- Home
- /
- Effingham
- /
- Steakhouses
- /
- Niemerg’s Steak House
Niemerg’s Steak House
No reviews yet
1410 W. Fayette Ave
Effingham, IL 62401
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pickup Window Carry-out Specials
Chicken Specials (W)
BBQ Pork Specials (W)
Finger Specials (W)
Eggroll - Catfish - Lenten Specials
Easter Family ToGo Meals
Family Pack Specials
Chicken Only (W)
Side Items (W)
- Pt Mashed Potatoes$2.75
- Pt Wedges$5.00
- Pt Corn$2.75
- Pt Green Beans$2.75
- Pt Cole Slaw$2.75
- Pt Potato Salad$3.00
- Pt Macaroni Salad$2.75
- Pt Broc/Cauliflower Salad$3.75
- Pt Soup$4.25
- Pt Carrots$3.00
- Pt Mac n' Cheese$3.75
- Pt Sausage Gravy$3.00
- Pt Brown Gravy$2.25
- Pt Baked Beans (After 4pm)$2.25
- Pt Noodles (After 4pm)$2.75
- Pt Fresh Fruit$5.00
- Pt Ice Cream$7.50
- Pt Flavored Butter$4.25
- Pt Cottage Cheese$5.25
- Pt Tuna Salad (Friday Only)$9.50
- QT Mashed Potatoes$5.50
- QT Wedges$9.50
- QT Corn$5.50
- QT Green Beans$5.50
- QT Cole Slaw$5.50
- QT Potato Salad$6.00
- QT Macaroni Salad$5.50
- QT Broc/Cauliflower Salad$7.50
- QT Soup$8.00
- QT Carrots$6.00
- QT Mac n' Cheese$7.50
- QT Sausage Gravy$6.00
- QT Brown Gravy$4.50
- Qt Noodles (After 4pm)$5.50
- Qt Fresh Fruit$10.00
- Qt Baked Beans (After 4pm)$4.50
- Qt Ice Cream$15.00
- Qt Hash Casserole$7.00
- 1/2 Gal Mashed Potatoes$10.00
- 1/2 Gal Corn$10.00
- 1/2 Gal Green Beans$10.00
- 1/2 Gal Cole Slaw$10.00
- 1/2 Gal Pot Salad$11.00
- 1/2 Gal Macaroni Salad$10.00
- 1/2 Gal Broccoli/Cauliflower Salad$15.00
- 1/2 Gal Soups$15.50
- 1/2 Gal Carrots$11.00
- 1/2 Gal Mac n Cheese$14.50
- 1/2 Gal Sausage Gravy$11.00
- 1/2 Gal Brown Gravy$8.00
- 1/2 Gal Noodles (4-10pm)$10.00
- 1/2 Gal Fruit$19.00
- Gal Mashed Potatoes$20.00
- Gal Noodles$20.00
- Gal Corn$20.00
- Gal Green Beans$20.00
- Gal Cole Slaw$20.00
- Gal Potato Salad$22.00
- Gal Macaroni Salad$20.00
- Gal Broc/Cauliflower Salad$29.00
- Gal Soup$29.99
- Gal Carrots$22.00
- Gal Mac n' Cheese$29.00
- Gal Sausage Gravy$22.00
- Gal Brown Gravy$16.00
- 1.5 Gallon 7 Layer Salad$39.75
- 1.5 Gallon Twice Potatoes$36.00
- Gal Bake Beans$20.00
- 1 Roll$0.35
- 3 Rolls$0.75
- 6 Rolls$1.75
- Dozen Rolls$3.50
- 1 Biscuit$0.40
- Dozen Biscuits$4.50
- Sandwich Bun(s)$0.45
- Homemade Roll$0.50
- Dozen Homemade Rolls$5.00
- Dining Room Loaf$1.49
Pt Cole Slaw
Meat by the Pound (W)
Pie/Cookies (W)
- Coconut Cream Meringue Pie$11.99
- Apple Pie$12.99
- Cherry Pie$12.99
- Peach Pie$13.49
- Blackberry Pie$14.99
- Blueberry Pie$13.49
- Banana Meringue Pie$12.99
- Lemon Meringue Pie$12.99
- Chocolate Meringue Pie$12.99
- Chocolate Pie with Whip Cream$13.99
- Cherry Cheesecake$11.99
- Custard Pie$12.99
- Rhubarb Crunch Pie$12.99
- Dutch Apple Pie$12.99
- Peanut Butter Pie$14.99
- Pumpkin Pie$12.99Out of stock
- Pecan Pie$13.49
- Strawberry/Rhubarb$14.99
- French Silk Pie$14.99
- 6pc Carrot Cake$9.99
- 6pc Hurricane Cake$9.99
- Sugar Free Cherry Pie (24 hour notice)$12.99
- Sugar Free Blackberry Pie (24 hour notice)$14.99
- Nut Breads$3.29
- New York Cheesecake$35.99
- Dozen Cookies$9.49
- 1/2 Dozen Cookies$4.75
- Individual Cookies$0.90
- Brownies$0.99
- Bag Whip Cream$9.00
- 32pc Carrot Cake$35.00
- 32pc Cobbler (24 hour notice)$35.00
- 32pc Texas Sheet Cake (24 hour notice)$35.00
- Fruit Pizza (24 Hour Notice)$30.00
- Key Lime$14.99
- 32pc Crisp (24 hour notice)$35.00
Pickup Window Lunch/Dinner Menu
Soups & Salads (W)
- Tossed Salad.$3.99
- Caesar Side Salad$3.99
- Taco Salad$8.49
- Grilled Chicken BLT Salad$9.49
- Super Chef Salad$8.79
- Small Chef Salad$8.29
- Crispy Chicken Salad$8.79
- Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad$8.99
- Grilled Chicken Chef Salad$8.79
- Crispy Chicken BLT Salad$9.49
- Fresh Fruit Bowl$5.99
- Fresh Fruit Cup$5.49
- Soup of the Day$4.79
- Vegetable Beef$4.79
Burgers (W)
- Grilled Cheeseburger$10.49
1/2 # Burger served on Grilled Bread
- Patty Melt on Rye$10.79
Hamburger patty topped with grilled onions and melted Swiss cheese served on grilled rye.
- Mushroom Swiss Burger$10.79
1/2 # Burger topped with Mushrooms and Swiss cheese served on Brioche Bun
- Bacon Cheeseburger$10.99
1/2 # Burger topped with Applewood smoked bacon and American cheese
- Firehouse Burger$11.79
Pepper jack cheese, jalapeno bacon and chipotle sauce
- Frisco Melt$10.99
The classic on grilled sourdough with 1000 island.
- Cowboy Burger$11.49
Pepper jack cheese, onion rings, bacon and BBQ sauce
- Hamburger (1/2#)$9.99
- Cheeseburger (1/2#)$10.29
- 1/2# Double Cheeseburger$13.99
- 1/2# Double Hamburger$13.79
- 1/2# Double Bacon Cheeseburger$15.99
Appetizers (W)
- Sampler$10.49
- &Breaded Meat Ravioli$5.49
- &Cream Cheese Poppers$6.49
- &Mozzarella Sticks$4.99
- &Wisconsin Cheese Curds$5.49
- &Onion Rings$5.49
- &Fried Mushroom$4.99
- &Fried Zucchini$4.99
- &Eggroll Appetizer$6.49
- &Sauteed Mushrooms$3.29
- Basket French Fries$7.99
- Basket Waffle Fries$7.99
- 1 Eggroll$3.99
- Basket Breadsticks (5)$4.99
Sandwiches (W)
- Smoky Mountain Chicken Sandwich$9.79
Grilled Chicken Breast, Bacon, Cheese, Barbecue Sauce on Grilled Sourdough
- Grilled Turkey Bacon Club$9.79
Grilled Sourdough with Sliced Turkey Breast, Cheese, Bacon and Tomato
- Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich$8.99
- Crispy Chicken Sandwich$9.49
With Bacon and Swiss
- Tomato Basil Wrap$9.99
Fajita Chicken, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Swiss Cheese & Ranch
- Horseshoe$9.79
Choice of Turkey, Ham, Hamburger or Pulled Pork with French Fries and Cheese Sauce on Toast.
- Ponyshoe$8.79
Choice of Turkey, Ham, Hamburger or Pulled Pork with French Fries and Cheese Sauce on Toast.
- Firehouse Chicken Sandwich$10.49
Breaded or Grilled Chicken Breast with Pepperjack Cheese, Jalepeno Bacon and Chipotle Sauce
- Grilled Pork Tenderloin$8.49
- Niemerg's Philly$10.99
Thinly sliced beef with onion, mushrooms and cheese
- Country Fried Steak Sand$7.79
- Club Sandwich$11.49
Ham, Turkey, Bacon, Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo with Chips
- Pork Fritter$7.49
- BLT$7.99
- Grilled Ham and Cheese$7.79
- Grilled Cheese$6.79
- French Dip$10.99
- Liver Appetizer (4-9pm)$6.49
- Fish Sandwich$6.29
- BBQ Pork Sandwich$5.99
Entrees (W)
- Zesty Orange Chicken$10.99
Glazed with Sweet & Tangy Orange Sauce on a Bed of Rice and Vegetable Medley
- Old Fashioned BBQ Pork$9.49
- Baby Back Ribs$16.99
- Ribs & Chicken$19.99
- Grill Chicken Breast (7oz)$10.99
7oz - Bourbon Glazed or Plain
- America's Cut$10.99
Bacon wrapped boneless pork chop
- Salt Creek Chicken$11.49
7oz grilled chicken breast with sauteed mushrooms, onions and cheeses
- Chicken Tenders$11.49
- Country Fried Steak$10.99
- Chicken Tenderloin Tips$10.99
Seasoned grilled chicken with red and green peppers, mushrooms and onions served with Bourbon Sauce.
- Ground Sirloin Steak$10.79
10oz of fresh ground beef w/ Gr Onion
- Steak n' Stuff$11.99
Ground Sirloin with onion, mushrooms, tomatoes and cheddar cheese
- Pork Chops 16oz$11.29
- Pork Chop 8oz$9.99
- Ham Steak$10.99
- Chicken Livers & Onions$9.99
Served between 4pm-9:45pm only
- Eggrolls & Salad$9.49
Two of our homemade eggrolls paired with a tossed salad
- Hot Beef Manhattan$9.79
- Eggroll Dinner(3)$14.79
Captain's Orders (W)
Steaks (W)
- Ribeye$26.99
Our most popular cut of beef, Iowa Premium Choice- 12oz
- Steak Medallions (3)$18.99
Tender beef medallions wrapped in applewood smoked bacon- 9oz
- Filet Mignon$20.99
Only the finest Heartland Angus Beef cuts will do for our filet wrapped in bacon- 7oz
- 9oz New York Strip$19.99
- 14oz New York Strip$26.99
- Sirloin Tips$15.99
Our own sirloin tips cut fresh daily, served with peppers, onions and mushrooms
- Bourbon Sirloin$22.99
Our 9oz New York Strip marinated overnight
- Prime Rib$30.99
Tender and flavorful Heartland Angus Beef cut. Served with au jus. 10oz
- Steak & Eggrolls$19.99
Tender beef medallions wrapped in applewood smoked bacon and two of our homemade eggrolls
- Steak & Mini Shrimp$19.79
Tender beef medallions wrapped in applewood smoked bacon and mini shrimp
- Steak & Grilled Chicken$19.99
Tender beef medallions wrapped in applewood smoked bacon with plain or bourbon glazed grilled chicken
- Steak & Fried Chicken$19.99
Pasta (W)
Chicken (W)
Pleasing Platters (W)
Drinks (W)
Individual Desserts (W)
- PC Coconut$3.99
- PC Apple$3.99
- PC Banana$3.99
- PC Blackberry$3.99
- PC Blueberry$3.99
- PC Cherry$3.99
- PC Cherry Cheesecake$3.99
- PC Chocolate$3.99
- PC Custard$3.99
- PC French Silk$4.29
- PC Lemon$3.99
- PC Peanut Butter$4.29
- PC Peach$3.99
- PC Pecan$4.29
- PC Pumpkin$3.99Out of stock
- PC Rhubarb$3.99
- PC Dutch Apple$3.99
- PC Str Rhubarb (Strawberry Rhubarb)$4.29
- PC Strawberry$4.29
- PC New York Cheesecake$4.79
- Ice Cream Sundae$3.99
- Brownie Delight$4.79
- PC Carrot Cake$2.99
- Cookies$0.90
- Brownies$0.99
Individual Sides (W)
- French Fries$2.49
- Waffle Fries$2.49
- Baked Potato (after 10am)$2.49
- Loaded Baked Potato (after 10am)$3.49
- Twice Baked Potato (after 4pm)$3.49
- Mashed Potatoes (after 10am)$2.29
- Sweet Potato Tots$2.99
- Hash Brown Casserole (6a-11p)$2.79
- Hash Browns$2.79
- American Fries$2.79
- Corn$1.99
- Green Beans$1.99
- Baked Beans$1.99
- Carrots$2.49
- Macaroni & Cheese$2.79
- Noodles (after 4pm)$2.79
- Rice Pilaf$2.49
- Vegetable Medley$2.99
- Cole Slaw$2.29
- Macaroni Salad$2.29
- Cottage Cheese$2.49
- Potato Salad$2.49
- Jello$1.99
- Chocolate Pudding$2.29
- Tapioca Pudding$2.29
- Apple Sauce$1.99
Weekly Specials - ONLY available 4-9pm
Monday Lunch Specials 10am-3pm (W)
Tuesday Lunch Specials 10am-3pm (W)
Wednesday Lunch Specials 10am-3pm (W)
Thursday Lunch Specials 10am-3pm (W)
Friday Lunch Specials 10am-3pm (W)
CS Lunch - Lenten Specials - Lunch (Copy)
CS Dinner - Lenten Specials - Dinner (Copy)
Pickup Window Breakfast
`Eggs & More / Omelettes (W)
- Omelettes$8.49
Our fresh cracked - made to order omelets
- 1 Egg & Meat$7.79
Choose from ham steak, country fried steak, medallions, ham, sausage, or bacon
- 2 Eggs & Meat$7.99
Choose from ham steak, country fried steak, medallions, ham, sausage, or bacon
- 3 Eggs & Meat$8.49
Choose from ham steak, country fried steak, medallions, ham, sausage, or bacon
`Waffles - Hotcakes & Fr Toast (W)
`Griddles (W)
- Special #1$6.49
One egg, half order of meat, and 3 small pancakes
- Special #2$5.99
2 eggs and 3 small pancakes
- Special #3$5.99
Full order of our homemade biscuits and gravy
- Special #3.5$5.29
Half order of our homemade biscuits and gravy
- Special #4$8.49
2 eggs, half order of meat, and hash browns with gravy
- Special #5 (6am-11am)$10.99
2 eggs- half order of ham, bacon, sausage- and our homemade hash casserole
`Farmers/Heavy Duty (W)
`Breakfast Sandwiches (W)
- Loaded Sandwich$8.79
Ham, Sausage, Bacon, and Cheese scrambled-served on Texas Toast
- Egg n' Muffin$5.29
Ham, egg, and cheese served on an English muffin
- Egg Sandwich$5.29
The classic with 2 eggs- served on your choice of toast
- NO Egg Sandwich$5.29
Our breakfast meat sandwich- served on your choice of toast
`Breakfast Sides (W)
Clothing + Hats
T-Shirts
Sunday | 6:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Monday | 6:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Tuesday | 6:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Wednesday | 6:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Thursday | 6:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Friday | 6:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Saturday | 6:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Come in and enjoy!
1410 W. Fayette Ave, Effingham, IL 62401