![Restaurant banner image](https://d2s742iet3d3t1.cloudfront.net/restaurants/restaurant-90422000000000000/banner_1670281869.jpg?size=medium)
Sarah's on Central - Eureka 127 South Central Avenue
127 South Central Avenue
Eureka, MO 63025
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
- CAKE SLICE Everyday Wedding Cake
Three layers of moist vanilla almond cake filled with our signature buttercream. Created back in 2006 when a customer said he just wanted a slice of wedding cake. Definitely one of top sellers for over 17 years!
$6.59 - GOOEY BUTTER
This St. Louis specialty cake is a staple at every holiday celebration in our house. It’s slightly gooey, buttery and sweet. We take it a step further and add a dollop of our signature cream cheese frosting on top. You just have to try it to appreciate the obsession....
$4.99 - Favorite Box$49.99
N/A Beverages
Coffee
Other Beverages
Dessert
Charcuterie Box
Cookies
- Chocolate Chewy Goodness
The best way to describe this cookie is crispy, buttery, chewy, chocolatey, the smell alone will get you excited for one bite. Customers drive from afar to get their fix and it has quickly become a favorite.
$4.09 - Chocolate Chip Cookie
Our signature chocolate chip cookie is crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. Packed with semi-sweet chocolate chips, with hints of caramelized sugar and butter.
$4.09 - Smores$4.09
- Holiday Butter Cookie
Our signature butter cookie decorated for the holiday season.
$4.99OUT OF STOCK - MACARON Birthday$2.75
- MACARON Chocolate$2.75
- MACARON Strawberry$2.75
- Gooey Butter Cookies$4.09OUT OF STOCK
- Small Cookie (3.5")$3.29OUT OF STOCK
- Mini Cookie (Doozie Size 2.5")$2.29OUT OF STOCK
- BOGO Holiday cookieOUT OF STOCK
- FROSTING BITES$1.65OUT OF STOCK
Daily Cupcakes (in-house)
- Confetti$3.50
- Snack Cake Cupcake$3.50OUT OF STOCK
- Monthly Cupcake$3.50
- Red Velvet$3.50
- Salted Caramel$3.50
- Carrot Cake$3.50
- Happy Day Yellow$3.50
- Happy Day Chocolate$3.50
- Date Night$3.50OUT OF STOCK
- Chef’s Selection$3.50OUT OF STOCK
- Chocolate Caramel Cupcake$3.50OUT OF STOCK
- Strawberry Cheesecake$3.50OUT OF STOCK
- Triple Chocolate Cupcake$3.50OUT OF STOCK
- Almond Cake Rasberry Jam$3.50OUT OF STOCK
- Moms Traditional$3.50OUT OF STOCK
Desserts
- BLONDIE$5.79
- BREAD PUDDING$5.29
- CAKE SLICE Chocolate Birthday
3 layers of double chocolate cake filled with sweet frosting and chocolate cookie crumbles, iced in chocolate buttercream and topped with chocolate cookie crumbles.
$6.99 - CAKE SLICE Everyday Wedding Cake
Three layers of moist vanilla almond cake filled with our signature buttercream. Created back in 2006 when a customer said he just wanted a slice of wedding cake. Definitely one of top sellers for over 17 years!
$6.59 - Decadent Fudge BROWNIE
Our rich decadent brownies will have you forgetting that it is Gluten-Free. Each brownie is topped with ganache and a swirl of our signature chocolate buttercream and chocolate curls.
$5.99 - GOOEY BUTTER
This St. Louis specialty cake is a staple at every holiday celebration in our house. It’s slightly gooey, buttery and sweet. We take it a step further and add a dollop of our signature cream cheese frosting on top. You just have to try it to appreciate the obsession....
$4.99 - Central Muffin
Savory muffin filled with bacon, cheddar, chives, and a hard-boiled egg.
$5.79 - BIG CAKE SLICE: Cinnamon Roll Cake$7.29
- CHEESECAKE SLICE: Key lime$5.99OUT OF STOCK
- CAKE SLICE: honey lavendar$6.79
- Cake Slice: Banana Bourbon Toffee Cake$6.79
- CHEESECAKE SLICE: Berry Swril$5.99
Small Bites
- CAKE POP Chocolate
Chocolate cake truffle dipped with chocolate and topped with rainbow sprinkles.
$2.25 - CAKE POP Vanilla
Vanilla cake truffle dipped in white chocolate and topped with rainbow sprinkles.
$2.25 - PETIT FOUR Chocolate
Three layers of almond cake filled with chocolate ganache and chocolate buttercream, covered in chocolate ganache.
$2.25 - PETIT FOUR Strawberry Champagne
Three layers of almond cake filled with champagne buttercream and strawberry jam, covered in white chocolate ganache.
$2.25 - Traditional GLITTER BITES shop color of season
These decadent bites are a customer favorite and a guaranteed crowd pleaser. Our signature Glitter Bites are 2 layers of white cake filled with vanilla buttercream, dipped in pink chocolate and rolled in sanding sugar. These decadent bites are a customer favorite and a guaranteed crowd pleaser. Truly magical and one of a kind!
$2.15 - brownie bites$2.00OUT OF STOCK
- Pina Colada glitter bite$2.25
- Mini box$15.99
- Small Box$29.99
- Medium Box$54.99
- Large Box$75.99
- Party Box$99.99
BUTTERCREAM
- CLASSIC FROSTING
Our Classic Frosting is the perfect pairing of two of our popular frosting. Our sweet frosting mixed with a bit of cream cheese frosting created this unbelievable twist on a classic. 2 pints of our classic frosting is enough for 2 cupcakes or 1-6" round cake.
$20.95 - VANILLA BUTTERCREAM
Our signature vanilla buttercream is light and creamy with just a touch of sweetness. 2 pints of our buttercream is enough for 12 cupcakes or a 6" 2 layer cake.
$18.95 - TRADITIONAL BUTTERCREAM
Our signature traditional buttercream is light and creamy with just a hint of almond. 2 pints is enough to ice 12 cupcakes or 1-6" 2 layer cake.
$18.95 - CHOCOLATE BUTTERCREAM
We've added chocolate to our signature vanilla buttercream for all of those chocolate lovers! 2 pints is enough to ice 12 cupcakes or 1-6" 2 layer cake.
$20.95
Bar Menu
Cocktails
- The Dena
Tito's Vodka, Zing Zang, Pickle, Olive, Celery
$8.00 - The Mayor
Triple Shot Tito's Vodka, Zing Zang, Shrimp, Slim Jim, Soft Pretzels, Bacon, Cheddar, Cucumber, Olive, Pickle
$18.00 - Virgin Dena Bloody Mary$5.00
- The Pitcher$22.00
- CLASSIC MIMOSA$6.50
- DREAMING OF SUMMER MIMOSA$7.00
- WINTER IS COMING MIMOSA$7.00
- Blackberry Mint$7.00
- Aperol Spritzer$8.00
- Grapefruit Rosemary Mimosa$7.00
- Chocolate Cupcake
Mozart Chocolate Liquor, Vanilla Vodka, Baileys, chocolate, and a mini chocolate cupcake.
$12.00 - Espresso Please
Pearl Vanilla Vodka, Kahlua, Espresso. Served with Chocolate Petit Four!
$12.00 - MARTINI Salted Caramel
Blue Chairbay Key Lime Rum, Pearl Vanilla Vodka, Godiva White Chocolate, Lime Juice. Servedd with a white chocolate dipped graham cracker cookie.
$12.00 - Gooey Butter Martini$12.00
- Breakfast Margarita$9.25
- Margarita$7.25
- Paloma
Tres Agaves Tequila, Grapefruit Juice, Lime, Club Soda
$7.00 - Strawberry Jalapeño
Tres Agaves, Jalapeño Simple Syrup, Strawberry Puree, Tres Agaves Margarita Mix
$9.00 - Strawberry Hibiscus
Strawberry Puree, Muddled mint, lime, hibiscus, ginger beer
$5.50 - Girlfriend
Muddled mint, orange, simple syrup, lemonade & grapefruit
$5.50 - Kahn-Tucky Mule
Bulleit Bourbon, Mint, Lime Juice, Ginger Beer
$9.00 - Tropical Mule (Copy)
Tito's, Lime Juice, Pineapple Juice, Ginger Beer
$8.00 - Classic Mule (Copy)
Tito's Vodka, Lime Juice, Ginger Beer
$8.00 - Skinny Mini Mule$8.00
- Old Fashioned Man
Bulleit Bourbon, Sweet Vermouth, Bitters, Orange, Cherry
$10.00 - Aviation
Gray Whale Gin, Tempus Fugit Liqueur de Violettes, Luxardo, lemon juice
$9.00 - Aperol Spritz
Aperol, Sparkling Freixenet, Club Soda, Orange Slice
$8.00 - Bee Keeper
Bulleit Bourbon, Honey, Lemon Juice, Lavendar
$9.00 - Cake by the Ocean
Malibu Rum, Cake Vodka, OJ, Pineapple
$8.25 - Gin & Jam
Hendrick's Gin, Seasonal Jam, Lemon Juice
$8.00 - Grapefruit Mint Greyhound$9.00
- Mojito$8.00
- Under The Lemon Tree$9.50
- Elderflower Cosmo
Citrus vodka, St. Germain liquor, cranberry, lemon
$10.00 - Brunch Punch Single$8.25
- Brunch Punch Pitcher$23.00
- Uncle Jack's Coffee$8.00
- church punch$8.00
- Paper Plane
Woodford Reserve bourbon, Aperol, Amaro Nonino, lemon juice
$10.00
HOLIDAY
Mother's Day
- Mother's Day MILF Heart Cake
6"-3 layer chocolate cake filled with dark chocolate buttercream and iced in vanilla buttercream.
$52.99 - Mothers day brunch box 2024$70.99
- Mother's Day Queen Bee Heart Cake
6"-3 layer lemon cake filled with lemon cream, iced in vanilla buttercream.
$52.99 - Mother's Day's Heart Cake
6"-3 layer almond cake filled and iced in our traditional buttercream.
$52.99 - Mother's Day Buttercream Board$24.99
- Mother's Day Cupcakes preorder$4.25OUT OF STOCK
Sunday | 8:00 am - 1:30 pm |
Monday | Closed |
Tuesday | Closed |
Wednesday | 7:30 am - 5:00 pm |
Thursday | 7:30 am - 5:00 pm |
Friday | 7:30 am - 7:30 pm |
Saturday | 7:30 am - 7:30 pm |
Locally owned restaurant & bakery serving breakfast, lunch, dinner, desserts and cocktails.