Skip to Main content

  • Pirate's Cove Pizza and Subs 126 E Main St.

    • Home
    • /
    • Cardington
    • /
    • Pirate's Cove Pizza and Subs

    This restaurant does not have any images

    Pizza

    Pirate's Cove Pizza and Subs

    126 E Main St.

    Cardington, OH 43315

    Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant

    Call

    Hours

    Directions

    PIZZA
    SUBS
    SALADS
    FOOD
    CHICKEN
    PASTA
    DESSERT
    DRESSINGS & SAUCES
    DRINKS

    Featured Items

    • X- LARGE 17"

      $16.00

    • LARGE 14"

      $13.00

    • MEDIUM 12"

      $10.00

    PIZZA

    Build Your Own

    • Individual 7"

      $5.00

    • SMALL 10''

      $8.00

    • MEDIUM 12"

      $10.00

    • LARGE 14"

      $13.00

    • X- LARGE 17"

      $16.00

    • SHEET 18"x26"

      $25.00

    SMALL Specialty Pizzas

    • SMALL 10" Deluxe Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE
      $13.50

    • SMALL 10" Extreme Meat Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, BACON, HAM, HAMBURGER
      $14.25

    • SMALL 10" Taco Pizza

      TACO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, TACO MEAT, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO. SOUR CREAM AND TACO SAUCE ON THE SIDE
      $15.00

    • SMALL 10" Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

      BACON, HAMBURGER, ONION, CHEDDAR AND MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $12.75

    • SMALL 10" Veggie Pizza

      MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE, TOMATO
      $12.00

    • SMALL 10" Cheezy Garlic Pizza

      GARLIC BUTTER SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $11.00

    • SMALL 10" Chicken Alfredo PIzza

      ALFREDO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, DICED CHICKEN
      $15.00

    MEDIUM Specialty Pizzas

    • MED 12" Deluxe Pizza

      PEPPERONI, MUSHROOM. ONION. GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE
      $17.25

    • MED 12" Extreme Meat Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, BACON, HAM, HAMBURGER
      $19.00

    • MED 12" Taco Pizza

      TACO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, TACO MEAT, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO. SOUR CREAM AND TACO SAUCE ON THE SIDE
      $19.50

    • MED 12" Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

      BACON, HAMBURGER, ONION, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $16.75

    • MED 12" Veggie Pizza

      MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE, TOMATO
      $15.00

    • MED 12" Cheezy Garlic Pizza

      GARLIC BUTTER SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $14.50

    • MED 12" Chicken Alfredo Pizza

      ALFREDO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, DICED CHICKEN
      $19.50

    LARGE Specialty Pizzas

    • LARGE 14" Deluxe Pizza

      PEPPERONI, MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE
      $22.00

    • LARGE 14" Extreme Meat Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, BACON, HAM, HAMBURGER
      $24.00

    • LARGE 14" Taco Pizza

      TACO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, TACO MEAT, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO SOUR CREAM AND TACO SAUCE ON SIDE
      $24.75

    • LARGE 14" Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

      BACON, HAMBURGER, ONION, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $21.25

    • LARGE 14" Veggie Pizza

      MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE, TOMATO
      $18.75

    • LARGE 14" Cheezy Garlic Pizza

      GARLIC BUTTER SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $18.75

    • LARGE 14" Chicken Alfredo Pizza

      ALFREDO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE DICED CHICKEN
      $24.75

    X-LARGE Specialty Pizzas

    • XL 17" Deluxe Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE
      $27.00

    • XL 17" Extreme Meat Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, BACON, HAM, HAMBURGER
      $30.00

    • XL 17" Taco Pizza

      TACO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, TACO MEAT, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO SOUR CREAM AND TACO SAUCE ON SIDE
      $30.50

    • XL 17" Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

      BACON, HAMBURGER, ONION, CHEDDAR AND MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $26.50

    • XL 17" Veggie Pizza

      MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE, TOMATO
      $23.50

    • XL 17" Cheezy Garlic Pizza

      GARLIC BUTTER SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $23.50

    • XL 17" Chicken Alfredo Pizza

      ALFREDO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, DICED CHICKEN
      $30.50

    SHEET Specialty Pizzas

    • SHEET Deluxe Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE
      $45.25

    • SHEET Extreme Meat Pizza

      PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, BACON, HAM, HAMBURGER
      $44.50

    • SHEET Taco Pizza

      TACO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, TACO MEAT, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO SOUR CREAM AND TACO SAUCE ON SIDE
      $48.50

    • SHEET Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza

      BACON, HAMBURGER, ONION, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $39.75

    • SHEET Veggie Pizza

      MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE, TOMATO
      $40.50

    • SHEET Cheezy Garlic Pizza

      GARLIC BUTTER SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $36.00

    • SHEET Chicken Alfredo Pizza

      ALFREDO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, DICED CHICKEN
      $48.50

