American
McGarity's Restaurant & Irish Pub®
2070 E Van Buren
Eureka Springs, AR 72632
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Featured Items
McGarity's CheeseBurger
huge 10oz angus pure beef burger cooked to order on a brioche bun. topped with lettuce, tomato & onion. choice of cheddar, provolone, swiss, pepper jack or blue cheese. sliced pickles on the side. add patty 3.95. add bacon 2.95$17.95Wild West Wings 10 piece
non-breaded. carrots & celery sticks. flavors: buffalo, lemon pepper (dry rub), sweet & spicy bbq, sweet teriyaki, sweet red chili, mango habanero or sauce on the side house-made ranch or blue cheese dressing can be prepared normal or extra crispy$18.00Chicken Alfredo Pasta
house-made alfredo sauce (parmesan & romano cheese) tossed in penne pasta. choice of mixed in grilled chicken or topped with house-battered fried chicken & parmesan reggiano$19.95
Main Menus
Starters
McGarity's Irish Nachos
house-made fresh pico de gallo, house-made ranch, fresh jalapeños, melted sharp & white cheddar cheese on top of sweet potato waffle fries. may substitute with seasoned fries$14.95Fried Spicy Meat Pies
two fried spicy meat pies filled with seasoned beef$10.95Irish Cheddar Pub Cheese
aged house-made cheddar cheese dip. two large soft bavarian pretzels sprinkled with sea salt$15.95Irish Reuben Egg Rolls
3 house-made egg-rolls stuffed with corned beef & sauerkraut. served with 1000 island dressing dipping sauce on the side$16.95Fried Calamari
lightly battered with salt & pepper. served with marinara & lemon wedges$13.95Fried Shrimp Starter
six wild caught jumbo house-battered shrimp. served with sweet red chili sauce$14.95Chicken Quesadilla
white & yellow cheddar cheese, pan roasted chicken, ranch, jalapeño & house-made fresh pico de gallo inside an x-large flour tortilla. side of sour cream$14.95Wisconsin Cheese Curds
white cheddar. mild or spicy. choice of house-made ranch or marinara$14.95OUT OF STOCKSpicy Wisconsin Cheese Curds
white cheddar. mild or spicy. choice of house-made ranch or marinara$14.95The Shrimp Cocktail
six wild caught jumbo chimichurri marinated shrimp served with house-made cocktail sauce$14.95Quail Medallions
four stuffed with mild jalapeño, wrapped in bacon & drizzled with house-made bourbon dijon$19.95
Salads
House Salad
romaine lettuce, red onion, grape tomatoes, cucumber, avocado, parmesan reggiano & balsamic vinaigrette on the side$13.95Iceberg Wedge Salad
sliced grape tomatoes, red onion, crispy real bacon, avocado & blue cheese crumbles on an iceberg wedge. blue cheese dressing on the side$19.95Strawberry Salad
loaded with strawberries, romaine lettuce, cucumbers, real bacon, avocado, fresh jalapeño & feta cheese served with balsamic vinaigrette on the side$21.95Romaine Caesar salad
$8.95Romaine Side Salad
$8.95
Wings
Wild West Wings 10 piece
non-breaded. carrots & celery sticks. flavors: buffalo, lemon pepper (dry rub), sweet & spicy bbq, sweet teriyaki, sweet red chili, mango habanero or sauce on the side house-made ranch or blue cheese dressing can be prepared normal or extra crispy$18.00Wild West Wings 15 piece
non-breaded. carrots & celery sticks. flavors: buffalo, lemon pepper (dry rub), sweet & spicy bbq, sweet teriyaki, sweet red chili, mango habanero or sauce on the side house-made ranch or blue cheese dressing can be prepared normal or extra crispy$26.00Wild West Wings 20 piece
non-breaded. carrots & celery sticks. flavors: buffalo, lemon pepper (dry rub), sweet & spicy bbq, sweet teriyaki, sweet red chili, mango habanero or sauce on the side house-made ranch or blue cheese dressing can be prepared normal or extra crispy$34.00
