- Home
- /
- Cary
- /
- Dessert & Ice Cream
- /
- Cary Dairy Ice Cream Café
Cary Dairy Ice Cream Café
138 Reviews
395 Cary Algonquin Road
Suite E
Cary, IL 60013
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
- Pint To-Go$7.25
Super-premium ice cream to be shared with a few friends, or enjoyed by yourself!
- Single Scoop$4.50
Single scoop of one flavor of your choice! (Flavor descriptions available at CaryDairy.com, GF & DF options available)
- Dole Whip$5.50+
Refreshingly delicious, enjoy this fruit-flavored soft serve sorbet! (Gluten-Friendly, Vegan & Fat-Free)
CUSTOM CAKE ORDER
- Custom 8" Cake$46.95
Serves 10-14. Two layers of rich cake, with a thick layer of super-premium ice cream in the middle! Handmade at Cary Dairy with Super-Premium Ice Cream from Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Company! *Please allow 24-48 hours for all custom cake orders. Any custom messages, please add in SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS section. If you see/would like a flavor we currently offer on our flavors page, please include in SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS section. * **All custom cake order sales are final.**
- Custom BabyCake$13.95
Serves 2-3. Layer of rich cake on the bottom, topped with a thick layer of super-premium ice cream. Handmade at Cary Dairy! *Please allow 24-48 hours for all custom cake orders. Any custom messages, please add in SPECIAL REQUESTS section* **All custom cake order sales are final.**
CUSTOM ICE CREAM PIE ORDER
- Ice Cream Pie$25.95
Serves 7-9. Handmade with a graham cracker crust at Cary Dairy with Super-Premium Ice Cream from Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Company! *Please allow 24-48 hours for all custom orders. Any custom messages, please add in SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS section. If you see/would like a flavor we currently offer on our flavors page, please include in SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS section. * **All custom cake order sales are final.**
Ice Cream Pie
Serves 7-9. Handmade with a graham cracker crust at Cary Dairy with Super-Premium Ice Cream from Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Company! *Please allow 24-48 hours for all custom orders. Any custom messages, please add in SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS section. If you see/would like a flavor we currently offer on our flavors page, please include in SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS section. * **All custom cake order sales are final.**
SOFT SERVE
- Vanilla Soft Serve$4.25+
Enjoy a cone or dish of our premium, super-creamy soft serve! (Gluten-Free)
- Chocolate Soft Serve$4.25+
Enjoy a cone or dish of our premium, super-creamy soft serve! (Gluten-Free)
- Vanilla/Chocolate Twist$4.25+
Enjoy a cone or dish of our premium, super-creamy soft serve! (Gluten-Free)
- Dairy-Free Chocolate Soft Serve$5.00+Out of stock
Oat-Milk based vanilla soft serve! Dairy-free, Vegan, Gluten-Free, Peanut/TreeNut-Free (*Cary Dairy is not a peanut/tree-nut free facility), and Cholesterol-Free!
DOLE WHIP
FLOATS
- ROOT BEER FLOAT$6.50
A classic! Vanilla ice cream served float-style with Root Beer.
- DOLE WHIP FLOAT$6.50
Deliciously refreshing Pineapple Dole Whip®, served float-style in pineapple juice! Add Boba Bubbles for extra bursts of flavor!
- SUNSET FLOAT$6.50
Tropical bliss! Pineapple Dole Whip® served float-style with bursts of Strawberry, Watermelon & Coconut flavors!
- SODA FLOAT$6.50
Premium vanilla soft serve ice cream, served float-style over your choice of soda!
- COFFEE FLOAT$6.50
Two scoops of your favorite ice cream, served float-style in our Cary Dairy Blend Coffee, from Conscious Cup® Coffee Roasters!
- HOT CHOCOLATE FLOAT$6.50
Two scoops of your favorite ice cream, served float-style in premium hot cocoa, topped with homemade whipped cream!
SUNDAES
- SUNDAE$6.95
Classic sundae with your choice of up to (2) flavors of ice cream, topped with syrup of choice & homemade whipped cream!
- BROWNIE SUNDAE$6.95
Warm gooey brownies, topped with your choice of up to (2) flavors of ice cream, choice of toppings, homemade whipped cream & a cherry!
- TURTLE SUNDAE$8.25
Classic turtle sundae with choice of up to (2) flavors of ice cream, hot fudge, pecans, caramel syrup, and topped with homemade whipped cream & a cherry!
MILKSHAKES
- VANILLA SHAKE$6.75
Classic milkshake made with premium vanilla ice cream.
- CHOCOLATE SHAKE$6.75
Classic chocolate milkshake made with premium chocolate ice cream.
- STRAWBERRY SHAKE$7.75
Classic strawberry milkshake made with premium vanilla ice cream, blended with sliced strawberry topping.
- FLAVORED SHAKE$6.95
Classic milkshake made with your choice of premium soft serve ice cream, with added flavor bursts to make any flavor shake you can imagine!
- HAND-SCOOPED SHAKE$6.75
Classic milkshake made with your choice of up to (3) flavors of premium hand-scooped ice cream.
- DAIRY-FREE CHOCOLATE SHAKE$7.75
Dairy-free shake made with our oat-based chocolate soft serve, blended with oat milk! (No Whipped Cream)
MALTS
- VANILLA MALT$6.95
Classic malt milkshake made with premium vanilla ice cream, topped with homemade whipped cream.
- CHOCOLATE MALT$6.95
Classic malt milkshake made with premium chocolate ice cream, topped with homemade whipped cream.
- STRAWBERRY MALT$7.95
Classic strawberry malt milkshake made with premium vanilla ice cream, blended with sliced strawberry topping.
- FLAVORED MALT$7.25
Classic malt milkshake made with your choice of premium soft serve ice cream, with added flavor bursts to make any flavor shake you can imagine!
- HAND-SCOOPED MALT$6.95
Classic malt milkshake made with your choice of up to (3) flavors of premium hand-scooped ice cream.
- DAIRY-FREE CHOCOLATE MALT$7.75
Dairy-free malt made with our oat-based chocolate soft serve, blended with oat milk! (No Whipped Cream)
SLUSHEE/SNOW-DAYS
SCOOPS
- Double Scoop$5.95
Double scoop of flavor(s) of your choice! Up to 2 flavors. (Flavor descriptions available at CaryDairy.com, GF & DF options available)
- Single Scoop$4.50
Single scoop of one flavor of your choice! (Flavor descriptions available at CaryDairy.com, GF & DF options available)
- Triple Scoop$6.75
Triple scoop of flavor(s) of your choice! Up to 3 flavors. (Flavor descriptions available at CaryDairy.com, GF & DF options available)
& MORE!
- Classic Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich$6.25
Creamy Old Fashioned Vanilla ice cream between two chocolate chip cookies, rolled in colorful sprinkles.
- Pup Cup$1.25
A little something for our four-legged friends! Vanilla soft serve, garnished with a milkbone for the most spoiled canines.
- Cat Cup$0.95
A treat for our purrfect four-legged friends! Homemade whipped cream with cat treats sprinkled on top.
BAKED GOODS
- Gourmet Brownie$3.75
Delicious gourmet brownies, loaded with extra candies and goodies. Prepared in-house!
- Cake Pop$3.25
Classic cake pop! Rich yellow or chocolate cake dipped in decadent white or milk chocolate. Made specially in-house at Cary Dairy!
- Gluten-Free Oatmeal Creme Pie Sandwich$5.25Out of stock
Gluten- and Dairy-Free. A delicious oatmeal cookie sandwich filled with cream cheese frosting from Rosie's Gluten Free Sweets.
- Gluten-Free Brownie$10.25
Gluten- and Dairy-Free, this dense, rich chocolate brownie is sure to satisfy any craving! Add a pint of Old Fashioned Vanilla ice cream (GF) to create your own gluten-free sundae! (Rosie's Gluten Free Sweets) *Contains Coconut Milk*
- Gluten-Free Brookie Bar$10.25
Brownie on bottom, chocolate chip cookie on top! This treat is dairy-free, gluten-free, and vegan. Baked fresh from Rosie's Gluten-Free Sweets.
- Gluten-Free S'Mores Bar$12.00Out of stock
Gluten- and Dairy-Free, this delightful treat is sure to satisfy any craving! Heat up in microwave 15-20 seconds for the perfect melty s'mores treat. (Rosie's Gluten Free Sweets)
PINTS TO GO
QUARTS TO GO
Call for Open Hours
Welcome to Cary’s premium ice cream stop, open year-round! We proudly serve Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream – a super-delicious, super-premium ice cream from Madison, WI – as well as premium soft serve, cane sugar slushees, ice cream cakes, delicious locally-baked goods and our own special blend coffee from Conscious Cup! We are proud to offer a variety of Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, Vegan, Kosher and No-Sugar-Added options. ~ Voted 2022 Best Ice Cream/Frozen Custard in McHenry County ~ Best of The Fox Award
395 Cary Algonquin Road, Suite E, Cary, IL 60013