Skip to Main content
  • Uncle Menny's Original Greek's Pizzeria Valparaiso

    • Home
    • /
    • Valparaiso
    • /
    • Uncle Menny's Original Greek's Pizzeria - Valparaiso
    Restaurant banner image
    Pizza

    Uncle Menny's Original Greek's Pizzeria - Valparaiso

    59 Indiana Ave

    Valparaiso, IN 46383


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    MONTHLY SPECIALS
    KNOTZ
    SALADS
    SANDWICHES
    BUILD IT UP PIZZAS
    SPECIALTY PIZZAS
    SIDES, SAUCES & DRESSINGS
    DRINKS
    COOKIES
    PIZZA KIT
    ‌
    ‌

    Featured Items

    • 16" PIZZA

      DESIGN YOUR OWN PIZZA TO BE PREPARED AND COOKED BY UNCLE MENNY. ORDERING INSTRUCTIONS: ALL PIZZAS START WITH OUR CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE. PLEASE PUT ITEMS YOU WOULD LIKE ON THE WHOLE PIZZA FIRST. THEN SEPARATE 1/2 ITEMS BY 1st HALF AND 2nd HALF AS APPLICABLE. DUPLICATE OR MORE ORDERED ITEMS WILL RESULT IN AN EXTRA CHARGE AS WELL AS EXTRA TOPPINGS APPLIED.
      $20.30
    • FULL GARLIC KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, GARLIC SALT AND PARMESAN
      $5.75
    • 12" PIZZA

      DESIGN YOUR OWN PIZZA TO BE PREPARED AND COOKED BY UNCLE MENNY. ORDERING INSTRUCTIONS: ALL PIZZAS START WITH OUR CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE. PLEASE PUT ITEMS YOU WOULD LIKE ON THE WHOLE PIZZA FIRST. THEN SEPARATE 1/2 ITEMS BY 1st HALF AND 2nd HALF AS APPLICABLE. DUPLICATE OR MORE ORDERED ITEMS WILL RESULT IN AN EXTRA CHARGE AS WELL AS EXTRA TOPPINGS APPLIED.
      $13.80

    MONTHLY SPECIALS

    MONTHLY SALAD

    • JIGGLY’S SATP

      MIXED FRUIT SERVED WITH A CREAM CHEESE MARSHMALLOW SPREAD
      $8.70

    MONTHLY KNOTZ

    • HALF LIFE & LEMONS

      KNOTZ COVERED IN LEMON, BUTTER, GRAHAM CRACKER AND POWDERED SUGAR SERVED WITH A SIDE OF CREAM CHEESE FROSTING
      $5.00
    • FULL LIFE & LEMONS

      KNOTZ COVERED IN LEMON, BUTTER, GRAHAM CRACKER AND POWDERED SUGAR SERVED WITH A SIDE OF CREAM CHEESE FROSTING
      $7.75

    MONTHLY SANDWICH

    • CHICKEN PEETA

      GREEK CHICKEN, TZATZIKI, DICED TOMATO, RED ONION AND FETA CHEESE SERVED ON FRENCH BREAD (PEPPERONCINI UPON REQUEST)
      $8.10

    MONTHLY PIZZA

    • 10" BURNT TOAST

      THIN CRUST COVERED IN OLIVE OIL, HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, FETA, KALAMATA OLIVES, CHOPPED GARLIC AND ANCHOVIES PREPARED WELL DONE THEN TOPPED WITH FRESH BRUSCHETTA
      $17.65
    • 12" BURNT TOAST

      THIN CRUST COVERED IN OLIVE OIL, HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, FETA, KALAMATA OLIVES, CHOPPED GARLIC AND ANCHOVIES PREPARED WELL DONE THEN TOPPED WITH FRESH BRUSCHETTA
      $21.75
    • 16" BURNT TOAST

      THIN CRUST COVERED IN OLIVE OIL, HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, FETA, KALAMATA OLIVES, CHOPPED GARLIC AND ANCHOVIES PREPARED WELL DONE THEN TOPPED WITH FRESH BRUSCHETTA
      $29.75

    MONTHLY POP UP

    • WINGS

      6 OVEN BAKED CHICKEN WINGS
      $8.50
    • BOLI BASKET

      CHICKEN STRIPS AND BOLI BREAD SERVED WITH A SIDE OF BOLI SAUCE
      $7.50
    • BURGER

      A BURGER WITH AMERICAN CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, RED ONION AND A DILL PICKLE SERVED WITH A SIDE OF CHIPS
      $7.50
    • KID AT HEART

