Skip to Main content
  • Madfish Grill 4059 Cattlemen Rd

    • Home
    • /
    • Sarasota
    • /
    • Madfish Grill 4059 Cattlemen Rd

    This restaurant does not have any images

    Seafood

    Madfish Grill 4059 Cattlemen Rd

    4059 Cattlemen Rd

    Sarasota, FL 34233


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    For Lunch Take Out Call 941-377-3474
    Dinner
    Chalk Board
    N/A Bevs
    Craft Cocktails Online
    Wines By The Glass
    Kids Menu Online

    For Lunch Take Out Call 941-377-3474

    Lunch not Available Online

    • Lunch Not Available Online


    Dinner

    Apps

    • Bang Shrimp App

      Crispy wild caught shrimp and spicy bang sauce
      $11.90
    • Brussel Sprout App

      Miso glazed, XVOO, sea salt and sriracha aioli
      $10.90
    • Chicken Lemongrass Dumplings

      5 pieces. Fried artisan chicken dumplings and sweet soy & spicy sauce
      $11.90
    • Clam Strip Appetizer

      hand breaded, golden fried + tartar sauce
      $14.90
    • Cocktail Shrimp (5)

      served with lemon & cocktail sauce
      $12.90
    • Cocktail Shrimp Each

      (each) Lemon and house made cocktail
      $2.59
    • Coconut Grouper Fingers App

      with sweet mango chili sauce
      $14.90
    • Deviled Eggs

      4 pieces. Made with love + bacon & spicy sriracha drizzle
      $6.90
    • Eggrolls

      The OG...jerked chicken, rice, black beans, cilantro, cheese + guava jelly & avocado ranch
      $12.90
    • Fried Artichokes

      crispy, fried artichoke hearts with creamy dill sauce
      $11.90
    • Maditaliano Mussels

      a full pound of PEI mussels... sauteed with roasted garlic, wine, cream + butter
      $17.90
    • Shrimp Coconut App (5)

      (4) coconut shrimp with mandarin orange dipping sauce
      $15.90
    • Wings

      (8) Jerk glazed + creamy dill...fan fave since 1999
      $15.90

    Soup/Salad

    • Cup Black Bean Soup

      Rice, red onion + sour cream
      $5.90
    • Cup Crab & Corn Chowder

      Cream based blue crab & corn chowder
      $6.90
    • Cup Lobster Bisque

      Sherry infused + herb oil drizzle
      $6.90
    • Cup Mangospacho

      Tomato based, chilled gaspacho with fresh mango + sour cream topping
      $5.90
    • Bowl Black Bean Soup

      Rice, red onion & sour cream
      $7.90
    • Bowl Crab & Corn Chowder

      Cream based blue crab & corn chowder
      $8.90
    • Bowl Lobster Bisque

      Sherry infused with herb oil drizzle
      $8.90
    • Bowl Mangospacho

      Tomato based, chilled gaspacho with fresh mango + sour cream topping
      $7.90
    • Wedge Salad

      Wedge of iceburg, tomato, bacon + blue cheese dressing
      $9.90
    • Large 4059 Salad

      Iceburg, ham, tomato, green olives, swiss & parmesan cheese + cuban vinaigrette
      $13.90
    • Large Caesar Salad

      Romaine, caesar dressing, parmesan + croutons
      $13.90
    • Large Madhouse Salad

      Mixed greens, tomato, pumpkin seeds, yucca chips + mandarin dressing
      $13.90
    • Large House Salad

      Mixed greens, cucumber, tomato, onion, carrot, croutons + dressing choice
      $13.90
    • Small 4059 Salad

      Iceburg, ham, tomato, green olive, parmesan & swiss cheese + cuban vinaigrette
      $9.90
    • Small Caesar Salad

      Romaine, caesar dressing, croutons + parmesan
      $8.90
    • Small House Salad

      Mixed greens, cucumber, tomato, carrots, onion, croutons + dressing choice
      $8.90
    • Small Madhouse Salad

