- Home
- /
- Brooklyn
- /
- Brighton Beach
- /
- Cafes, Coffee & Tea
- /
- The Bay Cafe -
The Bay Cafe
No reviews yet
2 Neptune Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11235
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
STARTERS
SAUCE BUY ONE GET ONE!
- Fish Tacos$20.00
3 Soft corn tortillas filled w/ Crispy Fried Cod, Slaw & Avocado Mango Salsa
- Penne Vodka$24.00
Penne pasta served with our homemade tomato cream sauce & fresh basil
- American Pizza$20.00
- CHURROS$16.00
There’s nothing like a fresh homemade churro. Crispy on the outside, soft & tender on the inside comes with a chocolate hazelnut ganache dipping sauce.
- Broccoli & Cheese Baked Potatoes$16.00
- Caesar Salad$18.00
Crispy romaine lettuce, grape tomatoes, house made croutons, parmesan cheese, gently tossed with our classic Caesar dressing.
- Mushroom & Cheese Baked Potatoes$16.00
- Spinach & Cheese Baked Potatoes$16.00
APPETIZERS
- Tempura Seabass Bites$26.00
This delicious fish appetizer has a mild flavor with a subtle sweetness, the flesh is moist and tender and a crunchy tempura coating. Tossed in a sweet & spicy chili sauce.
- Arancini Cheesy Rissoto Balls$18.00
Arancini are crispy risotto balls with a cheesy center - Served with a tomato basil pink sauce
- Fish Tacos$20.00
3 Soft corn tortillas filled w/ Crispy Fried Cod, Slaw & Avocado Mango Salsa
- Pan de Queso$16.00
This traditional gluten free Brazilian cheese bread is the perfect appetizer for any cheese lover. Crunchy on the outside, soft & chewy inside. Never fried always baked
- Lasagna Cheese Frittas$20.00
A great twist on lasagna, this delicious cheese filled lasagna roll ups are breaded & pan fried. Served with Alfredo and marinara sauce.
- Mozzarella Sticks$18.00
Breaded & Seasoned Mozzarella Fried Golden served w/ Marinara Sauce
- BBQ Cauliflower Florets$18.00
Breaded cauliflower florets served w/ BBQ Sauce
- Stuffed Mushrooms$17.00
Stuffed with Herbs, Garlic & Cheese
- Truffle Fries with Parmesan$16.00
- Maryland Crab Cakes$18.00
Crispy on the outside & tender in the inside these succulent pan-fried imitation Crab cakes are served with our in house made tartar sauce
- Mozzarella Caprese$20.00
Fresh Homemade Mozzarella, Sun Ripened Tomatoes, Fresh Basil, Extra Virgin Olive Oil & Balsamic Drizzle
- Beet Carpaccio$18.00
Thinly Sliced Roasted Beets, Goat Cheese & Mixed Greens w/ Herb Vinaigrette
- Stuffed baked potato$15.00
SIDE DISHES
SALADS
- Middle Eastern Chopped Salad$20.00
Romaine, tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, red bell pepper, parsley, za’atar, breadcrumbs, feta, fresh lemon, extra virgin olive oil
- Greek Salad$19.00
Romaine Hearts, Red Onion, Cucumber, Cherry Tomatoes, Kalamata Olives, Stuffed Grape Leaves, Feta Cheese, Oregano w/ Greek Dressing
- GRILLED HALLOUMI SALAD$23.00
A delicious blend of fresh & flavorful ingredients, including grilled halloumi, cool crisp cucumber, rich kalamata olives & toasted pine nuts. Then brightened up with lots of fresh greens, mint then made extra hearty with some chewy nutritious farro.
- Caesar Salad$18.00
Crispy romaine lettuce, grape tomatoes, house made croutons, parmesan cheese, gently tossed with our classic Caesar dressing.
