American
McGarity's Restaurant & Irish Pub®
2070 E Van Buren
Eureka Springs, AR 72632
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items
Shepherd's/Cottage Pie
beef, lamb, carrots, corn & green beans in house-made brown gravy, topped with house-made mashed potatoes & parmesan reggiano$24.95Penne Pasta White Cheddar Mac & Cheese
house-made cheese sauce tossed in penne pasta. topped with toasted breadcrumbs & parmesan reggiano$14.95Wild West Wings 10 piece
non-breaded. carrots & celery sticks. flavors: buffalo, lemon pepper (dry rub), sweet & spicy bbq, sweet teriyaki, sweet red chili, mango habanero or sauce on the side house-made ranch or blue cheese dressing can be prepared normal or extra crispy$18.00
MAIN & VEGAN MENU
Starters
McGarity's Irish Nachos
house-made fresh pico de gallo, house-made ranch, fresh jalapeños, melted sharp & white cheddar cheese on top of sweet potato waffle fries. may substitute with seasoned fries$14.95Fried Spicy Meat Pies
two fried spicy meat pies filled with seasoned beef$10.95Irish Cheddar Pub Cheese
aged house-made cheddar cheese dip. two large soft bavarian pretzels sprinkled with sea salt$15.95Irish Reuben Egg Rolls
3 house-made egg-rolls stuffed with corned beef & sauerkraut. served with 1000 island dressing dipping sauce on the side$16.95Fried Calamari
lightly battered with salt & pepper. served with marinara & lemon wedges$13.95Fried Shrimp Starter
six wild caught jumbo house-battered shrimp. served with sweet red chili sauce$14.95Chicken Quesadilla
white & yellow cheddar cheese, pan roasted chicken, ranch, jalapeño & house-made fresh pico de gallo inside an x-large flour tortilla. side of sour cream$14.95Wisconsin Cheese Curds
white cheddar. mild or spicy. choice of house-made ranch or marinara$14.95Spicy Wisconsin Cheese Curds
white cheddar. mild or spicy. choice of house-made ranch or marinara$14.95The Shrimp Cocktail
six wild caught jumbo chimichurri marinated shrimp served with house-made cocktail sauce$14.95Quail Medallions
four stuffed with mild jalapeño, wrapped in bacon & drizzled with house-made bourbon dijon$19.95
Salads
House Salad
romaine lettuce, red onion, grape tomatoes, cucumber, avocado, parmesan reggiano & balsamic vinaigrette on the side$13.95Iceberg Wedge Salad
sliced grape tomatoes, red onion, crispy real bacon, avocado & blue cheese crumbles on an iceberg wedge. blue cheese dressing on the side$19.95Strawberry Salad
loaded with strawberries, romaine lettuce, cucumbers, real bacon, avocado, fresh jalapeño & feta cheese served with balsamic vinaigrette on the side$21.95Romaine Caesar salad
$8.95Romaine Side Salad
$8.95
Wings
Wild West Wings 10 piece
non-breaded. carrots & celery sticks. flavors: buffalo, lemon pepper (dry rub), sweet & spicy bbq, sweet teriyaki, sweet red chili, mango habanero or sauce on the side house-made ranch or blue cheese dressing can be prepared normal or extra crispy$18.00Wild West Wings 15 piece
non-breaded. carrots & celery sticks. flavors: buffalo, lemon pepper (dry rub), sweet & spicy bbq, sweet teriyaki, sweet red chili, mango habanero or sauce on the side house-made ranch or blue cheese dressing can be prepared normal or extra crispy$26.00Wild West Wings 20 piece