      Mixed greens, pumpkin seeds, tomato, yucca chips + mandarin dressing
      $7.90
    • Quart Black Bean Soup

      Rice, red onion + sour cream
      $18.00
    • Quart Chowder

      Cream based corn & blue crab chowder
      $22.00
    • Quart Lobster Bisque

      Sherry infused with herb oil drizzle
      $22.00
    • Quart Mangospacho

      Chilled tomato based gaspacho with fresh mango + sour cream
      $18.00

    Handhelds

    • Bang Shrimp BLT

      Crispy fried shrimp, bang sauce, bacon, shredded lettuce, tomato, toasted brioche bread + choose one side
      $17.90
    • Butcher Burger

      1/2 pound chargrilled fresh ground beef from the Butcher Block on 17th St. Choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and brioche bun + choose one side
      $15.90
    • Cobia Burger

      6 oz sustainably raised open blue cobia with more omega 3 acids than salmon! Blackened or grilled with tartar, lettuce, tomato, onion and brioche bun + choose one side
      $17.90
    • Coconut Fish Tacos

      coconut crusted grouper, shredded lettuce mango chile sauce, pineapple, pico de gallo + choose one side
      $16.90
    • Crispy Chicken Tacos

      Breaded chicken thigh, lettuce, cilantro slaw, pico, cheddar-jack cheese, avocado ranch, flour tortillas + black beans & rice
      $15.90
    • D-Reuben Sandwich

      We use ben's grandma bridie's Irish recipe! Corned beef, sliced thin & piled high, swiss, sauerkraut, 1000 island and grilled marble rye + choose one side
      $18.90
    • Grouper Sandwich

      Gulf grouper, lettuce, tomato, onion, tartar, brioche bun + choose one side
      $21.90
    • Hogfish Hoagie

      Hogfish, hoagie roll, tartar sauce + choose one side
      $28.90
    • Key West Fish Sandwich

      Crunchy battered schrod, Cuban roll, lettuce, tomato, onion, tartar + choose one side
      $18.90
    • Mad Cuban

      Pressed ham, pork, swiss, mustard, pickles, fresh Cuban roll + choose one side
      $16.90
    • Mahi Tacos

      2 pieces. These tacos are a local favorite! Lightly blackened mahi, lettuce, pico, cilantro slaw, chipotle aioli, cheddar jack, flour tortilla + choose one side
      $16.90
    • Maine Lobster Roll

      A nod to our new England heritage. ¼ lb chilled lobster, lettuce, mayo, celery, griddled split top, brioche roll + choose one side
      $28.90
    • Nantucket Shrimp Roll (D)

      6oz chilled shrimp, lettuce, Old Bay, mayo, celery + fries
      $18.90
    • Waygu Burger

      1/2 pound Australian Wagyu burger, Amish cheddar, pecanwood bacon, frizzled onion, lettuce, tomato, onion on brioche bun + side choice
      $19.90

    Seafood

    • Bourbon Salmon

      Grilled salmon, bourbon glaze + choose 2 sides
      $28.90
    • Fish & Chips

      Hand battered, wild caught schrod, tartar sauce + choose your side
      $20.90
    • Grouper Chimichanga

      A fan favorite! Blackened Gulf grouper, jasmine rice, chipotle crema, cheddar jack, wrapped in a tortilla, smothered with lobster sherry cream, pico de gallo + choose one side
      $23.90
    • Grouper Fish & Chips

      hand battered grouper, tartar sauce + choose one side
      $24.90
    • Lobster Tail Single

      Single lobster tail with drawn butter + choose two sides
      $24.90
    • Lobster Tails Twin

      Two lobster tails with drawn butter + choose two sides
      $42.90
    • Pan Seared Haddock

      Wild caught haddock sauteed with fresh lemon + choose two sides
      $23.90
    • Poke Tuna Platter

      Diced sushi grade tuna, spicy Hawaiian poke sauce, jasmine rice, cusabi drizzle, sesame seeds wonton crisps and avocado
      $21.90
    • Shrimp Rangoon