- Spinach apple$18.00
This apple spinach salad is our all time favorite. It is made with a delicious mix of sweet & savory ingredients - Fresh spinach, apples, onions, toasted pecans, dried cranberries & feta cheese
- Avocado Salad$17.00
Romaine Hearts, Avocado Slices, Tomatoes, Cucumber & Red Onion
- Quinoa & Kale Tropical Power Salad$18.00
A healthy and nutrient filled salad. Baby kale, quinoa, mango, cashews, blueberries, & sliced avocado
- Mediterranean Farro Salad$20.00
Mixed greens, farro, cucumber, roasted.red peppers, sun dried tomatoes, feta cheese, red onion, parsley, radish, marinated artichoke & fresh mint.
- Bay Salad$18.00
Romaine Hearts, Cherry Tomatoes, Toasted Pecans, Crispy Breaded Goat Cheese, Cucumber & Orange Segments
- Roasted Beet & Quinoa Salad$18.00
This sweet & savory winter salad is a delicious start to any meal. Roasted red and golden beets, sliced pears, toasted walnuts, feta, mixed greens & quinoa.
- Sesame Crusted Salmon Teriyaki Salad$30.00
Sesame crusted baked salmon, romaine hearts, red cabbage, arugula, haricot verts, & baked sweet potato
SOUP
HOT SOUPS
- Split Pea Soup$8.00+Out of stock
- Lentil Soup$8.00+Out of stock
- French Onion$13.00+
French Onion Soup with toasted baguette & Cheese
- Vegetable Soup$8.00+
- Red Lentil Soup$8.00+Out of stock
- Mushroom Barley Soup$8.00+Out of stock
A thick and creamy soup. Makes a wonderful meal with a nice crusty bread
- Cream of Mushroom$14.00Out of stock
SANDWICHES / POTATOES / WRAPS/ PANINIS
PANINI
WRAPS
- MOZZARELLA WRAP$17.00
Fresh mozzarella, avocado & tomato with pesto
- AVOCADO WRAP$16.00
Avocado, hard eggs, feta, lettuce, olive tapenade & tomato
- ROASTED PORTOBELLO WRAP$17.00
Roasted portabello mushroom, fresh mozzarella, fire roasted red bell peppers with pesto
- TUNA MELT WRAP$18.00
Tuna salad, mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato & onion
- GRILLED SALMON WRAP$20.00
Grilled fresh salmon, lettuce, cucumber & onions served with garlic mayo dressing
BAKED POTATOES
PIZZA
- American Pizza$20.00
- Margherita Pizza$22.00
Tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese & Basil
- Mushroom Pesto Pizza$24.00
Fresh mushrooms, mozzarella cheese, basil pesto using an alfredo sauce
- Olive Zaatar Pizza$22.00
Mozzarella, olives, zaatar & sesame (no sauce)
- Pizza Bianca$22.00
This delicious White Pizza is drizzled with olive oil, garlic, and white cheeses
- Truffle Mushroom Pizza$25.00
Seasoned with fresh truffle zest and mushrooms. Truffle takes this pizza from fine to sublime
- Vegetable Pizza$24.00
Broccoli, onion, mushroom, tomatoes, mozzarella, tomato sauce.
PASTA
PASTA
- Fettuccini Alfredo with Mushrooms$26.00
House made Fettuccini pasta, creamy wild mushroom alfredo sauce (add smoked salmon $6)
- Mac & Cheese$24.00
Mac & Considered the queen of comfort food, our Mac & Cheese includes a selected types of cheeses to bring you the most delightful cheesy pasta experience. Cheese
FISH / SIDE DISHES
FISH
- Maple Cedar Planked Salmon$43.00
A delicious, grilled salmon with enormous flavor. You will get that lovely smoky flavor from the cedar wood in this select cut salmon. The maple and ginger are the perfect complement to this recipe.
- Grilled Salmon$40.00
Fresh fillet salmon, seasoned with salt & pepper grilled over an open fire
- Salmon Teriyaki$41.00
Perfectly baked salmon with our homemade teriyaki sauce & finished off with toasted sesame seeds.
