- Home
- /
- New Windsor
- /
- Brothers Barbecue

Brothers Barbecue
2402 state route 32
New Windsor, NY 12553
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
2 Meat Combo
Choose two of your favorite smoked meats: pulled Pork, brisket, ribs, smoked chicken, chopped BBQ, or sausage.
$29.00Mac N Cheese
$6.00Boneless Wings
Buttermilk fried boneless chicken chunks tossed in your choice of sauce. Served with celery, carrots, and homemade blue cheese dressing
$16.00
FOOD
Appetizer
Beaufort Shrimp
Gulf shrimp seasoned with our house rub grilled then glazed with BBQ sauce served with our horseradish cream sauce.
$18.00Boneless Wings
Buttermilk fried boneless chicken chunks tossed in your choice of sauce. Served with celery, carrots, and homemade blue cheese dressing
$16.00Brothers Cheese Fries
Hand cut French fries smothered with Monterey Jack and Cheddar cheese, topped with apple wood smoked bacon and served with homemade ranch dressing
$14.00Hungry Helpers
$14.00Nachos
Tortilla chips, topped with our BBQ meat of the day, smothered with Monterey jack and cheddar cheese, topped with smoked Pico de Gallo, and sour cream. Ask your sever for the meat of the day!
$16.00Smoked Wings
Chicken wings hickory smoked until juicy and tender, then deep fried 'til crispy and tossed in your choice of sauce. Served with celery, carrots, and homemade blue cheese dressing
$16.00Sticky Ribs
Our St. Louis ribs smoked low n slow and caramelized in our house BBQ sauce
$18.00Uncle Bo Shrimp
Gulf shrimp seasoned with our house rub grilled then glazed with BBQ sauce served with our horseradish cream sauce.
$19.00Deep Fried Wings
$16.00Fried Mac and Cheese Balls
$15.00Bacon Burnt Ends
$17.00salmon ends
$21.00OUT OF STOCK
Soup/Salad
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese, and homemade cornbread croutons, tossed with our homemade Caesar dressing.
$13.00Dads Iceburg
Just like dad made at home, a hunk of iceberg smothered with blue cheese dressing, chopped tomatoes, and apple wood smoked bacon
$14.00Brothers Greens
Mixed Greens and Romaine topped with diced tomato, onion, Monterey jack and cheddar cheese, served with homemade balsamic vinaigrette
$12.00split pea with ham
$11.00OUT OF STOCKBrunswick stew soup
$12.00OUT OF STOCKbrisket chili
$12.00pre- caesar salad
OUT OF STOCKpre-iceburg wedge
OUT OF STOCKShrimp Bisque
$12.00OUT OF STOCKBrocc Chedder
$10.00OUT OF STOCK
Burger
Classic
8oz blend of porterhouse, chuck, and brisket burger topped with your choice of cheese. Please use special instructions to notify if you would like to add Lettuce Tomatoes Pickles and/or Onions. Served on a brioche bun, with French fries. Add apple wood smoked bacon $2
$16.00Smokehouse
$18.00Big Tex
$19.00Porko Burger
8oz blend of porterhouse, chuck, and brisket burger, topped with cheddar, apple wood smoked bacon, pulled pork, fried onion strings, and our famous BBQ sauce. Served on a brioche bun, with French fries.
$21.00
Sandwich
Bro Ribber
$17.00Chopped BBQ Sandwich
Smoked pork chopped up and dressed with our eastern North Carolina vinegar based sauce, topped with homemade coleslaw and pickles, served on a brioche bun.
$19.00Rooster Sandwich
House marinated chicken breast grilled and glazed with BBQ sauce, served on a brioche bun.
$17.00Fried Chicken Sandwich
Buttermilk marinated chicken breast, fried golden brown, topped with apple wood smoked bacon and cheddar, served on a brioche bun.
$17.00Gunslinger
$20.00Shrimp Po Boy
$19.00Brisket Sandwich
Our tender pepper-crusted hickory smoked brisket sliced and piled high on a brioche bun.
$19.00Pulled Pork Sandwich
Our smoked until tender pork pulled to order, served on a brioche bun.
$17.00BIG BOY Sandwich
Can’t decide? Don’t, get them all. Pulled pork, brisket, sausage, and apple wood smoked bacon, stacked high and topped with our BBQ sauce. Served on a brioche bun.
$20.00Ruban
$17.00OUT OF STOCKPulled BBQ Chicken Sandwich
$17.00OUT OF STOCK
From Our Pit
Smoked Yard Bird
Half chicken brined for 12 hours, then rubbed and smoked until juicy and tender.
$21.00Pulled Pork Plate
Our super tender smoked pork, hand-pulled to order
$22.00Chopped BBQ Plate
A North Carolina staple, what the brothers grew up on. Our fresh smoked pork chopped and dressed with our eastern North Carolina vinegar based sauce.
$22.00Brothers Smoked Brisket
Pepper-crusted and smoked low and slow for over 15 hours, until perfectly tender and juicy. Sliced to order.
$27.00Brothers Legendary Half Rack Ribs
Your choice of Baby Back or St. Louis ribs seasoned with our house dry rub smoked and slow for over 5 hours until they’re juicy, tender and almost fall of the bone.
$26.00Brothers Legendary Full Rack Ribs
Your choice of Baby Back or St. Louis ribs seasoned with our house dry rub smoked and slow for over 5 hours until they’re juicy, tender and almost fall of the bone.
$39.00Texan Smoked Sausage
Straight from the South Side Market in Elgin Texas these sausages are specially handcrafted for us. A duo of Texas style beef sausage and Jalapeno Cheddar Sausage smoked then kissed on the grill.
$21.002 Meat Combo
Choose two of your favorite smoked meats: pulled Pork, brisket, ribs, smoked chicken, chopped BBQ, or sausage.
$29.003 Meat Combo
Choose three of your favorite smoked meats: pulled pork, brisket, ribs, smoked chicken, chopped BBQ, or sausage.
$34.00Uncle Dave
A sampler of our most popular smoked meats: ribs, pulled pork, brisket, smoked chicken, and sausage.
$40.00Pulled Pint
$22.00Chopped BBQ Pint
$22.00Pound of Brisket
$30.00Whole Smoked Chicken
$28.00pre-2 meat combo
$55.00OUT OF STOCKpre-Prime Rib
$70.00OUT OF STOCKpre-Beef rib
$70.00OUT OF STOCK
Southern
Aunt Edna's Fried Chicken
Just like our Great Aunt Edna used to make for us, its crispy, juicy, and fried to order, a brothers favorite served with your choice of two sides
$21.00Aunt Caroline's Fried Shrimp
Gulf shrimp dredged in seasoned flour, fried to perfection, and served with your two sides
$23.00Mama's Shrimp Grits
Gulf shrimp sautéed with bacon, peppers, and onions, served over our cheesy grits. Just like when we were kids
$24.00Smoken Rooster Entree
Our house marinated chicken breasts grilled and glazed with BBQ sauce. Served with your choice of two sides.
$21.00pre-fried chicken
$55.00OUT OF STOCKpre-rooster plate
$55.00OUT OF STOCKpre-fried shrimp
$55.00OUT OF STOCK
Family Meals
EAT LIKE A KING
Serves 2-4 A full rack of ribs, half a chicken, half a pound of brisket, & half a pound of pulled pork, served with your choice of two large sides
$85.00Eat Like the Brothers
Served 4-6 people or 3 brothers 2 Full racks of ribs, 1 pound of brisket, 1 whole chicken, and 1 pound of pulled pork or chopped BBQ, Served with pickles, coleslaw, and your choice of three large sides
$158.00Yard Bird
$57.00OUT OF STOCKFish Fry
$24.00Bro Seafood Platter
$28.00Salmon Burnt Ends
$21.00OUT OF STOCKCorned Beef and Cabbage
$27.00OUT OF STOCK
Sides
Desserts
Kids Menu
Happy Hour (Copy)
LUNCH (3PD)
Lunch (Copy)
Soup & Salad
$13.00OUT OF STOCKBrisket Chopped Cheese
$15.00Tex- Mex Quesadilla
$14.00Brothers Mac Bowl
$16.00Chili Cheese Dogs
$14.00Wings & Fries
$14.00Smoked Chicken Salad Wrap
$15.00Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
$15.00Buffalo Chicken Blue Cheese Wrap
$15.00BBQ Sliders
$16.00Po Boy Sliders
$16.00Lunch Pecan Pie
$8.00OUT OF STOCKFrench Toast Bread Pudding
$8.00OUT OF STOCKBrownie Sundae
$8.00OUT OF STOCK
Sunday | 11:15 am - 7:45 pm |
Monday | Closed |
Tuesday | 11:15 am - 8:45 pm |
Wednesday | 11:15 am - 8:45 pm |
Thursday | 11:15 am - 8:45 pm |
Friday | 11:15 am - 9:15 pm |
Saturday | 11:15 am - 9:45 pm |
Brothers Barbecue is about authenticity. The smells of smoke that hit your nose once you open the doors will let you know you have arrived in the right place. We specialize in freshly smoked meats daily such as pulled pork, ribs, brisket, chicken & sausage. Come in and enjoy!