American Hotel
No reviews yet
128 West Main Street
Angelica, NY 14709
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
DINING ROOM
Appetizers
- Buffalo Chicken Wings$11.99
A full dozen wings come in several different options: Hot, Medium, Mild, Hot Garlic, Medium Garlic, Mild Garlic, Garlic Parmesan, Mississippi Honey BBQ, Tangy Golden BBQ, Spicy Chipolte Citrus BBQ, Sweet Teriyaki, Bourban Molasses, Mango Habanero, Asian Ginger, Sweet and Spicy Chili, or Country Sweet's Mild. Served with celery and carrot sticks, and our Famous Bleu Cheese
- French Onion Soup$6.99
Topped with croutons, melted Swiss, mozzarella, and baked golden brown
- Italian Sampler Platter$15.99
A rich and creamy, three-cheese crab dip is baked and served with toasted pita wedges
- Shrimp Cocktail$12.99
Five Jumbo (and I mean JUMBO) Shrimp are served with our zippy cocktail sauce and a fresh lemon wedge
- Unlimited Soup and Salad Bar$10.99
Enjoy Unlimited visits to our famous soup and salad bar……. -always homemade! Includes both cream soup and broth soup as well as salads, and fresh baked breads
Seafood
- Alaskan Haddock$23.99
Haddock filet topped with surimi crabmeat and creamy garlic sauce is baked to perfection
- Shrimp OR Scallops$21.99
Choose either scallops or jumbo shrimp; beer battered, breaded or broiled
- Fish Fry (full)$17.99
Whether you choose our famous beer-battered fish fry, our lightly hand-breaded fish fry, or our broiled haddock with your choice of plain, lemon pepper, or cajun seasoning, we're sure you'll keep coming back for more! Each of our fish dinners includes the all-you-can-eat soup and salad bar as well as your choice of potato, pasta, or vegetable.
- Fish Fry (half)$15.99
Whether you choose our famous beer-battered fish fry, our lightly hand-breaded fish fry, or our broiled haddock with your choice of plain, lemon pepper, or cajun seasoning, we're sure you'll keep coming back for more! Each of our fish dinners includes the all-you-can-eat soup and salad bar as well as your choice of potato, pasta, or vegetable.
- Giant Lobster Tail$79.99
- Haddock Florentine$19.99
Haddock filet topped with spinach, mushrooms, and swiss; baked to perfection
- Haddock Maurice$19.99
Haddock with slices of fresh tomatoes, onions, and shredded cheddar is baked in white wine.
- Salmon Steak$25.99
- Seafood Alfredo$21.99
Homemade alfredo sauce is teaming with shrimp, scallops and crab meat. Served over a bed of tender fettucini and garlic toast
- Seafood Platter$23.99
Choose either a breaded OR broiled platter! Served with a full piece of haddock, jumbo shrimp and sea scallops
- Walleye Fish Fry (Full)$20.99
An 8-10oz Walleye filet with you option of beer batter, breading, plain broiled, lemon pepper, or cajun. (No splitting)
Italian
- All-You-Can-Eat Spaghetti Dinner$18.99
Choose from our selection of homemade sauces which include a traditional red sauce, minced garlic butter, or our famous creamy alfredo sauce! Add veggies and Dill - $2.99 Add jumbo meatballs - $4.99
- Cheese Ravioli$16.99
Ricotta cheese filled ravioli are topped with your choice of garlic butter or red sauce and come with a slice of garlic toast
- Traditional Lasagna$21.99
Layers of rich cheeses, ground beef, and sausage are combined with tender pasta and topped with our homemade red sauce
Beef
- Delmonico Steak 12oz$29.99
Delmonico Steak 12oz
- Delmonico Steak 16oz$32.99
Delmonico Steak 16oz
- Dinner for Two$100.00
- French Rib$32.99
12oz grilled Prime Rib is smothered with French onions, au jus, and mozzarella cheese
- Ham Dinner$19.99
- Land & Sea$49.99
- Liver & Onions$17.99
- NY Strip Steak$27.99
12oz NY Strip Steak
- Prime Rib King (16oz)$32.99
Our Prime Rib is slow-roasted and hand-cut. Served with Au Jus.
- Prime Rib Petite (8oz)$25.99
Our Prime Rib is slow-roasted and hand-cut. Served with Au Jus.
- Prime Rib Queen (12oz)$29.99
Our Prime Rib is slow-roasted and hand-cut. Served with Au Jus.
- Surf & Turf NYE$69.99
- Surf & Turf$34.99
12oz Strip or Delmonico with your choice of scallops OR jumbo shrimp. Choose beer battered, breaded, broiled, or cajun style
Chicken
- Chicken Alfredo$19.99
Grilled chicken breast and fettucini noodles are tossed with our rich, homemade, creamy alfredo sauce and is served with garlic toast
- Chicken Parmesan$19.99
Breaded chicken topped with mozzarella and homemade red sauce served with a side of fettucini and garlic toast
- Smothered Chicken$19.99
Grilled chicken topped with slices of smoked ham and swiss cheese is finished with our creamy dijon sauce
- Shawmut Chicken$19.99
A chicken breast is double-dipped in our very own ranch seasoned breading and fried to a crisp golden brown
- Shawmut Alfredo$21.99
- Turkey Dinner$19.99
Sandwiches
- Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe$14.99
- Beef on Weck$14.99
Tender, shaved roast beef is stacked on our freshly made, seasoned roll and completed with a cup of horseradish
- Cheeseburger Deluxe$12.99
Char-grilled black angus burger is topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo, and onion. Served on a fresh kaiser roll
- Chicken Bacon Rancher$14.99
Ranch seasoned, crispy chicken with bacon, cheddar, lettuce, and tomato is drizzled with ranch dressing and served on a kaiser roll
- Chicken Cordon Bleu$14.99
- Grilled Reuben$13.99
Corned beef is combined with sauerkraut and swiss cheese and served on grilled sourdough bread with 1000 island dressing
- Mushroom Swiss Burger$13.99
- Rodeo Burger$13.99
- Add Salad Bar$5.99
Kids
- Kids Cheeseburger$8.99
Black angus burger with American cheese. Burger comes with one side
- Kids Chicken Fingers$6.99
(2) Crispy, fried chicken strips are served with your choice of side
- Kids Hot Dog Octopus$6.99
Wow, what a treat! A hot dog in the shape of an octopus with your choice of side
- Kids Mac and Cheese$6.99
What kid can resist mac and cheese when it comes with ther choice of side
- Kids Soup and Salad Bar$5.99
- Add Kids Salad Bar$3.99
SPECIALS
BUFFETS
Holiday Dinner Buffet
Thursday Dinner Buffet
BAR FOOD
From the Fryer
- # Add Salad Bar$5.99
- 12 Boneless Wings$11.99
- 12 Wings$11.99
- 12 Wings BREADED$18.99
- 6 Boneless Wings$5.99
- 6 Wings$5.99
- 6 Wings BREADED$9.99
- Basket Chips$6.99
- Basket Fries$6.99
- Basket Sweet Potato Fries$7.99
- Cauliflower Nuggets$5.99
- Chicken Tender Sandwich$7.99
Lettuce, tomato, mayo, onion, cheese OR wing sauce, lettuce, mozz., bleu/ranch
- Chicken Tenders$9.59
- Chips$4.59
- Corn Nuggets$5.99
- Curly Fries$5.59
- Dill Pickle Chips$6.99
- Fish Fry$14.99
- Fish Fry - Half$12.99
- Fish Sandwich$12.99
- French Fries$4.59
- Fries and Gravy$5.59
- Large Hodge Podge$14.99
(Mushrooms, Cauliflower, and Corn Nuggets)
- Loaded Fries$6.99
Cheddar, Salsa, side of sour cream
- Loaded Sweet Potato Fries$8.99
- Mozzarella Sticks (5)$6.79
- Mushrooms$5.99
- Onion Rings$4.99
- Pizza Logs (4)$6.79
- Poutine Boat$8.99
- Spicy Cheese Curd$6.99
- Sweet Potato Fries$5.59
From the Grill
- # Add Salad Bar$5.99
- B.L.T. on Sourdough$11.99
- Bacon Cheeseburger$13.99
1/3LB Black Angus
- Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe$14.99
Lettuce, tomato, mayo, onion
- Beef on Weck (BAR)$12.99
- Cheeseburger$9.59
1/3LB Black Angus
- Cheeseburger Deluxe (BAR)$10.59
Lettuce, tomato, mayo, onion
- Deluxe Grilled Cheese$9.99
American, Cheddar, Mozzarella Sticks
- Grilled Cheese$6.99
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich$10.99
Lettuce, tomato, mayo, onion
- Grilled Ham & Cheese Spicy$12.99
- Grilled Ham and Cheese$11.99
- Hamburger$8.99
1/3LB Black Angus
- Hamburger Deluxe$9.99
Lettuce, tomato, mayo, onion
- Mushroom Cheeseburger$11.99
1/3LB Black Angus
- Mushroom Cheeseburger Deluxe$12.99
Lettuce, tomato, mayo, onion
- Prime Burger$14.99
- Prime Cheeseburger$15.59
- Reuben on Sourdough$12.99
Salads + Wraps + Etc
- # Add Salad Bar$5.99
- #1 Bleu Chesse$5.99
- Chicken Tender Salad$13.99
- Chicken Tender Wrap$12.99
Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo
- Coleslaw$2.99
- Cottage Cheese$3.99
- Greek Chicken Salad$13.99
- Grilled Chicken Salad$13.99
- Grilled Chicken Wrap$12.99
Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo
- Homemade Bowl o' Soup$4.99
- Homemade Cup o' Soup$3.99
- Large Tossed Salad$10.99
- Mac Salad$2.99
- Montreal Steak Wrap$14.99
Peppers, Onions, Bacon, Cheddar
- Pepperoni Pizza$15.99
- Philly Steak Wrap$13.99
Peppers, Onions, Mozzarella
- Prime Rib Wrap$15.99
- Sante Fe Chicken Wrap$13.99
Peppers, Onions, Cheddar, Salsa
- Small Side Salad$4.99
- Soup Bowl$4.99
- Soup Cup$3.99
- Taco$2.75
Bar Snacks
ALCOHOL + DRINKS
Draft Beer
Liquor
- *Well Vodka$4.00
- Absolut$6.00
- Absolut Flavors$6.00
- Deep Eddie$5.00
- Ellicottville Lavender$5.00
- Grey Goose$7.50
- Pinnacle Flavors$5.00
- Smirnoff Flavors$5.00
- Titos$5.00
- UV Vodka$4.50
- *Well Rum$4.00
- Bacardi$5.00
- Bacardi Flavors$5.00
- Blue Chair Banana$5.00
- Blue Chair Vanilla$5.00
- Captain Cherry$4.50
- Captain Morgan$5.00
- Malibu$6.00
- Malibu Strawberry$6.00
- *Well Gin$4.00
- Beefeaters$5.00
- Empress$5.00
- Hendricks$6.00
- Nolets$6.00
- Sloe$3.75
- Tanqueray$5.50
- Tangueray Sevilla$5.50
- *Well Bourbon$4.00
- *Well Whiskey$4.00
- Ballot in Turtle$5.00
- Black Velvet$5.00
- Buffalo Trace$7.00
- Bulliet$7.00
- Bushmills$5.00
- Canadian Club$6.00
- Clover Bourbon$7.00
- Crown Apple$6.00
- Crown Blackberry$7.00
- Crown Carmel$6.00
- Crown Peach$6.00
- Crown Royal$6.00
- Crown Vanilla$6.00
- Dirty Monkey$5.00
- Eagle Rare$7.00
- Elijah Craig$9.00
- Four Roses$6.00
- Jack Daniels$6.00
- Jack Fire$6.00
- Jack Honey$6.00
- Jameson Irish$6.00
- Jameson Orange$6.00
- Jim Beam$5.00
- Jim Beam Flavors$5.00
- Makers Mark$7.00
- Milam & Greene$7.00
- Old Camp Peach$5.00
- Proper 12$6.00
- Proper 12 Apple$6.00
- Screwball$5.00
- Seagrams 7$5.00
- Southern Comfort$5.00
- Southern Tier Flavors$6.00
- Travelers$6.00
- Tullamore Dew$6.00
- Wild Turkey$5.00
- Wild Turkey Honey$5.00
- Wiseman$7.50
- Woodford Reserve$7.00
- Yukon Jack$5.00
- *Well Scotch$4.00
- Brandy E & J$5.00
- Brandy Flavors$4.00
- Courvoisier$6.00
- Dewars White$6.00
- Johnnie Black$8.00
- Hennessey Black$9.00
- *Well Tequila$4.00
- Jose Cuervo Gold$5.00
- Espalone$5.00
- Patron$6.00
- Espalone silver$5.00
- Absenthe$7.00
- Aftershock$4.50
- Amaretto$4.00
- Bailey's$6.00
- Baja Rosa/Luna$5.00
- Black Haus$5.00
- Blue Chair Banana$5.50
- Blue Curaco$3.75
- Creme De Cocoa$4.00
- Creme De Menthe$4.00
- DeSoronno Velvet$6.00
- DeSorrono$6.00
- Drambuie$6.00
- Ellicottville Bourbon Cream$6.00
- Fireball$5.00
- Fultons Pumpkin Pie$4.00
- Goldschlauger$5.00
- Grand Marnier$6.00
- Ice 101$5.00
- Jagermeister$5.00
- Kahula$6.00
- Kapali$4.00
- Limoncello$5.00
- Liquor 43$5.00
- Midori$5.00
- RumChatta$5.00
- Rumplemintz$5.00
- Sambucca$5.00
- Schnapps$4.00
- Shanky's Whip$5.00
- Tequila Rose$5.00
- Tia Maria$5.00
- Triple Sec$4.00
Cocktails
- Alabama Slammer$7.00
- B.F.F.$8.00
- Bay Breeze$5.00
Bay Breeze
- Black Russian$8.00
Black Russian
- Bloody Mary$7.00
Bloody Mary
- Bloody Mary Bar$8.00
- Blue Hawaiian$5.00
Blue Hawaiian
- Brandy Alexander$8.00
Brandy Alexander
- Cherry Bomb$6.00
Cherry Bomb
- Cherry-rita$6.00
Pink Squirrel
- Cho. PB Pretzel$5.50
- Cosmopolitan$7.00
Cosmopolitan
- Daquiri$7.00
Daquiri
- Elvis$5.00
- Flaming Dr. Pepper$5.00
Flaming Dr. Pepper
- Flight - Bailey's$10.00
- Flight - Whiskey$10.00
- Frozen Daquiri$7.00
Frozen Daquiri
- Frozen Margarita$7.00
Frozen Margarita
- Fuzzy Navel$4.00
Fuzzy Navel
- Gimlet$7.00
Gimlet
- Grasshopper$6.00
Grasshopper
- Green Tea$6.00
- Jagerbomb$6.00
Jagerbomb
- Kamikaze$5.00
Kamikaze
- Long Island Iced Tea$8.00
Long Island Iced Tea
- Manhattan$8.00
Manhattan
- Margarita$7.00
Margarita
- Martini$8.00
Martini
- Mini Beer$6.00
- Old Fashioned$7.00
Old Fashioned
- Pickle Shot$5.00
- Pina Colada$7.00
Pina Colada
- Purple Mother Fucker$10.00
- Red Headed Slut$5.00
Red Headed Slut
- Rob Roy$6.00
Rob Roy
- Screwdriver$4.00
Screwdriver
- Seabreeze$5.00
Seabreeze
- Sex on the Beach$5.00
Sex on the Beach
- Slippery Nipple$5.00
Slippery Nipple
- Sloe Gin Fizz$4.00
Sloe Gin Fizz
- Sours$7.00
Sours
- Tequila Sunrise$5.00
Tequila Sunrise
- Tom Collins$7.00
Tom Collins
- Virgin Daquiri$5.00
Virgin Daquiri
- Washington Apple$6.00
Washington Apple
- White Russian (Kahlua)$8.00
White Russian (Kahlua)
- White Russian (Kapali)$7.00
White Russian (Kapali)
- Wine Spritzer$5.00
Wine Spritzer
Wine
Beverages
- Chocolate Milk$2.99
- Coffee$2.99
- Cranberry Juice$2.79
- Diet Pepsi$2.99
- Gingerale$2.99
- Grapefruit Juice$2.79
- Hot Cocoa$2.79
- Hot Tea$1.99
- Lemonade$2.99
- Mountain Dew$2.99
- Mug Rootbeer$2.99
- Orange Juice$2.79
- Pepsi$2.99
- Pineapple Juice$2.79
- Raspberry Tea$2.99
- Red Bull$2.00
- Sierra Mist$2.99
- Tomato Juice$2.79
- Unsweetened Tea$2.99
- White Milk$2.59
Bottled Beer + Cans
- 1911 Cider$5.00
- 4Mile IPA$5.00
4Mile IPA
- 4Mile Polynomial$5.00
- Arizona Hard Tea$5.00
- Asylum Porter$6.00
- Beast Seltzer$5.00
- Beatbox$6.00
- Bud Light$4.00
Bud Light
- Bud Light 55$4.50
Bud Light 55
- Bud Light Bucket$20.00
- Bud Light Lime$4.50
Bud Light Lime
- Bud Light Seltzer$5.00
- Bud Zero N/A$4.00
- Budweiser$4.00
Bud
- Busch$3.75
Busch
- Busch Light$3.75
Busch Light
- Coors Light$4.00
Coors
- Corona$5.00
Corona
- Crown Royal Cocktail$5.00
- Ellicottville Sour$7.00
- Genny$3.75
Genny
- Genny Cream Ale$3.75
Genny Cream Ale
- Genny Kolsch$4.00
- Genny Light$3.75
Genny Light
- Genny Spring Bock$4.00
Genny Light
- Guinness Extra Stout$6.00
- Guinness Tallboy$7.00
- Hayburner IPA$5.00
Hayburner IPA
- Hayburner Stout$5.00
- Heineken N/A$5.00
- Heinekin$5.00
Heinekin
- High Noon$5.00
- Labatt Blue$4.00
Labatt Blue
- Labatt Blue Light$4.00
Labatt Blue Light
- Labatt Blue N/A$4.00
Labatt Blue N/A
- Leinenkugel Summer Shandy$5.00
- Michelob Ultra$4.50
Michelob Ultra
- Miller High Life$4.00
Miller High Life
- Miller Lite$4.00
Miller Lite
- Modelo$5.00
- Molson Canadian$4.00
Molson Canadian
- O'Douls$4.00
O'Douls
- PBR$4.00
- Sam Adams$5.00
Sam Adams
- Sam Cherry$5.00
Sam Cherry
- Sam Seasonal$5.00
Sam Seasonal
- Smirnoff$5.00
Smirnoff's
- Southern Tier IPA$5.00
Southern Tier 2Xs
- Stella Artois$6.00
- Sullivan's$5.00
- Truly$5.00
Truly
- Twisted Tea$5.00
Twisted Tea
- White Claw$5.00
White Claw
- Yuengling$4.00
Yuengling
- Yuengling Light$4.50
Sunday | 11:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Monday | Closed |
Tuesday | 11:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Wednesday | 11:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Thursday | 11:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Friday | 11:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Saturday | 11:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Come in and enjoy!
128 West Main Street, Angelica, NY 14709
Photos coming soon!