- THE QUEENS FISH ‘N’ CHIPS$38.00
Fresh fillet of white fish, coated in our signature batter, gently fried to the perfect crispness & accompanied by fresh cut russet potato fries – served with malt vinegar & tartar sauce
- Mediterranean Branzino$47.00
Simply … healthy & delicious. The oregano and lemon make it truly a Greek cuisine that we are sure you will enjoy - ** Whole Fish Butterfly Fillet **
- Pan Seared Branzino$42.00
2 Fillets are gently pan seared and seasoned
- Mushroom Crusted Sea Bass$55.00
This amazing buttery fish is perfectly baked with a crust prepared with the intense flavor of dried porcini mushrooms, spices & herbs
- Lemon & Walnut Crusted Turbot$40.00
A light, zesty & hearty. The Turbot is perfectly flaky & buttery enough to melt in your mouth & the walnut crust gives each bite the perfect crunch.
- Pepper Crusted Tuna Steak$48.00
If you enjoy steak, you will love this black pepper crusted Ahi tuna steak, always prepared medium rare
- Sole francaise$44.00
SIDE DISHES
- Charred Cauliflower - SIDE$11.00
- SAUTEED BROCCOLI - SIDE$11.00
- FRENCH FRIES - SIDE$11.00
- GARLIC FRIES - SIDES$11.00
- GRILLED VEGETABLES - SIDE$11.00
- RICE - SIDE$11.00
- MASHED POTATOES - SIDE$11.00
- SAUTEED SPINACH - SIDE$11.00
- ROASTED BABY POTATO - SIDE$11.00
- TRUFFLE FRIES - SIDE$15.00
- CHARRED FENNEL$11.00
- SAUTEED STRING BEANS$11.00
- SIDE SALAD$8.00
DESSERTS
DESSSERT
- Chocolate Souffle$19.00
This classic dessert is airy, with a deep chocolate flavor with a decadent chocolate center served warm with a scoop of ice cream
- NY STYLE CHEESE CAKE$20.00
Our famous creamy cheesecake with a graham cracker crust
- CHURROS$16.00
There’s nothing like a fresh homemade churro. Crispy on the outside, soft & tender on the inside comes with a chocolate hazelnut ganache dipping sauce.
- Lemon Curd Cheesecake$18.00
This dessert is prepared in a cup with the bottom layer of graham crust, center filled with the rich & buttery texture of the most delicious Mascarpone cheesecake and topped off with the perfect silky smooth tangy sweet Lemon Curd
- Belgian Waffles$18.00
Fresh baked Belgian waffles with ice cream, whipped cream, candy sprinkles berries & bananas
- CREME BRULEE$20.00
The smooth and creamy texture of this sweet custard is highlighted by its candied top – always a delicious classic
- Apple crisp caramel$17.00
A delicious blend of fuji and granny smith apples cinnamon & a touch of nutmeg bring this dessert to a whole new level. Served with a scoop of ice cream - vanilla, chocolate, strawberry or coffee
- Classis Tiramisu$18.00
This homemade classic Italian recipe uses all the best & freshest ingredients from the mascarpone cheese to the rum & espresso. Served with fresh sweet ricotta cream filled Canoli.
- Ice Cream Scoop$4.00
Vanilla, Strawberry, Chocolate, Coffee Price per scoop
BEVERAGES
Hot Drinks
- Cappuccino$4.95+
Espresso, steamed milk topped with milk froth & cinnamon
- Americano$3.95+
Shot of espresso with hot water
- Cafe Latte$4.95+
Espresso & steamed milk
- Coffee Brewed$2.75+
- Espresso$3.50+
- Caramel Macchiato$5.45+
- Cafe Misto$3.50
- Hazelnut Latte$5.45+
- Almond Milk Latte$8.00
- Vanilla Latte$5.45+
Shot of espresso, steamed milk, French vanilla
- Espresso Con Panna$4.95+
- Honey Almond Milk Latte$5.45+
Shot of espresso, almond milk, and a touch of honey
- Hot chocolate$4.95+
A warming and comforting cup of our decadent hot chocolate
- Macchiato$4.45+
Shot of espresso topped with steamed milk
- Matchta Latte Hot$7.00
- HOT SPICED APPLE CIDER$6.75+
Our cider is pressed fresh daily at our restaurant. This soothing naturally sweet cider is brewed with a blend of cinnamon, orange peel, star anise, cloves and other spices & herbs to give our guests a deep warming experience.
- Hot Tea$2.50+
- Large tea$18.00
- Medium tea$12.00
- Mocha Latte$5.45+
Espresso, steamed milk & chocolate
- Nana tea$4.50
- Small tea$7.00
Cold Specialty Drinks
- Iced Coffee$5.00
- Cold Brew$5.50
- Iced Latte$8.00
- Iced Cappuccino$8.00
- FRAPPUCINO$9.50
- Mocha Cookie Frappuccino$9.50
- Smore's Frappuccino$10.00
- Pressed Almond Milk$3.50
- Apple Cider$7.50
- Lemon Nana$8.50
- Ice tea$4.00
- Smoothie$12.00
- Matchta Ice$8.00
- MILK SHAKE$8.00
- Pina Colada V$10.00
- Strawberry Daiquiri V$10.00
- Fresh Brewed Ice Tea Pitcher$12.00
- Sangria$16.00
- Watermelon Mojito$11.00
- Teqila Sunrise$11.00
- Espresso Martini$13.00
- Blue Lagoon$11.00
SOFT DRINKS
Catering Menu
Fish Catering Menu
- Salmon Teriyaki Catering$68.00+
Baked Sides of fresh salmon glazed with our homemade teriyaki sauce. Topped with toasted sesame seeds & scallions. ** Please let us know if you prefer no sesame and or scallions on your order Each side of salmon is sliced into 3 to 4 oz pcs so guests can easily serve themselves at the buffet. Disposable serving utensil included.
- Grilled Salmon Catering$68.00+
Fresh sides of salmon gently grilled over an open flame. Topped with chopped fresh parsley, salt & pepper. Each side of salmon is sliced into 3 to 4 oz pcs so guests can easily serve themselves at the buffet. Disposable serving utensil included.
- Maple Glazed Salmon Catering$68.00+
A delicious, grilled salmon with enormous flavor. The maple and ginger are the perfect complement to this recipe.
- Pan Seared Branzino$30.00
- Beer Battered Turbot$29.00
Pasta Catering Menu
- Penne Vodka Catering Tray$60.00+
Penne pasta served with our homemade tomato cream sauce & fresh basil. Comes with disposable serving utensils. Disposable warming tray & sternos are available at extra cost.
- Eggplant Parmesan Catering Tray$65.00+
Thin slices of fresh eggplant breaded, baked with our homemade marinara sauce, & topped with mozzarella & parmesan. Comes with disposable serving utensils. Disposable warming tray & sternos are available at extra cost.
- Baked Zitti Catering Tray$60.00+
Penne pasta, ricotta cheese, marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese. Comes with disposable serving utensils. Disposable warming tray & sternos are available at extra cost.
- Fettuccini Alfredo Catering Tray$60.00+
Fettuccini pasta served with our creamy alfredo sauce Comes with disposable serving utensils. Disposable warming tray & sternos are available at extra cost.
- Mac & Cheese Catering Tray$70.00+
Considered the queen of comfort food, our Mac & Cheese includes a selected types of cheeses to bring you the most delightful cheesy pasta experience. Comes with disposable serving utensils. Disposable warming tray & sternos are available at extra cost.
- Pasta Marinara Catering Tray$50.00+
Penne pasta with our signature marinara sauce Comes with disposable serving utensils. Disposable warming tray & sternos are available at extra cost.
- Gnocchi Catering Tray$70.00+
In house made potato gnocchi pan seared with fresh mushroom, garlic, and cream sauce Comes with disposable serving utensils. Disposable warming tray & sternos are available at extra cost.
- Mushroom Ravioli 9x13 Tray$79.00
- Spinach Ravioli 9x13 Tray$79.00
Salad Catering Menu
- Caesar Salad Catering$50.00
Crispy romaine lettuce, grape tomatoes, house made croutons, parmesan cheese, gently tossed with our classic Caesar dressing.