      MUNSTER, MOZZARELLA AND AMERICAN CHEESE WITH FRESH BASIL ON SOURDOUGH BREAD SERVED WITH A SIDE OF OUR CLASSIC RED SAUCE
      $7.00
    • SPAGHETTI AND MEAT BALLS

      SPAGHETTI WITH RED SAUCE AND MEATBALLS
      $7.50

    KNOTZ

    GARLIC

    • HALF GARLIC KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, GARLIC SALT AND PARMESAN
      $3.65
    • FULL GARLIC KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, GARLIC SALT AND PARMESAN
      $5.75

    PARMESAN

    • HALF PARM KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER AND PARMESAN
      $3.65
    • FULL PARM KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER AND PARMESAN
      $5.75

    HERB

    • HALF HERB KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, ITALIAN SEASONING AND PARMESAN
      $3.65
    • FULL HERB KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, ITALIAN SEASONING AND PARMESAN
      $5.75

    GRECIAN

    • HALF GRECIAN KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, OLIVE OIL, GREEK SEASONING, OREGANO AND FETA WITH A SQUEEZE OF FRESH LEMON
      $4.95
    • FULL GRECIAN KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, OLIVE OIL, GREEK SEASONING, OREGANO AND FETA WITH A SQUEEZE OF FRESH LEMON
      $8.25

    MATT'S EVERYTHING

    • HALF MATT'S EVERYTHING KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, OLIVE OIL, GARLIC SALT, CELERY SALT, ITALIAN SEASONING, FETA AND PARMESAN WITH A SIDE OF CREAMY GARLIC DRESSING
      $6.00
    • FULL MATT'S EVERYTHING KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, OLIVE OIL, GARLIC SALT, CELERY SALT, ITALIAN SEASONING, FETA AND PARMESAN WITH A SIDE OF CREAMY GARLIC DRESSING
      $8.50

    BUFFALO

    • HALF BUFFALO KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN BUFFALO SAUCE, PARMESAN AND BLUE CHEESE CRUMBLES SERVED WITH A SIDE OF BLUE CHEESE DRESSING
      $4.95
    • FULL BUFFALO KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN BUFFALO SAUCE, PARMESAN AND BLUE CHEESE CRUMBLES SERVED WITH A SIDE OF BLUE CHEESE DRESSING
      $8.25

    PLAIN

    • HALF PLAIN KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ WITH NOT A THING ON THEM
      $3.65
    • FULL PLAIN KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ WITH NOT A THING ON THEM
      $5.75

    CINNAMON & SUGAR

    • HALF CINNAMON KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, CINNAMON AND SUGAR
      $3.65
    • FULL CINNAMON KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, CINNAMON AND SUGAR
      $5.75

    MEXICAN HOT CHOCOLATE

    • HALF MEXICAN HOT CHOCOLATE KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, CHOCOLATE, CINNAMON AND SUGAR
      $4.95
    • FULL MEXICAN HOT CHOCOLATE KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, CHOCOLATE, CINNAMON AND SUGAR
      $7.50

    CARAMEL

    • HALF CARAMEL KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, CARAMEL AND POWDERED SUGAR
      $4.95
    • FULL CARAMEL KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, CARAMEL AND POWDERED SUGAR
      $7.50

    CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER

    • HALF CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, PEANUT BUTTER, CHOCOLATE AND CRUSHED CANDY
      $4.95
    • FULL CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN BUTTER, PEANUT BUTTER, CHOCOLATE AND CRUSHED CANDY
      $7.50

    S'MORES

    • HALF S'MORES KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN MARSHMALLOW, CHOCOLATE, BUTTER AND CRUSHED GRAHM CRACKERS
      $4.95
    • FULL S'MORES KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN MARSHMALLOW, CHOCOLATE, BUTTER AND CRUSHED GRAHM CRACKERS
      $7.50

    SECRET SWEET

    • HALF SECRET SWEET KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN CARAMEL, MARSHMALLOW, BUTTER, POWDERED SUGAR AND A BUTTERY CRUMBLED CANDY BAR
      $4.95
    • FULL SECRET SWEET KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN CARAMEL, MARSHMALLOW, BUTTER, POWDERED SUGAR AND A BUTTERY CRUMBLED CANDY BAR
      $7.50

