Skip to Main content

  • Pirate's Cove Pizza and Subs 126 E Main St.

    • Home
    • /
    • Cardington
    • /
    • Pirate's Cove Pizza and Subs

    This restaurant does not have any images

    Pizza

    Pirate's Cove Pizza and Subs

    126 E Main St.

    Cardington, OH 43315

    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant

    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    PIZZA
    SUBS
    SALADS
    FOOD
    CHICKEN
    PASTA
    DESSERT
    DRESSINGS & SAUCES
    DRINKS

    Featured Items

    • X- LARGE 17"

      $16.00

    • LARGE 14"

      $13.00

    • MEDIUM 12"

      $10.00

    PIZZA

    Build Your Own

    • Individual 7"

      $5.00

    • SMALL 10''

      $8.00

    • MEDIUM 12"

      $10.00

    • LARGE 14"

      $13.00

    • X- LARGE 17"

      $16.00

    • SHEET 18"x26"

      $25.00

    SMALL Specialty Pizzas

    • SMALL 10" Deluxe Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE
      $13.50

    • SMALL 10" Extreme Meat Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, BACON, HAM, HAMBURGER
      $14.25

    • SMALL 10" Taco Pizza

      TACO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, TACO MEAT, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO. SOUR CREAM AND TACO SAUCE ON THE SIDE
      $15.00

    • SMALL 10" Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

      BACON, HAMBURGER, ONION, CHEDDAR AND MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $12.75

    • SMALL 10" Veggie Pizza

      MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE, TOMATO
      $12.00

    • SMALL 10" Cheezy Garlic Pizza

      GARLIC BUTTER SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $11.00

    • SMALL 10" Chicken Alfredo PIzza

      ALFREDO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, DICED CHICKEN
      $15.00

    MEDIUM Specialty Pizzas

    • MED 12" Deluxe Pizza

      PEPPERONI, MUSHROOM. ONION. GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE
      $17.25

    • MED 12" Extreme Meat Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, BACON, HAM, HAMBURGER
      $19.00

    • MED 12" Taco Pizza

      TACO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, TACO MEAT, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO. SOUR CREAM AND TACO SAUCE ON THE SIDE
      $19.50

    • MED 12" Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

      BACON, HAMBURGER, ONION, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $16.75

    • MED 12" Veggie Pizza

      MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE, TOMATO
      $15.00

    • MED 12" Cheezy Garlic Pizza

      GARLIC BUTTER SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $14.50

    • MED 12" Chicken Alfredo Pizza

      ALFREDO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, DICED CHICKEN
      $19.50

    LARGE Specialty Pizzas

    • LARGE 14" Deluxe Pizza

      PEPPERONI, MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE
      $22.00

    • LARGE 14" Extreme Meat Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, BACON, HAM, HAMBURGER
      $24.00

    • LARGE 14" Taco Pizza

      TACO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, TACO MEAT, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO SOUR CREAM AND TACO SAUCE ON SIDE
      $24.75

    • LARGE 14" Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

      BACON, HAMBURGER, ONION, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $21.25

    • LARGE 14" Veggie Pizza

      MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE, TOMATO
      $18.75

    • LARGE 14" Cheezy Garlic Pizza

      GARLIC BUTTER SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $18.75

    • LARGE 14" Chicken Alfredo Pizza

      ALFREDO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE DICED CHICKEN
      $24.75

    X-LARGE Specialty Pizzas

    • XL 17" Deluxe Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE
      $27.00

    • XL 17" Extreme Meat Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, BACON, HAM, HAMBURGER
      $30.00

    • XL 17" Taco Pizza

      TACO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, TACO MEAT, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO SOUR CREAM AND TACO SAUCE ON SIDE
      $30.50

    • XL 17" Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

      BACON, HAMBURGER, ONION, CHEDDAR AND MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $26.50

    • XL 17" Veggie Pizza

      MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE, TOMATO
      $23.50

    • XL 17" Cheezy Garlic Pizza

      GARLIC BUTTER SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $23.50

    • XL 17" Chicken Alfredo Pizza

      ALFREDO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, DICED CHICKEN
      $30.50

    SHEET Specialty Pizzas

    • SHEET Deluxe Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE
      $45.25

    • SHEET Extreme Meat Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, BACON, HAM, HAMBURGER
      $44.50

    • SHEET Taco Pizza

      TACO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, TACO MEAT, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO SOUR CREAM AND TACO SAUCE ON SIDE
      $48.50

    • SHEET Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

      BACON, HAMBURGER, ONION, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $39.75

    • SHEET Veggie Pizza

      MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE, TOMATO
      $40.50

    • SHEET Cheezy Garlic Pizza

      GARLIC BUTTER SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $36.00

    • SHEET Chicken Alfredo Pizza

      ALFREDO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, DICED CHICKEN
      $48.50

    SUBS

    8" Subs

    • 8" Captain Hook Sub

      Ham, salami, mushroom, onion, green & mild pepper, sauce, cheese.
      $7.00

    • 8" Buccaneer Sub

      Ham, salami, sauce, cheese.
      $7.00

    • 8" Italian Sub

      Ham, salami, onion, cheese, lettuce, tomato, side of Italian.
      $7.00

    • 8" Meatball Sub

      Meatballs, sauce, cheese.
      $7.00

    • 8" Pizza Sub

      Pepperoni, sauce, cheese.
      $7.00

    • 8" BLT Sub

      Bacon, lettuce, tomato, side of mayo.
      $7.00

    • 8" Ham & Cheese Sub

      Ham, cheese.
      $6.50

    • 8" Veggie Sub

      Mushroom, onion, green & mild pepper, sauce, cheese.
      $6.50

    • 8" Steak Sub

      Steak, onion, green pepper, cheese, side of mayo.
      $7.00

    • 8" Buffalo Chicken Sub

      Hot sauce covered chicken, lettuce, tomato, side of ranch or blue cheese.
      $7.00

    • 8" Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

      Chicken, bacon, mozzarella & cheddar, lettuce, tomato, side of ranch.
      $8.00

    • 8" Chicken Parm Sub

      Chicken, sauce, cheese.
      $7.00

    12" Subs

    • 12" Captain Hook Sub

      Ham, salami, mushroom, onion, green & mild pepper, sauce, cheese.
      $8.50

    • 12" Buccaneer Sub

      Ham, salami, sauce, cheese.
      $7.75

    • 12" Italian Sub

      Ham, salami, onion, cheese, lettuce, tomato, side of Italian.
      $8.50

    • 12" Meatball Sub

      Meatballs, sauce, cheese.
      $8.50

    • 12" Pizza Sub

      Pepperoni, sauce, cheese.
      $8.50

    • 12" BLT Sub

      Bacon, lettuce, tomato, side of mayo.
      $8.50

    • 12" Ham & Cheese Sub

      Ham, cheese.
      $7.75

    • 12" Veggie Sub

      Mushroom, onion, green & mild pepper, sauce, cheese.
      $7.75

    • 12" Steak Sub

      Steak, onion, green pepper, cheese, side of mayo.
      $8.50

    • 12" Buffalo Chicken Sub

      CHICKEN, BUFFALO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO RANCH OR BLUE CHEESE ON SIDE
      $8.50

    • 12" Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

      Chicken, bacon, mozzarella & cheddar, lettuce, tomato, side of ranch.
      $9.50

    • 12" Chicken Parm Sub

      Chicken, sauce, cheese.
      $8.50

    SUB BOWL

    • Captain Hook Bowl

      HAM, SALAMI, MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $8.50

    • Buccaneer Bowl

      HAM, SALAMI, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $7.75

    • Italian Bowl

      HAM, SALAMI, ONION, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO ITALIAN DRESSING ON SIDE
      $8.50

    • Meatball Bowl

      MEATBALLS, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $8.50

    • Pizza Bowl

      PEPPERONI, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $8.50

    • BLT Bowl

      BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATO MAYO ON SIDE
      $8.50

    • HAM & CHEESE Bowl

      HAM AND CHEESE
      $7.75

    • Veggie Bowl

      MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE, TOMATO
      $7.75

    • Steak Bowl

      STEAK, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MOZZARELLA CHEESE MAYO ON SIDE
      $8.50

    • Buffalo Chicken Bowl

      CHICKEN, BUFFALO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO RANCH OR BLUE CHEESE ON SIDE
      $8.50

    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Bowl

      CHICKEN, BACON, CHEDDAR AND MOZZARELLA CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO RANCH ON SIDE
      $9.50

    • Chicken Parm. Bowl

      CHICKEN, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND PARMESAN CHEESE
      $8.50

    SALADS

    Small Salads

    • Small Chicken Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, cheddar, onion, chicken.
      $5.75

    • Small Regular Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, cheddar.
      $3.50

    • Small Super Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, cheddar, onion, green pepper, mushroom, ham, mozzarella.
      $5.75

    • Small Taco Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, cheddar, onion, taco meat, side of taco sauce & sour cream.
      $5.75

    Large Salads

    • Large Chicken Salad

      LETTUCE, TOMATO, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, CHICKEN
      $8.00

    • Large Regular Salad

      LETTUCE, TOMATO, CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $5.00

    • Large Super Salad

      LETTUCE, TOMATO, CHEDDAR CHEESE, MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, HAM, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $8.00

    • Large Taco Salad

      LETTUCE, TOMATO, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, TACO MEAT SOUR CREAM AND TACO SAUCE ON SIDE
      $8.00

    FOOD

    Fold Overs

    • Small Fold Over

      $8.00

    • Large Fold Over

      $13.00

    • Taco Fold Over

      Taco meat, onion, mozzarella & cheddar, sour cream and taco sauce on side.
      $10.25+

    Bread

    • 8" Garlic Bread

      8" BUN WITH GARLIC BUTTER AND GARLIC SEASONING PIZZA SAUCE FOR DIPPING
      $4.00

    • 8" Cheesy Garlic Bread

      8" BUN WITH GARLIC BUTTER, GARLIC SEASONING, MOZZARELLA CHEESE PIZZA SAUCE FOR DIPPING
      $5.00

    • 12" Garlic Bread

      12" BUN WITH GARLIC BUTTER AND GARLIC SEASONING PIZZA SAUCE FOR DIPPING
      $6.00

    • 12" Cheesy Garlic Bread

      12" BUN WITH GARLIC BUTTER, GARLIC SEASONING, MOZZARELLA CHEESE PIZZA SAUCE FOR DIPPING
      $7.00

    • Bread Sticks

      4 BREADTSTICKS WITH GARLIC BUTTER AND GARLIC SEASONING PIZZA SAUCE FOR DIPPING
      $5.00

    • Breadsticks with Cheese

      4 BREADSTICKS WITH GARLIC BUTTER, GARLIC SEASONING, MOZZARELLA CHEESE PIZZA SAUCE FOR DIPPING
      $6.00

    Potato Wedges

    • Plain Wedge

      $4.00

    • Cheese Wedge

      POTATO WEDGES WITH MELTED CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $5.00

    • Loaded Wedge

      Cheese & bacon, side of sour cream.
      $7.00

    • Taco Wedge

      Taco meat, onion, cheese, sour cream & taco sauce on side.
      $7.00

    Pretzel Bites (10 CNT)

    • Pretzel Bites with Beer Cheese

      $5.50

    • Pretzel Bites with Honey Mustard

      $5.50

    • Cinnamon Sugar Pretzels with Icing

      $5.50

    CHICKEN

    Chicken Strips

    • 5 Chicken Strips

      $4.50

    Wings - 5 Piece

    • Plain - 5 Piece WIngs

      $7.00

    • Garlic Parmesan - 5 Piece Wings

      $7.00

    • Buffalo - 5 Piece Wings

      $7.00

    • Golden BBQ - 5 Piece Wings

      $7.00

    • Smokey BBQ - 5 Piece Wings

      $7.00

    • Hot Honey - 5 piece

      $7.00

    • Red Chilli - 5 piece

      $7.00

    Wings - 10 Piece

    • Plain - 10 Piece Wings

      $12.00

    • Garlic Parmesan - 10 Piece Wings

      $12.00

    • Buffalo - 10 Piece Wings

      $12.00

    • Golden BBQ - 10 Piece Wings

      $12.00

    • Smokey BBQ - 10 Piece Wings

      $12.00

    • Hot Honey - 10 piece

      $12.00

    • Red Chilli - 10 piece

      $12.00

    Boneless Wings - 10 piece

    • Boneless Wings - Plain

      $7.00

    • Boneless Wings - Garlic Parmesan

      $7.00

    • Bonless Wings - Buffalo

      $7.00

    • Boneless Wings - Golden BBQ

      $7.00

    • Boneless Wings - Smokey BBQ

      $7.00

    • Boneless Wings- Hot Honey

      $7.00

    • Boneless Wings - Red Chilli

      $7.00

    PASTA

    • Pirate's Penne

      PENNE NOODLES, MEATBALLS, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $8.00

    • Chicken Alfredo

      PENNE NOODLES, DICED CHICKEN, ALFREDO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $9.50

    • Chicken Parm Penne

      PENNE NOODLES, DICED CHICKEN, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND PARMESAN CHEESE
      $9.00

    DESSERT

    Dessert Pizzas

    • 7" Plain Cinnamon Streusel

      CARAMEL BASE, CINNAMON STREUSEL TOPPING, ICING DRIZZLE
      $7.00

    • 7" Cinnamon Streusel with Apple

      APPLE FILLING, CINNAMON STREUSEL, ICING DRIZZLE
      $7.00

    • 7" Plain Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING
      $7.00

    • 7" Strawberry Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STRAWBERRY FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING
      $7.00