    SUBS

    8" Subs

    • 8" Captain Hook Sub

      Ham, salami, mushroom, onion, green & mild pepper, sauce, cheese.
      $7.00

    • 8" Buccaneer Sub

      Ham, salami, sauce, cheese.
      $7.00

    • 8" Italian Sub

      Ham, salami, onion, cheese, lettuce, tomato, side of Italian.
      $7.00

    • 8" Meatball Sub

      Meatballs, sauce, cheese.
      $7.00

    • 8" Pizza Sub

      Pepperoni, sauce, cheese.
      $7.00

    • 8" BLT Sub

      Bacon, lettuce, tomato, side of mayo.
      $7.00

    • 8" Ham & Cheese Sub

      Ham, cheese.
      $6.50

    • 8" Veggie Sub

      Mushroom, onion, green & mild pepper, sauce, cheese.
      $6.50

    • 8" Steak Sub

      Steak, onion, green pepper, cheese, side of mayo.
      $7.00

    • 8" Buffalo Chicken Sub

      Hot sauce covered chicken, lettuce, tomato, side of ranch or blue cheese.
      $7.00

    • 8" Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

      Chicken, bacon, mozzarella & cheddar, lettuce, tomato, side of ranch.
      $8.00

    • 8" Chicken Parm Sub

      Chicken, sauce, cheese.
      $7.00

    12" Subs

    • 12" Captain Hook Sub

      Ham, salami, mushroom, onion, green & mild pepper, sauce, cheese.
      $8.50

    • 12" Buccaneer Sub

      Ham, salami, sauce, cheese.
      $7.75

    • 12" Italian Sub

      Ham, salami, onion, cheese, lettuce, tomato, side of Italian.
      $8.50

    • 12" Meatball Sub

      Meatballs, sauce, cheese.
      $8.50

    • 12" Pizza Sub

      Pepperoni, sauce, cheese.
      $8.50

    • 12" BLT Sub

      Bacon, lettuce, tomato, side of mayo.
      $8.50

    • 12" Ham & Cheese Sub

      Ham, cheese.
      $7.75

    • 12" Veggie Sub

      Mushroom, onion, green & mild pepper, sauce, cheese.
      $7.75

    • 12" Steak Sub

      Steak, onion, green pepper, cheese, side of mayo.
      $8.50

    • 12" Buffalo Chicken Sub

      CHICKEN, BUFFALO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO RANCH OR BLUE CHEESE ON SIDE
      $8.50

    • 12" Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

      Chicken, bacon, mozzarella & cheddar, lettuce, tomato, side of ranch.
      $9.50

    • 12" Chicken Parm Sub

      Chicken, sauce, cheese.
      $8.50

    SUB BOWL

    • Captain Hook Bowl

      HAM, SALAMI, MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $8.50

    • Buccaneer Bowl

      HAM, SALAMI, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $7.75

    • Italian Bowl

      HAM, SALAMI, ONION, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO ITALIAN DRESSING ON SIDE
      $8.50

    • Meatball Bowl

      MEATBALLS, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $8.50

    • Pizza Bowl

      PEPPERONI, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $8.50

    • BLT Bowl

      BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATO MAYO ON SIDE
      $8.50

    • HAM & CHEESE Bowl

      HAM AND CHEESE
      $7.75

    • Veggie Bowl

      MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MILD PEPPER, GREEN OLIVE, TOMATO
      $7.75

    • Steak Bowl

      STEAK, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, MOZZARELLA CHEESE MAYO ON SIDE
      $8.50

    • Buffalo Chicken Bowl

      CHICKEN, BUFFALO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO RANCH OR BLUE CHEESE ON SIDE
      $8.50

    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Bowl

      CHICKEN, BACON, CHEDDAR AND MOZZARELLA CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO RANCH ON SIDE
      $9.50

    • Chicken Parm. Bowl

      CHICKEN, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND PARMESAN CHEESE
      $8.50

    SALADS

    Small Salads

    • Small Chicken Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, cheddar, onion, chicken.
      $5.75

    • Small Regular Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, cheddar.
      $3.50

    • Small Super Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, cheddar, onion, green pepper, mushroom, ham, mozzarella.
      $5.75

    • Small Taco Salad

      Lettuce, tomato, cheddar, onion, taco meat, side of taco sauce & sour cream.
      $5.75

    Large Salads

    • Large Chicken Salad

      LETTUCE, TOMATO, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, CHICKEN
      $8.00

    • Large Regular Salad

      LETTUCE, TOMATO, CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $5.00

    • Large Super Salad

      LETTUCE, TOMATO, CHEDDAR CHEESE, MUSHROOM, ONION, GREEN PEPPER, HAM, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $8.00