    FLUFFERNUTTER

    • HALF FLUFFERNUTTER KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN PEANUT BUTTER, MARSHMALLOW, BUTTER AND POWDERED SUGAR
      $4.95
    • FULL FLUFFERNUTTER KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN PEANUT BUTTER, MARSHMALLOW, BUTTER AND POWDERED SUGAR
      $7.50

    TURTLE

    • HALF TURTLE KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN CHOCOLATE, CARAMEL, PEACANS, BUTER AND POWDERED SUGAR
      $4.95
    • FULL TURTLE KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN CHOCOLATE, CARAMEL, PEACANS, BUTER AND POWDERED SUGAR
      $7.50

    HONEY PECAN (LOUKOUMADES)

    • HALF HONEY PECAN KNOTZ

      FOUR KNOTZ COVERED IN HONEY, CRUSHED PEACANS, CINNAMON AND POWDERED SUGAR
      $4.95
    • FULL HONEY PECAN KNOTZ

      EIGHT KNOTZ COVERED IN HONEY, CRUSHED PEACANS, CINNAMON AND POWDERED SUGAR
      $7.50

    SILVER FOX

    • HALF SILVER FOX

      KNOTZ WITH OLIVE OIL, SEA SALT, CRACKED PEPPER AND PARM
      $3.65
    • FULL SILVER FOX

      KNOTZ WITH OLIVE OIL, SEA SALT, CRACKED PEPPER AND PARM
      $5.75

    SALADS

    ANTIPASTO SALAD

    • ANTIPASTO

      CHOPPED ROMAINE LETTUCE, DANISH HAM, GENOA SALAMI, BLACK OLIVES, GREEN OLIVES, PROVOLONE CHEESE, PEPPERONCINI PEPPER, ROMA TOMATOES, GREEN PEPPERS AND ONIONS SERVED WITH OUR HOUSE VINAIGRETTE (ANCHOVIES ADDED UPON REQUEST)
      $9.90

    GREEK SALAD

    • GREEK

      CHOPPED ROMAINE LETTUCE, FETA, KALAMATA OLIVES, PEPPERONCINI PEPPER, ROMA TOMATOES, GREEN PEPPERS AND ONIONS SERVED WITH OUR HOUSE VINAIGRETTE (ANCHOVIES ADDED UPON REQUEST)
      $6.95

    HOUSE SALAD

    • HOUSE

      CHOPPED ROMAINE LETTUCE, ROMA TOMATOES, GREEN PEPPERS AND ONIONS
      $4.95

    WEDGE

    • CLASSIC WEDGE

      ICEBERG LETTUCE, DICED TOMATOES, RED ONIONS, CRISP BACON SERVED WITH OUR HOMEMADE BLUE CHEESE DRESSING
      $9.90

    SIMPLE SALAD

    • A SIMPLE SALAD

      FRESH ARUGULA TOPPED WITH LEMON, OLIVE OIL, AND PARMESAN CHEESE
      $5.50

    SANDWICHES

    CHICKENBOLI

    • 6" CHICKENBOLI

      MOM'S SPECIAL "BOLI" SAUCE, CHICKEN, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE ON FRENCH BREAD
      $8.10

    ITALIAN BEEF

    • 6" ITALIAN BEEF

      ITALIAN BEEF, AUJUS ON SANDWICH, GREEN PEPPERS AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE ON FRENCH BREAD
      $9.50

    STROMBOLI

    • 6" STROMBOLI

      CRUMBLED ITALIAN SAUSAGE, CLASSIC RED SAUCE, GREEN PEPPERS, ONIONS AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE ON FRENCH BREAD
      $8.10

    CLASSIC MEATBALL

    • 6" MEATBALL

      ITALIAN MEATBALLS, CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE ON FRENCH BREAD
      $8.10

    HAMBOLI

    • 6" HAMBOLI

      MOM'S SPECIAL "BOLI" SAUCE, DANISH HAM, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE ON FRENCH BREAD
      $8.10

    DANISH HAM & CHEESE

    • 6" DANISH HAM & CHEESE

      DANISH HAM, CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE ON FRENCH BREAD
      $8.10

    ITALIAN SAUSAGE

    • 6" ITALIAN SAUSAGE

      CRUMBLED ITALIAN SAUSAGE, CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE ON FRENCH BREAD
      $8.10

    "BOLI" BLT

    • 6" "BOLI" BLT

      MOM'S SPECIAL "BOLI" SAUCE, BACON, DICED ROMA TOMATOES, ROMAINE LETTUCE AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE ON FRENCH BREAD
      $8.10

