- Home
- /
- New York
- /
- Hell's Kitchen
- /
- Bakeries
- /
- Little Pie Company
Little Pie Company
No reviews yet
424 W 43rd St New York NY 10036
New York, NY 10036
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Holiday Items
Mother's Day Special
- Strawberry Shortcake - MED$50.00
Fresh Strawberries in between 3 layers of moist cake topped off with fresh whipped cream. (Serves 6-8)
- Mom's Spring Pie Sampler$48.00
Make Mom smile this Mother’s Day with this limited-edition sampler! Available exclusively for Mother’s Day, this delightful sampler pack features four of our favorite berry-licious pies in adorable five-inch varieties: Strawberry Rhubarb, Montmorency Cherry, Three Berry, and Blueberry Crumb! All packaged in a beautiful gift box.
Handmade Pies
5 inch (serve 1-2)
- Sour Cream Apple Walnut 5"$12.00
It’s not your ordinary pie. Our signature pie is baked with hand-sliced Granny Smith apples, fresh sour cream and topped with brown sugar, cinnamon and walnut streusel.
- Old Fashioned Apple 5"$12.00
Our old-fashioned apple pie is low in sugar and bursting with flavor. It’s made with fresh golden delicious apples, spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg and covered with a light flaky crust. Serve warm with a scoop of cold vanilla ice cream.
- Florida Key Lime 5"$12.00
Our Key Lime Pie is made with fresh key lime juice from a 75-year-old recipe, unlocking a sunburst of flavors. It’s sweet tart, smooth and creamy. Serve chilled with fresh whipped cream.
- Mississippi Mud 5"$12.00
Romance the chocolate lover in all of us. This sinful seducer is made up of quality imported Belgian chocolate, brownie streusel and a chocolate glaze in a chocolate cookie crust. Serve with freshly whipped cream or ice cream.
- Three Berry 5"$12.00
A taste revolution in and of itself, our blend of fresh strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries are simmered into a sweet confection and then topped with a superb lattice crust.
- Sugarless Apple 5"$12.00
The right pie with the perfect sweetener. Nature’s own grade A golden delicious apples. We add a little nutmeg, cinnamon and unsalted butter to complete this great tasting pie.
- Banana Coconut Cream 5"$12.00
This dessert is filled with fresh banana slices and banana custard. Topped off with freshly whipped cream and toasted coconut, make this pie supreme.
- Chicken Pot pie$12.00
This wholesome and hearty pie is filled with tender white chicken chunks and a mixture of fresh cream, peas, carrots and onions. Then baked just right.
- GLUTEN-FREE Blueberry Apple Crumb 5"$14.00
Our Gluten Free Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie combines ripe blueberries with chunks of Golden Delicious Apples — making for the perfect not-too-sweet, not-to-tart filling. But, we didn’t stop there: Each Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie is topped with brown sugar-coated chopped walnuts for a crunchy, sweet finish that’s sure to tantalize your taste buds. ***Please note that our gluten-free pies are made fresh to order in limited quantities and must be ordered ahead of time online.***
- GLUTEN-FREE Florida Key Lime$14.00
Our Gluten-Free Key Lime Pie is made with Florida Key lime juice and a homemade Gluten free graham cracker crust that's sweetened with a hint of honey. Each pie is sprinkled with fresh lime zest for a tropical burst of flavors you won’t be able to resist. ***Please note that our gluten-free pies are made fresh to order in limited quantities and must be ordered ahead of time online.***
- Montmorency Cherry 5" (Seasonal)$12.00
Topped with lightly browned crinkle crust and the perfect amount of sugary crystals, plump, fresh cherries leap out of their time-honored bowl and proclaim quite honestly, "Life is just a forkful of cherries!
- Blueberry Crumb 5" (Seasonal)$12.00
Farm-fresh, plump, and juicy blueberries and a delectable oatmeal crumb topping with brown sugar, cloves, and cinnamon. After all, it’s prime blueberry season, which means it’s the perfect time to savor our Blueberry Crumb Pie. And, for an irresistible combination of flavors, top your slice with a generous scoop of vanilla ice cream.
