Fitzy's Cafe
424 East Silver Spring Drive
Milwaukee, WI 53217
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Beverages
Brewed Coffee
Espresso
- Affogato$7.00
Double shot of espresso paired with a scoop of Scratch or Purple Door ice cream
- Americano$3.50+
Espresso and water
- Cappuccino$4.00+
Espresso, steamed milk, and a heavy layer of foam
- Cortado$4.00
Double shot of espresso and equal parts steamed milk
- Espresso$3.50
Fitzy's House Blend Espresso roasted by Metric Coffee
- Espresso Macchiato$4.00
Espresso with a light dollop of milk foam
- Latte$4.00+
Espresso and steamed milk with a smooth layer of milk foam
- Mocha$6.50+
Espresso paired with rich Indulgence Chocolate and steamed milk
House Drinks
- All Upon a Foggy Night$6.75+
Rishi London Fog, 1883 Wild Peach, Toasted Granola Cashew Milk. Only served iced.
- Burn One All The Way$6.75+
Espresso. Dark Chocolate. Orange. Almond. Rosemary. Only served hot.
- Days of Heaven$6.75+
Days of Heaven Tea, Dromme Calm N/A, Honey, Yuzu Juice, Lemon. Only served iced.
- Elderflower and Matcha Gin Rickey$9.00+Out of stock
N/A Gin, Matcha, Elderflower Tonic, Agave Nectar, Lime, Verjus. Only served iced.
- Ginger Matcha Latte$6.75+
Matcha, Ginger Syrup, Coconut Milk
- Golden Tea$6.75+Out of stock
Ginger & Turmeric Cold Press, Coconut Milk, Ginger Syrup, Lemon Juice, Cayenne, Nutmeg. Only served iced.
- Grapefruit Rosemary Latte$8.00+
Rosemary, Vanilla, Cashew Milk, Citrus, Espresso. Only served hot.
- Lavender Milk Punch$6.75+
Lavender, Cashew Milk, Chamomile, Dram. Only served iced.
- Molten Cherry Mocha$6.75+
Cascara Slow Drip, Cashew Milk, Cherry Mocha Syrup, Cherry Bark Bitters, Cayenne
- Raspberry Beret$6.75+
Coconut Milk, Raspberry, Rosewater, Cardamom Syrup. Only served iced.
- Sweater Weather$6.75+
Chai, Oat Milk, Gingerbread, Trinity Bitters, Sweater Spice
- The Fitz$6.75+
Espresso, Choice of milk, Maple, Palo Santo Bitters, Lemon Fennel Salt
- Miso Peach Sage$8.00
- Hot Honey Limeade$7.00
Brewed Tea
- Bergamot Rose, 12 oz.$6.00
Organic Botanical, Caffeine-Free. Rooibos, Hibiscus, Maqui Berry, Schisandra Berry, Murta Berry, Rose Petals, Bergamot, Lavender, Tulsi
- Black Metallic, 12 oz.$6.00
Black, High Caffeine. Flavor Notes: Candied Violet, Elderberry, Blackberry, Incense
- Blueberry Rooibos, 12 oz.$6.00
Organic Botanical, Caffeine-Free. Rooibos, Elderberry, Hibiscus Flowers, Currants, Blueberry, Schisandra Berry, Strawberry
- Days of Heaven, 12 oz.$6.00
Organic Herbal Rhubarb Lemon Verbena and Chamomile, Caffeine-Free. Flavor Notes: Rhubarb Jam, Custard, California Sagebrush, Pie Crust
- Dragon Well, 12 oz.$6.00
Organic Green, Low Caffeine. Traditional pan-roasted green tea with a pleasant roasted chestnut flavor and low tannin
- English Breakfast, 12 oz.$6.00
Organic Black, High Caffeine. Malty and robust, with sweet, chocolatey undertones
- Mojave, 12 oz.$6.00
Herbal Smoky Hibiscus Cherry Tea, Low Caffeine. Flavor Notes: Black Cherry, Hibiscus, Mezcal
- Mystic Mint, 12 oz.$6.00
Organic Botanical, Caffeine-Free. Peppermint, Cardamom, Licorice Root, Basil, and Clove Leaf
- Silencio, 12 oz.$6.00
Spicy Black, High Caffeine. Flavor Notes: Ripe Pineapple, Black Pepper, Cocoa Bean
- Turmeric Ginger, 12 oz.$6.00
Organic Botanical, Caffeine-Free. Turmeric, Ginger, Licorice Root, Lemongrass, Orange, Lemon
Bakery
Bagels
- Everything Bagel$5.75
- Plain Bagel$5.75
- Poppy Seed Bagel$5.75
- Rosemary Bagel$5.75
- Sesame Bagel$5.75
Sesame Bagel
Croissants
All Day Menu
All Day Menu
- Ancient Grain Bowl$13.00
Farro, Quinoa, Chickpeas, Arugula, Sweet Potato, Goat Cheese, Avocado, Cherry Tomato, Cucumber, Lemon Vin, Hummus & Bagel Chips
- Avocado and Egg Sandwhich$13.00
Fried Egg, Avocado, Fontina, Pickled Red Onions, Truffle Glaze, Arugula on an Err'Thang Bagel
- Avocado Toast$12.00
Avocado Mash, Cherry Tomatoes, Pickled Red Onions, Chive, Burrata, Lemon Vin on Sourdough
- Bowl of Soup$7.00
Rotating Daily, 16 oz.
- Fitzy's House Salad$15.00
Mixed Greens, Radish, Apple, Sweet Potato, Quinoa, Mint, Goat Cheese, Granola, & Labneh Gastrique
- Fruit & Yogurt Granola Bowl$12.00
Yogurt, Apple, Blueberry, Honey, House Granola
- Horsey Beef$15.00
Roasted Beef, Radish, Pickled Red Onion, Calabrian Chili, Arugula, Horseradish, Aioli on Ciabatta
- Labneh Tartine$12.00
Olive, Cucumber, Cherry Tomato, Aleppo Pepper, Pickled Cucumber, Za'atar, & Mint on Sourdough
- Quiche$11.00
Rotating Daily
- Salmon BLT$19.00
Salmon "Bacon," Boston Bib, Vine Tomato, Garlic Aioli on an Err'Thang Bagel
- Tomato Basil Grilled Cheese$13.00
Fontina, Aged Cheddar Chevre, Vine Tomato, Basil Vin on Focaccia
Kid Friendly
Sunday | 7:30 am - 4:45 pm |
Monday | 7:30 am - 4:45 pm |
Tuesday | 7:30 am - 4:45 pm |
Wednesday | 7:30 am - 4:45 pm |
Thursday | 7:30 am - 4:45 pm |
Friday | 7:30 am - 4:45 pm |
Saturday | 7:30 am - 4:45 pm |
Come in and enjoy great coffee, food, and service!
424 East Silver Spring Drive, Milwaukee, WI 53217