    THE VEGGIE

    • 6" THE VEGGIE

      CLASSIC RED SAUCE, BROCCOLI, ZUCCHINI, ARTICHOKE HEARTS, ROMA TOMATOES, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, MUSHROOMS AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE ON FRENCH BREAD
      $8.10

    BARBY’S B&C

    ITALIAN BEEF AND WHITE ONION WITH A BBQ, BUFFALO SAUCE BASE SMOTHERED IN MILD CHEDDAR CHEESE SERVED ON A GARLIC FRENCH BREAD
    • BARBY’S B&C

      ITALIAN BEEF AND WHITE ONION WITH A BBQ, BUFFALO SAUCE BASE SMOTHERED IN MILD CHEDDAR CHEESE SERVED ON A GARLIC FRENCH BREAD
      $8.10

    BUILD IT UP PIZZAS

    START BUILDING

    ORDERING INSTRUCTIONS: ALL PIZZAS START WITH OUR CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE. PLEASE PUT ITEMS YOU WOULD LIKE ON THE WHOLE PIZZA FIRST. THEN SEPARATE 1/2 ITEMS BY 1st HALF AND 2nd HALF AS APPLICABLE. DUPLICATE OR MORE ORDERED ITEMS WILL RESULT IN AN EXTRA CHARGE AS WELL AS EXTRA TOPPINGS APPLIED.
    • 10" PIZZA

      DESIGN YOUR OWN PIZZA TO BE PREPARED AND COOKED BY UNCLE MENNY. ORDERING INSTRUCTIONS: ALL PIZZAS START WITH OUR CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE. PLEASE PUT ITEMS YOU WOULD LIKE ON THE WHOLE PIZZA FIRST. THEN SEPARATE 1/2 ITEMS BY 1st HALF AND 2nd HALF AS APPLICABLE. DUPLICATE OR MORE ORDERED ITEMS WILL RESULT IN AN EXTRA CHARGE AS WELL AS EXTRA TOPPINGS APPLIED.
      $10.60
    • 12" PIZZA

      DESIGN YOUR OWN PIZZA TO BE PREPARED AND COOKED BY UNCLE MENNY. ORDERING INSTRUCTIONS: ALL PIZZAS START WITH OUR CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE. PLEASE PUT ITEMS YOU WOULD LIKE ON THE WHOLE PIZZA FIRST. THEN SEPARATE 1/2 ITEMS BY 1st HALF AND 2nd HALF AS APPLICABLE. DUPLICATE OR MORE ORDERED ITEMS WILL RESULT IN AN EXTRA CHARGE AS WELL AS EXTRA TOPPINGS APPLIED.
      $13.80
    • 16" PIZZA

      DESIGN YOUR OWN PIZZA TO BE PREPARED AND COOKED BY UNCLE MENNY. ORDERING INSTRUCTIONS: ALL PIZZAS START WITH OUR CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE. PLEASE PUT ITEMS YOU WOULD LIKE ON THE WHOLE PIZZA FIRST. THEN SEPARATE 1/2 ITEMS BY 1st HALF AND 2nd HALF AS APPLICABLE. DUPLICATE OR MORE ORDERED ITEMS WILL RESULT IN AN EXTRA CHARGE AS WELL AS EXTRA TOPPINGS APPLIED.
      $20.30
    • 12" SICILIAN CRUST

      TAKE OUR 12" x 9" SICILIAN CRUST (2 INCHES HIGH THROUGHOUT) AND TOP IT WITH ANY ITEMS FROM THE "BUILD IT UP" MENU. SICILIAN PIZZAS START WITH OUR CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE.
      OUT OF STOCK
      $15.80
    • 10” GLUTEN FREE

      ORDERING INSTRUCTIONS: CHOOSE WHICH TYPE OF GLUTEN FREE CRUST YOU WOULD LIKE. ALL PIZZAS START WITH OUR CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE. PLEASE PUT ITEMS YOU WOULD LIKE ON THE WHOLE PIZZA FIRST. THEN SEPARATE 1/2 ITEMS BY 1st HALF AND 2nd HALF AS APPLICABLE. DUPLICATE OR MORE ORDERED ITEMS WILL RESULT IN AN EXTRA CHARGE AS WELL AS EXTRA TOPPINGS APPLIED.
      $10.60