- Greek Salad Catering$55.00
- Halloumi Salad Catering$60.00
- Arugula Salad Catering$55.00
- The Bay Salad Catering$60.00
Romaine Hearts, Cherry Tomatoes, Toasted Pecans, Crispy Breaded Goat Cheese, Cucumber & Orange Segments
- Avocado Salad Catering$55.00
Romaine Hearts, Avocado Slices, Tomatoes, Cucumber & Red Onion
- Middle Eastern Salad Catering$55.00
Romaine, tomatoes, cucumber, red onion, red bell pepper, parsley, za’atar, breadcrumbs, feta
- Quinoa & Kale Tropical Power - Catering$60.00
A healthy and nutrient filled salad. Baby kale, quinoa, mango, cashews, blueberries, & sliced avocado
- Roasted Beet & Quinoa Salad - CATERING$60.00
his sweet & savory winter salad is a delicious start to any meal. Roasted red and golden beets, sliced pears, toasted walnuts, feta, mixed greens & quinoa.
Wraps / Panini - Platters Menu
- Asst Wrap Platter Medium (6 wraps)$54.00
6 assorted wraps cut in 1\2 (12 pcs) You can choose your wraps. Whole wheat also.available
- Asst Wrap Platter Large (12 wraps)$108.00
12 assorted wraps cut in 1\2 (24 pcs) You can choose your wraps. Whole wheat also.available
- Asst Panini platter - Medium$50.00
5 assorted paninis cut in 1\2 Can also.be cut in 1\3 please specify if.you would like in 3rds
- Asst Panini platter - Large$100.00
10 assorted paninis cut in 1\2 Can also.be cut in 1\3 please specify if.you would like in 3rds
Appetizers - Catering
- Mozzarella Sticks - Catering$2.00
Breaded & Seasoned Mozzarella Fried Golden served w/ Marinara Sauce * Minimum Order Must be 12 pcs * Comes with Marinara Dipping sauce
- Stuffed Baby Bella Mushrooms - CATERING$2.00
Stuffed with Herbs, Garlic & Cheese ** MINIMUM ORDER MUST BE 12 PCS. **
- Lasagna Cheese Frittas - CATERING$3.00
A great twist on lasagna, this delicious cheese filled lasagna roll ups are breaded & pan fried. Served with Alfredo and marinara sauce. ** MINIMUM ORDER MUST BE 12 PCS
- Maryland Crab Cakes - CATERING$3.50
Crispy on the outside & tender in the inside these succulent pan-fried imitation Crab cakes are served with our in house made tartar sauce ** MINIMUM ORDER MUST BE 12 PCS
- BBQ Cauliflower Florets 9x13 Tray$60.00
Breaded cauliflower florets served w/ BBQ Sauce
DESSERT CATERING MENU
- CHURROS - CATERING / PER DOZEN ONLY$12.00
HOMEMADE CHURROS - SOLD ONLY BY DOZEN
- NY STYLE CHEESECAKE - WHOLE CAKE CATERING$60.00
- CHOCOLATE MOUSSE CUPS - CATERING by Dozen Only$48.00
CHOCOLATE MOUSSE CUPS - CATERING by Dozen Only
- LEMON CURD CHEESECAKE CUPS - CATERING - By Dozen Only$60.00
LEMON CURD CHEESECAKE CUPS - CATERING - By Dozen Only
Sunday | 11:00 am - 9:30 pm |
Monday | 11:00 am - 9:30 pm |
Tuesday | 11:00 am - 9:30 pm |
Wednesday | 11:00 am - 9:30 pm |
Thursday | 11:00 am - 9:30 pm |
Friday | Closed |
Saturday | Closed |
The Bay Cafe is a restaurant, that brings our guests the freshest homemade dishes. Our menu is constantly changing with seasons. We offer our guest gourmet homemade pasta, fresh pressed apple cider, desserts are all made in house as well. We look forward to serving you soon.
2 Neptune Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11235