar and a carnal and chocolate drizzle
      $10.00
    • Gelato

      $8.00

    Merchandise

    • Gift Certificate

      Please add email address or post office address in notes
      $25.00
    • Gift Certificate

      Please add email address or post office address in notes
      $50.00
    • Gift Certificate

      Please add email address or post office address in notes
      $75.00
    • Gift Certificate

      Please add email address or post office address in notes
      $100.00
    • Sid Rosenberg Signed Book

      $28.00

    Beverages

    N/A Beverages

    • Boylen's Birch

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Black Cherry

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Cream Soda

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Creamy Red

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Ginger Ale

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Grape

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Orange

      $6.00
    • Boylen's Root Beer

      $6.00
    • Club Soda

      $2.00+
    • Coffee

      $4.00
    • Cranberry Juice

      $3.00
    • Diet Pepsi

      $3.00+
    • Dirty Coke - Non Alcholic

      OUT OF STOCK
      $7.00
    • Dr. Pepper

      $3.00+
    • Ginger Ale - Schweppes

      $3.00+
    • Ginger Beer

      $5.00
    • Milk

      $2.50
    • Mocktail

      OUT OF STOCK
      $8.00
    • Orange Juice

      $3.00
    • Peach Iced Tea

      $6.00
    • Pepsi

      $3.00+
    • Pepsi - Glass Bottle

      $5.00
    • pineapple juice

      $3.00
    • Pink Lemonade

      $3.00+
    • Pitcher of Soda

      $12.00
    • Saratoga Water - Flat

      $10.00
    • Saratoga Water - Sparkling

      $10.00
    • Seltzer

      $2.00+
    • Shirley Temple

      $5.00
    • Shirley Temple

      $5.00
    • Starry

      $3.00+
    • Tea

      $3.00
    • Topo Chico

      $5.00
    • Unsweet Iced Tea

      $4.00
    • Water (tap)

    • Wild Bills Soda

      $5.00
    • Guava Juice

      $3.00
    • Mango Juice

      $3.00

    T-Rex

    $0.00

    marinara sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, Murray's roasted pulled chicken, ground beef, & bacon

    Customize your item

    Size

    Required
    Select 1

    Small Toppings

    Optional

    Large Toppings

    Optional
    Request advisory
    We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
    1

    All hours
    Sunday4:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    MondayClosed
    TuesdayClosed
    Wednesday4:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Thursday4:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Friday4:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Saturday4:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Restaurant info

    #Catskillspizza

    Location

    5 Horseshoe Lake Rd, White Lake, NY 12786

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Liberty Pizza - Bowling + Arcade Broadway Bowling 498 Broadway
    View restaurantnext
    Liberty Pizza 2 512 Broadway
    View restaurantnext
    Liberty Pizza | Liberty, NY
    View restaurantnext
    Kartrite Surfside Surfside
    View restaurantnext
    Bridge & Main 251 Bridge Street
    View restaurantnext
    Forest Edge 1441 Route 590
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook