Mayer’s Tavern
894 3rd Ave
Cape May, NJ 08204
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
- Fried Scallops$29.00
A half pound of lightly fried local sea scallops. Served with citrus slaw and housemade french fries. Includes choice of one sauce.
- Crab fritter$15.00
Crab and scallion fritters served with homemade jalapeno-cilantro sauce. 5 per order.
- Brioche Bread Pudding$12.00
Brioche bread pudding with cinnamon and Tahitian vanilla bean. Served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Food
Appetizers
- Clams$16.00
Local middleneck clams steamed with fregula (toasted Sardinian pasta), tomato, and Calabrian chiles. Pleasantly spicy. Approximately 8 clams per order, varies with size.
- Crab fritter$15.00
Crab and scallion fritters served with homemade jalapeno-cilantro sauce. 5 per order.
- Fried Calamari$14.00
A half pound of local calamari lightly fried and served with homemade lemon mayo. A mix of tentacles and rings.
- Baked oysters$15.00
Local oysters, freshly shucked and broiled with pimento cheese. 6 per order.
- Green Salad$11.00
Spring green salad lightly dressed with housemade shallot & herb vinaigrette.
- Kale Salad$14.00
Tuscan kale massaged w/ yogurt-tahini dressing, topped with savory housemade granola. Contains nuts.
- Bluefish Spread$9.00
Smoked bluefish whipped into a creamy spread. Served with 2 pieces of toasted baguette.
- Pimento Cheese$7.00
A southern classic cheddar cheese spread w/ pimento peppers. Served with 2 pieces of toasted baguette.
- Radish$9.00Out of stock
- Gnocchi$22.00Out of stock
- Chicken App$15.00Out of stock
Mains
- Fried Scallops$29.00
A half pound of lightly fried local sea scallops. Served with citrus slaw and housemade french fries. Includes choice of one sauce.
- Cheeseburger$18.00
Mayer's famous burger with white cheddar cheese. A half pound of humanely raised ground beef on a brioche bun with lettuce, dijon mayo, and house pickled onions.
- Burger$18.00
Mayer's famous burger. NO CHEESE. A half pound of humanely raised ground beef on a brioche bun with lettuce, dijon mayo, and house pickled onions.
- Chicken$24.00
Yogurt-marinated humanely raised chicken breast roasted and served with polenta and braised collard greens.
- Sausage$26.00
Housemade pork sausage w/ Rob's seasonal pick
- Mussels white large$18.00
PEI mussels in a rotating seasonal broth. Large order, approximately 24 mussels, varies depending on size. Served with wedge of toasted baguette.
- Mussels white small$11.00
PEI mussels in a rotating seasonal broth. Small order, approximately 12 mussels, varies depending on size. Served with wedge of toasted baguette.
- Mussels red large$18.00
PEI mussels in a rotating seasonal broth. Large order, approximately 24 mussels, varies depending on size. Served with wedge of toasted baguette.
- Mussels red small$11.00
PEI mussels in a rotating seasonal broth. Small order, approximately 12 mussels, varies depending on size. Served with wedge of toasted baguette.
Sauces
- Remoulade$0.75
Classic seafood accompaniment. Made in house with homemade mayo, ketchup, whole grain mustard, celery, scallion. 2oz
- Cocktail$0.75
Homemade with ketchup, horseradish, worcestershire, lemon. 2oz
- Tartar$0.75
Made in house with homemade mayo, mustard, capers, pickles, lemon, parsley. 2oz
- Horseradish
Classic spicy condiment. 2oz
- Jalapeno-cilantro sauce$0.75
Made in house with jalapenos, cilantro, aji verde chiles, cotija cheese, lime juice, and more. Contains dairy & egg. 2oz
- Dijon mayo$0.75
Housemade dijon mayo. 2oz
- Regular mayo$0.75
Housemade plain mayo. 2oz
- Lemon mayo$0.75
Housemade mayo spiked with lemon. 2oz
- Melted butter$0.75
2oz
Sides
- Citrus Slaw$5.00
Side serving of our cabbage & citrus slaw
- Fries$7.00
Side serving of our housemade fries
- Mac & Cheese$11.00
Housemade baked mac and cheese with corkscrew pasta, bechamel sauce, cheddar and gruyere.
- Mussel Fries$6.00
- Small Green Salad$6.00
Side serving of our spring green salad with homemade shallot vinaigrette
- Spinach$6.00
Side serving of fresh spinach lightly sauteed with garlic, olive oil, lemon
- Toasted bread$2.00
Three wedges of fresh toasted baguette
- Curry Carrots$8.00Out of stock
Spinach
Side serving of fresh spinach lightly sauteed with garlic, olive oil, lemon
Kids
Dessert
Sunday | 4:00 pm - 11:45 pm |
Monday | 4:00 pm - 11:45 pm |
Tuesday | 4:00 pm - 11:45 pm |
Wednesday | 4:00 pm - 11:45 pm |
Thursday | 4:00 pm - 11:45 pm |
Friday | 4:00 pm - 11:45 pm |
Saturday | 4:00 pm - 11:45 pm |
Cape May's best spot for local seafood, burgers, cocktails, and more!
894 3rd Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204