    • 7" Raspberry Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, RASPBERRY FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING
      $7.00

    • 7" Caramel Apple Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, APPLE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING, CARAMEL DRIZZLE
      $7.00

    • 7'' Cheesecake with Chocolate Drizzle

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING, CHOCOLATE DRIZZLE
      $7.00

    • 7" Cheesecake with Caramel Drizzle

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING, CARAMEL DRIZZLE
      $7.00

    • 12'' Plain Cinnamon Streusel

      CARAMEL BASE, CINNAMON STREUSEL TOPPING, ICING DRIZZLE
      $12.00

    • 12" Cinnamon Streusel with Apple

      APPLE FILLING, CINNAMON STREUSEL, ICING DRIZZLE
      $12.00

    • 12" Plain Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING
      $12.00

    • 12'' Strawberry Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STRAWBERRY FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING
      $12.00

    • 12" Raspberry Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, RASPBERRY FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING
      $12.00

    • 12" Caramel Apple Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, APPLE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING, CARAMEL DRIZZLE
      $12.00

    • 12'' Cheesecake with Chocolate Drizzle

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING, CHOCOLATE DRIZZLE
      $12.00

    • 12" Cheesecake with Caramel Drizzle

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING, CARAMEL DRIZZLE
      $12.00

    More Desserts!

    • 7" Pan Brownie

      $6.00

    • 7" Pan Cookie

      $6.00

    • Cinnamon Sugar Pretzels with Icing

      $5.50

    DRESSINGS & SAUCES

    Misc. Items

    • Italian Dressing

      $0.50

    • Ranch Dressing

      $0.50

    • French Dressing

      $0.50

    • Honey Mustard

      $0.50

    • 1000 Island Dressing

      $0.50

    • Blue Cheese Dressing

      $0.50

    • Pizza Sauce

      $0.50

    • Garlic Butter Sauce Cup

      $0.50

    • Alfredo sauce

      $2.00

    • Beer Cheese

      $1.25

    • Buffalo Sauce

      $1.00

    • Garlic Parmesan Sauce

      $1.00

    • Smokey BBQ Sauce

      $1.00

    • Golden BBQ Sauce

      $1.00

    • Hot Honey Sauce Cup

      $1.00

    • Red Chilli Sauce

      $1.00

    • Taco Sauce Packet (2)

      $0.50

    • Sour Cream Packet (2)

      $0.50

    • Mayo Packet (2)

      $0.50

    • Icing

      $1.00

    DRINKS

    20 OZ

    • Aquafina Water 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Mountain Dew 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Diet Mountain Dew 20oz

      $2.50

    • Pepsi 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Diet Pepsi 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Pepsi Zero 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Dr. Pepper 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Mug Rootbeer 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Orange Crush 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Starry 20 oz

      $2.50

    2 LITERS

    • Pepsi - 2 liter

      $3.50

    • Diet Pepsi - 2 liter

      $3.50

    • Orange Crush - 2 liter

      $3.50

    • Mug Rootbeer - 2 liter

      $3.50

    • Mountain Dew - 2 liter

      $3.50

    • Dr. Pepper - 2 liter

      $3.50

    Gatorade

    • Red Gatorade

      OUT OF STOCK
      $2.50

    • White Gatorade

      $2.50

    • Blue Gatorade

      OUT OF STOCK
      $2.50

    • Yellow Gatorade

      $2.50

    • Purple Gatorade

      $2.50

    Breadsticks with Cheese

    $6.00

    4 BREADSTICKS WITH GARLIC BUTTER, GARLIC SEASONING, MOZZARELLA CHEESE PIZZA SAUCE FOR DIPPING

    Request advisory
    We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
    1
    All hours
    SundayClosed
    Monday4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Tuesday4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Wednesday4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 1:00 pm, 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 1:00 pm, 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
    Saturday4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    126 E Main St., Cardington, OH 43315

    Directions

    Similar restaurants in your area

    Pizzaburg Mount Gilead
    View restaurantnext
    Pizza To Go 16 S Main St
    View restaurantnext
    Legend's Pizza 2778 Marion-Waldo Road
    View restaurantnext
    Payne's Pizza & More
    View restaurantnext
    Bombers Pizza N Wings
    View restaurantnext
    Berwick Pizza and Subs 205 Marion Street
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook