
American
Kitty O'Reillys Irish Pub
59 E Oak St
Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items
MAIN MENU
Appetizers
Seared Ahi Tuna
sesame crusted ahi tuna. avocado. tomato. wasabi aioli.$16.00
Bone-In Wings
bone-in wings. sauce choice: bang-bang sauce, guinness bbq sauce, hot honey sauce, garlic parmesan sauce, franks' hot sauce, garlic teriyaki sauce, kitty's signature sauce, or sweet chili sauce. dipping sauce choice: ranch dressing or blue cheese dressing.$15.00
Bone-Less Wings
bone-less wings. sauce choice: bang-bang sauce, guinness bbq sauce, hot honey sauce, garlic parmesan sauce, franks' hot sauce, garlic teriyaki sauce, kitty's signature sauce, or sweet chili sauce. dipping sauce choice: ranch dressing or blue cheese dressing.$15.00
Cheese Curds
wisconsin white cheddar cheese curds. ranch dressing on side.$12.50
Crab Rangoons
crab mix: cream cheese. garlic. worcestershire. fried egg roll. sweet chili sauce on side.$15.00
Dragon Eggs
grilled chicken. bacon. cream cheese. ranch seasoning. stuffed in jalapeño. ranch dressing on side.$12.50
Kick'n Shrimp
breaded shrimp. bang-bang or garlic teriyaki sauce. ranch dressing.$0+
Lobster Rolls
lobster mix: mayo. cilantro. celery. lemon juice. fried egg roll. melted butter on side.$15.00Nachos Cheez Whiz
seasoned ground beef or grilled chicken. cheez whiz. cheddar cheese. mozzarella cheese. shredded lettuce. black olives. tortilla chips. sour cream. fresh jalapenos.$16.00+
Spinach Artichoke Dip
artichoke. spinach, mozzarella cheese. parmesan cheese. mayo. garlic. garlic salt. served with tortilla chips.$15.00
Walleye Nuggets
$16.00
Irish Favorites

Beef Boxty
guinness braised beef. bacon. guinness mushrooms. caramelized onions. burgundy wine. potato. sour cream on side.$24.00
Atlantic Cod Sandwich
harp-ale hand battered atlantic cod. lettuce. tomatoes. red onion. brioche bun. tartar sauce. lemon wedge. kettle chips.$14.00
Corned Beef & Cabbage
slow-cooked corned beef. cabbage. carrot. red potato.$24.00
Corned Beef Sandwich
hand cut corned beef. swiss cheese. lettuce. tomato. red onion. marble rye. creamy horseradish on side. kettle chips.$18.00
Fish & Chips
harp-ale hand battered cod. tartar sauce on side. coleslaw. lemon. fries.$22.00
Irish Stew
slow-cooked beef. rutabaga. turnip. potato. carrot. onion. peas. corn. savory gravy. sliced marble rye on side$16.00
Open-Faced Ruben
hand cut corned beef. swiss cheese. kraut. marble rye. 1,000 island dressing on side. kettle chips.$18.00
Perch Basket
hand-breaded perch filets. coleslaw. tartar sauce on side. lemon wedge. fries.$26.00
Perch Po Boy
hand battered perch fillets. lettuce. tomatoes. red onion. chipotle aioli. lemon wedge. hoagie roll. kettle chips.$16.00
Shepherd's Pie
slow-cooked beef. rutabaga. turnip. potato. carrot. onion. peas. corn. savory gravy. mashed potatoes. cheddar.$18.00
Shrimp Basket
fried jumbo shrimp. coleslaw. cocktail sauce on side. lemon wedge. fries.$24.00
Salads

