Sandwiches
Martha
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items
Betty
Thick cut, house-made hickory smoked bacon, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce. Create your own unique sandwich by adding your favorite toppings!$12.00
Karleen's Cornmeal Fries
Award winning! Served with your choice of sauce for dipping!$6.00
Doris
Pork smash patty, ground in-house, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce. Create your own unique sandwich by adding your favorite toppings!$12.00
Egg Sandwiches
Agnes
House-made shaved and griddled steak, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce. Create your own unique sandwich by adding your favorite toppings!$13.00
Jane
American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce. Create your own unique sandwich by adding your favorite toppings!$8.00Betty
Thick cut, house-made hickory smoked bacon, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce. Create your own unique sandwich by adding your favorite toppings!$12.00Doris
Pork smash patty, ground in-house, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce. Create your own unique sandwich by adding your favorite toppings!$12.00
Shirley
House-made baloney, caramelized onion, tomato jam, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce$14.00
Pearl
Mushroom sausage patty, avocado spread, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce (vegetarian)$12.00
Hoagies
Smoked Turkey Breast Hoagie
Shaved house-smoked turkey breast, crisp bacon, cucumber, baby kale, charred onion mayo, and tomato jam served on our fresh baked sesame hoagie bun.$17.00
Garlic Steak Hoagie
Griddled roast beef, smoked provolone, spicy pickled peppers & onions, and herb mayo served on our fresh baked sesame hoagie bun.$15.00
Sit-Downs
Bake Shop
Cinnamon Roll
Orange zest and vanilla bean icing$5.00
Cake Donut w/ Apple Cinnamon Glaze
Fresh Fried Scratch Made Cake Donut with house made apple cinnamon glaze.OUT OF STOCK$5.00
Cheesy Ham Pocket Pie
Plenty of ham and velvety cheese sauce baked in our flaky pie crust.OUT OF STOCK$5.00
Lemon Meringue Pie
Lemon curd topped with baked meringue in an all-butter crust.OUT OF STOCK$5.00
On the Side
Karleen's Cornmeal Fries
Award winning! Served with your choice of sauce for dipping!$6.00Hartville Potato Chips - 7 oz
1.5 ozOUT OF STOCK$4.00Black Pepper Gravy
It's gravy! Great for dipping Karleen's Cornmeal Fries or your favorite sandwich (vegetarian).$3.00Bacon Side
$4.00Sausage Side
$4.00Mushroom Sausage Side
(Vegan)$4.00Baloney Side
$4.002 oz. Extra Side of Sunshine Sauce
$0.501 oz. Side of Black Cap Hot Sauce
$0.502 oz Side of Apple Butter
$0.502 oz Side of Tomato Jam
$0.502 oz Side of Maple Syrup
$1.00
Beverages
Cinnamon Roll Iced Latte
OUT OF STOCK$5.00
“Captain Cereal” Iced Latte
Enjoy the nostalgic Saturday morning flavors of this cereal oat milk latte!$5.00
Guardian Drip Coffee
16oz of a fresh brewed Guardian Coffee.$4.00
Guardian Cold Brew
12oz bottle of Cleveland's favorite, Guardian Cold Brew coffee!$4.00
Orange Juice Carton
8oz$2.00
Chocolate Milk
8oz$2.00
Fruit Punch Juice Carton
$2.00Sixth City Soda Co. Root Beer
Root beer sweetened with cane sugar & honey, from Sixth City Craft Soda Co, Cleveland$2.00Vernors Ginger Ale
Genuine...Deelicious!$2.00
Diet Coke, Caffeine Free
Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink$2.00Bottled Water
$2.00
Nitro Guardian Cold Brew
12oz$5.00
Hot Tea
16oz of a woody and sweet Chinese Pu-erh Tea.OUT OF STOCK$3.00
Paint Valley Farms Chocolate Milk
Paint Valley Farms Chocolate Milk From Beach City, OH - 16oz bottle, sweetened with organic cane sugarOUT OF STOCK$3.00Pecan Milk Mocha Iced Latte
Toasted pecans blended with oat milk, brown sugar, dark chocolate and vanilla. Served over ice with Guardian Cold Brew.(16oz cup)OUT OF STOCK$5.00
Souvenirs
Embroidered Martha logo patch on Weld MFG Checkerboard Field Trip™ Hat
Pat Scratch-Made Tee
Screen printed on premium Comfort Colors shirts$30.00
Martha Checkerboard Hat
Embroidered Martha logo on a super cool checker hatOUT OF STOCK$35.00
I <3 Martha Mug
13oz Screen printed clear glass coffee mugOUT OF STOCK$15.00
Sunshine Long Sleeve Pocket Tee
Screen printed on premium Comfort Colors shirts$30.00
Sunshine Long Sleeve Pocket Tee (Butter)
Screen printed on premium Comfort Colors shirts$30.00
Pie of My Eye Tee
Screen printed on premium Comfort Colors shirtsOUT OF STOCK$20.00
Martha Vintage Nylon Hat
Look so good with this embroidered Martha logo on a vintage 5 panel nylon hat.OUT OF STOCK$25.00
Martha Corduroy Hat
$25.00
Martha on the Fly Beanie
OUT OF STOCK$25.00
Martha Bumper Sticker
Weatherproof vinyl bumper sticker. I BRAKE FOR BREAKFAST SANDWICHES!$3.00
Shiny Shirley Sticker
$1.00
Guardian Coffee Beans
12oz Guardian Signature Roast whole bean coffee bag.$15.00
Black Cap Hot Sauce Bottle
Live fermented hot sauce, 8oz.$12.00
Jalapeño Ramp Black Cap Hot Sauce Bottle
Live fermented hot sauce, 8oz.OUT OF STOCK$15.00
Ruffled Feather X Guardian Hot Sauce Bottle
Our friends Guardian Coffee and Ruffled Feather have teamed up to offer this unique hot sauce variety. Live fermented with a coffee kick.$15.00
Guardian Cold Brew
$4.00
12oz bottle of Cleveland's favorite, Guardian Cold Brew coffee!
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 9:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Monday | 8:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 8:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 8:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Thursday | 8:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Friday | 8:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Saturday | 9:00 am - 3:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Serving up scratch made, elevated nostalgia!
Location
2173 Professor Ave, Cleveland, OH 44113
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