      (5) crispy coconut shrimp over herbed cream cheese with sweet Thai chili sauce + choose two sides
      $22.90
    • Todd's Glazed Shrimp

      grilled shrimp, sweet & spicy curry sauce + choose two sides
      $23.90

    Meats

    • Chicken Entree

      Two chicken breasts, cooked your way + choose two sides
      $19.90
    • Coco-Mac Chicken

      Coconut-macadamia crust, mango sauce + choose two sides
      $19.90
    • Martha's Chicken

      Sautéed chicken breast, goat cheese, citrus beurre Blanc, grape tomatoes, spinach + choose two sides
      $19.90
    • Pumpkin Ravioli

      Mascarpone cream, fresh basil, bacon & crispy onions
      $21.90
    • Sous Vide Filet Mignon

      8 oz Iowa premium beef tenderloin + choose two sides
      $32.90
    • Steak Tips

      3/4lb chargrilled sirloin tips (pink or no pink), signature tip glaze, mashed potatoes + dilled carrots
      $25.90

    Bowls & Specialty Salads

    • L-Bang Shrimp Bowl

      Fried wild gulf shrimp, bang sauce, fried rice, Asian vegetables, teriyaki drizzle and cilantro
      $16.90
    • Bonaire Pasta

      Penne pasta, cream alfredo sauce, applewood bacon & scallion + optional protein
      $16.90
    • Cobb Salad

      Mixed greens, bacon, pico, boiled egg, cheddar-jack, honey mustard vinaigrette + choice of protein
      $12.90
    • Large Caesar Salad

      Romaine, caesar dressing, parmesan + croutons
      $13.90
    • Mad Thai

      Pad thai rice noodles, edamame, onion, peppers, carrots, fried egg, cilantro, peanuts, spicy panang sauce + choice of protein
      $15.90
    • Quesadilla Salad

      Romaine, corn, tortilla strips, black beans, cheddar-jack cheese, pico de gallo, avocado ranch, balsamic vinaigrette, quesadilla wedges + choice of protein
      $12.90
    • Shrimp Campanella Pasta

      sautéed shrimp, spinach, tomato, Campanella pasta, sherry cream sauce + basil
      $24.90
    • Shrimp Luis Salad

      a scoop of shrimp salad, romaine, avocado, hard boiled egg, grape tomatoes + a side of creamy dressing
      $18.90
    • SRQ Salad

      Mixed greens, strawberries, goat cheese, candied pecans, balsamic vinaigrette + choice of protein
      $12.90
    • Surf & Turf Caesar

      chargrilled tenderloin & shrimp, romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, creamy caesar dressing + croutons
      $25.90
    • Thai Salad

      romaine, napa cabbage, carrots, bell pepper, edamame, wontons, sesame seeds, spicy peanut dressing + choice of protein
      $13.90

    Desserts

    • Apple Crisp

      Served Ala mode with vanilla bean ice cream
      $10.90
    • Bete Noir

      Chocolate, flourless cake with white chocolate & raspberry drizzle
      $9.90
    • Brownie Lava Cake

      Warm molten chocolate brownie, vanilla ice cream and whipped cream
      $10.90
    • Chocolate Pecan Pie

      "To die for" secret recipe and whipped cream
      $9.90
    • Key Lime Pie

      A "Quintessential" Florida favorite graham cracker crust and whipped cream
      $9.90
    • Pudding Bites

      Served crispy with caramel sauce, vanilla ice cream, cinnamon and whipped cream
      $10.90
    • Sundae

      vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, caramel + chocolate sauce
      $8.90
    • Tiramisu

      Italian ladyfinger cookies dipped in espresso, whipped mascarpone cheese and cocoa powder
      $9.90