- Strawberry Rhubarb 5" (Seasonal)$12.00
Our Spring favorite! Savor this Strawberry Rhubarb pie as we relish spring's finest efforts. Filled with ripe fruit as if plucked from a country-fresh roadside stand and delicately enveloped by a golden brown lattice crust, our pie is bound to elicit spring smiles.
10 inch (serve 8-10)
- Sour Cream Apple Walnut 10"$45.00
It’s not your ordinary pie. Our signature pie is baked with hand-sliced Granny Smith apples, fresh sour cream and topped with brown sugar, cinnamon and walnut streusel.
- Old Fashioned Apple 10"$45.00
Our old-fashioned apple pie is low in sugar and bursting with flavor. It’s made with fresh golden delicious apples, spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg and covered with a light flaky crust. Serve warm with a scoop of cold vanilla ice cream.
- Mississippi Mud 10"$45.00
Romance the chocolate lover in all of us. This sinful seducer is made up of quality imported Belgian chocolate, brownie streusel and a chocolate glaze in a chocolate cookie crust. Serve with freshly whipped cream or ice cream.
- Florida Key Lime 10"$45.00
Our Key Lime Pie is made with fresh key lime juice from a 75-year-old recipe, unlocking a sunburst of flavors. It’s sweet tart, smooth and creamy. Serve chilled with fresh whipped cream.
- Three Berry 10"$45.00
A taste revolution in and of itself, our blend of fresh strawberries, blueberries, and raspberries are simmered into a sweet confection and then topped with a superb lattice crust.
- Southern Pecan 10"$45.00
A rich and tender crust is the perfect foil for this heavenly, not overly sweet, classic. The ratio of pecans to filling is generously balanced and a scoop of freshly whipped cream complements a warm slice.
- Sugarless Apple 10" (24 HOURS IN ADVANCE)$45.00
The right pie with the perfect sweetener. Nature’s own grade A golden delicious apples. We add a little nutmeg, cinnamon and unsalted butter to complete this great tasting pie.
- GLUTEN-FREE Blueberry Apple Crumb 10"$52.00
Our Gluten Free Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie combines ripe blueberries with chunks of Golden Delicious Apples — making for the perfect not-too-sweet, not-to-tart filling. But, we didn’t stop there: Each Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie is topped with brown sugar-coated chopped walnuts for a crunchy, sweet finish that’s sure to tantalize your taste buds. ***Please note that our gluten-free pies are made fresh to order in limited quantities and must be ordered ahead of time online.***
- GLUTEN-FREE Florida Key Lime 10"$52.00
Our Gluten-Free Key Lime Pie is made with Florida Key lime juice and a homemade Gluten free graham cracker crust that's sweetened with a hint of honey. Each pie is sprinkled with fresh lime zest for a tropical burst of flavors you won’t be able to resist. ***Please note that our gluten-free pies are made fresh to order in limited quantities and must be ordered ahead of time online.***
- Strawberry Rhubarb 10" (Seasonal)$45.00
Our Spring favorite! Savor this Strawberry Rhubarb pie as we relish spring's finest efforts. Filled with ripe fruit as if plucked from a country-fresh roadside stand and delicately enveloped by a golden brown lattice crust, our pie is bound to elicit spring smiles.
- Blueberry Crumb Pie (Seasonal)$45.00
Farm-fresh, plump, and juicy blueberries and a delectable oatmeal crumb topping with brown sugar, cloves, and cinnamon. After all, it’s prime blueberry season, which means it’s the perfect time to savor our Blueberry Crumb Pie. And, for an irresistible combination of flavors, top your slice with a generous scoop of vanilla ice cream.
- Montmorency Cherry 10" (Seasonal)$45.00
Topped with lightly browned crinkle crust and the perfect amount of sugary crystals, plump, fresh cherries leap out of their time-honored bowl and proclaim quite honestly, "Life is just a forkful of cherries!
Homemade Cakes
Small Cakes
- SM Applesauce Carrot Cake$20.00
By making our own homemade apple sauce for the carrot cake, determined that we would not need to add a lot of additional sugar. The natural sweetness of the apples gave our cake a perfect balance of flavors. The addition of California walnuts, imported spices and cream cheese, added the right taste and texture to this delicious cake.