Avocado Chicken Salad
arugula. spinach. grilled chicken. red onion. tomatoes. cilantro-black-bean-corn salsa. avocado. balsamic glaze. house balsamic dressing.$16.00
Caesar Salad
romaine lettuce. parmesan cheese. tomatoes. garlic croutons. tossed in creamy caesar dressing. add crispy chicken $6 | grilled chicken $6 | grilled shrimp $6 | grilled salmon $14$14.00
Classic House Salad
mixed greens. cheddar cheese. tomatoes. shaved carrots. red onions. garlic croutons. choice dressing: add: crispy chicken $6 | grilled chicken $6 | grilled shrimp $6 | seared ahi tuna $12 | grilled salmon $14$14.00
Dublin Shrimp Salad
arugula. spinach. grilled shrimp. parmesan cheese. red onion. walnuts. avocado. poppy seed dressing.$16.00
Firecracker Shrimp Salad
mixed greens. breaded shrimp. bang-bang sauce. cheddar cheese. tomato. cilantro-black-bean-corn salsa. avocado. ranch dressing.$16.00
Kitty Cobb Salad
mixed greens. slow-cooked corned beef. bacon. blue cheese crumbles. red onion. tomatoes. avocado. creamy blue cheese dressing.$16.00
Spinach Walnut Salad
spinach. blue cheese crumbles. door county dried cherries. granny smith apples. red onion. walnuts. raspberry vinaigrette dressing. add crispy chicken $6 | grilled chicken $6 | grilled shrimp $6 | grilled salmon $14$16.00
Side Caesar Salad
romaine lettuce. parmesan cheese. tomatoes. garlic croutons. tossed in creamy caesar dressing. add crispy chicken $6 | grilled chicken $6 | grilled shrimp $6 | grilled salmon $14$8.00
Side House Salad
mixed greens. cheddar cheese. tomatoes. shaved carrots. red onions. garlic croutons. choice dressing: add: crispy chicken $6 | grilled chicken $6 | grilled shrimp $6 | seared ahi tuna $12 | grilled salmon $14$7.00
By the Bowl
Burgers
Blue Wagyu Burger
wagyu beef burger. bacon. blue cheese crumbles. caramelized onions. brioche bun. fries.$20.00
Carolina Smash Burger
double 1/4 lb burger, mozzarella cheese, crispy onion strings, garlic aioli, sweet carolina bbq sauce, potato bun & served with fries$16.00
Dill-Light Burger
1/2 lb angus beef burger. bacon. pepper jack cheese. fried pickles. caramelized onions. lettuce. dill sauce. kaiser bun.$16.00
Kitty's Deluxe Burger
angus beef burger. american cheese. dill pickle. lettuce. tomato. mayo on side. kaiser bun. fries.$16.00
Garlic Burger
1/2 lb angus beef burger. mozzarella cheese. lettuce. red onion. garlic burger sauce. kaiser bun.$16.00
Getting Smashed Burger
1/4 lb angus beef burger. smashed with carmalized onion. american cheese. lettuce. dill pickle. kitty’s smashed sauce. kaiser bun. fries.$14.00
On the Border Burger
angus beef burger. fried pepper jack + swiss cheese. caramelized onion. crunchy jalapeño. kaiser bun. chipotle ranch dressing on side. fries.$16.00
Kitty's Patty Melt Burger
angus beef burger. swiss cheese. caramelized onion. marble rye. 1,000 island dressing on side. fries.$16.00
Swiss & Shroom Smash Burger
1/4 lb angus beef burger. swiss cheese. guinness braised mushrooms. garlic aioli. brioche bun. fries. add 1/4 lb burger patty $3$14.00
Wagyu & Whiz Burger
wagyu beef burger. cheez whiz. lettuce. brioche bun. fries.$20.00
Plain 1/2lb Burger
angus beef burger. kaiser bun. fries.$15.00
Tacos & Quesadillas

Lobster Tacos
two lobster tacos - lobster mix: mayo. cilantro. celery. lemon juice. mozzarella cheese. tomato. chipotle aioli. lemon wedge. flour tortillas.$16.00
Mahi Tacos
three grilled mahi tacos - avocado. red cabbage. red onion. tomato. chipotle aioli. lemon wedge. flour tortillas.$16.00
Shrimp Tacos
three grilled shrimp tacos- avocado. arugula. cilantro black bean corn salsa. chipotle aioli. lemon wedge. flour tortillas.$16.00
Quesadilla
cheddar. mozzarella cheese. green pepper. red onion. tomato. flour tortilla. salsa & sour cream on side. add: chicken. grilled shrimp. or shaved steak. $4$14.00
Sandwiches & Wraps