Seafood
Guinness Fish, Shrimp & Chips
guinness battered wild caught cod, house-breaded wild caught shrimp, fries, house-made cocktail & tartar sauce. lemon wedges. london pub malt vinegar on the table (or in a ramekin for take-out)$29.95Garlic Shrimp Pasta
house-made garlic sauce tossed in penne pasta & topped with wild caught jumbo grilled shrimp & parmesan reggiano$22.95Blackened Red Fish
blackened wild caught red fish, topped with a house-made garlic shrimp sauce that includes wild caught jumbo shrimp. lemon wedges. choice of 2 sides$29.95Shrimp Creole & Grits
wild caught jumbo shrimp resting on house-made cajun creole red sauce served over house-made cheese grits$22.95Wild Caught White Wine Salmon
wild caught salmon topped with house-made creamy reduced white wine & dill sauce. lemon wedges. choice of 2 sides$29.95McGarity's Crab Cakes
two packed with real crab meat. grilled. house-cocktail sauce. choice of 2 sides$39.95Wild Caught Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna
wild caught sashimi-grade ahi tuna crusted in sesame seeds & seared (raw in the middle). served with house-made wasabi & sweet & spicy plum sauce. choice of 2 sides$32.95GLUTEN FREE Garlic Shrimp Pasta
house-made garlic sauce tossed in gluten-free penne pasta & topped with wild caught jumbo grilled shrimp & parmesan reggiano$22.95
Carnivore
Shepherd's/Cottage Pie
beef, lamb, carrots, corn & green beans in house-made brown gravy, topped with house-made mashed potatoes & parmesan reggiano$24.95Guinness Irish Beef Stew
beef, potatoes, carrots, peas, celery, guinness (reduced). served with toasted baguette$19.95Chicken Alfredo Pasta
house-made alfredo sauce (parmesan & romano cheese) tossed in penne pasta. choice of mixed in grilled chicken or topped with house-battered fried chicken & parmesan reggiano$19.95Irish Bangers and Mash
2 large traditional irish sausages, house-made mashed potatoes & grilled cabbage with bacon$21.95Shredded Corned Beef and Cabbage
shredded corned beef & grilled cabbage served with house-made mashed potatoes. dijon mustard on the side$24.95Chicken Fried Steak
huge 4x hand pressed cfs served with house-made mashed potatoes & covered in house-made white country gravy$25.95The Pork Chop
16oz double bone french cut pork chop (butterflied), house-made mashed potatoes topped with house-made gravy with brown sugar & butter braised carrots as a side$33.95Chicken & Sausage Gumbo
bowl of house-made spicy chicken & Sausage gumbo served with toasted baguette$19.95McGarity's Chicken Curry
house-made mild or spicy chicken curry mixed with carrots, corn, green beans & potatoes served over house-made cheese grits$21.95Cowboy Split Bone Cut Ribeye
huge 16 oz. cowboy cut split bone ribeye topped with a scoop of garlic & herb compound butter. cooked to order. choice of 2 sides$59.95Penne Pasta White Cheddar Mac & Cheese
house-made cheese sauce tossed in penne pasta. topped with toasted breadcrumbs & parmesan reggiano$14.95GLUTEN FREE PASTA Chicken Alfredo
house-made alfredo sauce (parmesan, romano cheese) tossed in gluten free penne pasta. mixed in grilled chicken breast$21.95GLUTEN FREE White Cheddar Mac & Cheese
house-made cheese sauce tossed in cooked to order in gluten free penne pasta$14.95
Sandwiches
McGarity's CheeseBurger