    SPECIALTY PIZZAS

    CAROL'S CHOICE

    • 10" CAROL'S CHOICE

      THIN CRUST, OLIVE OIL TOPPED WITH LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, ARTICHOKE HEARTS, FETA AND DILL
      $17.65
    • 12" CAROL'S CHOICE

      THIN CRUST, OLIVE OIL TOPPED WITH LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, ARTICHOKE HEARTS, FETA AND DILL
      $21.75
    • 16" CAROL'S CHOICE

      THIN CRUST, OLIVE OIL TOPPED WITH LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, ARTICHOKE HEARTS, FETA AND DILL
      $29.75

    CALABRIESE

    • 10" CALABRIESE

      THIN CRUST, LIGHT CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, PROVOLONE CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, GENOA SALAMI, ARTICHOKE HEARTS, BLACK OLIVES, GREEN OLIVES AND CAPERS (ANCHOVIES ADDED UPON REQUEST)
      $17.65
    • 12" CALABRIESE

      THIN CRUST, LIGHT CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, PROVOLONE CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, GENOA SALAMI, ARTICHOKE HEARTS, BLACK OLIVES, GREEN OLIVES AND CAPERS (ANCHOVIES ADDED UPON REQUEST)
      $21.75
    • 16" CALABRIESE

      THIN CRUST, LIGHT CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, PROVOLONE CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, GENOA SALAMI, ARTICHOKE HEARTS, BLACK OLIVES, GREEN OLIVES AND CAPERS (ANCHOVIES ADDED UPON REQUEST)
      $29.75

    5 CHEESE WHITE

    • 10" 5 CHEESE WHITE

      THIN CRUST WITH AN OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH OUR HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, PROVOLONE CHEESE, FETA, FRESH MOZZARELLA, PARMESAN, GARLIC AND FRESH BASIL
      $17.65
    • 12" 5 CHEESE WHITE

      THIN CRUST WITH AN OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH OUR HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, PROVOLONE CHEESE, FETA, FRESH MOZZARELLA, PARMESAN, GARLIC AND FRESH BASIL
      $21.75
    • 16' 5 CHEESE WHITE

      THIN CRUST WITH AN OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH OUR HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, PROVOLONE CHEESE, FETA, FRESH MOZZARELLA, PARMESAN, GARLIC AND FRESH BASIL
      $29.75

    NAPOLI

    • 10" NAPOLI

      THIN CRUST, OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH A LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, PROVOLONE CHEESE, GARLIC, FRESH SPINACH AND ITALINAN SEASONING
      $17.65
    • 12" NAPOLI

      THIN CRUST, OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH A LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, PROVOLONE CHEESE, GARLIC, FRESH SPINACH AND ITALINAN SEASONING
      $21.75
    • 16" NAPOLI

      THIN CRUST, OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH A LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, PROVOLONE CHEESE, GARLIC, FRESH SPINACH AND ITALINAN SEASONING
      $29.75

    HOUSE SPECIAL

    • 10" HOUSE SPECIAL

      REGULAR CRUST PIZZA, CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH SAUSAGE, PEPPERONI, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, MUSHROOMS AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE
      $17.65
    • 12" HOUSE SPECIAL

      REGULAR CRUST PIZZA, CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH SAUSAGE, PEPPERONI, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, MUSHROOMS AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE
      $21.75
    • 16" HOUSE SPECIAL

      REGULAR CRUST PIZZA, CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH SAUSAGE, PEPPERONI, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, MUSHROOMS AND HOUSE BLEND CHEESE
      $29.75

    BRUSCHETTA

    • 10" BRUSCHETTA

      THIN CRUST, OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, DICED TOMATOES, BLACK OLIVES, FETA, GARLIC AND FRESH BASIL
      $17.65
    • 12" BRUSCHETTA

      THIN CRUST, OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, DICED TOMATOES, BLACK OLIVES, FETA, GARLIC AND FRESH BASIL
      $21.75
    • 16" BRUSCHETTA

      THIN CRUST, OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, DICED TOMATOES, BLACK OLIVES, FETA, GARLIC AND FRESH BASIL
      $29.75

    CHICKEN BOLI

    • 10" CHICKEN BOLI

      REGULAR CRUST, SMOTHERED IN 'BOLI' SAUCE THEN TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, TOMATOES, CHICKEN, GREEN PEPPERS, ONIONS AND DRY BASIL (BACON ADDED UPON REQUEST)
      $17.65
    • 12" CHICKEN BOLI