non-breaded. carrots & celery sticks. flavors: buffalo, lemon pepper (dry rub), sweet & spicy bbq, sweet teriyaki, sweet red chili, mango habanero or sauce on the side house-made ranch or blue cheese dressing can be prepared normal or extra crispy$34.00
Seafood
Guinness Fish, Shrimp & Chips
guinness battered wild caught cod, house-breaded wild caught shrimp, fries, house-made cocktail & tartar sauce. lemon wedges. london pub malt vinegar on the table (or in a ramekin for take-out)$29.95Garlic Shrimp Pasta
house-made garlic sauce tossed in penne pasta & topped with wild caught jumbo grilled shrimp & parmesan reggiano$22.95Blackened Red Fish
blackened wild caught red fish, topped with a house-made garlic shrimp sauce that includes wild caught jumbo shrimp. lemon wedges. choice of 2 sides$29.95Shrimp Creole & Grits
wild caught jumbo shrimp resting on house-made cajun creole red sauce served over house-made cheese grits$22.95Wild Caught White Wine Salmon
wild caught salmon topped with house-made creamy reduced white wine & dill sauce. lemon wedges. choice of 2 sides$29.95McGarity's Crab Cakes
two packed with real crab meat. grilled. house-cocktail sauce. choice of 2 sides$39.95Wild Caught Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna
wild caught sashimi-grade ahi tuna crusted in sesame seeds & seared (raw in the middle). served with house-made wasabi & sweet & spicy plum sauce. choice of 2 sides$32.95GLUTEN FREE Garlic Shrimp Pasta
house-made garlic sauce tossed in gluten-free penne pasta & topped with wild caught jumbo grilled shrimp & parmesan reggiano$22.95
Carnivore
Shepherd's/Cottage Pie
beef, lamb, carrots, corn & green beans in house-made brown gravy, topped with house-made mashed potatoes & parmesan reggiano$24.95Guinness Irish Beef Stew
beef, potatoes, carrots, peas, celery, guinness (reduced). served with toasted baguette$19.95Chicken Alfredo Pasta
house-made alfredo sauce (parmesan & romano cheese) tossed in penne pasta. choice of mixed in grilled chicken or topped with house-battered fried chicken & parmesan reggiano$19.95Irish Bangers and Mash
2 large traditional irish sausages, house-made mashed potatoes & grilled cabbage with bacon$21.95Shredded Corned Beef and Cabbage
shredded corned beef & grilled cabbage served with house-made mashed potatoes. dijon mustard on the side$24.95Chicken Fried Steak
huge 4x hand pressed cfs served with house-made mashed potatoes & covered in house-made white country gravy$25.95The Pork Chop
16oz double bone french cut pork chop (butterflied), house-made mashed potatoes topped with house-made gravy with brown sugar & butter braised carrots as a side$33.95Chicken & Sausage Gumbo
bowl of house-made spicy chicken & Sausage gumbo served with toasted baguette$19.95McGarity's Chicken Curry
house-made mild or spicy chicken curry mixed with carrots, corn, green beans & potatoes served over house-made cheese grits$21.95Cowboy Split Bone Cut Ribeye
huge 16 oz. cowboy cut split bone ribeye topped with a scoop of garlic & herb compound butter. cooked to order. choice of 2 sides$59.95Penne Pasta White Cheddar Mac & Cheese
house-made cheese sauce tossed in penne pasta. topped with toasted breadcrumbs & parmesan reggiano$14.95GLUTEN FREE PASTA Chicken Alfredo
house-made alfredo sauce (parmesan, romano cheese) tossed in gluten free penne pasta. mixed in grilled chicken breast$21.95GLUTEN FREE White Cheddar Mac & Cheese