huge 10oz angus pure beef burger cooked to order on a brioche bun. topped with lettuce, tomato & onion. choice of cheddar, provolone, swiss, pepper jack or blue cheese. sliced pickles on the side. add patty 3.95. add bacon 2.95$17.95McGarity's Reuben
tender corned beef, melted swiss cheese, grilled sauerkraut cooked in thousand island dressing. served on toasted marbled rye or toasted baguette. thousand island on the side$19.95The Chicken Sandwich
grilled or house-battered fried chicken served inside an x-large flour tortilla, brioche bun or toasted baguette. lettuce, tomato, avocado & ranch$16.95Irish Banger Sandwich
two irish bangers, sauerkraut, red onions, dijon mustard on a toasted buttered baguette$16.95Chicken Salad Sandwich
chicken salad with cranberries & pecans, lettuce & sliced tomato served on a baguette$14.95Tuna Salad Sandwich
yellowfin tuna salad, lettuce & sliced tomato served on a baguette$14.95
Signature Sides & Extras
Colcannon
(traditional irish mash mixed with cabbage, 2.25 up-charge if added as a choice of side)$9.95House-Made Mash
(make it loaded for 2.95)$6.95Brown Sugar & Butter Braised Carrots
$8.95Grilled Cabbage with Bacon
$7.95Boiled Cabbage
$7.95Asparagus
$7.95Romaine Side Caesar Salad
$8.95House-Made Cheese Grits
$5.95Fresh Green Beans
$5.95Romaine Side Salad
$8.95Seasoned Skin on French Fries
$5.95Sweet Potato Waffle Fries
$5.95Onion Rings
$5.95Bowl of Vegetable Soup
(2.25 up-charge if added as a choice of side)$9.95Loaded Mashed Potatoes
1.95 up-charge if added as a choice of side$7.95Side of Jumbo Shrimp
$13.95Toasted Baguette with butter
$2.95Toasted Brioche Bun with butter
$2.95Toasted Marble Rye Bread with butter
$2.95Grilled Chicken Breast
$6.95Fried Chicken Breast
$6.95Pub Cheese without pretzels
$5.99One Irish Banger Sausage
$3.99Wild Caught Seared Ahi Tuna (No Sides)
$24.95One Irish Reuben Egg Roll
$5.99One Bavarian Pretzel (No Pub Cheese)
$3.99½ Ramekin of Real Grated Parmesan Reggiano
$4.99Small White Cup Shredded Yellow Cheddar Cheese
$1.99One Piece of Guinness battered Cod
$3.99Bowl of Cold Sauerkraut
$1.99Bowl of Hot Sauerkraut
$1.99Two slices of pickles
$0.99Shredded Corned Beef Only
$9.99Bowl of Hot Sauerkraut
$1.99Ramekin Sliced Jalepeno's
$1.99Small White Cup Shredded White Cheddar Cheese
$1.99One House Battered Fried Wild Caught Shrimp
$2.95One Grilled Wild Caught Shrimp
$2.95Ramekin of Real Crab Meat (grilled)
$12.95One Crab Cake
$12.95
Vegan/Vegetarian
Vegan French Dip
caramelized onions & organic jackfruit on a toasted vegan buttered baguette. vegan au jus on the side$14.95OUT OF STOCKSweet BBQ Carnitas Sandwich (Vegan)
organic pulled jackfruit mixed in a sweet vegan bbq sauce, sliced tomatoes, lettuce, served on a toasted vegan buttered baguette$14.95Mixed Vegetable Pesto Pasta (Vegan)
asparagus, green beans, whole cherry tomatoes, onions & vegan penne pasta tossed in a house-made vegan pesto sauce$18.95Double Black Bean Burger (Vegan)
two black bean quinoa veggie burgers served inside a vegan brioche bun. includes lettuce, tomato, sliced onions. sliced pickles on the side$16.95BBQ Organic Jackfruit Wrap (Vegetarian)
pulled organic jackfruit in a sweet bbq sauce with lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, wrapped in a flour tortilla$14.95Vegetarian Alfredo Pasta (Vegetarian)
house-made parmesan & romano cheese alfredo sauce, vegan penne pasta topped with a black bean quinoa veggie patty$19.95Fresh Veggie Wrap (Vegetarian)
pan roasted asparagus, lettuce, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions & avocado with a honey mustard sauce wrapped in a 14" flour tortilla$13.95Crispy Chickpea Salad (Vegetarian)
lettuce, cucumber, tomatoes, avocado, red onions, parmesan topped with crispy fried chickpeas & drizzled with our delicious house-made vinaigrette$12.95Jackfruit Mac-N-Cheese (Vegetarian)
our house signature mac-n-cheese topped with sautéed cajun jackfruit & breadcrumbs$16.95OUT OF STOCK
Desserts
5 Layer Carrot Cake
spiced dessert featuring shredded carrots, pineapple, raisins, & nuts$10.995 Layer Atomic Cheesecake/Cake Blend
chocolate cake, yellow cake, cheesecake, strawberry fruit fillings & chocolate mousse$10.995 Layer Lemon Cake
light, fluffy & refreshingly tangy with cold lemon cream filling$10.995 Layer Chocolate Seduction Cake
artisan quality luxurious, indulgent treat with a deep chocolate profile$10.99Chocolate Hazlenut Espresso Cake
espresso-soaked chocolate layers, hazelnut mousse & honey ganache$10.99
Extra Condiments (Take-Out Only)
Extra Paid Sauces/Dressings
Ramekin Au Jus
$0.99Ramekin BBQ
$0.99Ramekin Buffalo
$0.99Ramekin Cocktail
$0.99Ramekin Horseradish
$0.99Ramekin Mango Habanero
$0.99Ramekin Marinara
$0.99Ramekin Ponzu
$0.99Ramekin Ranch
$0.99Ramekin Sweet Red Chili Sauce
$0.99Ramekin Sweet Teriyaki
$0.99Ramekin Tartar
$0.99Ramekin Worcestershire
$0.99Small Cup of White Country Gravy
$4.99Ramekin Brown Demi Sauce Gravy
$2.99Large Cup of White Country Gravy
$8.99Ramekin Real Whipped Butter
$0.99Ramekin Thousand Island
$0.99Ramekin Creole Sauce
$1.99Ramekin of Pico
$1.99Ramekin Yellow Mustard
$0.99Ramekin Dijon Mustard
$0.99Blackened Red Fish Sauce with Wild Caught Shrimp
$9.99Ramekin Wasabi
$0.99Blackened Red FIsh Sauce (No Redfish)
$14.99Ramekin Sour Cream
$0.99White 8oz Deli Cup of Hot Curry Sauce Only
$4.99White 16oz Deli Cup Medium Curry Sauce Only
$8.99White 8oz Deli Cup of Medium Curry Sauce Only
$4.99White 16oz Deli Cup Hot Curry Sauce Only
$8.99Sliced Strawberries
$1.99Ramekin Sliced Jalapeno's
$0.99Caesar Dressing
$0.99House-made Balsamic Vinaigrette
$0.99Thousand Island
$0.99Ranch
$0.99Honey Mustard
$0.99Blue Cheese with crumbles on top
$1.99Blue Cheese without crumbles
$0.99
Drink Menu
N/A Beverages
Coke
$3.95Coke Zero
$3.95Sprite
$3.95Dr. Pepper
$3.95Diet Dr. Pepper
$3.95Lemonade
$3.95Iced Unsweetened Tea
$3.95Iced Sweet Tea
$3.95Freshly Grounded Cappucino
$5.95Freshly Grounded Decaf Cappucino
$5.95Freshly Grounded Coffee
$4.95Freshly Grounded Decaf Coffee
$4.95Freshly Grounded Espresso
$2.95Freshy Grounded Decaf Espresso
$2.95Barq's Root Beer
$3.95Ginger Ale
$3.95Bottled Pellegrino
$7.95Bottled Aqua Panna
$4.95Cranberry Juice
$4.25Orange Juice
$4.95Ginger Beer
$3.95Pineapple Juice
$3.95Hot Tea
$2.95Red Bull
$4.25Sugar Free Red Bull
$4.25Tonic
$2.95½ & ½ Tea
$3.95
Ramekin BBQ
$0.99
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests, but may not be able to honor it. We are people pleasers, so we will try our best.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 11:00 am - 10:00 pm |
| Monday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Tuesday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Thursday | 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
| Friday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
| Saturday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Restaurant info
FEATURED ON AMERICA'S BEST RESTAURANTS. FEATURED ON NEWSBREAK. NAMED TOP TEN RESTAURANT IN NWA. AMERICAN & IRISH CLASSICS KID FRIENDLY -- 5 & UNDER EAT FREE -- REAL KIDS MENU 479-363-6038 – MCGARITYSRESTAURANT.COM
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.
Made with 
in Boston
in Boston