      REGULAR CRUST, SMOTHERED IN 'BOLI' SAUCE THEN TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, TOMATOES, CHICKEN, GREEN PEPPERS, ONIONS AND DRY BASIL (BACON ADDED UPON REQUEST)
      $21.75
    • 16" CHICKEN BOLI

      REGULAR CRUST, SMOTHERED IN 'BOLI' SAUCE THEN TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, TOMATOES, CHICKEN, GREEN PEPPERS, ONIONS AND DRY BASIL (BACON ADDED UPON REQUEST)
      $29.75

    THE VEGGIE

    • 10" VEGGIE

      REGULAR CRUST, CLASSIC RED SAUCE BASE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, MUSHROOMS, BROCCOLI, ZUCCHINI, ARTICHOKE HEARTS AND ROMA TOMATOES
      $17.65
    • 12" VEGGIE

      REGULAR CRUST, CLASSIC RED SAUCE BASE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, MUSHROOMS, BROCCOLI, ZUCCHINI, ARTICHOKE HEARTS AND ROMA TOMATOES
      $21.75
    • 16" VEGGIE

      REGULAR CRUST, CLASSIC RED SAUCE BASE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, MUSHROOMS, BROCCOLI, ZUCCHINI, ARTICHOKE HEARTS AND ROMA TOMATOES
      $29.75

    SPANA KOPITA

    • 10" SPANA KOPITA

      THIN CRUST, OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH FRESH SPINACH, LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ONIONS, FETA AND DILL
      $17.65
    • 12" SPANA KOPITA

      THIN CRUST, OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH FRESH SPINACH, LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ONIONS, FETA AND DILL
      $21.75
    • 16" SPANA KOPITA

      THIN CRUST, OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH FRESH SPINACH, LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ONIONS, FETA AND DILL
      $29.75

    CHICKEN FLORENTINE

    • 10' CHICKEN FLORENTINE

      REGULAR CRUST, CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, CHICKEN, GARLIC, DRY BASIL AND SPINACH
      $17.65
    • 12" CHICKEN FLORENTINE

      REGULAR CRUST, CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, CHICKEN, GARLIC, DRY BASIL AND SPINACH
      $21.75
    • 16" CHICKEN FLORENTINE

      REGULAR CRUST, CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, CHICKEN, GARLIC, DRY BASIL AND SPINACH
      $29.75

    KANSAS CITY SHUFFLE

    • 10" KANSAS CITY SHUFFLE

      REGULAR CRUST, BBQ TOPPED HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, YOUR CHOICE OF BEEF OR CHICKEN, ONIONS, AND GREEN PEPPERS (PEPPERONCINI PEPPERS ADDED UPON REQUEST)
      $17.65
    • 12" KANSAS CITY SHUFFLE

      REGULAR CRUST, BBQ TOPPED HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, YOUR CHOICE OF BEEF OR CHICKEN, ONIONS, AND GREEN PEPPERS (PEPPERONCINI PEPPERS ADDED UPON REQUEST)
      $21.75
    • 16" KANSAS CITY SHUFFLE

      REGULAR CRUST, BBQ TOPPED HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, YOUR CHOICE OF BEEF OR CHICKEN, ONIONS, AND GREEN PEPPERS (PEPPERONCINI PEPPERS ADDED UPON REQUEST)
      $29.75

    MEDITERRANEAN

    • 10" MEDITERRANEAN

      REGULAR CRUST, CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, BROCCOLI, FETA, GARLIC AND SESAME SEEDS
      $17.65
    • 12" MEDITERRANEAN

      REGULAR CRUST, CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, BROCCOLI, FETA, GARLIC AND SESAME SEEDS
      $21.75
    • 16" MEDITERRANEAN

      REGULAR CRUST, CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, BROCCOLI, FETA, GARLIC AND SESAME SEEDS
      $29.75

    FRENCH CONNECTION

    • 10" FRENCH CONNECTION

      THIN CRUST, DIJON MUSTARD TOPPED WITH LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, CHICKEN, FRESH SPINACH AND DRY BASIL
      $17.65
    • 12" FRENCH CONNECTION

      THIN CRUST, DIJON MUSTARD TOPPED WITH LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, CHICKEN, FRESH SPINACH AND DRY BASIL
      $21.75
    • 16" FRENCH CONNECTION

