Jeremiahs Tavern - Penfield 2164 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd
No reviews yet
2164 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd
Fairport, NY 14450
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
Shareables
- Birria Tacos$13.99
flour tortillas stuffed with tender shredded beef, pico de gallo, melted cheddar jack cheese, seared and served with sour cream and consommé for dipping
- Nacho 3 Cheese Nevadomski$14.99
Corn Chips Smothered with Our Buffalo Cheese Sauce, Melted Cheddar Jack, Diced Tomatoes, Pickled Jalapenos, Sour Cream and Salsa. *Add Chicken, Chili, or Pulled Pork $5*
- Pow Pow Shrimp$14.50
Panko Breaded Shrimp tossed in a Creamy Spicy Sauce. Also available with any of Our Wing Sauces. *Allergy Alert: Contains Peanuts*
- Steak Quesadilla$17.50
Mushrooms, Caramelized Onions, Mozzarella Cheese, served with Sour Cream and Salsa.
- Homemade Tavern Pretzels$13.99
Baked with Butter and Salt, served with Beer Cheese and Honey Dijon Mustard.
- Jerry's Queso Dip N' Chips$11.99
Creamy Queso Blanco served with Flash Fried Corn Tortilla Chips and a side of Salsa.
- Chicken Wing Dip$13.99
Buffalo Chicken and a Three Cheese Blend served with Tortilla Chips.
- Shrimp Tacos$14.99
A Trio of Flour Tortillas, Fresh Shrimp, Shredded Cabbage, Pico de Gallo, Diced Avocado and Lime Sour Cream.
- Poutine$13.50
crispy steak fries topped with yancey’s fancy local cheese curds and gravy
- Chicken Fingers$13.99
(3) Breaded Chicken Breast Strips with choice of dipping Sauce. Served with Fries.
- Basket of Onion Rings$8.99
- Basket of Steak Fries$8.99
- Basket of Sweet Fries$8.99
- Basket of Curly Fries$8.99
- Basket Of Tots$8.99
Soups & Salads
- Broccoli Cheddar$5.50+
An Old Favorite Blend of Broccoli and Cheddar in a Creamy Base
- Ellie's French Onion Soup$7.99
The BEST French Onion Soup you'll ever have! with Croutons and Melted Provolone Cheese.
- Greens and Beans Soup$5.50+
Cannellini Beans, Kale and Italian sausage simmered with tomato and onions
- Homestyle Chili$5.50+
Our own secret recipe made in-house from scratch.
- Boston Clam Chowda$5.50+
A Classic Soup Perfected by Us!
- Wayne's World$14.50
A bowl of our Soup Du Jour and a House Salad with your choice of Dressing, served with Toasted Garlic Bread.
- Kenny's Salad$14.50
Grilled Pita Bread, Crumbled Feta Cheese, Steamed Broccoli, Artichoke Hearts, and Roasted Red Peppers, tossed in Seasoned Olive Oil, served over Fresh Romaine Lettuce. Add Chicken $5.00 - Add Shrimp or Steak $7.00
- Mandarin Salad$14.75
Romaine Lettuce, Shredded Carrots, Madarin Oranges and sliced almonds drizzled with Thai Peanut Sauce and topped with crispy Wonton Strips, served with a Honey-Lime Vinaigrette **ALLERGY ALERT-CONTAINS PEANUTS** Add chicken $5.. Add steak or shrimp $7
- Black and Blue Tenderloin Salad$20.99
Tenderloin tips, Romaine Lettuce, Red Onion, Grape Tomatoes, Pepperoncini and Crumbled Bleu Cheese served with a Horseradish Ranch Dressing.
- Chicken Milanese$18.99
Panko Breaded Chicken Breast, Arugula, Sliced Almonds, Shaved Parmesan, Grape Tomatoes served with a Citrus-Cider Vinaigrette.
- Beesting Salad$17.99
Breaded Chicken tossed in our Famous Bee Sting™ Sauce, with Shredded Cheddar-Jack Cheese, Virginia Ham, Red Onions, Grape Tomatoes, and Pepperoncini served over Romaine Lettuce with our House-Made Bleu Cheese Dressing.
- Southwest Bowl$14.99
Romaine Lettuce, Cheddar jack Cheese, Pico de Gallo, Black Bean-Corn Relish, Avocado, Lime Sour Cream Salsa Ranch Dressing, Crunchy Tortilla Strips. Add Chicken $5.00 - Add Shrimp or Steak $7.00
- Classic Caesar Salad$14.50
A bed of Fresh-Cut Crisp Romaine Lettuce tossed in Creamy Caesar Dressing with Homestyle Garlic Croutons and Shaved Parmesan Cheese. Add Chicken $5.00 - Add Shrimp or Steak $7.00
- Side Salad$6.99
- Side Caesar Salad$6.99
Chicken Wings
Pizza
- Bruschetta$15.50
Fresh Chopped Tomatoes, Garlic, Olive Oil, Mozzarella and Romano Cheese.
- BBQ Chicken$15.50
Tavern BBQ Sauce, Chicken Breast, Sauteed Onions, Bacon and Mozzarella Cheese.
- The Standby$15.50
Jerry’s Red Pizza Sauce, Mozzarella and Pepperoni.
- The Froman$15.50
Jerry's red sauce, mozzarella cheese and sweet Italian sausage
- The Beesting$15.50
Crispy Chicken Tossed in Bee Sting Sauce with Mozzarella Cheese and Ranch drizzle
Sandwiches, Wraps & Burgers
- The Smashburger$17.99
Ground Chuck seasoned and pressed to perfection with melted American cheese, pickles, shredded lettuce, bacon and topped with our smash sauce on brioche
- Black and Bleu Burger$17.99
Cajun Seasoning, Bacon and Crumbly Bleu Cheese on Brioche
- Build a Better Burger$14.25
Fresh Ground Sirloin On Brioche.. Add your toppings
- The Manny Melt$17.99
Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Sauteed Mushrooms & Onions on Grilled Sourdough
- Turkey Burger$17.50Out of stock
Hand-Formed Turkey Burger blended with peppers and onions topped with Spinach, Sliced Tomato, Provolone and Lemon Garlic Aioli on Brioche
- 3 Cheese Iron Smoke Whiskey Brisket Melt$17.50
Smoked Beef Brisket, Iron Smoke™ Whiskey BBQ Glaze, Cheddar and Pepper Jack on Grilled Sourdough Bread.
- Apple-Pecan Chicken Salad Wrap$16.99
NY State local apples, Roasted Pecans,, Dried Cranberries, Celery, Seasoned Mayo, Lettuce and Tomato in a Flour Tortilla
- Bee Sting Fried Chicken$17.99
Buttermilk Marinated Chicken Breast Double Dredged in our Seasoned Breading and deep-fried golden brown with Arugula, Pickles and Garlic Aioli served on a Grilled Brioche Roll.
- Brenda's Cajun Belmont$16.99
Cajun Seasoned Chicken Breast, Pepper Jack Cheese and Chipotle Mayo on Grilled Brioche.
- California Chicken Pita$16.99
Grilled Chicken Breast on Toasted Pita with Avocado, Bacon, Provolone Cheese, Fresh Spinach, Sliced Tomato and Chipotle Mayo.
- Webb's Rueben$16.99
Turkey or Corned Beef, Russian Dressing, Sauerkraut, and Swiss Cheese on Grilled Rye Bread.
- French Dip$17.99
House Roasted Beef and Swiss Cheese on a Toasted Artisan Baguette served with Au Jus for dipping.
- Jerry's Cheese Steak$17.99
Choice Steak chopped and grilled “Philly Style” with our specialty Sam Adams Peppers and Onions, topped with Aged Cheddar Cheese Sauce and Melted Provolone on a Hoagie Roll.
- Pork Schnitzel Sandwich$16.99
Crisp Breaded Dijon Pork Loin, Swiss Cheese, Lemon Garlic Mayo and Arugula on a Toasted Artisan Baguette.
- Sherwin's Russian Mistress$16.99
Oven Roasted Turkey, Sliced Tomato, Bacon, Fresh Spinach, Swiss Cheese and Russian Dressing on Grilled Sourdough Bread.
- The Cuban$16.99
Slow Roasted Pork, Virginia Ham, Swiss Cheese, Dill Pickles, Mayonnaise and Yellow Mustard on a Grilled Hoagie Roll.
- Shrimp Po-Boy Wrap$17.99
Panko Breaded shrimp, green leaf lettuce, Tomato, sliced onion and Lemon Garlic Aioli in a flour tortilla
- Thai Chicken Wrap$16.99
Grilled Chicken, Shredded Carrots and Cabbage, Thai Peanut Sauce and Korean BBQ Sauce in a Flour Tortilla **ALLERGY ALERT: CONTAINS PEANUTS*
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap$16.99
Breaded Chicken tosses in Jeremiah's Buffalo Sauce, Lettuce, Blue Cheese Crumbles and Creamy Bleu Cheese in a Cheddar Jalapeno Tortilla
- Turkey Bacon Avacado Wrap$16.99
- The Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap$16.99
Crispy chicken, bacon, ranch, cheddar jack cheese and lettuce in a flour tortilla
Entrees
- Friday Fish Fry$18.99
- Friday Fish Sandwich$16.99
- Friday Broiled Fish$18.99
- Fish and Chips$19.99
Beer battered cajun seasoned haddock served with steak fries, cole slaw and tarter sauce
- Big Red's Boston Steak Tips$20.99
Grilled choice tenderloin tips in a steak sauce served with macaroni salad or cole slaw and choice of side
- Buffalo Chicken Mac N' Cheese$17.99
Crispy fried chicken, cavatappi pasta baked with our signature recipe buffalo cheese sauce, crumbled bleu cheese and toasted bread crumbs
- Island Mahi and Mango Tacos$20.99
Blackened Mahi fillet, mango salsa, shredded cabbage and chipotle cilantro cream in (3) flour tortillas with choice of side
- The "1104" Plate$17.50
The BEST Plate in Town! two cheeseburgers, mac salad, fries topped with burger meat hot sauce, topped with mustard and chopped onion
- Jeremiah's Chicken Wing Platter$20.99
our famous (10)chicken wings, served with corn bread and choice of side
- Boneless Wing Platter$20.99
Our famous boneless wings (10) served with corn bread and choice of side
- Chicken Alfredo$19.99
Penne tossed with broccoli in a creamy sauce made with heavy cream, parmesan cheese and topped with a crispy breaded chicken cutlet
Dessert
- Brownie Sundae$9.99
A big hunk of our homeade Brownie and a scoop of creamy Vanilla Ice Cream. Finished with Chocolate Sauce.
- Peanut Butter Pie$9.99
A layer of Milk Chocolate and a layer of Peanut Butter Mousse in a Chocolate Cookie Crumb Crust.
- Carrot Cake$10.99
A blend of carotts, pineapple, coconut, pecans and raisins topped with a honey-vanilla glaze, finished with a cream cheese frosting, toasted coconut and chopped pecans
Kids Menu
- Alexa's Mac and Cheese$8.99
Served with a choice of side
- Ellie's Marinara Pasta And A Meatball$8.99
Served with a choice of side
- Kayliann's Grilled Cheese$8.99
Served with a choice of side
- Mahlon's Cheeseburger$8.99
Served with a choice of side
- Drew's Hamburger$8.99
Served with a choice of side
- Grace's Cheese Pizza$8.99
Served with a choice of side
- Leila's Dino Chicken Nuggets$8.99
Served with a choice of a side
- Nora's Mozarella Sticks$8.99
Served with a choice of a side
- Pepperoni Pita Pizza$8.99
Pepperoni , red sauce, mozzarella cheese served with choice of side
Sauces, Extras, Dressings
- Wing Sauces$0.75
- Salad Dressings$0.75
- Proteins
- Add Ons$0.75
- Add Cheese$1.75
- Add Bacon$3.00
- Add Avocado$2.75
- Side Blue Cheese$0.75
- Side Gravy$2.75Out of stock
- Side Queso$2.75
- Side Beer Cheese$2.75
- Side Chimi$0.75
- Side Marinara$0.75
- Side Buff Cheese$2.75
- Side Meat Hot$2.75
- Add Egg$1.50Out of stock
- Horseradish$1.75
- Mushrooms$1.75
- Grilled onions$1.75
- Roasted red peppers$1.75
- Banana peppers$1.75
- Pico de Gallo$1.75
- Crumbly blue$1.75
- Jalapeño peppers$1.75
- Garlic Bread$2.99
- Celery$0.75
- Malt Vinegar
- Salsa$0.75
- Sour cream$0.75
- Steak Sauce$0.75
- Ketchup
- Mustard
- Xtra Tartar$0.75
- Bee Sting Sour Cream$0.75
- Peanut Sauce$0.75
Sunday | 8:00 am - 3:59 am |
Monday | 8:00 am - 3:59 am |
Tuesday | 8:00 am - 3:59 am |
Wednesday | 8:00 am - 3:59 am |
Thursday | 8:00 am - 3:59 am |
Friday | 8:00 am - 3:59 am |
Saturday | 8:00 am - 3:59 am |
Come in and enjoy!
2164 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd, Fairport, NY 14450
Photos coming soon!