house-made cheese sauce tossed in cooked to order in gluten free penne pasta$14.95
Sandwiches
McGarity's CheeseBurger
huge 10oz angus pure beef burger cooked to order on a brioche bun. topped with lettuce, tomato & onion. choice of cheddar, provolone, swiss, pepper jack or blue cheese. sliced pickles on the side. add patty 3.95. add bacon 2.95$17.95McGarity's Reuben
tender corned beef, melted swiss cheese, grilled sauerkraut cooked in thousand island dressing. served on toasted marbled rye or toasted baguette. thousand island on the side$19.95The Chicken Sandwich
grilled or house-battered fried chicken served inside an x-large flour tortilla, brioche bun or toasted baguette. lettuce, tomato, avocado & ranch$16.95Irish Banger Sandwich
two irish bangers, sauerkraut, red onions, dijon mustard on a toasted buttered baguette$16.95Chicken Salad Sandwich
chicken salad with cranberries & pecans, lettuce & sliced tomato served on a baguette$14.95Tuna Salad Sandwich
yellowfin tuna salad, lettuce & sliced tomato served on a baguette$14.95
Signature Sides & Extras
Colcannon
(traditional irish mash mixed with cabbage, 2.25 up-charge if added as a choice of side)$9.95House-Made Mash
(make it loaded for 2.95)$6.95Brown Sugar & Butter Braised Carrots
$8.95Grilled Cabbage with Bacon
$7.95Boiled Cabbage
$7.95Asparagus
$7.95Romaine Side Caesar Salad
$8.95House-Made Cheese Grits
$5.95Fresh Green Beans
$5.95Romaine Side Salad
$8.95Seasoned Skin on French Fries
$5.95Sweet Potato Waffle Fries
$5.95Onion Rings
$5.95Bowl of Vegetable Soup
(2.25 up-charge if added as a choice of side)$9.95Loaded Mashed Potatoes
1.95 up-charge if added as a choice of side$7.95Side of Jumbo Shrimp
$13.95Toasted Baguette with butter
$2.95Toasted Brioche Bun with butter
$2.95Toasted Marble Rye Bread with butter
$2.95Grilled Chicken Breast
$6.95Fried Chicken Breast
$6.95Pub Cheese without pretzels
$5.99One Irish Banger Sausage
$3.99Wild Caught Seared Ahi Tuna (No Sides)
$24.95One Irish Reuben Egg Roll
$5.99One Bavarian Pretzel (No Pub Cheese)
$3.99½ Ramekin of Real Grated Parmesan Reggiano
$4.99Small White Cup Shredded Yellow Cheddar Cheese
$1.99One Piece of Guinness battered Cod
$3.99Bowl of Cold Sauerkraut
$1.99Bowl of Hot Sauerkraut
$1.99Two slices of pickles
$0.99Shredded Corned Beef Only
$9.99Bowl of Hot Sauerkraut
$1.99Ramekin Sliced Jalepeno's
$1.99Small White Cup Shredded White Cheddar Cheese
$1.99One House Battered Fried Wild Caught Shrimp
$2.95One Grilled Wild Caught Shrimp
$2.95Ramekin of Real Crab Meat (grilled)
$12.95One Crab Cake
$12.95
Vegan/Vegetarian
Vegan French Dip
caramelized onions & organic jackfruit on a toasted vegan buttered baguette. vegan au jus on the side$14.95Sweet BBQ Carnitas Sandwich (Vegan)
organic pulled jackfruit mixed in a sweet vegan bbq sauce, sliced tomatoes, lettuce, served on a toasted vegan buttered baguette$14.95Mixed Vegetable Pesto Pasta (Vegan)
asparagus, green beans, whole cherry tomatoes, onions & vegan penne pasta tossed in a house-made vegan pesto sauce$18.95Double Black Bean Burger (Vegan)
two black bean quinoa veggie burgers served inside a vegan brioche bun. includes lettuce, tomato, sliced onions. sliced pickles on the side$16.95BBQ Organic Jackfruit Wrap (Vegetarian)
pulled organic jackfruit in a sweet bbq sauce with lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, wrapped in a flour tortilla$14.95Vegetarian Alfredo Pasta (Vegetarian)
