- Home
- /
- Idaho Falls
- /
- Lucy's NY Pizza - Broadway
Lucy's NY Pizza - Broadway
No reviews yet
560 W Broadway St.
Idaho Falls, ID 83402
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Starters & Salads
Appetizers
- Breadsticks$5.00
Our breadsticks are baked with garlic butter and seasonings. They are served with our house made marinara.
- Cheesesticks$6.00
Enhance our breadsticks with mozzarella…enough said!
- Firesticks$8.00
This delicious appetizer is a hybrid of hot and mild flavor. They are basted with buffalo sauce and then topped with cheese and jalapenos. Yum!
- Fried Mutz$5.00
Our delicious whole milk cheese hand breaded and fried, served with marinara!
- Wings (10)$12.00
Ten tasty chicken wings doused with your choice of sauce. Choose from our signature buffalo, sweet chili, honey garlic, or BBQ sauce. Served with ranch or blue cheese.
- Boneless Wings (10)$12.00
Real chicken chunks breaded and fried! Pick a sauce and enjoy!
- Meatball$7.00
Our 10-ounce zesty meatball smothers with our house made marinara.
Boneless Wings (10)
Real chicken chunks breaded and fried! Pick a sauce and enjoy!
Salads
- Half Caprese Salad$4.50
Not a traditional salad by any means, including flavor. (3)Slices of fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and basil. Lightly seasoned with salt, pepper and olive oil.
- Full Caprese Salad$8.00
Not a traditional salad by any means, including flavor. (6)Slices of fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and basil. Lightly seasoned with salt, pepper and olive oil.
- House Salad$4.00
A small green salad with cheese, olives, pepperoni, tomatoes and pepperoncini.
- Antipasto Salad$9.00
Green salad topped with cheese, tomatoes, olives and a variety of peppers, topped with pepperoni, salami, and ham.
- Family Salad$14.00
This king size version of our house salad comes with cheese, olives, pepperoni, tomatoes and pepperoncini. Perfect if your group has an appetite for leafy greens!
- T.O. Pickles And Olives$2.50
Beverages
2LT Soda
Water Bottle
Alcohol
Bottled Beer
Pizzas
12" Pizza
- 12" Build Your Own$12.00
Build your own pizza starting with cheese and red sauce. Add any toppings or change the sauce to make a masterpiece.
- 12" Half&Half Specialty$12.00
Try one of our award-winning combinations! Can't decide? Pick two of your favorites starting at $11!
- 12" Meaty$19.50
The meaty comes topped with pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball, and bacon. Bulk up with this one!
- 12" Supreme$17.50
Our Supreme comes topped with pepperoni, peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms.
- 12" Margherita$14.50
This refreshing pie comes with fresh tomatoes and basil. A royal mix!
- 12" Zestpian$20.00
This fan favorite boasts our smokey ranch sauce with pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple and jalapenos.
- 12" CCB$15.00
Our creamy white sauce, fresh baked chicken topping and bacon is a divine combination.
- 12" Pacific$14.50
Ham and pineapple. Like the traditional Hawaiian pizza, but way better!
- 12" Veggie$17.00
This pie is a vegetarian’s dream topped with artichoke, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.
- 12" BBQ$13.50
Pizza with tangy BBQ sauce and house made chicken breast topping.
- 12" Buffalo$13.50
Our fresh dough with warm buffalo sauce and house made chicken breast topping.
- 12" Blaise$16.00
Honey stinging ranch sauce topped with chicken, bacon, and mushrooms.
- 12" Zim$17.50
A pie that will make anyone stand at attention, topped with pepperoni, ham, sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes.
- 12" BLT$17.00
This pie boasts our creamy ranch sauce topped with bacon, fresh tomatoes, and crisp lettuce drizzled with balsamic glaze.
- 12" Pizzle$13.50
Try this dillicious pickle pizza! Creamy sauce with pickles, garlic, and dill weed over the top!
15" Pizza
- 15" Build Your Own$15.50
Build your own pizza starting with cheese and red sauce. Add any toppings or change the sauce to make a masterpiece.
- 15" Half&Half Specialty$15.50
Try one of our award-winning combinations! Can't decide? Pick two of your favorites starting at $13!
- 15" Meaty$25.50
The meaty comes topped with pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball, and bacon. Bulk up with this one!
- 15" Supreme$23.50
Our Supreme comes topped with pepperoni, peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms.
- 15" Margherita$19.00
This refreshing pie comes with fresh tomatoes and basil. A royal mix!
- 15" Zestpian$26.50
This fan favorite boasts our smokey ranch sauce with pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple and jalapenos.
- 15" CCB$19.50
Our creamy white sauce, fresh baked chicken topping and bacon is a divine combination.
- 15" Pacific$19.00
Ham and pineapple. Like the traditional Hawaiian pizza, but way better!
- 15" Veggie$23.00
This pie is a vegetarian’s dream topped with artichoke, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.
- 15" BBQ$18.00
Pizza with tangy BBQ sauce and house made chicken breast topping.
- 15" Buffalo$18.00
Our fresh dough with warm buffalo sauce and house made chicken breast topping.
- 15" Blaise$21.00
Honey stinging ranch sauce topped with chicken, bacon, and mushrooms.
- 15" Zim$23.00
A pie that will make anyone stand at attention, topped with pepperoni, ham, sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes.
- 15" BLT$22.50
This pie boasts our creamy ranch sauce topped with bacon, fresh tomatoes, and crisp lettuce drizzled with balsamic glaze.
- 15" Pizzle$18.00
Try this dillicious pickle pizza! Creamy sauce with pickles, garlic, and dill weed over the top!
18" Pizza
- 18" Build Your Own$19.00
Build your own pizza starting with cheese and red sauce. Add any toppings or change the sauce to make a masterpiece.
- 18" Half&Half Specialty$19.00
Try one of our award-winning combinations! Can't decide? Pick two of your favorites starting at $16.50!
- 18" Meaty$31.50
The meaty comes topped with pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball, and bacon. Bulk up with this one!
- 18" Supreme$29.50
Our Supreme comes topped with pepperoni, peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms.
- 18" Margherita$23.50
This refreshing pie comes with fresh tomatoes and basil. A royal mix!
- 18" Zestpian$33.00
This fan favorite boasts our smokey ranch sauce with pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple and jalapenos.
- 18" CCB$24.00
Our creamy white sauce, fresh baked chicken topping and bacon is a divine combination.
- 18" Pacific$23.50
Ham and pineapple. Like the traditional Hawaiian pizza, but way better!
- 18" Veggie$29.00
This pie is a vegetarian’s dream topped with artichoke, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.
- 18" BBQ$21.50
Pizza with tangy BBQ sauce and house made chicken breast topping.
- 18" Buffalo$21.50
Our fresh dough with warm buffalo sauce and house made chicken breast topping.
- 18" Blaise$26.00
Honey stinging ranch sauce topped with chicken, bacon, and mushrooms.
- 18" Zim$29.00
A pie that will make anyone stand at attention, topped with pepperoni, ham, sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes.
- 18" BLT$28.00
This pie boasts our creamy ranch sauce topped with bacon, fresh tomatoes, and crisp lettuce drizzled with balsamic glaze.
- 18" Pizzle$21.50
Try this dillicious pickle pizza! Creamy sauce with pickles, garlic, and dill weed over the top!
Gluten Free Pizza
- GF Build Your Own$12.00
Build your own pizza starting with cheese and red sauce. Add any toppings or change the sauce to make a masterpiece.
- GF Half&Half Specialty$12.00
Try one of our award-winning combinations! Can't decide? Pick two of your favorites starting at $11!
- GF Meaty$16.00
The meaty comes topped with pepperoni, ham, sausage, and bacon. Bulk up with this one!
- GF Supreme$16.00
Our Supreme comes topped with pepperoni, peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms.
- GF Margherita$15.00
This refreshing pie comes with fresh tomatoes and basil. A royal mix!
- GF Zestpian$17.00
This fan favorite boasts our smokey ranch sauce with pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple and jalapenos.
- GF CCB$14.50
Our creamy white sauce, fresh baked chicken topping and bacon is a divine combination.
- GF Pacific$14.00
Ham and pineapple. Like the traditional Hawaiian pizza, but way better!
- GF Veggie$16.00
This pie is a vegetarian’s dream topped with artichoke, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.
- GF BBQ$13.50
Pizza with tangy BBQ sauce and house made chicken breast topping.
- GF Buffalo$13.50
Our fresh dough with warm buffalo sauce and house made chicken breast topping.
- GF Blaise$15.00
Honey stinging ranch sauce topped with chicken, bacon, and mushrooms.
- GF Zim$15.00
A pie that will make anyone stand at attention, topped with pepperoni, ham, sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes.
- GF BLT$15.00
This pie boasts our creamy ranch sauce topped with bacon, fresh tomatoes, and crisp lettuce drizzled with balsamic glaze.
- GF Pizzle$13.50
Try this dillicious pickle pizza! Creamy sauce with pickles, garlic, and dill weed over the top!
Take&Bake Pizza
- Take&Bake BYO$9.00
Build your own pizza starting with cheese and red sauce. Add any toppings or change the sauce to make a masterpiece.
- Take&Bake Half&Half Specialty$9.00
Try one of our award-winning combinations! Can't decide? Pick two of your favorites starting at $9!
- Take&Bake Meaty$16.50
The meaty comes topped with pepperoni, ham, sausage, meatball, and bacon. Bulk up with this one!
- Take&Bake Supreme$16.50
Our Supreme comes topped with pepperoni, peppers, onions, black olives and mushrooms.
- Take&Bake Margherita$12.00
This refreshing pie comes with fresh tomatoes and basil. A royal mix!
- Take&Bake Zestpian$18.00
This fan favorite boasts our smokey ranch sauce with pepperoni, ham, chicken, bacon, pineapple and jalapenos.
- Take&Bake CCB$12.00
Our creamy white sauce, fresh baked chicken topping and bacon is a divine combination.
- Take&Bake Pacific$12.00
Ham and pineapple. Like the traditional Hawaiian pizza, but way better!
- Take&Bake Veggie$16.50
This pie is a vegetarian’s dream topped with artichoke, peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms.
- Take&Bake BBQ$10.50
Pizza with tangy BBQ sauce and house made chicken breast topping.
- Take&Bake Buffalo$10.50
Our fresh dough with warm buffalo sauce and house made chicken breast topping.
- Take&Bake Blaise$13.50
Honey stinging ranch sauce topped with chicken, bacon, and mushrooms.
- Take&Bake Zim$15.00
A pie that will make anyone stand at attention, topped with pepperoni, ham, sauerkraut, and fresh tomatoes.
- Take&Bake BLT$15.00Out of stock
This pie boasts our creamy ranch sauce topped with bacon, fresh tomatoes, and crisp lettuce drizzled with balsamic glaze.
- Take&Bake Pizzle$11.00
Subs
- Meatball Sub$10.00
An instant favorite! Our 10-ounce meatball sliced and coated with marinara and melted cheese.
- Chicken Parmesan Sub$9.50
A hand breaded chicken breast smothered in our house made marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese.
- Pepperoni Melt Sub$7.50
Our classic pepperoni and marinara covered in melted whole milk mozzarella.
- CCBLT Sub$9.50
A browned bun with our fresh made chicken breast topping, bacon, romaine, tomatoes and ranch.
Xtras
- Xtra Lime/ Lemon$0.25
- 3 for $1 Ranch$1.00
- 2oz Dressing$0.50
Just needing a little more sauce, pick your palates desire.
- 2oz Marinara$0.50
Made fresh daily marinara sauce.
- Pint of Dressing$6.00
Need more sauce?! Here's a pint you can have for now or later!
- Pint of Marinara$6.00
Our made fresh daily marinara sauce. Take a pint home and enjoy it in any home made dish.
- 12" Dough Ball$2.00
Take home one of our fresh made 12" dough balls to create a pie in your own kitchen.
- 15" Dough Ball$2.00
Take home one of our fresh made 15" dough balls to create a pie in your own kitchen.
- 18" Dough Ball$2.00
Take home one of our fresh made 18" dough balls to create a pie in your own kitchen.
- Gluten Free Crust$4.00
A delicious personal size gluten free crust.
- Pizza Packet$9.00
Everything you need to make a 15” pizza right in your home. Dough, sauce, cheese, topping, and a cooking sheet! Your choice of cheese, pepperoni, or ham!
- Dining Bond$40.00
Sunday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Monday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Tuesday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Wednesday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Thursday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Friday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Saturday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
THE BEST DOUGH & SAUCE IN THE BUSINESS! Give your family the quality time they need and the down time you want. Have a sit down, family style meal at Lucy’s. Here at Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria, our dough is prepped fresh daily. Always hand-made, hand-tossed from the best ingredients, you can taste the authenticity of New York.
560 W Broadway St., Idaho Falls, ID 83402