    Sides

    • Side Asparagus

      $6.90
    • Side BB & Rice

      $2.90
    • Side Broccoli

      $3.90
    • Side Brussel Sprouts

      $5.90
    • Side Cole Slaw

      $2.90
    • Side Dill Carrots

      $3.90
    • Side Edamame Rice

      $4.90
    • Side Fries

      $3.90
    • Side Fruit

      $3.90
    • Side Homemade Chips

      $3.90
    • Side Jasmine Rice

      $2.90
    • Side Mashed Potatoes

      $3.90
    • Side Onion Ring (4)

      $5.90
    • Side Onion Strings

      $3.90
    • Side Pasta

      $6.00
    • Side Plantains (4 pcs)

      $3.90
    • Side Ste Mushrooms

      $3.90
    • Side Ste Spinach

      $3.90
    • Side Truffle Fries

      $5.90
    • Side Yucca Chips

      $3.90

    Chalk Board

    Catch

    • Clam Strip Entree

      Hand breaded + tartar sauce & choice of two sides New Bedford, MA
      $26.90
    • Haddock

      Alaska
      $23.90
    • Hogfish

      Florida Keys
      $36.90
    • One Lobster Tail

      $24.90
    • Red Grouper

      Gulf of Mexico
      $32.90
    • Salmon

      Florida (Bluehouse)
      $22.90+
    • Sea Scallop Entree

      Massachusetts
      $37.90
    • Shrimp Entree

      $21.90
    • Snapper

      Gulf of Mexico
      $27.90
    • Twin Lobster Tails

      $39.90

    N/A Bevs

    • Bottled Sparkling Water

      $5.90
    • Bottled Still Water

      $5.90
    • Cactus-Berry Sparkler N/A

      cold pressed cactus pear & pomegranate juices, fresh strawberries, sparkling water + lime
      $8.90
    • Citrus NO-jito N/A

      fresh squeezed citrus juices, simple syrup, mint + sparkling water
      $8.90
    • Coffee

      $3.49
    • Cold Brew

      $4.90
    • Flavored Tea

      $3.90
    • Fountain Lemonade

      $3.49
    • Fresh Lemonade

      $4.90
    • Iced Tea

      $3.49
    • Milk

      $4.49
    • Orange Juice

      $3.90
    • Pineapple Ginger Cooler N/A

      fresh pressed pineapple juice, ginger simple, lime juice splash of lemon soda, shaken over ice
      $8.90
    • Plant City Strawberry Lemonade N/A

      fresh muddled strawberries with fresh squeezed lemonade
      $6.90
    • Root Beer

      Mr Browns (can)
      $3.90
    • Soda

      $3.49
    • Sweet Tea

      $3.49

    Craft Cocktails Online

    Craft Cocktails

    • Cactus Pear Cosmo

      Chopin Vodka, cold pressed cactus pear juice + fresh lime juice
      $14.90
    • Lavender Lemon Drop

      Chopin vodka, fresh lemon juice + French lavender syrup
      $14.90
    • Pomegranate Margarita

      1800 silver, pomegranate, agave + fresh lime juice
      $14.90
    • Sparkling Paloma

      1800 silver, fresh grapefruit juice, sea salt + sparkling water
      $14.90
    • Grand Old Fashioned

      New Riff bourbon, Grand Marnier + orange bitters
      $14.90
    • Sarasota Sour

      Tincup whiskey, house made citrus sour + foam
      $14.90
    • Citrus Grove Mojito

      Papa's Pilar blonde rum, three citrus juices, fresh mint + simple syrup
      $14.90
    • Papa Hemingway

      Papa's Pilar blonde rum, pineapple juice, ginger, agave + dark rum float
      $14.90