      THIN CRUST, DIJON MUSTARD TOPPED WITH LIGHT HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, CHICKEN, FRESH SPINACH AND DRY BASIL
      $29.75

    EL GRECO

    • 10" EL GRECO

      REGULAR CRUST, CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, ONIONS, KALAMATA OLIVES, FETA AND OREGANO
      $17.65
    • 12" EL GRECO

      REGULAR CRUST, CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, ONIONS, KALAMATA OLIVES, FETA AND OREGANO
      $21.75
    • 16" EL GRECO

      REGULAR CRUST, CLASSIC RED SAUCE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLEND CHEESE, ROMA TOMATOES, ONIONS, KALAMATA OLIVES, FETA AND OREGANO
      $29.75

    MIGHTY DYNESSIE

    • 10" THE MIGHTY DYNESSIE

      HAND TOSSED CRUST WITH A OG SAUCE BASE, FRESH MOZZARELLA, DOUBLE BAKED PEPPERONI, FETA CHEESE, ARUGULA AND HONEY
      $17.65
    • 12" THE MIGHTY DYNESSIE

      HAND TOSSED CRUST WITH A OG SAUCE BASE, FRESH MOZZARELLA, DOUBLE BAKED PEPPERONI, FETA CHEESE, ARUGULA AND HONEY
      $21.75
    • 16" THE MIGHTY DYNESSIE

      HAND TOSSED CRUST WITH A OG SAUCE BASE, FRESH MOZZARELLA, DOUBLE BAKED PEPPERONI, FETA CHEESE, ARUGULA AND HONEY
      $29.75

    WHAT’S IN THE BOX

    • 10" WHAT'S IN THE BOX

      EXTRA CRUST, OLIVE OIL BASE, EXTRA CHEESE TOPPED WITH CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND PARMESAN CHEESE SERVED WITH A SIDE OF CREAMY GARLIC
      $16.15
    • 12" WHAT'S IN THE BOX

      EXTRA CRUST, OLIVE OIL BASE, EXTRA CHEESE TOPPED WITH CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND PARMESAN CHEESE SERVED WITH A SIDE OF CREAMY GARLIC
      $19.70
    • 16" WHAT'S IN THE BOX

      EXTRA CRUST, OLIVE OIL BASE, EXTRA CHEESE TOPPED WITH CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND PARMESAN CHEESE SERVED WITH A SIDE OF CREAMY GARLIC
      $26.95

    ROCKIT

    • 10" THE ROCKIT

      HAND TOSSED REGULAR CRUST, ORIGINAL GREEKS "OG" RED SAUCE, HOUSE BLENDED CHEESE, PEPPERONI, ITALIAN SEASONING.. NOT DABBED OFF.. THEN COVERED IN PARMESAN. MAKE IT COWABUNGA DUDE AND SUB THE PARM FOR CHOCOLATE SAUCE
      $13.45
    • 12" THE ROCKIT

      HAND TOSSED REGULAR CRUST, ORIGINAL GREEKS "OG" RED SAUCE, HOUSE BLENDED CHEESE, PEPPERONI, ITALIAN SEASONING.. NOT DABBED OFF.. THEN COVERED IN PARMESAN. MAKE IT COWABUNGA DUDE AND SUB THE PARM FOR CHOCOLATE SAUCE
      $17.00
    • 16" THE ROCKIT

      HAND TOSSED REGULAR CRUST, ORIGINAL GREEKS "OG" RED SAUCE, HOUSE BLENDED CHEESE, PEPPERONI, ITALIAN SEASONING.. NOT DABBED OFF.. THEN COVERED IN PARMESAN. MAKE IT COWABUNGA DUDE AND SUB THE PARM FOR CHOCOLATE SAUCE
      $24.25

    DOUBLE DOUBLE

    • 10" DOUBLE DOUBLE

      REGULAR CRUST WITH A OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLENDED CHEESE, HAM, MORE HAM, KOSHER DILL PICKLES, MORE DILL FINISHED WITH A BROWNED CREAMY GARLIC
      $17.65
    • 12" DOUBLE DOUBLE

      REGULAR CRUST WITH A OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLENDED CHEESE, HAM, MORE HAM, KOSHER DILL PICKLES, MORE DILL FINISHED WITH A BROWNED CREAMY GARLIC
      $21.75
    • 16" DOUBLE DOUBLE

