Mahi Mahi's Island Grill
2217 South Croatan Highway
Nags Head, NC 27959
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Shareables
- Fried Calamari$14.00
lightly breaded calamari rings & tentacles | creamy lemon & caper sauce | fresh herbs | queso fresco
- Loaded Nacho$13.00
- Oven Roasted Brussels$15.00
honey brussels | candied walnuts | gorgonzola cheese | smoked bacon | green apple salad | balsamic glaze
- Chips & Dip Trio$14.00
- Chupe de Mejillones (Mussels Appetizer)$16.00
fresh sauteed mussels | aji’s light cream | fresh herbs | queso fresco | grilled garlic French bread
- Oyster Casino$16.00
oven-roasted on the half shell | smoked bacon | onions | peppers | fresh herbs | garlic butter | house-pickled jalapeno
- Egg Rolls Cheesesteak$14.00
- NC Crab Dip$16.00
a blend of crab | three kinds of cheese toasted French bread | fresh herbs
- Tuna Nachos **$14.00
rare sushi-grade local tuna | wakame seaweed salad | crisp wontons | wasabi drizzle | honey-miso soy | peanut lime vinaigrette | pickle ginger | fresh avocado
Soup & Salads
- Cup Award Winning Mahi-Mahi Chowder$9.00
smoked corn | Idaho potatoes | local mahi-mahi | fresh vegetables | heavy cream | fresh herbs | oyster crackers on the side
- Bowl Award Winning Mahi-Mahi Chowder$12.00
smoked corn | Idaho potatoes | local mahi-mahi | fresh vegetables | heavy cream | fresh herbs | oyster crackers on the side
- Garden Salad$13.00
spring lettuce | red onions | grape tomatoes | cucumbers | shaved carrots | sunflowers seeds | your choice of dressing
- Traditional Caesar Salad$12.00
crisp romaine | creamy Caesar dressing garlic croutons | shaved parmesan cheese
- Southwestern Salad$15.00
spring lettuce | grape tomatoes | red onions | shaved carrots | queso fresco grilled corn & black bean salsa | fresh avocado | blackened tortilla strips | chipotle honey vinaigrette
- Avocado Caprese$14.00
spring lettuce | fresh mozzarella vine ripe tomatoes | fresh avocado slices balsamic reduction | basil oil | crispy basil
- Cup Soup Of The Day$7.00
- Bowl Soup Of The Day$9.00
Handhelds
- Chicken Sandwich$15.00
grilled chicken breast | smoked bacon provolone cheese | sauteed onions honey chipotle aioli | toasted brioche bun lettuce | tomato | pickle spear |seasoned hand-cut fries
- Bacon Jam Burger$16.00
- Mahi-Mahi Reuben$19.00
lightly breaded then golden fried Mahi-Mahi | sassy slaw Swiss cheese | Thousand Island dressing | baked sourdough bread | pickle spear | seasoned hand-cut fries
- Philly Cheesesteak$17.00
seared thinly sliced beef | sauteéd onions | sauteéd peppers | toasted sub roll | roasted garlic aioli | pickle spear | seasoned hand-cut fries | Your choice of provolone or cheddar cheese
Main Course Dinner
- Tacos Callejeros (street tacos)$20.00
lightly breaded fried fish the day | flour tortilla | cilantro cabbage slaw | queso fresco | pico de gallo | avocado lime crema | Spanish rice | black beans
- Jack Fruit Tacos$18.00
- Award Winning Shrimp & Grits$26.00
sauteéd NC shrimp | Andouille sausage sherry wine cream sauce | peppers | green onions | cheddar cheese stone-ground grits
- Fisherman's Seafood Stew$35.00
local mahi-mahi | NC shrimp | fresh mussels | fresh corn | local vegetables | Idaho potatoes | traditional Peruvian broth | Spanish rice | fresh herbs
- Bone In Pork Chop$26.00
- Shrimp Pasta Dinner$26.00