    Wines By The Glass

    Glass Wine

    • *Gl Hse Cabernet

      $5.00
    • *Gl Hse Chard

      $5.00
    • *Gl Hse Merlot

      $5.00
    • *Gl Hse PG

      $5.00
    • *Gl Hse WZ

      $5.00
    • Gl Lunetta Prosecco

      $7.00
    • Gl Chianti

      $8.90
    • Gl Austin Hope Cab

      $19.90
    • Gl Aime Rose

      $11.90
    • Gl Gavi

      $10.90
    • Gl Brancott SB

      $11.90
    • Gl Chalone PN

      OUT OF STOCK
      $14.90
    • Gl Domaine B Malbec

      $9.90
    • Gl Ferrari Sauv Blanc

      $10.90
    • Gl Epicurean Chard

      $12.90
    • Gl Highlands Red Blend

      $10.90
    • Gl J Lohr Hilltop Cab

      OUT OF STOCK
      $14.90
    • Gl KJ Chard

      $11.90
    • Gl Kris PG

      $10.90
    • Gl Meomi PN

      $12.90
    • Gl Santa Margherita Rose

      $10.90
    • Gl Sonoma Chard

      $14.90
    • Gl Stella Rosa Moscato

      $9.90
    • Gl Stoneleigh Sauv Blanc

      $11.90
    • Gl Super Tuscan

      $10.90
    • Gl Thomas Schmitt Ries

      $10.90
    • Split Prosecco

      $9.90

    Kids Menu Online

    Kids Meals

    • Pasta Marinara

      Spaghetti or Camanelle (conch shell shaped). Includes a side dish, beverage and vanilla ice cream
      $10.90
    • Buttered Pasta

      Spaghetti or Campanelle (conch shell shaped). Includes side dish, beverage + vanilla ice cream
      $10.90
    • Mac & Cheese

      Kraft Mac & Cheese. Includes side dish, beverage & vanilla ice cream
      $10.90
    • Flatbread Pizza

      Flatbread with marinara & mozzarella. Includes side dish, beverage & vanilla ice cream
      $10.90
    • Burger

      Served on a brioche bun with American cheese. Includes side dish, beverage & vanilla ice cream
      $12.90
    • Chicken Tenders

      With BBQ, ranch or honey mustard. Includes a side dish, beverage & vanilla ice cream
      $12.90
    • Pasta Alfredo

      Spaghetti or Campanelle (conch shell shaped). Includes side dish, beverage & vanilla ice cream
      $12.90
    • Mac & Chicken

      Kraft mac & cheese + chopped chicken tenders. Includes side dish, beverage & vanilla ice cream
      $12.90
    • Fish & Chips

      hand battered whitefish + tartar sauce. Includes side dish, beverage & vanilla ice cream
      $12.90
    • Bang Shrimp

      Hand battered shrimp + bang sauce. Includes side dish, beverage & vanilla ice cream
      $12.90
    • Grilled Shrimp

      Grilled shrimp +cocktail sauce. Includes side dish, beverage & vanilla ice cream
      $12.90
    • Grilled Mahi Fingers

      Grilled mahi fingers + tartar sauce. Includes side dish, beverage & vanilla ice cream
      $12.90
    • Coconut Grouper Fingers

      Coconut grouper fingers + mango chili sauce. Includes side dish, beverage & vanilla ice cream
      $12.90
    • Filet Medallions

      Two (3 oz) filet medallions. Includes side dish, beverage & vanilla ice cream
      $19.90

    Sweet Tea

    $3.49
    Request advisory
    We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply at time of pick up.
    1

    All hours
    Sunday3:00 pm - 7:15 pm
    Monday3:00 pm - 7:15 pm
    Tuesday3:00 pm - 8:15 pm
    Wednesday3:00 pm - 8:15 pm
    Thursday3:00 pm - 8:15 pm
    Friday3:00 pm - 8:15 pm
    Saturday3:00 pm - 8:15 pm
    Restaurant info

    Local's favorite Bar & Grill for 26 years!

    Location

    4059 Cattlemen Rd, Sarasota, FL 34233

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Wow Wow Hawaiian Lemonade
    View restaurantnext
    Kacey's Seafood & More - Fruitville
    View restaurantnext
    Viva La Vida 3440 Clark Road
    View restaurantnext
    Connors Steak and Seafood Sarasota
    View restaurantnext
    Fin & Tonic
    View restaurantnext
    Lucky 8
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook