
Deli
Penny's
104 E Clay Avenue
Lexington, KY 40502
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Only
Food
Snacks
Sandwiches
Benedictine BLT
toasted Midway Bakery milk bread with crispy bacon, sliced and seasoned local tomatoes, cucumbers, lettuce & benedictine spread$11.00Turkey Rachel
Midway Bakery milk bread with shaved turkey breast, swiss cheese, Penny’s pepita slaw, thousand island dressing, and pickled red onions$12.00Pimento Grilled Cheese
Midway Bakery milk bread with pimento cheese, swiss, roasted red peppers and onions.$10.00Shady Lane Chicken Salad Wrap
made with toasted almonds, celery, and dried cranberries, with romaine, pickled red onions and cranberry chutney$12.00OUT OF STOCKMediterranean Grain Wrap
massaged kale, mixed grains, marinated roasted red peppers, curried chickpeas, pickled red onions, feta, lemon tahini vinaigrette$10.00
Salads & Bowls
Penny's Pepita Crunch
shredded cabbage, kale and broccoli, dried cranberries, toasted pepitas, crumbled feta, pickled onions, creamy poppyseed dressing$13.00Chef's Wedge
RomaCrunch wedge, sliced cucumbers, tomatoes, pickled red onions, grilled chicken breast, bacon bits & basil pesto ranch$13.00Great Grains Bowl
chopped lettuce, mixed grains, marinated roasted red peppers, curried chickpeas, pickled red onions, toasted pepitas, feta, lemon tahini vinaigrette$11.00
Sides & Spreads
Pepita Poppyseed Slaw
$5.00Green Pesto Pasta Salad
a light pesto dressed pasta salad with peas & asparagus$5.00Pimento Cheese
half pint of our house made pimento cheese to enjoy here, at home or at the office$8.00Chicken Salad
half pint of our house made chicken salad with cranberries, celery and toasted almonds. to enjoy here, at home or at the office!$8.00OUT OF STOCKBenedictine
a traditional Kentucky spread made of cream cheese and cucumber. sold by the half-pint$8.00Pide Crackers
Fresh from the Midway Bakery, these crispy yeast risen flat bread crackers are perfect for dipping in our house made spreads!$3.00Sea Salt Kettle Chips
$3.00
Soup
Have our specialty soup by the cup hot, or take home to heat up and enjoy later!
Bakery
7 Layer Bar
Fresh from the Midway Bakery! Graham cracker crust with chocolate chips, butterscotch chips, coconut & pecans.$5.00Brownie Bar
Fresh from the Midway Bakery! Dense and rich, topped with chocolate ganache (aka "The Danger Brownie").$5.00Lemon Bar
Fresh from the Midway Bakery! Made with lemon juice and zest and a rich, buttery crust.$5.00Chocolate Chip Cookie
Fresh from the Midway Bakery, this classic is the perfect midday treat!$4.00OUT OF STOCKOatmeal Raisin Cookie
$4.00Peanut Butter Cookie
Fresh from the Midway Bakery, this cookie will satisfy all your peanut-buttery cravings!$4.00Corn Cookie
Fresh from the Midway Bakery, our corn cookie magically taste like buttery corn on the cob, thanks to a healthy helping of Weisenberger Mill cornmeal from just down the road.$2.00Sorghum Cookie
Fresh from the Midway Bakery. An old family recipe from local cookbook author Rona Roberts and her mother, made with Country Rock sorghum, boiled down every autumn by Randal Rock on his Woodford County farm.$2.00GF Brownie
$5.00OUT OF STOCKPeanut Butter Bliss Bar GF & Vegan
$5.00
Drinks
Cold Drinks
Elixir Kombucha
Made right up the road in Louisville, KY. Revel in the magic of Elixir Kombucha - where flavor and wellbeing unite. Available in either Blueberry Pomegranate or Lavender Lemonade.$6.00Natalie's Lemonade
Refresh with Natalie's fresh-press lemonade, available in classic or strawberry.$4.00OUT OF STOCKFrothy Cold Brew
Frothy Monkey cold brew coffee is natural, sugar-free, low calorie, and plant-based, making it vegan, vegetarian, keto, and paleo-friendly.$6.00Phocus
Refresh your taste buds with this caffeinated sparkling water that enhances clarity and drives focus. Available in Blood Orange, Lemon Lime, or Mixed Berry.$4.00Coca Cola Product
Always cold and in a can! Choose from Regular Coke, Diet Coke, or Sprite.$2.00Iced Tea
$3.00Hot Coffee
$2.00Hot Tea
$3.00Seb's sips
House made with strawberries from Stepping Stone$4.00
Catering Party Platters
Platters
Arranged spreads of Kentucky classics for any offsite occasion. Order with 48 hours notice and schedule a pickup at Penny's! Prices include disposable plates, napkins and silverware. The estimated number of guests each platter will feed is listed; simply order multiples if your crowd is larger. These are packed to-go. Please email us if you want to host a party at Penny's!