    • Large Taco Salad

      LETTUCE, TOMATO, ONION, CHEDDAR CHEESE, TACO MEAT SOUR CREAM AND TACO SAUCE ON SIDE
      $8.00

    FOOD

    Fold Overs

    • Small Fold Over

      $8.00

    • Large Fold Over

      $13.00

    • Taco Fold Over

      Taco meat, onion, mozzarella & cheddar, sour cream and taco sauce on side.
      $10.25+

    Bread

    • 8" Garlic Bread

      8" BUN WITH GARLIC BUTTER AND GARLIC SEASONING PIZZA SAUCE FOR DIPPING
      $4.00

    • 8" Cheesy Garlic Bread

      8" BUN WITH GARLIC BUTTER, GARLIC SEASONING, MOZZARELLA CHEESE PIZZA SAUCE FOR DIPPING
      $5.00

    • 12" Garlic Bread

      12" BUN WITH GARLIC BUTTER AND GARLIC SEASONING PIZZA SAUCE FOR DIPPING
      $6.00

    • 12" Cheesy Garlic Bread

      12" BUN WITH GARLIC BUTTER, GARLIC SEASONING, MOZZARELLA CHEESE PIZZA SAUCE FOR DIPPING
      $7.00

    • Bread Sticks

      4 BREADTSTICKS WITH GARLIC BUTTER AND GARLIC SEASONING PIZZA SAUCE FOR DIPPING
      $5.00

    • Breadsticks with Cheese

      4 BREADSTICKS WITH GARLIC BUTTER, GARLIC SEASONING, MOZZARELLA CHEESE PIZZA SAUCE FOR DIPPING
      $6.00

    Potato Wedges

    • Plain Wedge

      $4.00

    • Cheese Wedge

      POTATO WEDGES WITH MELTED CHEDDAR CHEESE
      $5.00

    • Loaded Wedge

      Cheese & bacon, side of sour cream.
      $7.00

    • Taco Wedge

      Taco meat, onion, cheese, sour cream & taco sauce on side.
      $7.00

    Pretzel Bites (10 CNT)

    • Pretzel Bites with Beer Cheese

      $5.50

    • Pretzel Bites with Honey Mustard

      $5.50

    • Cinnamon Sugar Pretzels with Icing

      $5.50

    CHICKEN

    Chicken Strips

    • 5 Chicken Strips

      $4.50

    Wings - 5 Piece

    • Plain - 5 Piece WIngs

      $7.00

    • Garlic Parmesan - 5 Piece Wings

      $7.00

    • Buffalo - 5 Piece Wings

      $7.00

    • Golden BBQ - 5 Piece Wings

      $7.00

    • Smokey BBQ - 5 Piece Wings

      $7.00

    • Hot Honey - 5 piece

      $7.00

    • Red Chilli - 5 piece

      $7.00

    Wings - 10 Piece

    • Plain - 10 Piece Wings

      $12.00

    • Garlic Parmesan - 10 Piece Wings

      $12.00

    • Buffalo - 10 Piece Wings

      $12.00

    • Golden BBQ - 10 Piece Wings

      $12.00

    • Smokey BBQ - 10 Piece Wings

      $12.00

    • Hot Honey - 10 piece

      $12.00

    • Red Chilli - 10 piece

      $12.00

    Boneless Wings - 10 piece

    • Boneless Wings - Plain

      $7.00

    • Boneless Wings - Garlic Parmesan

      $7.00

    • Bonless Wings - Buffalo

      $7.00

    • Boneless Wings - Golden BBQ

      $7.00

    • Boneless Wings - Smokey BBQ

      $7.00

    • Boneless Wings- Hot Honey

      $7.00

    • Boneless Wings - Red Chilli

      $7.00

    PASTA

    • Pirate's Penne

      PENNE NOODLES, MEATBALLS, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $8.00

    • Chicken Alfredo

      PENNE NOODLES, DICED CHICKEN, ALFREDO SAUCE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
      $9.50

    • Chicken Parm Penne

      PENNE NOODLES, DICED CHICKEN, PIZZA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND PARMESAN CHEESE
      $9.00

    DESSERT

    Dessert Pizzas

    • 7" Plain Cinnamon Streusel

      CARAMEL BASE, CINNAMON STREUSEL TOPPING, ICING DRIZZLE
      $7.00

    • 7" Cinnamon Streusel with Apple

      APPLE FILLING, CINNAMON STREUSEL, ICING DRIZZLE
      $7.00

    • 7" Plain Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING
      $7.00

    • 7" Strawberry Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STRAWBERRY FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING
      $7.00

    • 7" Raspberry Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, RASPBERRY FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING
      $7.00

