
European
Otter Creek Bakery & Deli - in town Middlebury location
14 College Street
Middlebury, VT 05753
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
BAKERY
PASTRIES + COOKIES
HAM + CHEDDAR CROISSANT
$4.75MUSHROOM + ONION + SWISS CROISSANT
Our fresh croissant dough stuffed with caramelized onion, mushroom, and swiss cheese.$4.75PLAIN CROISSANT
Orders must be placed 12 hours in advance. For same-day availability, please call the bakery.$4.00ORANGE ALMOND CROISSANT
$4.25CHOCOLATE CROISSANT
Orders must be placed 12 hours in advance. For same-day availability, please call the bakery.$4.25CINNAMON ROLL CROISSANT
Orders must be placed 12 hours in advance. For same-day availability, please call the bakery.$4.25APPLE STRUDEL
Dairy Free.$3.75MAPLE CREAM CHEESE DANISH
$4.50CINNAMON TWIST
$2.50SCONE
$3.50MUFFIN
$3.50HONEY CORN SCONE
$2.50OTTER PAW
Puff pastry filled with lemon-poppyseed cream cheese$3.50GF + V MUFFIN
Gluten Free/Dairy Free$3.75CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
$2.75MAPLE OATMEAL RAISIN COOKIE
$2.75CHOCOLATE ORANGE PECAN COOKIE
$2.75WHITE CHOCOLATE CHUNK COOKIE
Fudgy dark chocolate cookie with white chocolate chunks.$2.75PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE
$2.75SUGAR COOKIE
$2.75RASPEBERRY JAM HEART
$1.50ORANGE JAM HEART
$1.50OUT OF STOCKHONEY COCONUT MACAROON -GF
Honey and coconut macaroon dipped in chocolate.$3.00maple snickerdoodle
$2.75pepperjack and roasted red pepp danish
$4.50
3 ITEMS + PASTRY & COOKIE
HAM + CHEDDAR CROISSANT
$4.75MUSHROOM + ONION + SWISS CROISSANT
Our fresh croissant dough stuffed with caramelized onion, mushroom, and swiss cheese.$4.75PLAIN CROISSANT
Orders must be placed 12 hours in advance. For same-day availability, please call the bakery.$4.00ORANGE ALMOND CROISSANT
$4.25CHOCOLATE CROISSANT
Orders must be placed 12 hours in advance. For same-day availability, please call the bakery.$4.25CINNAMON ROLL CROISSANT
Orders must be placed 12 hours in advance. For same-day availability, please call the bakery.$4.25APPLE STRUDEL
Dairy Free.$3.75MAPLE CREAM CHEESE DANISH
$4.50CINNAMON TWIST
$2.50SCONE
$3.50MUFFIN
$3.50HONEY CORN SCONE
$2.50OTTER PAW
Puff pastry filled with lemon-poppyseed cream cheese$3.50GF + V MUFFIN
Gluten Free/Dairy Free$3.75CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE
$2.75MAPLE OATMEAL RAISIN COOKIE
$2.75CHOCOLATE ORANGE PECAN COOKIE
$2.75WHITE CHOCOLATE CHUNK COOKIE
Fudgy dark chocolate cookie with white chocolate chunks.$2.75PEANUT BUTTER COOKIE
$2.75SUGAR COOKIE
$2.75RASPEBERRY JAM HEART
$1.50ORANGE JAM HEART
$1.50OUT OF STOCKHONEY COCONUT MACAROON -GF
Honey and coconut macaroon dipped in chocolate.$3.00Nutella No Bake - 4 pack
$5.75roasted red pepper and pepperjack danish
$4.50
DELI
SANDWICHES
BUILD YOUR OWN
$12.00OTTER CREEK SUB
On French Baguette, Italian Oil, Hot Pepper Spread, Maple Cured Ham, Smoked Turkey, Salami, Provolone, Tomato, Red Onion, Pickles, Mixed Greens$15.00WEST COASTER
On Sourdough, Avocado Spread, Honey Mustard, Sun-dried Tomato Spread, Smoked Turkey, Cheddar, Mixed Greens$14.00MID-WESTER
On Sourdough, Horseradish Mayo, Roast Beef, Provolone, Tomato, Red Onion, Mixed Greens$15.00CRUNCHY OTTER
Sourdough, Maple Mayo, Smoked Turkey, Cheddar, Tomato, Apple, Red Onion, Mixed Greens.$14.00BLT
On Toasted Sourdough, Mayo, Bacon Tomato, Mixed Greens$13.00BLT & BRIE
On Toasted Sourdough, Mayo, Bacon Tomato, Mixed Greens, Brie$14.50NORWEIGAN
On Rye, Dill Cream Cheese, Smoked Salmon, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onions, Mixed Greens.$16.00VERMONTER
On Sourdough, Creamy Goat Cheese, Honey Mustard, Tomato, Cucumber, Carrots, Mixed Greens.$10.50GREEK POCKET
On Pita, Olive Oil, Feta, Tomato, Cucumbers, Black Olives, Spinach.$11.00HUMMUS POCKET
On Pita, Olive Oil, Hummus, Tomato, Red Onion, Mixed greens.$12.00CHICKEN SALAD SANDWICH
On Sourdough, Chicken Salad, Tomato, Mixed Green.$12.00TUNA SALAD SANDWICH
On Sourdough, Tuna, Tomato, Mixed Green.$12.00
PANINI
BYO PANINI
$11.00PESTO PANINI
On Sourdough, Pesto, Sun-dried Tomato Spread, Provolone, Caramelized Onion, Spinach. Chicken or Veggie$13.00+RUBEN PANINI
On Rye, Russian Dressing, Sauerkraut, Pastrami, Swiss.$13.00BAKED HAM & BRIE PANINI
On Sourdough, Dijon Mustard, Maple Ham, Brie, Tomato.$12.00cuban panini
$16.00
BEVERAGES
ESPRESSO + COFFEE + TEA
HOT COFFEE
Fresh Awake Coffee, Brewed Locally, Dark, Medium, Light, Decaf$2.00+ICED COFFEE
$3.00TEA
$1.75+MACCHIATO
Espresso + Dollop Foamed Milk$4.00+ESPRESSO SHOT (DOUBLE)
Locally Roasted, Fair Trade & Organic.$3.00+CORTADO
Equal Parts Espresso + Milk.$3.75+AMERICANO
Espresso + Hot Water.$3.50+CAPPUCCINO
Espresso + Foamed Milk.$4.00LATTE
Espresso + Steamed Milk$5.00+FLAT WHITE 8 OZ NO FOAM
Small Latte No Foam$3.00+RED EYE
Espresso + Brewed Coffee.$4.50+CAFE AU LAIT
Brewed Coffee + Steamed Milk.$3.50+MOCHA
Espresso + Foamed milk + Cocoa$5.00+BOX OF JOE TO GO
Box of your choice of coffee. Serves 12 people, comes with cups, lids, milk, coffee sleeves, stirrers, sugar, splenda,$26.00
NON ESPRESSO
HOT COCOA
Our house-made hot chocolate mix with steamed milk. Note: contains milk powder (not vegan).$3.00+CHAI
Spiced + Sweetened Chai + Foamed Milk Add a shot to make it a dirty Chai$4.00+MATCHA
Organic Matcha Powder + Steamed Milk.$4.50+LONDON FOG
Early Grey Tea + Steamed Milk + Lavender, Vanilla Syrup.$3.50+MAPLE STEAMER
Steamed Milk + Maple Syrup. (Fun For Kids)$2.50+
MATCHA
$0.00
Organic Matcha Powder + Steamed Milk.
Customize your item
MATCHA SIZE
Required
Select 1
MILK OPTIONS
Select up to 1
SYRUPS + SWEETENERS
Select up to 1
Request advisory
Additions may be charged extra.
1
All hours
| Sunday | 7:30 am - 1:45 pm |
| Monday | 7:30 am - 1:45 pm |
| Tuesday | 7:30 am - 1:45 pm |
| Wednesday | 7:30 am - 1:45 pm |
| Thursday | 7:30 am - 1:45 pm |
| Friday | 7:30 am - 1:45 pm |
| Saturday | 7:30 am - 1:45 pm |
Restaurant info
Otter Creek Bakery & Deli, in downtown Middlebury at 14 College Street.
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.





