Sandwiches
Martha
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items
Betty
Thick cut, house-made hickory smoked bacon, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce. Create your own unique sandwich by adding your favorite toppings!$12.00
Karleen's Cornmeal Fries
Award winning! Served with your choice of sauce for dipping!$6.00
Doris
Pork smash patty, ground in-house, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce. Create your own unique sandwich by adding your favorite toppings!$12.00
Egg Sandwiches
Agnes
House-made shaved and griddled steak, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce. Create your own unique sandwich by adding your favorite toppings!$13.00
Jane
American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce. Create your own unique sandwich by adding your favorite toppings!$8.00Betty
Thick cut, house-made hickory smoked bacon, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce. Create your own unique sandwich by adding your favorite toppings!$12.00Doris
Pork smash patty, ground in-house, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce. Create your own unique sandwich by adding your favorite toppings!$12.00
Shirley
House-made baloney, caramelized onion, tomato jam, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce$14.00
Pearl
Mushroom sausage patty, avocado spread, American cheese, egg and Martha's Sunshine Sauce (vegetarian)$12.00
Hoagies
Smoked Turkey Breast Hoagie
Shaved house-smoked turkey breast, crisp bacon, cucumber, baby kale, charred onion mayo, and tomato jam served on our fresh baked sesame hoagie bun.$17.00
Garlic Steak Hoagie
Griddled roast beef, smoked provolone, spicy pickled peppers & onions, and herb mayo served on our fresh baked sesame hoagie bun.$15.00
Sit-Downs
Bake Shop
Cinnamon Roll
Orange zest and vanilla bean icing$5.00
Cake Donut w/ Apple Cinnamon Glaze
Fresh Fried Scratch Made Cake Donut with house made apple cinnamon glaze.$5.00
Cheesy Ham Pocket Pie
Plenty of ham and velvety cheese sauce baked in our flaky pie crust.OUT OF STOCK$5.00
Lemon Meringue Pie
Lemon curd topped with baked meringue in an all-butter crust.OUT OF STOCK$5.00
On the Side
Karleen's Cornmeal Fries
Award winning! Served with your choice of sauce for dipping!$6.00Hartville Potato Chips - 7 oz
1.5 ozOUT OF STOCK$4.00Black Pepper Gravy
It's gravy! Great for dipping Karleen's Cornmeal Fries or your favorite sandwich (vegetarian).$3.00Bacon Side
$4.00Sausage Side
$4.00Mushroom Sausage Side
(Vegan)$4.00Baloney Side
$4.002 oz. Extra Side of Sunshine Sauce
$0.501 oz. Side of Black Cap Hot Sauce
$0.502 oz Side of Apple Butter
$0.502 oz Side of Tomato Jam
$0.502 oz Side of Maple Syrup
$1.00
Beverages
Cinnamon Roll Iced Latte
OUT OF STOCK$5.00
“Captain Cereal” Iced Latte
Enjoy the nostalgic Saturday morning flavors of this cereal oat milk latte!$5.00
Guardian Drip Coffee
16oz of a fresh brewed Guardian Coffee.$4.00
Guardian Cold Brew
12oz bottle of Cleveland's favorite, Guardian Cold Brew coffee!$4.00
Orange Juice Carton
8oz$2.00
Chocolate Milk
8oz$2.00
Fruit Punch Juice Carton
$2.00Sixth City Soda Co. Root Beer
Root beer sweetened with cane sugar & honey, from Sixth City Craft Soda Co, Cleveland$2.00Vernors Ginger Ale
Genuine...Deelicious!$2.00
Diet Coke, Caffeine Free
Take a Diet Coke break with this refreshing, no-calorie soft drink$2.00Bottled Water
$2.00
Nitro Guardian Cold Brew
12oz$5.00
Hot Tea
16oz of a woody and sweet Chinese Pu-erh Tea.OUT OF STOCK$3.00
Paint Valley Farms Chocolate Milk
Paint Valley Farms Chocolate Milk From Beach City, OH - 16oz bottle, sweetened with organic cane sugarOUT OF STOCK$3.00Pecan Milk Mocha Iced Latte
Toasted pecans blended with oat milk, brown sugar, dark chocolate and vanilla. Served over ice with Guardian Cold Brew.(16oz cup)OUT OF STOCK$5.00
Souvenirs
Embroidered Martha logo patch on Weld MFG Checkerboard Field Trip™ Hat
Pat Scratch-Made Tee
Screen printed on premium Comfort Colors shirts$30.00
Martha Checkerboard Hat
Embroidered Martha logo on a super cool checker hatOUT OF STOCK$35.00
I <3 Martha Mug
13oz Screen printed clear glass coffee mugOUT OF STOCK$15.00
Sunshine Long Sleeve Pocket Tee
Screen printed on premium Comfort Colors shirts$30.00
Sunshine Long Sleeve Pocket Tee (Butter)
Screen printed on premium Comfort Colors shirts$30.00
Pie of My Eye Tee
Screen printed on premium Comfort Colors shirtsOUT OF STOCK$20.00
Martha Vintage Nylon Hat
Look so good with this embroidered Martha logo on a vintage 5 panel nylon hat.OUT OF STOCK$25.00
Martha Corduroy Hat
$25.00
Martha on the Fly Beanie
OUT OF STOCK$25.00
Martha Bumper Sticker
Weatherproof vinyl bumper sticker. I BRAKE FOR BREAKFAST SANDWICHES!$3.00
Shiny Shirley Sticker
$1.00
Guardian Coffee Beans
12oz Guardian Signature Roast whole bean coffee bag.$15.00
Black Cap Hot Sauce Bottle
Live fermented hot sauce, 8oz.$12.00
Jalapeño Ramp Black Cap Hot Sauce Bottle
Live fermented hot sauce, 8oz.OUT OF STOCK$15.00
Ruffled Feather X Guardian Hot Sauce Bottle
Our friends Guardian Coffee and Ruffled Feather have teamed up to offer this unique hot sauce variety. Live fermented with a coffee kick.$15.00
Pat Scratch-Made Tee
$30.00
Screen printed on premium Comfort Colors shirts
Customize your item
Select 1
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 9:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Monday | 8:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 8:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 8:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Thursday | 8:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Friday | 8:00 am - 3:00 pm |
| Saturday | 9:00 am - 3:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Serving up scratch made, elevated nostalgia!
Location
2173 Professor Ave, Cleveland, OH 44113
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
