- Home
- /
- Sagaponack
- /
- Old Stove Pub
Old Stove Pub
27 Reviews
$$$
3516 Montauk Hwy
Sagaponack, NY 11962
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Food
Starters
- Beet Salad$23.00
- Caesar Salad$23.00
- Greek Salad$26.00
- Wedge Salad$22.00
- Trio Dips$16.00
- Calamari$22.00
- Crab Cake$26.00
- Onion Soup$16.00
- Truffle Burrata$26.00
- Vegetable Soup$14.00
- Saganaki$23.00
- Oysters$25.00
- Mussels$24.00
- Shrimp Cocktail$24.00
- Tuna Tartare$27.00
- Clams Dozen$20.00
- Clams Oregano$18.00
- Crudite$3.50
- Pita$5.00
- Zucchini Spirals$24.00
Entrees
Sides
Dessert
Sushi Starters
Sushi Entrees
Prefix
Brunch
- Feta Or Goat Cheese And Spinich Omelet 20
- Gardent Plate 20
- Lobster Salad$36.00
- Granola 20$18.00
- Quinoa Bolw 20
- Sweet Potatoe Hash 20
- Lentils 20
- Greens 20
- Corn Salad 20
- Gaspacho 20
- Fruit Plate 20
- Burger 20
- Greek Salad 20
- Fruit berries$16.00
- Trio Dips$18.00
- Calamari$18.00
- Wedge Salad$18.00
- Burrata$28.00
- Zucchini Spirals$18.00
- Greek Salad$22.00
- Spinach and Feta Omlet$22.00
- French toast$22.00
- Eggs Benedicts$26.00
- Steak and Eggs$30.00
- Egg Sandwich$24.00
- Avocado Toast 20$20.00
- Smoked Salmon Platter$26.00
- OSP Burger$28.00
- Jumbo Lump Cake$28.00
Kids
Drinks
Beer
Liquor
- Absolut$18.00
- Absolut Watermelon$19.00
- Belvedere$22.00
- Chopin$22.00
- Grey Goose$20.00
- Ketel One$19.00
- Ketel Citrus$19.00
- Ketel Orange$19.00Out of stock
- Sagaponacka$16.00Out of stock
- Stoli$18.00
- Stoli Citrus$18.00
- Stoli Vanilla$18.00
- Tito's$19.00
- House Vodka$16.00
- Stoli Orange$19.00
- Bombay$18.00
- Hendricks$19.00
- Tanqueray$20.00
- Brooklyn$18.00
- Gray Whale$18.00
- House Gin$14.00
- Gunpowder$19.00
- Empress$19.00
- Roku$19.00
- Beefeater$18.00
- Martin Millers$22.00
- Captain Morgan$16.00
- Bacardi Limon$16.00
- Bacardi$16.00
- Malibu$15.00
- Gosling$18.00
- Bacardi Anejo$19.00
- Banks Rum 5 Blend$19.00
- Diplomatico$21.00
- Mount Gay$17.00
- Patron Silver$22.00
- Jose Cuervo Gold$16.00
- Casamigos Blanco$20.00
- Casamigos Anejo$26.00
- Clas Azul Blanco$36.00
- Casamios Mezcal$28.00Out of stock
- Don Julio Blanco$22.00
- Espalon$18.00
- Clas Azul Repesado$39.00
- Casamigos Reposado$24.00
- Patron Anejo$24.00
- Don Julio Reposado$24.00
- Don Julio Anejo$26.00Out of stock
- Clas Azul Mezcal$79.00
- 1942$55.00
- Jager Coldbrew$18.00
- House Tequila$15.00
- Montelobos Mezcal$22.00
- Montaulika Blanco$20.00
- Montaukila Anejo$26.00
- Volcan Blanco$22.00
- Volcan Anejo$28.00
- Cantera Negra Reposado$25.00
- Cantera Negra Blanco$20.00
- Gem & Bolt Mezcal$20.00
- Dos Hombres Mezcal$25.00
- Milagro$24.00
- Volcan Reprosado$28.00
- Terraman Reprosado$25.00
- Teremana Anejo$26.00