Kitty's Cheese Steak
shaved ribeye. cheez whiz. caramelized onions. hoagie roll. kettle chips. add guinness braised mushrooms $2 | add sauteed green peppers $2$16.00
Chicken Caesar Wrap
crispy chicken. romaine lettuce. shredded parmesan cheese. creamy caesar dressing. flour tortilla. kettle chips.$16.00
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
crispy chicken. lettuce. pickles. kitty's signature sauce. broiche bun. kettle chips.$16.00
Kitty's Cubano Sandwich
pulled pork. ham. swiss cheese. dill pickle. yellow mustard. sour dough bread. kettle chips.$16.00
French Dip Sandwich
shaved beef. mozzarella cheese. guinness braised mushrooms. caramelized onions. au jus. hoagie roll. kettle chips.$18.00
Grilled Club Sandwich
bacon. turkey. ham. swiss cheese. mozzarella cheese. lettuce. tomato. texas toast. side of mayo. kettle chips.$16.00Hot Honey Chicken Wrap
crispy chicken. hot honey sauce. lettuce. red onion. tomato. flour tortilla. side of ranch dressing. kettle chips.$16.00
Kilt Tiler Wrap
grilled chicken. hot sauce. cheddar cheese. lettuce. tomato. red onion. flour tortilla. side of chipotle ranch dressing. kettle chips.$16.00
Lobster Boat
lobster mix: mayo, cilantro, celery, lemon juice. lettuce. tomato. garlic aioli. hoagie roll. lemon wedge. kettle chips.$20.00
Pulled Pork Sandwich
pulled pork. guinness bbq sauce. broiche bun. coleslaw. kettle chips.$15.00
Salmon BLTA Sandwich
baked atlantic salmon. bacon. arugula. tomato. pesto sauce. garlic aioili. focaccia bread. kettle chips.$20.00
Shaved Prime Rib Sliders
shaved prime rib. fried onion strings. swiss cheese. creamy horseradish sauce. au jus. ciabatta bun. kettle chips.$16.00
Simply BLT Sandwich
bacon. lettuce. tomato. sour dough bread. kettle chips. add avocado $2$15.00
Tenderloin Sliders
marchant's grilled tenderloin. caramelized onions. guinness braised mushrooms. creamy horseradish sauce. ciabatta bun. kettle chips.$24.00
Turkey Pesto Sandwich
turkey. mozzarella cheese. red onion. spinach. pesto sauce. garlic aioli. focaccia bread. kettle chips.$16.00
Ultimate Grilled Cheese Sandwich
bacon. cheddar cheese. american cheese. mozzarella cheese. tomato. sour dough bread. cup of tomato basil soup.$15.00
Mac & Cheeses

Four Cheese Mac & Cheese
smithwicks beer cheese. cheddar. mozzarella. parmesan. elbow pasta. topped with seasoned panko crumbs.$14.00
Buffalo Mac & Cheese
boneless wings. hot sauce. smithwicks beer cheese. cheddar. mozzarella. parmesan. elbow pasta. topped with seasoned panko crumbs.$16.00
Grilled Shrimp Mac & Cheese
grilled jumbo shrimp. smithwicks beer cheese. cheddar. mozzarella. parmesan. elbow pasta. topped with seasoned panko crumbs.$16.00
Lobster Mac & Cheese
smithwicks beer cheese. cheddar. mozzarella. parmesan. elbow pasta. topped with seasoned panko crumbs.$24.00
Mak'N Bacon Mac & Cheese
$16.00
Pulled Pork Mac & Cheese
pulled pork. guinness bbq. smithwicks beer cheese. cheddar. mozzarella. parmesan. elbow pasta. topped with crunchy jalapeños & seasoned panko crumbs.$16.00
Thursday
BBQ THURSDAY

Texas BBQ Nachos
pulled pork. guinness bbq sauce. mozzarella cheese. cheddar cheese. kettle chips. fresh jalapenos. ranch dressing$14.00
Pulled Pork Sandwich
pulled pork. guinness bbq. coleslaw. kaiser bun. kettle chips.$14.00
BBQ Chicken Salad
mixed greens. bbq grilled chicken. cheddar cheese. cilantro-black-bean-corn salsa. crunchy jalapenos. red onion. tomato. ranch dressing$14.00
Ribs & Fries
baby back ribs. guinness bbq sauce. coleslaw. fries$18.00+

Getting Smashed Burger
$14.00
1/4 lb angus beef burger. smashed with carmalized onion. american cheese. lettuce. dill pickle. kitty’s smashed sauce. kaiser bun. fries.
Customize your item
Fries
Required
Select 1
Getting Smashed
Optional
ALLERGIES
Optional
1
All hours
| Sunday | 9:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Monday | 10:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Thursday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 9:00 pm |
| Saturday | 9:00 am - 9:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Great Food, Great Drinks, Great People, Great Fun
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.


