Kentucky Cocktail Party
serves between 12-20 depending upon appetites COUNTRY HAM BISCUITS with apple butter, 2 dozen CHEESE WAFERS with pecan 2 dozen PIMENTO CHEESE, 1 pint KENTUCKY BENEDICTINE, 1 pint WARM MARINATED OLIVES, ½ pint SPICED NUTS, ½ pint DRESSED EGGS sour cream, lemon and chive, 2 dozen ACCOMPANIMENTS crackers, crostini and fresh cut vegetables JUMBO SHRIMP COCKTAIL with classic cocktail sauce and lemons, 5 dozen HOT BROWN GOUGERES, 2 dozen STRAWBERRIES REBECCA, 2 dozen BABY SORGHUM COOKIES, 3 dozen$475.00Pomegranate Mezze Party
serves between 12-20 depending upon appetites BABA GANOUSH, 1 pint DAVID’S HUMMUS with seasonal topping, 1 pint MUHAMMARA with pomegranate seeds, ½ pint ACCOMPANIMENTS toasted pita and fresh cut vegetables WARM MARINATED OLIVES, 1 pint MARINATED FETA CHEESE, 1 pint DOLMAS, 2 dozen LAMB MEATBALLS with tzatziki, 2 dozen CHICKEN SHAWARMA SKEWERS, 2 dozen CRISPY FALAFEL FRITTERS, 2 dozen TABBOULEH SALAD, 2 quarts SCRATCH MADE BAKLAVA, 2 dozen FRESH FRUIT$475.00Grazing Party
serves 24-36 depending upon appetites VEGETABLES featuring local vegetables when possible SMOKED TOMATO RANCH & DAVID’S HUMMUS additional dips available upon request FRESH FRUIT DISPLAY minted melon balls, strawberries and Rebecca sauce (vanilla sour cream sauce) red and green grapes, pineapple, and blueberries ARTISAN CHEESES baby baked camembert, marinated bocconcini, fresh Capriole goat cheese, Tillamook aged sharp white cheddar, Kenny’s Kentucky blue and Kenny’s gouda CHARCUTERIE Kentucky country ham, artisan salami, Spanish aged chorizo, thin sliced capicola, house made pate de campagne, olives, cornichons, dijonnaise ACCOMPANIMENTS water crackers, sourdough croustades, toasted almonds, apple mostarda, scratch made zaatar potato chips, rosemary cashews PICKUP SWEETS assorted little cookies, lemon bars, brownies and seven layer bars,$1,150.00Tea and Scone Party
serves 12-20 depending upon appetites TEA SANDWICHES chicken salad with dried cranberries and toasted almonds, benedictine and bacon with thin sliced cucumber, egg salad, pimento cheese, strawberries and lemon cream, 1 dozen each PROSCIUTTO WRAPPED ASPARAGUS, 2 dozen BABY BRIE AND FIG JAM TARTS, 2 dozen MINI BETTY ANN SCONES, 1 dozen CINNAMON SCONES with whipped sorghum butter, 1 dozen PICKUP SWEETS lemon bars, brownies, blueberry cheesecake bar and assorted cookies, 3 dozen pieces ELMWOOD INN FINE TEAS hot or iced, Cup of Serenity or Kentucky Black$400.00
Phocus
$4.00
Refresh your taste buds with this caffeinated sparkling water that enhances clarity and drives focus. Available in Blood Orange, Lemon Lime, or Mixed Berry.
Customize your item
Flavor
Required
Select 1
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1
All hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 10:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Wednesday | 10:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Thursday | 10:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Friday | 10:00 am - 2:00 pm |
| Saturday | 10:00 am - 2:00 pm |
Restaurant info
Intentionally intensely local bites for now, for later, for any time — always fresh. In the Pomegranate courtyard for patio dining and to go orders!
Location
Similar restaurants in your area
© 2026 Toast, Inc.



