Bobby Bay's Sandwich Shop
1878 E lincoln highway
Lancaster, PA 17602
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Full Menu
Sides
- French Fries$3.49+
Skin on. Sea salt. Large is ideal for 2.
- Loaded Fries$8.99
Truffle whiz. Bacon. Scallions
- Tuscan Fries$7.49
Parmesan. Mediterranean herbs. Truffle oil
- Carolina Coleslaw$3.49+
Creamy, sweet and tangy. Perfect side for anything!
- Baked Potato Salad$3.79+
Bacon. White Cheddar. Scallions.
- Dipping Sauces$0.65+
Baked Potato Salad
Bacon. White Cheddar. Scallions.
Chicken
- Crispy chicken$8.99
Crispy buttermilk chicken breast, Special sauce, LTO. On a brioche bun
- Nashville Hot Sandwich$9.99
Crispy buttermilk chicken breast, spices, Carolina coleslaw, and B&B pickles. On a brioche bun
- Grilled Sammy$8.99
Grilled buttermilk chicken, Cooper American, herb mayo, LTO. On a brioche bun
Salads
- House Salad$7.99
Iceberg, cherry tomatoes, red onions, red cabbage, boiled egg, and shredded cheddar
- Orchard Salad$10.99
Arugula, dried apricots, sliced almonds, gorgonzola. Served with balsamic vinaigrette
- Chef Salad$10.99
Iceberg, tomatoes, red onions, red cabbage, boiled egg, ham, turkey, sharp provolone
- Kobb Salad$10.99
Iceberg, tomatoes, onions, red cabbage, boiled egg, bacon, avocado and gorgonzola crumbles. Served with blue cheese
- Puebla Salad$12.99
Tajin grilled chicken, iceberg lettuce, pickled red onions, avocado, grape tomatoes, and queso cotija. Served with Jalapeno Ranch
- Memphis Salad$12.99
Memphis BBQ chicken, iceberg, pickled red onions, red cabbage, grape tomatoes, white cheddar. Recommended with buttermilk ranch
Burgers
Cheesesteaks
- Bobby’s Cheesesteak$13.99
Shaved ribeye, caramelized onions, truffle whiz, cherry pepper mayo
- Cali Style$13.99
Shaved ribeye, caramelized onions, cherry pepper mayo, tomatoes, Cooper American, and lettuce
- Chicken Cheesesteak$12.99
chopped grilled chicken, caramelized onions, cherry pepper mayo, Cooper American
Deli Sandwiches
- The Turk$12.49
Roasted turkey, Findlandia swiss, avocado, herb mayo, LTO
- Pilgrim$13.49
Roasted turkey, mild cheddar, cranberry mayo, applewood bacon, LTO
- Ham & Cheese$9.99
cotto ham, Sharp Provolone, herb mayo, LTO
- Italian$10.79
Cotto ham, Genoa salami, sharp provolone, cherry peppers, LTO, and O/V
- Big Vito$12.99
Pistachio mortadella, spicy soppressata, cotto ham, sharp provolone, herb mayo, O/V, cherry peppers and arugula.
- Johnny Boy$12.49
Prosciutto crudo, spicy soppressata, fresh mozz, arugula, truffle oil
- BLTA$12.99
Applewood bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomatoes, and cranberry mayo
- Don Parma$11.79
Prosciutto crudo, fig jam, fresh mozzarella, arugula
- Brooklyn$12.99
Pastrami, Finlandia swiss, Carolina coleslaw, B&B pickles, russian dressing
- Caprese$9.99
Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, avocado, tomatoes, EVOO, & fig balsamic glaze
- Sicilian$12.49
Pistachio mortadella, basil pesto aioli, fresh mozzarella, crushed Sicilian pistachios, and arugula
- Diablo$12.49
Spicy soppressata, habanero jack cheese, Calabrian chili-honey, arugula
- el Ricky$12.49
pastrami, horseradish cream, mild cheddar, pickled red onions, arugula
- Canelo$12.99
Chorizo, ghost pepper cheddar, tomatillo jam, avocado, arugula
Kids
Sweets
Beverages
Dog Cookies
Catering
Sandwiches
- Sandwich Lunch Box$12.00
5” sandwich, small chips bag, and chocolate chip cookie (minimum 6 required). Choose up to 3 types
- Sandwich Party Box$54.99
Eight 5" sandwiches. Choose up to 2 different sandwiches. Served with lettuce & tomatoes. Onions and condiments on the side unless specified otherwise.
- Brioche Box$56.99
Seven sandwiches made on toasted Brioche Buns. Turkey + Cheddar and/or Cotto Ham + Swiss. Lettuce + Tomatoes. Mayo variety on side.
Salads
- House Salad Tray$24.99
Feeds up to 6. Choose 2 dressings. Serving utensils provided.
- Orchard Salad Tray$32.99
Feeds up to 6. Choose 2 dressings. Serving utensils provided.
- Chef Salad Tray$32.99
Feeds up to 6. Choose 2 dressings. Serving utensils provided.
- Kobb Salad Tray$32.99
Feeds up to 6. Choose 2 dressings. Serving utensils provided.
Sides
- Mac N' Cheese Tray$49.99
Gouda, parm, cheddar, bacon, cavatappi. Ideal for up to 10 people served with other food. Serving utensils provided.
- Carolina Coleslaw$14.99
Ideal for up to 6 people served with other food. Serving utensil provided.
- Baked Potato Salad$17.99
Ideal for up to 6 people served with other food. Serving utensil provided.
Sunday | 10:45 am - 8:00 pm |
Monday | 10:45 am - 8:00 pm |
Tuesday | Closed |
Wednesday | 10:45 am - 8:00 pm |
Thursday | 10:45 am - 8:00 pm |
Friday | 10:45 am - 9:00 pm |
Saturday | 10:45 am - 9:00 pm |
Elevated, Chef-Driven Sandwiches & Salads
1878 E lincoln highway, Lancaster, PA 17602