- SM Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake$20.00
We wanted to meet three important goals with our chocolate cake: It should be very moist. It should have a rich chocolate taste and it should be luxurious. These are the qualities we trust you will find and enjoy in our Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake.
- SM Creamy New York Cheese Cake$8.50
Our famous New York Cheesecake sends the senses reeling with a creamy, yet slightly dense, combination of fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all natural ingredients that rest in a golden graham cracker crust. Serve with fresh fruit or fruit glaze to complement the rich flavors.
- SM Creamy NY Cheese Cake w/ Strawberry topping(72 Hr. Pre-order ONLY)$9.50
Our famous New York Cheesecake sends the senses reeling with a creamy, yet slightly dense, combination of fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all natural ingredients that rest in a golden graham cracker crust. Serve with fresh fruit or fruit glaze to complement the rich flavors.
Medium Cakes
- MD Applesauce Carrot Cake$40.00
By making our own homemade apple sauce for the carrot cake, determined that we would not need to add a lot of additional sugar. The natural sweetness of the apples gave our cake a perfect balance of flavors. The addition of California walnuts, imported spices and cream cheese, added the right taste and texture to this delicious cake.
- MD Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake$40.00
We wanted to meet three important goals with our chocolate cake: It should be very moist. It should have a rich chocolate taste and it should be luxurious. These are the qualities we trust you will find and enjoy in our Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake.
Large Cakes
- LG Applesauce Carrot Cake$55.00
By making our own homemade apple sauce for the carrot cake, determined that we would not need to add a lot of additional sugar. The natural sweetness of the apples gave our cake a perfect balance of flavors. The addition of California walnuts, imported spices and cream cheese, added the right taste and texture to this delicious cake.
- LG Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake$55.00
We wanted to meet three important goals with our chocolate cake: It should be very moist. It should have a rich chocolate taste and it should be luxurious. These are the qualities we trust you will find and enjoy in our Old-Fashioned Chocolate Cake.
- LG Creamy New York Cheese Cake$45.00
Our famous New York Cheesecake sends the senses reeling with a creamy, yet slightly dense, combination of fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all natural ingredients that rest in a golden graham cracker crust. Serve with fresh fruit or fruit glaze to complement the rich flavors.
- Strawberry Cheesecake(72 Hr. Pre-order ONLY)$53.00
Our famous New York Cheesecake sends the senses reeling with a creamy, yet slightly dense, combination of fresh cream cheese, pure vanilla, and all natural ingredients that rest in a golden graham cracker crust. Serve with fresh fruit or fruit glaze to complement the rich flavors.
Dessert Loaves
Banana Nut Bread
- Banana Nut Bread$5.00+
Very ripe bananas, give this bread its rich flavor. Walnuts and buttermilk bring out the moist and crunchy taste we enjoy, making it a treat we can enjoy anytime.
Banana Nut Bread
Very ripe bananas, give this bread its rich flavor. Walnuts and buttermilk bring out the moist and crunchy taste we enjoy, making it a treat we can enjoy anytime.
Apple Cinnamon
Other Desserts
- Apple Turnover$6.95
Our triangular golden crusts, are filled with chunks of golden delicious apples, flavored with cinnamon and sugar, a delight to feast on any time day or night. The crust are hand roll nearly eight times, before they reach the oven the end result a croissant like flakiness with a melt in your mouth moment.
- Brownies$5.50+
Our brownies are traditional American style, but with a slight difference, we use Belgian chocolate. The rich and smooth texture of this chocolate with the addition of walnuts in the mixture takes the American brownie to the next level.
- Sour Cream Coffee Cake w/ Apple Filling$6.50
Moist and fluffy are two good words to describe our coffee cake, brown sugar, cinnamon and butter are the right combinations for a perfect streusel. We discovered that by placing thinly sliced apples in the center and sometimes blueberries, gave this cake a refreshing and delightful flavor, so now, you may enjoy the pleasures of our delicious version of this traditional cake; enjoyed by everyone that truly appreciates good desserts.
Call for Open Hours
Dessert made from scratch, using only fresh, honest, pure ingredients mixed together by hand—never any artificial preservatives. Simply good & ready to eat
424 W 43rd St New York NY 10036, New York, NY 10036