house-made parmesan & romano cheese alfredo sauce, vegan penne pasta topped with a black bean quinoa veggie patty$19.95Fresh Veggie Wrap (Vegetarian)
pan roasted asparagus, lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions & avocado with a honey mustard sauce wrapped in a 14" flour tortilla$13.95Crispy Chickpea Salad (Vegetarian)
lettuce, cucumber, tomatoes, avocado, red onions, parmesan topped with crispy fried chickpeas & drizzled with our delicious house-made vinaigrette$12.95Jackfruit Mac-N-Cheese (Vegetarian)
our house signature mac-n-cheese topped with sautéed cajun jackfruit & breadcrumbs$16.95
Desserts
5 Layer Carrot Cake
spiced dessert featuring shredded carrots, pineapple, raisins, & nuts$10.995 Layer Atomic Cheesecake/Cake Blend
chocolate cake, yellow cake, cheesecake, strawberry fruit fillings & chocolate mousse$10.995 Layer Lemon Cake
light, fluffy & refreshingly tangy with cold lemon cream filling$10.995 Layer Chocolate Seduction Cake
artisan quality luxurious, indulgent treat with a deep chocolate profile$10.99Chocolate Hazlenut Espresso Cake
espresso-soaked chocolate layers, hazelnut mousse & honey ganache$10.99
Extra Condiments (Take-Out Only)
Extra Paid Sauces/Dressings
Ramekin Au Jus
$0.99Ramekin BBQ
$0.99Ramekin Buffalo
$0.99Ramekin Cocktail
$0.99Ramekin Horseradish
$0.99Ramekin Mango Habanero
$0.99Ramekin Marinara
$0.99Ramekin Ponzu
$0.99Ramekin Ranch
$0.99Ramekin Sweet Red Chili Sauce
$0.99Ramekin Sweet Teriyaki
$0.99Ramekin Tartar
$0.99Ramekin Worcestershire
$0.99Small Cup of White Country Gravy
$4.99Ramekin Brown Demi Sauce Gravy
$2.99Large Cup of White Country Gravy
$8.99Ramekin Real Whipped Butter
$0.99Ramekin Thousand Island
$0.99Ramekin Creole Sauce
$1.99Ramekin of Pico
$1.99Ramekin Yellow Mustard
$0.99Ramekin Dijon Mustard
$0.99Blackened Red Fish Sauce with Wild Caught Shrimp
$9.99Ramekin Wasabi
$0.99Blackened Red FIsh Sauce (No Redfish)
$14.99Ramekin Sour Cream
$0.99White 8oz Deli Cup of Hot Curry Sauce Only
$4.99White 16oz Deli Cup Medium Curry Sauce Only
$8.99White 8oz Deli Cup of Medium Curry Sauce Only
$4.99White 16oz Deli Cup Hot Curry Sauce Only
$8.99Sliced Strawberries
$1.99Ramekin Sliced Jalapeno's
$0.99Caesar Dressing
$0.99House-made Balsamic Vinaigrette
$0.99Thousand Island
$0.99Ranch
$0.99Honey Mustard
$0.99Blue Cheese with crumbles on top
$1.99Blue Cheese without crumbles
$0.99
DRINK MENU
Non-Alcoholic Beverages / Sodas
Bottled Aqua Panna
$4.95Bottled Pellegrino
$7.95Cappucino
$5.95Coffee
$4.95Coke
$3.95Cranberry Juice
$4.25Coke Zero
$3.95Dr. Pepper
$3.95Diet Dr. Pepper
$3.95Barq's Root Beer
$3.95Espresso
$2.95Ginger Ale
$3.95Ginger Beer
$3.95Hot Tea
$2.95Lemonade
$3.95Orange Juice
$4.95Pineapple Juice
$3.95Red Bull
$4.25Sprite
$3.95Sugar Free Red Bull
$4.25Sweet Tea
$3.95Tonic
$2.95Unsweetened Tea
$3.95½ & ½ Tea
$3.95
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 10:00 pm |
| Monday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Thursday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Restaurant info
FEATURED ON AMERICA'S BEST RESTAURANTS. FEATURED ON NEWSBREAK. NAMED TOP TEN RESTAURANT IN NWA. AMERICAN & IRISH CLASSICS KID FRIENDLY -- 5 & UNDER EAT FREE -- REAL KIDS MENU 479-363-6038 – MCGARITYSRESTAURANT.COM
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