- Cantera Negra Coffee$24.00
- Bushmills$18.00
- Dewars$18.00
- Johnny Walker Black$20.00
- Johnny Walker Red$20.00
- Wild Turkey Rye$18.00
- Bulleit Bourbon$20.00
- Woodford Reserve$24.00
- Bulleit Rye$20.00
- Jameson$16.00
- Jack Daniels$16.00
- Mcallen 12$34.00
- Red Breast$26.00
- Makers Mark$20.00
- Glenlivet 12$20.00
- Yamazaki$36.00Out of stock
- Johnny Walker Blue$45.00Out of stock
- Dewars 12$26.00
- Remy Martin XO$60.00
- Basil Hayden$22.00
- Suntory$20.00
- Eagle Rare$25.00
- Courvoisier XO$26.00Out of stock
- Chivas Regal$20.00
- House Whiskey$15.00
- Mcallen 15$38.00
- Jefferson Ocean$28.00
- Jefferson$24.00
- Buffalo Trace$22.00
- Crown Royal$22.00
- Angels Envy$24.00
- Kahluha$18.00
- Drambuie$18.00
- Grand Marnier$18.00
- Sambuca$18.00
- Lillet$18.00
- Chambord$18.00Out of stock
- Campari$18.00
- Harvey's$18.00
- Amaretto$18.00
- Frangelico$18.00
- Limoncello$10.00
- Baileys$18.00
- Aperol$18.00
- Sambuca Romana Black$18.00
- Disaronno$19.00
- Averna Amaro$19.00
- DOM Benedictine$28.00
- Chambord$17.00
- D'usse Cognac$28.00
Bottled Water
Whites
- St Michelle Chardonnay$17.00+
- Santa Margarita Pinot Grigio$19.00+
- Louis Jadot Pouilly Fuisse$20.00+
- Sonoma-Cutrer Chardonnay$70.00+
- Flowers Chardonnay 2017$85.00
- Far Niente Chardonnay$85.00
- Matua Sav Blanc$17.00+
- Gavi$80.00
- Patz and Hall Chardonnay$70.00
- Puligny-Montrachet$110.00
- Kistler$95.00
- Les Charmes Chardonnay$17.00+
- Kendall Jackson Chardonnay$70.00
- Jean-Paul Sancerre
Reds
- Altos Malbec$16.00+
- Rodney Strong Cabernet Sauv$17.00+
- Four Graces Pinot Noir$17.00+
- Stags Leap Cabernet Sauv$105.00
- Beringer Knights Valley Cab$21.00+
- Chateau de Sales Pomerol$90.00
- Renieri Brunello$185.00
- Heitz Cellar Cabernet Sauv$195.00
- Pio Cesare Barolo$115.00
- Silver Oak Cabernet Sauv$165.00
- Banfi Chianti Classico$18.00+
- Marchese Antinori Chianti$90.00
- Tignanello$210.00
- Louis Jadot Santenay Pinot Noir$75.00
- Tignanello Marchese Antinori Chianti Classico$95.00
- Brunello Pian Dello Vigno Antinori$105.00
- Termes Numanthia$16.00+
- Faust Cabernet Sauv$95.00
- Caymus Cabernet Sauv$120.00
- Rutherford Hill Merlot$18.00+
- Chateau Du Taillan 2015$90.00Out of stock
- Chateau de Sales Pomerol$90.00
- Chateau Monbousquet$165.00
- Chatteauneuf-du-Pape$80.00
- Robert Mondavi$105.00
- Quintessa$220.00
- Prunotto Barolo$85.00
Champagne & After Dinner Drinks
- Veuve Cliquot$95.00
- Prosecco Gl$17.00
- PerrierJouet$100.00
- Fonseca$14.00Out of stock
- Taylor 10 yr$22.00
- Sauternes$22.00
- Cockburns Vintage$22.00Out of stock
- Dom Perignon$195.00
- Dolce Barton Glass$18.00Out of stock
- Dolce Napa Bottle$55.00Out of stock
- Moet Chandon$85.00
- Veuve Cliquot (Copy)$28.00+
- Zonin Prosecco$50.00
- Santa Marina Prosecco$60.00Out of stock
- Villa Marcello Prosecco Bottle$75.00
- Hennesey VSOP$18.00
Cocktails
- Aperol Spritz$20.00
- Bloody Mary$18.00
- Bourbon Sweet Tea$20.00
- Cosmo$20.00
- Cucumber Sakatini$24.00
- Dark n Stormy$20.00
- Dirty Martini$22.00
- Grey Whale Spritz$20.00
- Manhattan$20.00
- Margarita$18.00
- Martini$22.00
- Mimosa$16.00
- Moscow Mule$18.00
- Lemondrop Martini$18.00
- Negroni$22.00
- Nespresso Martini$22.00
- Old Stove Old fashioned$22.00
- Old Stove VIP$20.00
- OS Spritz$22.00
- OSP Mojito$24.00
- Paloma$24.00
- Rose Paloma$20.00
- Sagapon-Star Martini$20.00
- Sakatini$22.00
- Spiced Apple Cider$18.00
- Spicy Pineapple Margarita$20.00
- Spicy Pineapple Mezcalarita$20.00
- Virgin Mojito$10.00
- Whisky Sour$20.00
- Hugo Spritz$21.00
- Especial Spritz$17.00
NA Beverages
Coffee
Sake
Rose
Pub Night Drinks
Party Drinks
Valentines Price Fix
Dessert
Pub Night
Menu
- Burger$15.00
- Beet Salad$10.00
- Caesar Salad$10.00
- Greek Salad$10.00
- Wedge Salad$10.00
- Calamari$10.00
- Chicken Wings$10.00
- Crab Cake$10.00
- Mussels$10.00
- Trio Dips$10.00
- Onion Soup$10.00
- Zucchini Spirals$10.00
- Oysters 1/2 Dozen$10.00
- Clams$10.00
- Clams 1/2 Dozen$10.00
- Two Beef Sliders$10.00Out of stock
- Sushi Special Roll$10.00Out of stock
- Clams Oreganato$10.00
PREFIX PRICING
PREFIX $
- PREFIX$55.00Out of stock
- KIDS PREFIX$25.00Out of stock
- PREFIX Party$75.00
- Thanksgiving Prefix$55.00
- PF Butternut Sq Soup
- PF Onion Soup
- PF Cesar Salad
- PF Beet Salad
- PF Roastd Turkey
- PF Eggplant
- PF Salmon
- PF Scallops
- PF Branzino
- PF Lamb Chops
- PF Filet Mignon
- PF Pumkin Pie
- PF Apple Pie
- PF Pecan Pie
- PF Berry Pie
- Green Salad
prefix tax
Course 3
Course 4
Course 5
Attributes and Amenities
All hours
Sunday | 6:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
Monday | Closed |
Tuesday | Closed |
Wednesday | 6:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
Thursday | 6:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
Friday | 6:00 pm - 9:00 pm |
Saturday | 6:00 pm - 10:00 pm |
Restaurant info
A True Hamptons Classic After and Extensive Restoration the Old Stove Pub Has Re-Opened Celebrating its 53rd Season. Indoor and Outdoor Dining.
Location
Gallery


Similar restaurants in your area
More near Sagaponack
Bridgehampton
Avg 4.3 (6 restaurants)
East Hampton
Avg 4.3 (17 restaurants)
Sag Harbor
Avg 4.1 (14 restaurants)
Amagansett
Avg 4.3 (7 restaurants)
Southampton
Avg 4.3 (20 restaurants)
Shelter Island Heights
No reviews yet
Greenport
Avg 4.4 (10 restaurants)
Montauk
Avg 3.6 (15 restaurants)
Westhampton Beach
No reviews yet
© 2023 Toast, Inc.