Skip to Main content
  • Peter Pan Diner

    • Home
    • /
    • Bay Shore
    • /
    • Peter Pan Diner
    Restaurant banner image
    American

    Peter Pan Diner

    999 Sunrise Highway

    Bay Shore, NY 11706


    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant


    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    Gift Cards

    BEVERAGES
    BREAKFAST
    LUNCH
    DINNER
    KIDS MENU
    DESSERT / ICE CREAM

    BEVERAGES

    Drinks

    • Soda

      $3.75
    • Club Soda

      $2.75
    • Ginger Ale

      $3.75
    • Hot Tea

      $3.99
    • Iced Tea (Sweet)

      $3.75
    • Brewed Iced Tea (Unsweetened)

      $4.68
    • Lemonade (Reg)

      $3.75
    • Juice (Small)

      Orange, Apple,Cranberry,Grapefruit,Pineapple,V8.
      $4.50
    • Juice (Large)

      Orange, Apple,Cranberry,Grapefruit,Pineapple,V8.
      $5.50
    • Milk (Small)

      $3.50
    • Milk (Large)

      $4.25
    • Chocolate Milk (Small)

      $3.95
    • Chocolate Milk (Large)

      $4.50
    • Iced Coffee

      $3.75
    • Espresso (Single)

      $4.99
    • Espresso (Double)

      $6.99
    • Latte

      Served hot or iced; espresso blended with steamed milk and a light layer of foam; smooth & rich with your choice of flavor.
      $5.99
    • Cappuccino

      Rich espresso, silky milk, thick layer of foam; smooth and aromatic.
      $5.99
    • Cold Brew

      Rich cold brew for a smooth creamy & bold taste.
      $5.99
    • Cafe Mocha

      Espresso with rich chocolate and steamed milk topped with a light layer of foam.
      $5.99
    • Coffee

      $3.99
    • Decaf

      $3.99
    • Hot Chocolate

      $3.50

    Red Bull

    • Red Bull

      $4.00
    • Sugar Free Red Bull

      $4.00

    BREAKFAST

    Eggs

    • Classic Benny

      Poached eggs, toasted English muffin, creamy hollandaise sauce, with caramelized Canadian bacon. Served with home fries.
      $18.30
    • Smashed Avocado Benny

      Poached eggs, toasted English muffin, creamy hollandaise sauce with roasted roma tomato, sautéed spinach, and smoked bacon. Served with home fries.
      $18.30
    • Smoked Salmon Benny

      Poached eggs, toasted English muffin, creamy hollandaise sauce with fresh spinach and topped with capers. Served with home fries.
      $19.35
    • CB Hash & Eggs

      Two eggs any style over hash, served with home fries and toast.
      $15.85
    • Two Eggs

      Two eggs any style with home fries and toast.
      $12.35
    • One Egg & Cheese Sandwich (Club Roll)

      One Egg, American Cheese on a Club Roll
      $7.20
    • Steak & Two Eggs

      $28.85
    • One Egg On A Club Roll [No Cheese]

      One Egg on a Club Roll
      $6.15

    French Toast & Waffle Delights

    • Belgian Waffle

      Served with Butter and Syrup.
      $13.40
    • Belgian Waffle Topped With Fresh Fruit

      $17.50
    • Belgian Waffle With Greek Yogurt And Fresh Fruit

      $19.60
    • Chicken & Waffles

      $21.10
    • Cinnamon Dream French Toast

      Golden-griddled cinnamon swirl bread, bananas, topped with cream cheese drizzle.
      $17.85
    • French Toast Bites

      Topped with mixed berries and nutella.
      $16.95
    • French Toast With Fruit

      Thick cut challah bread, topped with strawberry, banana and blueberries.
      $17.00
    • La Waffle Royale

      Belgian waffle, nutella, two scoops of ice cream, strawberries, bananas, topped with chocolate sauce and whipped cream.
      $22.65
    • Peter Pan Original French Toast

      Thick cut challah bread.
      $15.95
    • Stuffed French Toast

      Stuffed with cream cheese, fresh strawberries and bananas topped with compote and whipped cream.
      $17.85

    Just Landed

    • Avocado Italiano Toast

      Fresh avocado smash, balsamic tomato bruschetta, topped with two eggs any style and a balsamic reduction drizzled over two slices of multigrain toast.
      $17.50
    • Berry, Berry Good Morning Bowl

      Three scrambled eggs, mixed farm fresh berries, avocado and orange slices.
      $15.45
    • Breakfast Burrito

      Scrambled eggs, bacon, avocado and jack blend.
      $18.55
    • Greek Avocado Toast

      Fresh avocado smash, grilled roma tomatoes, kalamata olives, feta, topped with two eggs any style, capers and a lemon vinaigrette drizzle over two slices of multigrain toast.
      $17.50
    • Greek Sunrise Burrito

      Scrambled eggs, spinach, cucumber, tomato, kalamata olives, feta and tzatziki.
      $17.50
    • Mediterranean Sunrise Bowl

      Two poached eggs, grilled roma tomato, chickpeas, basil hummus, arugula, finished with hollandaise.
      $19.10
    • Mexicano Avocado Toast

      Fresh avocado smash, pico de gallo, topped with two eggs any style and red chili flakes over two slices of multigrain toast.
      $17.50
    • Sweet And Crunchy Yogurt Bliss Bowl

      Greek yogurt, berries, granola, sliced almonds and honey drizzle.
      $14.45
    • Bagel All The Way

      $25.75

    Omelets/Wrap

    • Avocado Omelet

      $18.55
    • Breakfast Wrap up to 3 Items

      Your choice of 3 ingredients with 3 scrambled eggs. Served with home fries, salsa and sour cream.
      $18.85
    • Farmer's Omelet

      Bacon, Ham, Mushrooms and Sausage. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $18.55
    • Greek Omelet

      Herbs, Feta Cheese, Onions and Spinach. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $18.55
    • Mexican Omelet

      with Chili, Cheddar Cheese and Sour Cream. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $18.55
    • Turkey Avocado Fusion Omelet

      $18.55
    • Veggie Omelet

      $18.55
    • Western Omelet

      Ham, Peppers and Onions. Served with toast and your choice of side.
      $18.55
    • Create Omelet up to 3 Items

      $18.55

    Peter Pancakes

    • Baked Apple And Cinnamon Swirl Pancakes

      Topped with whipped cream.
      $17.50
    • Banana Walnut And Caramel Sauce Pancakes

      Topped with whipped cream.
      $17.50
    • Blueberry And Almond Pancakes

      Topped with whipped cream.
      $17.50
    • Chocolate Chip Pancakes

      Topped with whipped cream.
      $17.50
    • Classic Pan Stack Pancakes

      $13.40
    • Oreo And Nutella Pancakes

      Topped with whipped cream.
      $17.50
    • Peanut Butter Pancakes

      Topped with whipped cream.
      $17.50
    • Peter Pancakes

      S'mores pancakes, with Graham Crackers & Chocolate Syrup
      $17.50
    • Short Stack Pancakes

      Served with Butter and Syrup.
      $10.30
    • The Big Stack Show Pancakes

      Fresh Strawberry, Banana & Bluberries topped with Whipped Cream
      $17.50

    The Bread Basket

    • Assorted Danish (1)

      $4.95
    • Assorted Muffins (1)

      Corn, bran, blueberry, oatmeal, & cinnamon.
      $4.15
    • Bagel With Butter

      $3.45
    • Bagel With Cream Cheese

      $4.60
    • Bagel With Lox & Cream Cheese

      $19.40
    • Buttered Toast

      With jelly or marmalade.
      $2.70
    • Cinnamon Toast (3)

      $3.80
    • English Muffin Or Pita

      $3.10
    • Hard Roll

      $2.90

    LUNCH

    Appetizers

    • Baked Clams

      $19.60
    • Cheeseburger Sliders (3)

      $14.45
    • Chicken Tenders

      $17.25
    • Chicken Tenders with French Fries

      $21.40
    • Chicken Wings (12)