sauteéd NC shrimp | rotini pasta | mixed vegetables Peruvian tomato & aji broth | shaved parmesan | fresh herbs | grilled garlic French bread
- Ribeye Steak **$42.00
grilled 12 oz USDA Ribeye steak garlic mashed potatoes seared broccolini gorgonzola cheese | demi-glace | fried onions
- Bronzed Salmon$27.00
seared to perfection | roasted tomatoes & peas risotto olives & capers relish | fried basil
- Fish & Chips$21.00
beer-battered Mahi | bed of seasoned hand-cut fries sassy slaw | roasted pepper & cilantro aioli
- Fried Oysters$26.00
lightly breaded then golden fried local oysters | bed of seasoned hand-cut fries | sassy slaw | roasted pepper & cilantro aioli
- Fried NC Shrimp$26.00
lightly breaded then golden fried local shrimp | bed of seasoned hand-cut fries | sassy slaw | roasted pepper & cilantro aioli
- BUILD YOUR OWN F.O.D.$28.00
Kid Menu
- Kid Tenders$9.00
choice of: seasoned hand-cut fries or fresh fruit
- Kid Fish Basket$9.00
choice of: seasoned hand-cut fries or fresh fruit
- Kid Cheeseburger$9.00
choice of: seasoned hand-cut fries or fresh fruit
- Kid Grilled Cheese$8.00
choice of: seasoned hand-cut fries or fresh fruit
- Kid Mac & Cheese$9.00
Kid Grilled Cheese
choice of: seasoned hand-cut fries or fresh fruit
Sweets
- Bread pudding (peru)$9.00
- Hershey Chocolate Cake$9.00
Outer Banks favor | homemade whipped cream | chocolate sauce
- Key Lime Pie$9.00
raspberry sauce | homemade whipped cream
- Apple Crisp$9.00
- Crème Brulée$9.00
homemade whipped cream | powder sugar fresh cookie
- Ice Cream one scoop$3.00
- Ice Cream two scoop$5.00
- Ice Cream three scoop$9.00
- Sorbet 1 Scoop$3.00
- Sorbet 2 Scoops$5.00
- Sorbet 3 Scoops$7.00
- Lemon Mascarpone Cake$9.00
Sides/Add on's
- EXTRA PLATE
- $$ TOPPINGS$1.00
- $$ Side Caesar Salad$6.00
- $$ Side Garden Salad$6.00
- $$ Avocado Slices$1.50
- $$ Black Beans$6.00
- $$ Broccolini$7.00
- $$ Bruseels - NOT APP$7.00
- $$ Corn & Sweet Peas$7.00
- $$ Garlic Mashed Potatoes$6.00
- $$ Green Beans & Onions$7.00
- $$ Grits$6.00
- $$ Side 4oz Guacamole$2.50
- $$ French Fries$5.00
- $$ Fresh Fruit$6.00
- $$ Mixed Vegetables$7.00
- $$ Sassy Slaw$5.00
- $$ Spanish Rice$6.00
- $$ Sweet Potato Mash$6.00
- $$ Side Bacon$2.50
- $$ Side Of Celery$1.50
- $$ EXTRA CHIPS$2.00
- $$ Extra Garlic Bread$4.00
- $$ Blackened Chicken$7.50
- $$ Blackened FOD$17.00
- $$ Blackened Mahi$13.50
- $$ Blackened Salmon$14.50
- $$ Blackened Scallops$16.50
- $$ Blackened Shrimp$8.50
- $$ Grilled Chicken$7.00
- $$ Fried Mahi$13.00
- $$ Fried Oysters$9.00
- $$ Fried Shrimp$8.00
- $$ Seared FOD$17.00
- $$ Seared Mahi$13.00
- $$ Seared Salmon$14.00
- $$ Seared Scallops$16.00
- $$ Seared Shrimp$8.00
Daily Dinner Specials
Side Sauces
- BALSAMIC DRESSING$0.75
- BALSAMIC GLAZE$0.75
- BASIL OIL$0.75
- BLEU CHEESE DRESSING$0.75
- Buffalo Sauce$0.75
- CAESAR DRESSING$0.75
- CHIPOTLE HONEY VINAIGRETTE$0.75
- Cocktail Sauce$0.75
- Come Back Sauce$0.75Out of stock
- CREAMY LEMON CAPER SAUCE$0.75
- HABANERO RANCH DRESSING$0.75
- Herb Vin
- HONEY MUSTARD$0.75
- HONEY-MISO SOY$0.75
- Lime Sour Cream$0.75
- Soft Butter$0.75
- Special Salad Dressing$0.75
- Tartar Sauce$0.75
- THOUSAND ISLAND$0.75
- WASABI DRIZZLE$0.75
Sunday | 12:00 pm - 9:45 pm |
Monday | 3:00 pm - 9:45 pm |
Tuesday | 3:00 pm - 9:45 pm |
Wednesday | 3:00 pm - 9:45 pm |
Thursday | 3:00 pm - 9:45 pm |
Friday | 3:00 pm - 9:45 pm |
Saturday | 12:00 pm - 9:45 pm |
Come in and enjoy!
2217 South Croatan Highway, Nags Head, NC 27959