    • 7" Caramel Apple Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, APPLE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING, CARAMEL DRIZZLE
      $7.00

    • 7'' Cheesecake with Chocolate Drizzle

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING, CHOCOLATE DRIZZLE
      $7.00

    • 7" Cheesecake with Caramel Drizzle

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING, CARAMEL DRIZZLE
      $7.00

    • 12'' Plain Cinnamon Streusel

      CARAMEL BASE, CINNAMON STREUSEL TOPPING, ICING DRIZZLE
      $12.00

    • 12" Cinnamon Streusel with Apple

      APPLE FILLING, CINNAMON STREUSEL, ICING DRIZZLE
      $12.00

    • 12" Plain Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING
      $12.00

    • 12'' Strawberry Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STRAWBERRY FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING
      $12.00

    • 12" Raspberry Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, RASPBERRY FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING
      $12.00

    • 12" Caramel Apple Cheesecake

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, APPLE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING, CARAMEL DRIZZLE
      $12.00

    • 12'' Cheesecake with Chocolate Drizzle

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING, CHOCOLATE DRIZZLE
      $12.00

    • 12" Cheesecake with Caramel Drizzle

      CHEESECAKE FILLING, STREUSEL TOPPING, CARAMEL DRIZZLE
      $12.00

    More Desserts!

    • 7" Pan Brownie

      $6.00

    • 7" Pan Cookie

      $6.00

    • Cinnamon Sugar Pretzels with Icing

      $5.50

    DRESSINGS & SAUCES

    Misc. Items

    • Italian Dressing

      $0.50

    • Ranch Dressing

      $0.50

    • French Dressing

      $0.50

    • Honey Mustard

      $0.50

    • 1000 Island Dressing

      $0.50

    • Blue Cheese Dressing

      $0.50

    • Pizza Sauce

      $0.50

    • Garlic Butter Sauce Cup

      $0.50

    • Alfredo sauce

      $2.00

    • Beer Cheese

      $1.25

    • Buffalo Sauce

      $1.00

    • Garlic Parmesan Sauce

      $1.00

    • Smokey BBQ Sauce

      $1.00

    • Golden BBQ Sauce

      $1.00

    • Hot Honey Sauce Cup

      $1.00

    • Red Chilli Sauce

      $1.00

    • Taco Sauce Packet (2)

      $0.50

    • Sour Cream Packet (2)

      $0.50

    • Mayo Packet (2)

      $0.50

    • Icing

      $1.00

    DRINKS

    20 OZ

    • Aquafina Water 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Mountain Dew 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Diet Mountain Dew 20oz

      $2.50

    • Pepsi 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Diet Pepsi 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Pepsi Zero 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Dr. Pepper 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Mug Rootbeer 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Orange Crush 20 oz

      $2.50

    • Starry 20 oz

      $2.50

    2 LITERS

    • Pepsi - 2 liter

      $3.50

    • Diet Pepsi - 2 liter

      $3.50

    • Orange Crush - 2 liter

      $3.50

    • Mug Rootbeer - 2 liter

      $3.50

    • Mountain Dew - 2 liter

      $3.50

    • Dr. Pepper - 2 liter

      $3.50

    Gatorade

    • Red Gatorade

      OUT OF STOCK
      $2.50

    • White Gatorade

      $2.50

    • Blue Gatorade

      OUT OF STOCK
      $2.50

    • Yellow Gatorade

      $2.50

    • Purple Gatorade

      $2.50

    Small Regular Salad

    $3.50

    Lettuce, tomato, cheddar.

    Customize your item

    Choice of Dressing

    Required
    Select 1

    Add Toppings (Small Salad/8" Sub)

    Optional
    Request advisory
    We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
    1
    All hours
    SundayClosed
    Monday4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Tuesday4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Wednesday4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Thursday11:00 am - 1:00 pm, 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm
    Friday11:00 am - 1:00 pm, 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
    Saturday4:00 pm - 10:00 pm
    Restaurant info

    Come in and enjoy!

    Location

    126 E Main St., Cardington, OH 43315

    Directions

    Similar restaurants in your area

    Pizzaburg Mount Gilead
    View restaurantnext
    Pizza To Go 16 S Main St
    View restaurantnext
    Legend's Pizza 2778 Marion-Waldo Road
    View restaurantnext
    Payne's Pizza & More
    View restaurantnext
    Bombers Pizza N Wings
    View restaurantnext
    Berwick Pizza and Subs 205 Marion Street
    View restaurantnext
    Search similar restaurants
    © 2026 Toast, Inc.
    Toast
    • About Toast
    • For restaurants
    • Terms of Service
    • Privacy Statement
    • Do not sell my
      personal information
    Made with love in Boston
    • Instagram
    • X (formerly Twitter)
    • Facebook