      Served naked, hot honey, general tso’s, or Frank's RedHot.
      $19.60
    • Disco Fries

      Melted mozzarella and gravy over french fries.
      $15.45
    • Everything Pretzel Bites

      With honey mustard and cheese sauce.
      $14.45
    • Fried Calamari

      $19.60
    • Fried Pickles

      Served with horseradish sauce.
      $14.45
    • Jalapeno Poppers

      $14.45
    • Loaded Nachos

      Black beans, olives, salsa, guacamole, diced tomatoes, sour cream, warm queso sauce and scallions. Topped with chili
      $21.65
    • Loaded Tater Tots

      With cheese sauce, bacon, and scallions.
      $12.35
    • Mediterranean Hummus & Pita

      Hummus, kalamata olives, diced tomatoes, olive oil drizzle.
      $13.40
    • Mozzarella Squares [4]

      with Marinara Sauce
      $16.50
    • Pulled Pork Sliders (3)

      $14.45
    • Spanakopita

      Spinach pie.
      $13.40

    Between The Bread

    • BLT

      $13.40
    • Carving Board Sandwich

      $16.50
    • Chicken Gryo

      Gyro served with Greek Salad
      $19.60
    • Chicken Salad Sandwich

      $14.45
    • Chicken Souvlaki

      Souvlaki comes with a Greek Salad
      $25.75
    • Chili Melt Sandwich

      $14.45
    • Classic Reuben

      served with Potato Salad and a Pickle
      $20.60
    • Fried Crispy Chicken Sandwich Deluxe

      Served on a toasted brioche bun, signature sauce and a Pickle
      $19.60
    • Grilled Cheese

      $12.35
    • Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich

      $19.60
    • Gyro

      $19.60
    • Hot Open Roast Beef

      $22.65
    • Hot Open Turkey

      $22.65
    • Long Islander Sandwich

      $22.65
    • New Champ

      Prime Rib with Chedder, Mushrooms on a toasted hero
      $25.75
    • Pear & Fig Formaggio

      $16.50
    • Philly Cheesesteak

      Roasted Prime Rib, onions, peppers and cheese sauce
      $26.75
    • Roast Beef Sandwich

      comes with Lettuce and Tomato
      $16.50
    • Souvlaki

      $25.75
    • Steakhouse Sandwich

      Sliced Skirt Steak, grilled Onions & Peppers, Melted Provolone, Chimichurri Sauce on Garlic Bread
      $25.75
    • Texas Smoke Sandwich

      Fried Chicken, melted Chedder, Bacon, BBQ Sauce on a toasted Sourdough Bread
      $20.60
    • Tuna Melt

      Tuna Salad served with melted American Cheese
      $15.45
    • Tuna Salad Sandwich

      $14.45
    • Turkey Club Sandwich

      $19.60
    • NY Knick Prime Rib Sanwich

      $27.75

    Burgers

    • Cali Burger

      Fresh Sliced Avocado, Bacon and Melted Swiss Cheese
      $20.60
    • Call My Doctor Burger

      Chunky Bleu Cheese with Bacon
      $20.60
    • Cubano Burger

      Jack Daniels Pulled Pork, Diced Pineapple and Swiss Cheese.
      $20.60
    • Jumbo Burger [No Fries]

      Your choice of patty served on a toasted bun with coleslaw and pickle.
      $12.90
    • Jumbo Burger Deluxe

      Your choice of patty served on a toasted bun with your Choice of French Fries, Onion Rings, Lettuce, Tomato, Coleslaw and a Pickle.
      $18.05
    • Loaded Double Smash Burger

      Smashed patties, layered with melted cheese, bacon, shoestring onions, shredded lettuce, tomato and house sauce. Served with french fries.
      $20.60
    • Lone Star Chili Cheeseburger

      Loaded with Beef Chili and Cheddar Cheese. Served with Sour Cream and Salsa.
      $20.60
    • Patty Melt

      Served on Grilled Rye Bread, Smothered with Sautéed Onions, American Cheese and Russian Dressing
      $20.60
    • Peter Pan's Classic Sliders (4)

      $20.60
    • PPD House Burger

      Topped with blue cheese, shoestring onions and house sauce. Served with french fries.
      $20.60
    • The Mexi Max Burger

      Pepper jack cheese, guacamole, bacon and tomatoes .Served with french fries.
      $20.60
    • The Unique Greek Burger

      Topped with feta cheese, kalamata olives, tomato, spiced with greek oregano and tzatziki sauce. Served with french fries.
      $20.60

    Paninis

    • Ham And Cheddar Melt Panini

      Honey maple ham, sharp cheddar, tomato, pickle slices, honey dijon mustard. Served with french fries or soup.
      $20.35
    • Peter Pan Panini

      Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella, Grilled Spinach and Roasted Red Peppers. Served with your Choice of Side.
      $20.35
    • Steak And Blue Pressed Panini

      Sliced skirt steak, crispy onions, blue cheese crumbles served with blue cheese dressing and A1 steak sauce. Served with french fries or soup.
      $23.65
    • Turkey Club Panini

      Roasted Turkey, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Roasted Red Peppers and Tomato with your Choice of Dressing. Served with your Choice of Side.
      $20.35
    • Veggie Panini

      Mushrooms, Mozzarella Cheese, Onion, Black Olives, Roasted Red Peppers and a Balsamic Glaze. Served with your Choice of Side.
      $20.35

    Quesadillas & Fajitas

    • Chicken Quesadilla

      Grilled Chicken with Onions, Peppers and Jack Blend Cheese. Served with Salsa and Sour Cream.
      $22.65
    • Fajitas (Chicken)

      Sizzling strips of marinated chicken, grilled with fresh peppers and onions served hot with warm tortillas.
      $25.75
    • Fajitas (Combo: Chicken, Steak, and Shrimp)

      Sizzling strips grilled with fresh peppers and onions served hot with warm tortillas.
      $30.85
    • Fajitas (Steak)

      Sizzling strips of marinated beef, grilled with fresh peppers and onions served hot with warm tortillas.
      $29.85
    • Garden Of Eatin' Quesadilla

      Grilled fresh spinach with garlic, tomatoes, onions and black beans sautéed in olive oil with choice of cheese, salsa, sour cream.
      $22.65
    • Pork And Cheese Overload Quesadilla

      Creamy mac & cheese, pulled pork folded in a crispy tortilla.
      $22.65
    • Roman Holiday Quesadilla

      Grilled Shrimp with Garlic, Mozzarella Cheese, Olive Oil, Onions, Tomatoes. Served with Salsa and Sour Cream.
      $25.70
    • South Of The Border Quesadilla

      Chili, beans, fresh spinach, three cheeses, salsa, sour cream.
      $20.60
    • Steak Quesadilla

      Skirt steak with jack cheese, fried mushrooms, onions.
      $25.70

    Salads

    • Chef's Salad

      Assorted greens with turkey, ham, roast beef, swiss & hard boiled egg. All salads served with toasted pita bread.
      $25.25
    • Cobb Salad

      Diced chicken or turkey bacon, avocado, bleu cheese, hard boiled egg & tomato with red wine vinaigrette. All salads served with toasted pita bread
      $23.20
    • Crispy Chicken Salad

      Fried chicken cutlet strips, romaine lettuce, bacon, cheddar, black olives and cherry tomatoes. All salads served with toasted pita bread.
      $24.00
    • Fruiti-Aki Salad

      Teriyaki chicken, mandarin oranges, strawberries, bananas, grape tomatoes, pineapple ring and sliced almonds served over mixed greens.
      $24.00
    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

      Grilled chicken, crisp romaine caesar salad, garlic croutons. All salads served with toasted pita bread.
      $24.00
    • Grilled Salmon Caesar Salad

      Grilled salmon over caesar salad. All salads served with toasted pita bread.
      $25.35
    • Our Famous Greek Salad

      Topped with feta cheese and greek olives. All salads served with toasted pita bread.
      $20.10
    • Santa Fe Cajun Chicken Salad

      Grilled cajun chicken, crisp romaine lettuce, garlic croutons, monterey jack cheese blend, guacamole, sour cream and salsa. All salads served with toasted pita bread.
      $24.00
    • Spinach Salad

      Spinach, mushrooms, bacon, boiled egg & red onion. All salads served with toasted pita bread.
      $20.60
    • Caesar Salad

      $18.55

    Sides

    • Bacon/Ham/Sausage (Side)

      $5.80
    • Canadian Bacon (Side)

      $7.55
    • Chili Cheese Fries

      $8.95
    • Cole Slaw

      $3.00
    • Corned Beef Hash (Side)

      $7.85
    • Cottage Cheese

      $4.95
    • Curly Fries

      $8.25
    • Feta Cheese

      $5.45
    • French Fries

      $7.20
    • Garlic Bread Or Bread Basket

      $4.65
    • Grape Leaves (5)

      $4.45
    • Greek Dinner Salad

      $11.35
    • Gyro Meat (Side)

      $10.30
    • Home Fries

      $8.15
    • Onion Rings

      $9.30
    • Pita

      $3.10
    • Potato Salad

      $4.25
    • Sauteed Spinach

      $5.15
    • Side Avocado

      $3.10
    • Sliced Turkey (Side)

      $5.55
    • Spaghetti With Tomato Sauce

      With meat sauce +2.00.
      $10.30
    • Steak Fries

      $8.25
    • Sweet Potato Fries

      $8.25
    • Tater Tots

      $8.25
    • Tossed Salad

      $9.30
    • Turkey Bacon Or Turkey Sausage (Side)

      $7.20
    • Vegetable Of The Day

      $4.00
    • Waffle Fries

      $8.25

    Soups

    • French Onion Soup

      $9.30
    • Soup (Bowl)

      Chicken noodle soup, matzah ball soup, or greek lemon orzo soup.
      $6.25
    • Soup (Cup)

      Chicken noodle soup, matzah ball soup, or greek lemon orzo soup.
      $5.15
    • Soup (Pint)

      $6.20
    • Soup (Quart)

      $10.30

    Wraps

    • Brooklyn Bridge Pastrami Wrap

      Hot NY Style Pastrami, Swiss Cheese and Sauerkraut
      $19.60
    • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

      Fried Chicken Strips Topped with Frank's Hot Sauce, Jack Blend Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato. Served with Bleu Cheese Dressing
      $19.60
    • Chicken, Avocado, BLT Wrap

      With ranch dressing. Served with french fries or soup.
      $19.60
    • Greek Salad Chicken Wrap

      Grilled chicken with romaine lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onion, kalamata olives, feta cheese, creamy tzatziki and greek salad dressing. Served with french fries or soup.
      $19.60
    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap

      Grilled Chicken, Caesar Salad and Croutons
      $19.60
    • Hot Honey Chicken Wrap

      Crispy chicken, cole slaw, diced bacon, pickles and hot honey. Served with french fries or soup.
      $19.60
    • Korean BBQ Steak Wrap

      Grilled skirt steak coated in a savory korean bbq sauce, layered with rice, broccoli and lettuce. Served with french fries or soup.
      $20.75
    • Mango Tango Wrap

      Grilled Chicken with Lettuce, Mandarin Oranges, Pineapple, Red Pepper,
      $19.60
    • Steakhouse Wrap

      Grilled skirt steak, sauteed onions & peppers, melted jack cheese, chipotle aioli. Served with french fries or soup.
      $21.80
    • Taco Wrap

      with Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Sour Cream and Tomato with Salsa on the Side.
      $19.60
    • Tom Turkey Wrap

      Roasted turkey, lettuce and tomato. Served with french fries or soup.
      $18.55
    • Gobble Gobble Wrap

      Roast Turkey and Stuffing
      $18.00

    Hot Dog Heaven

    • Classic Hot Dog

      $10.30
    • Chili Cheese Dog

      $11.35

    DINNER

    Entrees

    • Broiled Filet of Flounder Oreganata

      Seasoned with italian bread crumbs, garlic butter, and capers. Served with choice of soup or salad, potato & vegetable.
      $29.90
    • Broiled Salmon

      Served over sautéed spinach and tomatoes. Served with choice of soup or salad, potato & vegetable.
      $30.90
    • Broiled Scrod Mykonos

      Asparagus, kalamata olives and grape tomatoes. Served with choice of soup or salad, potato & vegetable.
      $30.90
    • Grilled Greek Lamb Chops

      Served with latholemono sauce. Served with choice of soup or salad, potato & vegetable.
      $36.05
    • Grilled Shrimp Bruschetta

      Garlic shrimp with tomatoes, scallions, and olive oil, served over garlic toast. Served with choice of soup or salad, potato & vegetable.
      $30.90
    • Skirt Steak Combo

      Served with a choice of garlic shrimp, stuffed shrimp, or stuffed mushrooms.
      $35.00
    • Sliced Steak Teriyaki

      Grilled fresh peppers, onions, tomatoes on toasted garlic bread. Served with choice of soup or salad, potato & vegetable.
      $36.05
    • Spanakopita Dinner

      Served with Rice or Potato and Soup or Salad.
      $24.75

    KIDS MENU

    Kids Meal

    • Egg-Cellent Breakfast

      One pancake, one egg, and two slices of bacon.
      $9.25
    • Tinkerbell Tenders

      Chicken tenders served with french fries or fruit.
      $14.40
    • Pan’s Perfect Grilled Cheese

      Golden, buttery bread, melted American cheese, served with french fries or fruit.
      $10.30
    • Golden Treasure Mac & Cheese

      Cheesy macaroni made just right for little adventurers.
      $12.30
    • Lost Boys Cheeseburger

      Served with french fries or fruit
      $13.35
    • Neverland Hot Dog

      Classic hot dog on a soft bun, served with french fries or fruit.
      $11.30
    • Storybook Sliders

      Served with french fries.
      $14.40
    • Peter's Pasta Bowl

      $10.30
    • Pixie Melt Quesadilla

      Served with french fries.
      $11.30

    Kids Meal Drinks

    • Small Fountain Soda

    • Small Club Soda

    • Small Ginger Ale

    • Small Brewed Iced Tea (Unsweetened)

    • Small Iced Tea (Sweet)

    • Small Lemonade

    • Small Juicea

    • Small Milk

    • Small Chocolate Milk

    Kids Meal Dessert

    • Cookie

    • Ice Cream ( One Scoop)


    DESSERT / ICE CREAM

    Desserts

    • Frozen Hot Chocolate

      Topped with whipped cream and chocolate shavings.
      $8.15
    • Biscoff Shake

      Vanilla ice cream, Biscoff cookie butter, Biscoff cookie rim, topped with a Biscoff cookie.
      $9.99
    • Café Nutella Freeze

      A silky, cold brew milkshake blended with rich Nutella and creamy vanilla ice cream for a smooth, chocolate coffee rush. Irresistibly indulgent with a cool café-style finish.
      $9.99
    • Moose Tracks Shake

      Moose Track ice cream swirled with chocolate syrup peanut butter, topped with whipped cream and peanut butter chips.
      $9.99
    • Cookies N Cream-A-Licious Shake

      Oreo ice cream and crumble rim, topped with whipped cream and Oreo cookies.
      $9.99
    • Minty Chocolate Chip Shake

      Mint chip ice cream topped with whipped cream and chocolate chips.
      $9.99
    • Classic Favorite Milkshakes

      Choice of flavor.
      $8.15
    • Old Fashioned Root Beer Float

      Choice of ice cream.
      $6.99
    • Creamsicle

      Vanilla ice cream and orange soda.
      $6.99
    • Brooklyn Egg Cream

      $4.99
    • Klondike Avalanche

      A towering vanilla-chocolate milkshake served in a glass with a crushed Oreo cookie rim, drenched in rich chocolate and caramel, crowned with whipped cream, crunchy chocolate chips, and a full Klondike bar on top. Cold, creamy, and outrageously indulgent; this one is an avalanche of pure chocolate bliss.
      $13.75
    • The Cookie Tower Shake

      A thick, cookies n cream milkshake served in a chocolate sprinkle rimmed glass, layered with chocolate syrup, topped with a mountain of whipped cream and an ice-cream sandwich. Creamy, crunchy, and stacked sky-high with classic chocolate-vanilla goodness.
      $13.75
    • Strawberry Dream Shake

      A creamy strawberry milkshake made with strawberry ice cream, topped with whipped cream, juicy strawberries, and a classic strawberry shortcake ice cream bar.
      $13.75
    • Ice Cream (Single Scoop)

      Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, mint chocolate chip, cookies n’ cream, moose tracks, sherbet, sugar free.
      $4.49
    • Ice Cream (Double Scoop)

      Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, mint chocolate chip, cookies n’ cream, moose tracks, sherbet, sugar free.
      $6.49
    • Brownie Sundae

      2 scoops ice cream, brownie, walnuts, whipped cream, chocolate drizzle.
      $11.99
    • Strawberry Shortcake Sundae

      2 scoops vanilla ice cream on top of buttery pound cake, strawberry sauce and whipped cream.
      $11.99
    • Sundae Your Way

      2 scoops ice cream, choice of 2 toppings.
      $11.99
    • Banana Split

      3 scoops ice cream, choice of 3 toppings.
      $14.99
    • The Candy Explosion

      A classic banana split taken to the extreme — banana, three scoops of ice cream layered with chocolate syrup, caramel, piled high with chopped Snickers, Twix, Reese's, and M&M's, finished with whipped cream and cherries. Sweet, crunchy, chocolatey, and completely over the top.
      $15.99
    • Affogato

      Vanilla ice cream meets espresso, pure bliss.
      $7.99
    • Creamy Cheesecake

      $8.49
    • Creamy Strawberry Cheesecake

      $9.49
    • Assorted Layer Cakes

      $7.49
    • Apple Pie

      $6.99
    • Apple Pie À La Mode

      $9.99
    • Brownie

      $5.99
    • Jumbo Cookie

      $4.49
    • Creamy Rice Pudding

      $5.49
    • Chocolate Pudding

      $5.49
    • Carrot Cake

      $7.49
    • Lemon Meringue

      $7.49
    • Tartuffo

      Vanilla, Chcolate & Strawberry ice cream with a cherry center covered with a hard chocolate shell.
      $6.99
    • Mini Cake

      $10.49

    Cookie

    $0.00
    Request advisory
    We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
    1

    All hours
    Sunday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Monday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Tuesday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Wednesday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Thursday8:00 am - 9:45 pm
    Friday8:00 am - 10:45 pm
    Saturday8:00 am - 10:45 pm
    Restaurant info

    Welcome Back to Peter Pan Diner For over 70 years, Peter Pan Diner has been a cherished part of the community. Today, we’re proud to welcome you back to a diner that has been thoughtfully rebuilt and reimagined. Honoring the classic traditions you’ve loved for generations while embracing fresh, modern flavors in a renewed, welcoming space. Our menu continues to celebrate the comfort, familiarity, and flavors that define Peter Pan. From morning to night, serving hearty breakfasts and made-to-order omelets, signature hamburgers, freshly crafted sandwiches, crisp salads, and delicious dinner entrées. Blending timeless favorites with contemporary touches. To our loyal guests, neighbors, and friends, thank you for your continued support and for welcoming us back. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick coffee, a family meal, or a late-night bite, Peter Pan Diner remains a place where comfort, connection, and good food come together. We look forward to serving you for many years to come.

    Location

    999 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    Directions


    Similar restaurants in your area

    Peter Pan Diner
    View restaurantnext
    Brightwaters Inn
    View restaurantnext
    Brightwaters Village Deli
    View restaurantnext
    Exit 42 Bagel & Deli 270 Spur dr S
    View restaurantnext
    Khyber Grill & Gyro 270 Spur dr S Khyber
    View restaurantnext
    Roto
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook