Webb's Captains Table
No reviews yet
115 West Lake Road
Mayville, NY 14757
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Pick-Up Requirements
Will your order be
Available only upon request
Dinner Menu
Starters
- French Onion Cup$7.00
Caramelized onions simmered in our homemade broth, topped with croutons, Swiss and Mozzarella
- French Onion Bowl$9.00
- Vegetable Soup Cup$6.00
- Vegetable Soup Bowl$8.00
- Bruschetta$14.95
Six grilled ciabatta bread topped with diced tomatoes, onions, basil, garlic and olive oil.
- Coconut Shrimp$18.95
Four pieces of fresh shrimp, hand-breaded to order, served with pineapple dipping sauce.
- Vegetable Spring Rolls$12.95
Thinly cut vegetables wrapped in an egg roll, served with an orange ginger sauce.
- Soup Of The Day Cup$6.00
- Soup Of The Day Bowl$8.00
- Shrimp Cocktail Add On$4.95
- Caprese$13.95
- Chacuterie Board$18.95
Salad
- Webb's House Salad$6.95
Iceberg lettuce and mixed greens, topped with tomatoes, peas, carrots, radishes, onions and cabbage.
- Caesar Salad$8.95
Crisp Romaine lettuce, tossed in Caesar dressing and topped with croutons and parmesan cheese.
- Cortland Apple Salad$10.95
Candied pecans, crumbled bleu cheese, cranberries, white raisins, sliced local Cortland apple over a bed of mixed greens and dressed with apple vinaigrette.
- Wedge Salad$10.95
Iceberg lettuce, crumbled and creamy bleu cheese, diced tomatoes, onions and topped with sliced bacon.
- Strawberry Salad$10.95
Sandwiches
- Grass Fed Burger$17.95
served with lettuce, tomato, pickle and a side of French Fries.
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich$15.50
Served on a hearth baked roll with lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise with a side of French Fries.
- Crab Cake Sandwich$17.95
House-made lump crab cake, sautéed and served with lemon aioli, tomato, lettuce and onion served with a side of French Fries.
- Chicken Caesar Wrap$15.95
Grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, tomato, red onion, parmesan cheese and Webb's Caesar dressing served with French Fries.
- The Big Catch Sandwich$15.95
Deep-fried haddock, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo served on a toasted hearth baked roll with a side of French Fries.
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap$15.95
Grilled chicken tossed in a spicy wing sauce served in an herb garlic tortilla with lettuce, tomato, onion and bleu cheese with a side of French Fries.
- Grilled Salmon Sandwich$17.95
Lettuce, tomato, onion, dill sauce on the side served on a toasted hearth baked roll with a side of French Fries.
- Quesadilla$15.95
Features
- Grilled Rack of Lamb$37.00
New Zealand rack of lamb served medium-rare over mashed sweet potato, drizzled with bourbon peppercorn sauce
- Tomahawk Pork Chop$36.00
Grilled bone-in pork chop, topped with Buffalo Trace Bourbon demi glaze served with mashed sweet potato
- Filet Oscar$39.00
6oz filet mignon, topped with fresh grilled shrimp, asparagus, hollandaise sauce and served with a baked potato
- Grilled Rib-Eye$56.00+
Grilled and seasoned with our house seasoning salt, seared and served with a baked potato
- Prime Rib *Thursday-Sunday Only*$32.00+
Slow roasted prime rib seasoned with our house seasoning salt with natural au jus served with a baked potato
- Maple Pecan Crusted Salmon$37.00
Canadian salmon filet broiled, served over mashed sweet potato, and covered with chopped candied pecans
- Herb Seared Mahi$36.00
8oz Mahi filet seared with Webb's herb crusting and finished with piccata sauce and capers on top served with rice pilaf
- Shrimp & Scallops Combo$36.00
4 oz. gulf shrimp and 4 oz. sea scallops broiled in house seasoning, served with rice pilaf
- Pan Fried Walleye$35.00
Canadian Lake Erie walleye, breaded, pan-fried served with lemon, tartar sauce and rice pilaf
- Chicken Mediterranean$33.00
Grilled chicken topped with goat cheese, sundried tomatoes, basil, black olives, roasted red peppers, capers and a lemon butter wine sauce served over linguini.
- Chicken Picatta$33.00
Our tender boneless breast of chicken, dusted with flour and pan sauteed, topped with lemon-butter white wine sauce, capers, sun-dried tomatoes, mushrooms, black olives, atrichoke hearts, served over linguini.
- Chicken Chautauqua$31.00
Our tender boneless breast of chicken lightly breaded, pan sauteed and topped with fresh mushroom, bacon and poulet sauce. Served with a baked potato
- Chicken Parmesan$31.00
Boneless chicken breast, lightly breaded, pan sautéed, topped with mozzarella cheese, Webb's marinara sauce and served with a side of linguini
- Our Own Herb Garden Pasta$25.00
Linguini topped with pomodoro sauce (diced tomatoes, onions, garlic, basil, virgin olive oil), reggiano parmesan cheese and melted mozzarella cheese.
- Sword Fish$32.95
- Grilled Sword Fish$31.95
- Bourbon Pork Tenderloin$29.95
- Shrimp Scampi$32.00
- Bacon Filet$38.00
- Short Rib$38.00
- Catch Of The Day$25.95
- $21.95 8oz Prime Rib$21.95
- Fresh Sea Bass W Butter Wine$33.00
Dessert
- Mini Pear Crisp$10.00
House made with local Bartlett pears, served warm topped with vanilla bean ice cream
- Cranberry Apple Crisp$10.00Out of stock
House made with apples and cranberries, served warm topped with vanilla bean ice cream
- Classic Créme Brûlée$10.00
Our own vanilla custard topped with a crisp caramelized sugar shell and whipped cream
- Carrot Cake$10.00
Old-fashioned carrot cake with just the right blend of sugar and spice
- Birthday Bomb
- Strawberry Creme Brulee$10.00Out of stock
- Sundae$10.00
Four Course $55 Spring Menu
Easter Menu 2023
Early Bird Special
- Chicken Chautauqua EBS$24.95
Our tender boneless breast of chicken lightly breaded and pan sauteed and topped with fresh mushroom caps, bacon strips and poulet sauce.
- Salmon Filet EBS$24.95
Your choice of Grilled, Blackened or Broiled with white wine.
- 8 Oz Prime Rib EBS$24.95
- Chicken Mediterranean EBS$24.95
Grilled chicken topped with goat cheese, sundried tomatoes, basil, black olives, roasted red peppers, capers and a lemon butter wine sauce served over linguini.
Sunday Cafe
FOOD
- Banana Bread Slices$4.50Out of stock
- Almond Cranberry Muffins$3.95
- Brownie Squares$3.50Out of stock
- Lemon Cheesecake Bars$3.95
- 6 Layer Bars$3.95Out of stock
- Ham/Cheddar Quiche$6.95
- Veggie Quiche$6.95
- Veggie Quiche w/Feta$3.95
- Specialty Quiche With Organic Eggs$7.95
- Chocolate Chip Pecan Cookies$1.95Out of stock
- Blueberry Crumb Muffins$2.95Out of stock
- Cherry Pie$2.95Out of stock
- Apple Cinnamon Cake$2.95Out of stock
- Cinnamon Coffee Cake$2.95Out of stock
- Mixed Berry Muffin$2.95Out of stock
- Lemon Blueberry Muffin$2.95Out of stock
- Cardamon Bread$3.95Out of stock
- Fresh Fruit$2.95Out of stock
- Yogurt Parfait$5.00Out of stock
- Chocolate Chip Banana Bread$4.50Out of stock
DRINKS
- Pour Over (CC)
- Latte 12oz$4.50
- Latte 16oz$6.50
- Cappuccino 12oz$5.00
- Mocha 12oz$5.50
- Mocha 16oz$6.50
- Espresso Single$3.00
- Espresso Double$4.00
- Regular Coffee 12oz$2.50
- Regular Coffee 16oz$3.50
- Decaf Coffee 12oz$2.50
- Decaf Coffee 16oz$3.50
- Iced Coffee$2.50
- Cold Brew$3.50
- Frappe$5.50
- Tea$2.50
- Iced Tea$2.50
- Americano 12oz$3.50
- Americano 16oz$4.50
- Hot Specialty$3.00
- Cold Specialty$4.00
- Pour Over Regular$5.50
- Pour Over Exotic$7.50
- Hot Chocolate 12oz$4.00
- Hot Chocolate 16oz$5.00
- Chai Latte 12oz$3.75
- Chai Latte 16oz$4.15
- Xtra Espresso Shot$1.00
- Peanut Butter$0.75
- Maple Syrup$0.75
- Vanilla$0.75
- Add White Chocolate$0.75
- Add Chocolate$0.75
- Mombucha$6.54
Retail
- Brittle Brothers Bacon Peanut Brittle 5oz$7.00Out of stock
- 2oz Conundrum Trail Mix$3.00Out of stock
- Maple Smoked Cashews$2.50
- Toma Bloody Mary Mixer- HR$16.95
- Toma Bloody Mary Mixer-Original$16.95
- OMG! Pretzels 50% Off$4.00Out of stock
- Bee Pollen$9.95
- 2oz Honey Bears$3.25
- Honey Suckers$2.50
- 12oz Honey Bears$7.25
- Honey$9.25
- Bible Verse Tea "His Mercy's Are New Every Morning"$15.00
- Bible Verse Tea "Hope Is An Anchor" Peach Black Tea$15.00
- Bible Verse Tea "Serve The Lord" Green Tea w Mango$15.00
- Bible Verse Tea "When You Go Through Deep Waters" Gunpowder$15.00
- Sleep Tea "Counting Sheep"$15.00
- Throat Tea$15.00
- Turmeric and Ginger Tea- ManOrange$15.00
- Professional Flight$92.00
- 12oz Lil Sic Kids Bottle Black$22.00
- 16oz Stemless Ice White$19.00
- 20oz Matte Red$24.99
- 12oz Pink Dimpled Tumblr$21.00
- 12oz Neon Yellow Dimpled Tumblr$21.00
- Slim Can Koozie Hawaiian Hibiscus$27.00Out of stock
- 12oz Hammered Gunmetal$21.00
- Pink Dimpled Golf Stemless$21.95
- 20oz Beachwood$27.00
- 16oz Stemless Cotton Candy$22.00
- 20oz Gloss Ice White$24.99
- Steel Straws$10.50
- Slim Can Cooler Salt Water Camo$23.00
- 12oz Lil Sic Cotton Candy$22.00
- Slim Can Koozie Dimpled Golf$22.00
- Slim Can Koozie Matte Black$19.99
- 12oz Dimpled Golf$21.00
- 20oz Hammered Gunmetal$24.99
- 20oz Splatter Paint$27.00
- 20oz Hammered Copper$24.99
- 20oz Hawaiian Hibiscus$27.00
- 12oz Marble$22.00
- Lil Sic 12oz Ice White$22.00
- 12oz Salt Water Camo$22.00
- 12oz Hammered Copper$21.00
- 30oz Dimpled Golf$30.00
- 30oz Stainless Steel$30.00
- 30oz Seafood Blue$30.00
- 20oz Matte Tuff Black$24.99
- NF Cracker Tray$34.00
- NF Octagonal Platter$56.00
- NF Square Platter$52.00
- NF Garnish Dish$44.00
- Rectangle Revamp
- NF Witchful Thinking$14.75
- Chillin' Chair Blue$13.95
- NF Top Of The Class$14.75
- NF Hot Stuff!$14.75
- NF Gobble Gobble!$14.75
- NF Flower Power$14.75
- NF Uncle Sam$14.75
- NF Anchors Aweigh$14.75
- NF Chicago Dog$14.75
- Mermaid Moments$13.95
- Cheese, Please!$13.95
- NF Catch Some Fun$14.75
- NF Tickled Pink$14.75
- NF Winter Songbird$14.75
- From The Vine$13.95
- NF Autumns Bounty$14.75
- NF Sunning&Funning$14.75
- NF Juicy Fruit$14.75
- NF Sail Me Away$14.75
- NF Lil' Ladybug$14.75
- NF Pumpkin Spice$14.75
- Tall Wine Chiller$52.95
- Short Wine Chiller$48.99
- Large Gurgle Pot$52.95
- Medium Gurgle Pot$27.95
- Extra Small Gurgle Pot$8.95
- Salt&Pepper Gurgle Pot$19.95
- Spicy Corn Relish$7.50
- 27oz Matte Tuff Black Water Bottle$22.00
- 27oz Salt Water Camo Water Bottle$22.00
- Stonewall Black Bean Salsa$7.50
- Stonewall Wild Maine Blueberry Jam$8.25Out of stock
- Stonewall Peach Amaretto Jam$8.25
- Smokin' Marg Mix 4oz$3.99
- Stonewall Watermelon Jelly$8.25Out of stock
- Stonewall Red Pepper Jelly$8.25
- Mombucha$6.54
- Smoking Marg Mix$10.99
- Spicy Ginger Mule$10.99
- Watermelon Mojitio$10.99
- Sweet Smoked Beef Stick$1.99
- Classic Bacon Jam$9.99Out of stock
- Sweet Chile Jam$9.99
- Black Peppercorn Bacon Jam$9.99
- Maple Bacon Sugar$6.99
- Himalayan Ghost Salt$8.00
- Honey Habanero Jam$9.99
KIDS
Beverages
- Apple Juice$3.75
- Arnold Palmer$3.75
- Bottle Water$3.75
- Chocolate Milk$3.75
- Coffee$3.75
- Cranberry Juice$3.75
- Decaf$3.75
- Diet Pepsi$3.75
- Dr Pepper$3.75
- Ginger Beer$3.75
- Gingerale$3.75
- Grapefruit Juice$3.75
- Hot Chocolate$3.75
- Hot Tea$3.75
- Iced Coffee$3.75
- Milk$3.75
- Orange Juice$3.75
- Pepsi$3.75
- Pineapple Juice$3.75
- Pink Lemonade$3.75
- Raspberry Tea$3.75
- Root Beer$3.75
- Saratoga Sparkling$3.75
- Shirley Temple$3.75
- Sierra Mist$3.75
- Soda Water$3.75
- Tonic Water$3.75
- Unsweetened Iced Tea$3.75
- V8 Juice$3.75
Children's Menu
Children's Menu
- Cheeseburger Kids$10.00
served with french fries
- Chicken Fingers Kids$10.00
(4) served with french fries
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich Kids$10.00
served with french fries
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich Kids$10.00
lettuce, tomato, mayo served with french fries
- Hamburger Kids$10.00
served with french fries
- Shrimp Basket Kids$10.00
(4) Fresh shrimp hand breaded served with french fries
- Spaghetti & Meatballs Kids$10.00
served with a side salad
- 6oz Prime$10.00
Children's First Course
Sunday Dinner Menu
Starters
- French Onion Cup$7.00
Caramelized onions simmered in our homemade broth, topped with croutons, Swiss and Mozzarella
- French Onion Bowl$9.00
- Vegetable Soup Cup$6.00
- Vegetable Soup Bowl$8.00
- Bruschetta$14.95
Six grilled ciabatta bread topped with diced tomatoes, onions, basil, garlic and olive oil.
- Coconut Shrimp$18.95
Four pieces of fresh shrimp, hand-breaded to order, served with pineapple dipping sauce.
- Vegetable Spring Rolls$12.95
Thinly cut vegetables wrapped in an egg roll, served with an orange ginger sauce.
- Soup Of The Day Cup$6.00
- Soup Of The Day Bowl$8.00
- Shrimp Cocktail Add On$4.95
- Caprese Salad$12.95
Salad
- Webb's House Salad$6.95
Iceberg lettuce and mixed greens, topped with tomatoes, peas, carrots, radishes, onions and cabbage.
- Caesar Salad$8.95
Crisp Romaine lettuce, tossed in Caesar dressing and topped with croutons and parmesan cheese.
- Cortland Apple Salad$10.95
Candied pecans, crumbled bleu cheese, cranberries, white raisins, sliced local Cortland apple over a bed of mixed greens and dressed with apple vinaigrette.
- Wedge Salad$10.95
Iceberg lettuce, crumbled and creamy bleu cheese, diced tomatoes, onions and topped with sliced bacon.
- Strawberry Salad$10.95
Sandwiches
- Grass Fed Burger$17.95
served with lettuce, tomato, pickle and a side of French Fries.
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich$15.50
Served on a hearth baked roll with lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise with a side of French Fries.
- Crab Cake Sandwich$17.95
House-made lump crab cake, sautéed and served with lemon aioli, tomato, lettuce and onion served with a side of French Fries.
- Chicken Caesar Wrap$15.95
Grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, tomato, red onion, parmesan cheese and Webb's Caesar dressing served with French Fries.
- The Big Catch Sandwich$15.95
Deep-fried haddock, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo served on a toasted hearth baked roll with a side of French Fries.
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap$15.95
Grilled chicken tossed in a spicy wing sauce served in an herb garlic tortilla with lettuce, tomato, onion and bleu cheese with a side of French Fries.
- Grilled Salmon Sandwich$17.95
Lettuce, tomato, onion, dill sauce on the side served on a toasted hearth baked roll with a side of French Fries.
- Quesadilla$15.95
Features
- Grilled Rack of Lamb$37.00
New Zealand rack of lamb served medium-rare over mashed sweet potato, drizzled with bourbon peppercorn sauce
- Tomahawk Pork Chop$36.00
Grilled bone-in pork chop, topped with Buffalo Trace Bourbon demi glaze served with mashed sweet potato
- Filet Oscar$39.00
6oz filet mignon, topped with fresh grilled shrimp, asparagus, hollandaise sauce and served with a baked potato
- Bacon Wrapped Filet$35.00
6oz filet wrapped in prosciutto, topped with red wine and served with a baked potato
- Grilled Rib-Eye$56.00+
Grilled and seasoned with our house seasoning salt, seared and served with a baked potato
- Prime Rib *Thursday-Sunday Only*$32.00+
Slow roasted prime rib seasoned with our house seasoning salt with natural au jus served with a baked potato
- Maple Pecan Crusted Salmon$37.00
Canadian salmon filet broiled, served over mashed sweet potato, and covered with chopped candied pecans
- Herb Seared Mahi$36.00
8oz Mahi filet seared with Webb's herb crusting and finished with piccata sauce and capers on top served with rice pilaf
- Shrimp & Scallops Combo$36.00
4 oz. gulf shrimp and 4 oz. sea scallops broiled in house seasoning, served with rice pilaf
- Pan Fried Walleye$35.00
Canadian Lake Erie walleye, breaded, pan-fried served with lemon, tartar sauce and rice pilaf
- Chicken Mediterranean$33.00
Grilled chicken topped with goat cheese, sundried tomatoes, basil, black olives, roasted red peppers, capers and a lemon butter wine sauce served over linguini.
- Chicken Picatta$33.00
Our tender boneless breast of chicken, dusted with flour and pan sauteed, topped with lemon-butter white wine sauce, capers, sun-dried tomatoes, mushrooms, black olives, atrichoke hearts, served over linguini.
- Chicken Chautauqua$31.00
Our tender boneless breast of chicken lightly breaded, pan sauteed and topped with fresh mushroom, bacon and poulet sauce. Served with a baked potato
- Chicken Parmesan$31.00
Boneless chicken breast, lightly breaded, pan sautéed, topped with mozzarella cheese, Webb's marinara sauce and served with a side of linguini
- Our Own Herb Garden Pasta$25.00
Linguini topped with pomodoro sauce (diced tomatoes, onions, garlic, basil, virgin olive oil), reggiano parmesan cheese and melted mozzarella cheese.
- 16oz Ribeye Oscar$57.99
- California Sea Bass$32.95Out of stock
- Filet Special$25.00
- Candy Snapper$32.95
- Grilled Sword Fish$31.95
- Shrimp Scampi$32.00
Dessert
- Mini Pear Crisp$10.00
House made with local Bartlett pears, served warm topped with vanilla bean ice cream
- Cranberry Apple Crisp$10.00Out of stock
House made with apples and cranberries, served warm topped with vanilla bean ice cream
- Classic Créme Brûlée$10.00
Our own vanilla custard topped with a crisp caramelized sugar shell and whipped cream
- Carrot Cake$10.00
Old-fashioned carrot cake with just the right blend of sugar and spice
- Birthday Bomb
- Strawberry Creme Brulee$10.00Out of stock
- Sundae$10.00
Four Course $45 Wintertide Menu
Four Course $55 Summer Menu (Copy)
Early Bird Special Menu
Early Bird Special
- Chicken Chautauqua EBS$24.95
Our tender boneless breast of chicken lightly breaded and pan sauteed and topped with fresh mushroom caps, bacon strips and poulet sauce.
- Salmon Filet EBS$24.95
Your choice of Grilled, Blackened or Broiled with white wine.
- 8 Oz Prime Rib EBS$24.95
- Chicken Mediterranean EBS$24.95
Grilled chicken topped with goat cheese, sundried tomatoes, basil, black olives, roasted red peppers, capers and a lemon butter wine sauce served over linguini.
Sunday | 7:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Monday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
Tuesday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
Wednesday | Closed |
Thursday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
Friday | 11:30 am - 9:00 pm |
Saturday | 7:00 am - 10:00 pm |
Webb's Captain's Table & Webb's Carryout & Cafe
115 West Lake Road, Mayville, NY 14757