      REGULAR CRUST WITH A OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH HOUSE BLENDED CHEESE, HAM, MORE HAM, KOSHER DILL PICKLES, MORE DILL FINISHED WITH A BROWNED CREAMY GARLIC
      $29.75

    SIDES, SAUCES & DRESSINGS

    ORDER SIDES HERE

    • ORIGINAL GREEK'S "O.G." RED SAUCE

      A BOLDER, SWEET AND SPICY OPTION TO OUR CLASSIC RED SAUCE
      $1.50
    • CLASSIC RED SAUCE

      $1.50
    • CHEEDAR CHEESE SIDE

      $1.50
    • LARGE RANCH

      $1.50
    • GARLIC BUTTER

      $1.50
    • MOM'S SPECIAL "BOLI" SAUCE

      $1.50
    • LARGE CREAMY GARLIC

      $1.50
    • LARGE BLEU CHEESE

      $1.50
    • TZATZIKI

      $1.50
    • BUFFALO SAUCE

      $1.50
    • AU JUS

      $1.00
    • PEPPERONCINI PEPPERS

      $1.00
    • FROSTING (SMALL ONLY)

      $1.50
    • SMALL HOUSE (OIL & VINEGAR)

      $0.95
    • SMALL CREAMY GARLIC

      $0.95
    • SMALL RANCH

      $0.95
    • SMALL BLEU CHEESE

      $0.95
    • SMALL FRENCH

      $0.95
    • JAR OF BOLI

      $8.00
    • JAR OF CREAMY GARLIC

      $8.00
    • JAR OF BLEU CHEESE

      $8.00

    DRINKS

    CANS & BOTTLES

    • COKE CAN

      Coca-Cola Original Taste — the crisp, refreshing taste you know and love
      $1.65
    • 6 CANS OF COKE

      $7.20
    • DIET CAN

      Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink
      $1.65
    • 6 CANS OF DIET COKE

      $7.20
    • SPRITE CAN

      Classic, cool, crisp lemon-lime flavored taste that's caffeine free
      $1.65
    • 6 CANS OF SPRITE

      $7.20
    • DR. PEPPER

      $1.65
    • 6 CANS DR. PEPPER

      $7.20
    • BOTTLE OF WATER

      $1.40

    KIDS DRINK

    • JUICE BOX

      $1.30

    COOKIES

    KOLACKZI

    THE FAMOUS COOKIES THAT WERE AT THE CELEBRATION OF LIFE FOR UNCLE MENNY
    • KOLACKZI

      6 OF THE FAMOUS COOKIES THAT WERE FEATURED AT UNCLE MENNY’S CELEBRATION OF LIFE CALL FOR FLAVOR PROFILE
      $9.00

    PIZZA KIT

    "BUILD IT UP PIZZA BOX" KIT

    • 12" ”BUILD IT UP PIZZA BOX” KIT

      OUR BUILD IT UP PIZZA BOX WILL COME WITH ONE 12” DOUGH PATTY, FLOUR, TWO 4oz CUPS OF CLASSIC RED SAUCE AND CHEESE. YOU CAN PICK ANY OTHER TOPPINGS YOU WOULD LIKE TO INCLUDE. PEHEAT OVEN AT 450 DEGREES. COOK FOR 10-15 MINUTE OR UNTIL IT IS TO YOUR LIKING
      $11.85

    BURGER

    $7.50

    A BURGER WITH AMERICAN CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, RED ONION AND A DILL PICKLE SERVED WITH A SIDE OF CHIPS

    Customize your item

    ADD ITEMS SANDWICHES

    Optional

    TAKE OFF BURGER

    Select up to 1
    Request advisory
    No substitutes. Additions may be charged extra.
    1

    All hours
    Sunday4:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Monday4:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    TuesdayClosed
    Wednesday1:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Thursday1:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Friday1:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Saturday1:00 pm - 8:30 pm
    Restaurant info

    • When taste matters. Since 1969 •

    Location

    59 Indiana Ave, Valparaiso, IN 46383

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Benelli’s Pizzeria
    View restaurantnext
    Gelsosomo’s Pizzeria Valparaiso
    View restaurantnext
    Lenny's Coal Fired Pizza 3800 N Calumet Ave
    View restaurantnext
    AJ's Pizza Co 3050 Matson Dr
    View restaurantnext
    The Original Old Mill Pizza Winfield
    View restaurantnext
    Bam Pizza Company
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook