- Home
- /
- Port Saint Lucie
- /
- Bagel Brothers of New York
This restaurant does not have any images
Bagel Brothers of New York
10802 Tradition Parkway
Port Saint Lucie, FL 34987
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
NEW STORE MENU
NEW!!! Original Philly Cheesesteak
NEW! Breakfast Burritos
- Huevorito
Burrito with 3 scrambled eggs, smashed tots, sautéed peppers & onions, house made Pico de Gallo & shredded Cheddar Jack Cheese and our Signature Bros Sauce.
$11.29 - SpicyRito
Burrito with 3 scrambled eggs, smashed tots, sausage, pickled jalapeños & shredded Cheddar Jack Cheese, topped with our Signature Bros Sauce.
$11.29 - CaliforniaRito
Burrito with Sauteed peppers & onions, 3 scrambled eggs, shredded Cheddar Jack Cheese, our smashed avocado spread, topped with our Signature Bros Sauce.
$11.29 - PastramiRito
Burrito with Carnegie Deli Pastrami, 3 scrambled eggs, shredded Cheddar Jack Cheese, smashed tots and our Signature Bros Sauce.
$11.29
NEW! Crispy Chicken Sandwiches
- Nashville Hot Chicken
Our Crispy Chicken, tossed in our Nashville sauce, sliced pickles, topped with our house made creamy Cole Slaw.
$12.99 - Crispy Cordon Bleu
Crispy Chicken, Boar's Head sliced Ham, Melted Swiss Cheese & Boar's Head Honey Mustard.
$12.99 - Spicy Chipotle
Crispy Chicken, melted Pepper Jack Cheese, sliced pickled jalapenos and our house made chipotle sauce.
$12.99 - Crispy Avocado Ranch
Our Crispy Chicken, avocado mash, bacon, melted Cheddar Cheese and ranch dressing.
$12.99
Bagel Breakfast & Nova Sandwiches
- "NEW" GRAB & GO Nova Package
Just add your bagel! Make it at home just the way you like it, everything included. Acme Smoked Center Cut Nova, Cream Cheese, Capers, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Red Onions.
$11.99 - The Nova Sandwich
Acme Smoked Center Cut Nova, Cream Cheese, Capers, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Red Onions.
$11.99 - Dilly Red Nova Sandwich (NEW)
Smoked Center Cut Nova, Cream Cheese, Red Onions, capers, fresh dill, EVOO Drizzle, ground pepper & sea salt
$13.99 - Basic Tomato Nova Sandwich (NEW)
Smoked Center Cut Nova, Cream Cheese, beautiful sliced tomatoes, squeeze of lemon, EVOO Drizzle, ground pepper & sea salt.
$13.99 - Long Island Originals
(Choose One) Bacon Egg and Cheese / Sausage Egg & Cheese or Ham Egg & Cheese on your Choice of Bagel or Kaiser Roll.
$8.30 - Carnegie Pastrami Egg & Cheese
Carnegie Deli Pastrami sliced thin & grilled, 2 eggs and Swiss Cheese on your choice of Bagel.
$9.29 - Nova Eggstreme
Scrambled eggs, Nova, Spinach, Provolone Cheese & our House Made Herb Mayo on your choice of a bagel.
$9.50 - Jersey Special
Taylor Pork Roll Egg & Cheese
$8.49 - The Original #6
2 Eggs, Bacon, Sausage, BH Deluxe Ham, Cheese on your choice of bagel.
$7.29 - Egg White Avocado
Egg Whites, Diced Tomatoes, Smashed Avocado, Choose Your Cheese and Bagel.
$8.50 - Brothers Deluxe
3 eggs scrambled, Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Cheese & Potatoes served on our hero bread.
$9.50 - Steak Egg & Cheese Sandwich
Scrambled Eggs, Grilled Seasoned Beef, Choice of Cheese on a fresh baked Bagel
$8.30 - Turkey Egg And Cheese
2 Eggs, Boar's Head Ovengold Turkey, choice of Cheese.
$8.30 - Just 2 Eggs$6.00
Freshly Baked Bagels
Bagel with
- Plain Bagel$1.85
- Poppy Bagel$1.85
- Sesame$1.85
- 7 Grain$1.85
- Everything Bagel$1.85
- Asiago Parmesan$2.25
- Cheddar Bacon Chive$2.25
- Cheese Bagel$2.25
- Cheesy Everything$2.25
- Jalapeño Cheddar$2.25
- Pesto Mozzarella$2.25
- Spinach Parmesan$2.25
- Bialy$1.99
- Blueberry$1.85
- Cinnamon Raisin$1.85
- Whole Wheat$1.85
- Cinnamon Sugar$1.85
- Egg$1.85
- Egg Everything$1.85
- Egg Onion$1.85
- Engish Bagel$1.85
- French Toast$1.85
- Garlic Bagel$1.85
- Minis$1.40
- Minis$1.40
- Onion Bagel$1.85
- Pumpernickel$1.85
- Rainbow$2.75
- Salt$1.85
- Special$2.25
Spreads by the Pound
- Plain Cream Cheese$2.25
- Vegetable Cream Cheese$2.99
- Chopped Scallion Cream Cheese$2.99
- Bacon Scallion Cream Cheese$2.99
- LOX Spread Cream Cheese$3.50
- Butter$1.59
- Honey Butter$1.25
- Cinnamon Raisin Cream Cheese$2.99
- Cinnamon Sugar Cream Cheese$2.99
- Blueberry Cream Cheese$2.49OUT OF STOCK
- Honey Walnut Cream Cheese$2.99
- Olive Pimento Cream Cheese$2.99
- NEW! Nutella$2.99
- Caramelized Onion$2.99
Classic Breakfast
- Belgian Waffle
Belgian Waffle / Maple syrup/ add breakfast potatoes/sausage or bacon
$9.90 - Challah French Toast
Two thick cu challah slices/ powdered sugar/ breakfast potatoes/ bacon or sausage
$9.90 - The Classic Platter
Two eggs your way/ bacon or sausage/ breakfast potatoes/ bagel
$9.75 - Home Fries
An order of our seasoned red potatoes.
$3.50 - Side of Bacon$2.75
- Side of Sausage$2.75
Omelettes
- Garden Veggie
Cherry Tomatoes, Bell Peppers, Baby Spinach, Sliced Mushrooms, Scallions, Diced Onions.
$9.79 - Spinach Florentine
Baby Spinach, Melted Pepper Jack Cheese, Diced Tomatoes.
$9.79 - Original Leo
Acme Chopped Nova, Diced fresh onions.
$10.75 - Classic Western
Bell Peppers, Spanish Onions, Sliced Mushrooms, Diced Ham, Diced Tomatoes.
$10.49 - Build Your Own Omelette$10.99
Weekly Specials
- Thanksgiving Wrap (Seasonal)
Roasted Turkey, Stuffing, Cranberry Sauce, Gravy & Mashed Potatoes on a Plain Pressed Wrap.
$10.99OUT OF STOCK - Italian Slam
Deluxe Ham, Genoa Salami, Capicola, Picante Provolone Cheese, Giardiniera, Red Onions, Tomato, Leaf Lettuce, Aioli, Pressed Gourmet Asiago Ciabatta.
$13.00 - Healthy Croissant
Our Homemade Chicken Salad, grapes, celery, walnuts & mixed greens on a fresh baked Croissant.
$11.00 - Bourbon Street
Bagel Brothers Original - Grilled Blackened Chicken, Smoked Bacon, Melted Pepper Jack Cheese, Baby Spinach, Sauteed Onions, Cajun Mayo on a pressed Ciabatta.
$10.44 - Eggplant Special (Friday Only)
Fried Eggplant, Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Sliced Mozzarella, Honey pesto Mayo on our Kalamata Olive Bread.
$11.79OUT OF STOCK
Bakery
- 6 oz Jumbo Muffins$3.95
- Homemade Crumb Cake$4.25
- Fresh Baked Brownie$4.25
- Assorted Danishes$2.95
- Linzer Tarts$2.85
- Carnegie Black & Whites$3.25
- Apple Turnovers$2.85
- Fresh Baked Cinnamon Rolls$3.25
- Assorted Butter Cookie Package Small$6.99
- Assorted Rugelach Package$6.99OUT OF STOCK
- Rainbow Cookies (by the lb)$10.99
Avocado Toast
- Smoked Salmon
Acme Smoked Nova, Housemade Avocado Mash, Everything Bagel Seasoning, Herb Salad, Red Onions, Capers, Drizzled with EVOO, Sliced Multigrain Toast.
$13.49 - Caprese (NEW)
Housemade Avocado Mash, thin sliced tomatoes, Fresh sliced Mozzarella, Basil infused Olive Oil, drizzled with Balsamic Glaze on Multigrain Toast.
$12.99 - Grated Egg Avocado
Hard Boiled Eggs Grated, Housemade Avocado Mash, Kosher Salt & Pepper, Mayo, Light Siracha Sauce, Drizzled with EVOO, Multigrain Toast.
$12.49
Signature Sandwiches 🥪
- French Dipper
Thin sliced beef, melted provolone cheese, caramelized onions on a fresh baked hero, served with our house made Au jus.
$11.59 - B.L.T
Smoked Bacon / Leaf Lettuce / Sliced Tomato / Herb Mayo / Buttery Brioche
$9.45 - Healthy Croissant
Our Homemade Chicken Salad, grapes, celery, walnuts & mixed greens on a fresh baked Croissant.
$11.00 - Smokehouse
Smoked Turkey, Sliced Cheddar Cheese, Crispy Bacon and our Housemade BBQ Mayo
$10.75 - Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, croutons, Caesar dressing on a wrap
$10.60 - Cracked Russian
Boar's Head Cracked Pepper Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, topped with Russian Dressing on a Kaiser Roll or Bagel of your choice.
$11.99 - California Dreaming
Roasted Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Avocado, Sliced Tomato, Lemon Aioli, Pressed Ciabatta.
$10.29 - Grilled Cheese With Fries
Our thick sliced Challah Bread, melted cheese of your choice, served with our house cut seasoned fries.
$8.99 - Grilled Ham And Cheese With Fries
Our thick sliced Challah Bread, melted cheese of your choice, Boar's Head Sliced Ham, served with our house cut seasoned fries.
$9.99 - Eggplant Special (Friday Only)
Fried Eggplant, Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Sliced Mozzarella, Honey pesto Mayo on our Kalamata Olive Bread.
$11.79OUT OF STOCK
Panini - Wraps
- Thanksgiving Wrap (Seasonal)
Roasted Turkey, Stuffing, Cranberry Sauce, Gravy & Mashed Potatoes on a Plain Pressed Wrap.
$10.99OUT OF STOCK - NEW! Firesmith Chicken Ciabatta
Boar's Head Firesmith Chicken, smoked Gouda Cheese, Bacon, lettuce, tomato and our own Roasted Red Pepper Spread on a rustic ciabatta.
$12.00 - The Cubano
Our Slow Roasted Pork, Ham, Swiss Cheese, Pickles, Mustard on a pressed Ciabatta.
$10.29 - Bourbon Street
Bagel Brothers Original - Grilled Blackened Chicken, Smoked Bacon, Melted Pepper Jack Cheese, Baby Spinach, Sauteed Onions, Cajun Mayo on a pressed Ciabatta.
$10.44 - Italian Slam
Deluxe Ham, Genoa Salami, Capicola, Picante Provolone Cheese, Giardiniera, Red Onions, Tomato, Leaf Lettuce, Aioli, Pressed Gourmet Asiago Ciabatta.
$13.00 - Chicken Caesar Wrap
Seasoned Grilled Chicken, Romaine, Croutons, Parmesan Cheese, Caesar Dressing, Wheat or Plain Wrap.
$10.75 - Garden Delight Wrap
Sliced Avocado, Cucumber, Carrots, Tomatoes, Spinach, Lettuce, Brothers House Dressing, In a Wheat or Plain Wrap.
$10.75
Deli Salad Sandwiches & By the 1 lb
Carnegie Deli Classics
- The Carnegie Hot Pastrami
Half Pound of Carnegie World Famous Pastrami, Swiss and Carnegie Mustard on a Bagel or NY Rye Bread.
$13.99 - The Carnegie Hot Corned Beef
A Half Pound OF World Famous Carnegie Corned Beef, Carnegie Mustard or Russian Dressing on a Bagel or NY Rye Bread.
$13.99 - The Carnegie Reuben
A half Pound of World Famous Carnegie Deli Pastrami, with Carnegie Mustard, Swiss, Sauerkraut on a Bagel or NY Rye.
$13.99 - The Carnegie One Pounder
A half pound of Carnegie Corned Beef & World Famous Pastrami, Sauerkraut, Swiss and Carnegie Mustard on NY Rye Bread
$17.99
Deli by the pound
- Acme Sliced Nova$9.50
- White Fish Salad$4.25
- Solid White Albacore Tuna$3.99
- Vegetable Tuna$3.24
- Everroast Chicken Salad Sandwich
Everroast Chicken Salad, craisins, celery, golden raisins, mayo, lettuce & tomato on your choice of bread or bagel.
$3.75 - Homemade Chicken Salad$3.40
- Healthy Chicken Salad$3.34
- Egg Salad$2.49
- Shrimp Salad$3.75
- Potato Salad$2.24
- Creamy Cole Slaw$1.99
- Cucumber Salad$2.24
Boar's Head / Carnegie Deli by the Pound
- American Cheese
Crafted from a hand-selected blend of rich, savory Cheddars, this all-American cheese has a smooth, creamy texture and pleasantly mild taste. Boar's Head American Cheese is an amazingly meltable, flavorful classic.
$11.99 - Picante Provolone Cheese
Made in the Old World manner, this versatile cheese has a distinctly sharp taste. Boar's Head Picante Provolone Cheese is aged more than 5 months to produce a full-bodied flavor and smooth, creamy texture.
$11.99 - Ovengold Turkey
Delivering homestyle flavor in every tender slice, Boar’s Head Ovengold Turkey Breast is seasoned with aromatic spices and slow roasted to perfection according to a family recipe for a taste of home.
- Deluxe Ham
It all started with Branded Deluxe Ham. Slow cooked for a tender taste, this was our very first product and continues to be a favorite today.
- London Broil Roast Beef
Hand-trimmed and carefully seasoned with garlic, and onion. This cut is then slow-roasted to tender perfection. Our house made London Broil Cap-Off Top Round Oven Roasted Beef packs classic meaty flavor in each rich and savory slice.
- Navel Pastrami
This flavorful cut is hand-trimmed and expertly seasoned, then brined and cured using traditional methods. Great for grilling!
- Genoa Salami
Hand-crafted according to century-old Salumiere traditions, Boar's Head Genoa Salami boasts a robust flavor from an expert blend of pork with peppercorns.
- Pepperoni
A rich blend of pork, beef and spices cured according to traditional methods, Boar's Head Pepperoni is packed with robust flavor.
- Carnegie Deli Corned Beef
Our corned beef is cured then simmered long and slow until juicy, succulent and tender. There is literally no excuse for not piling this drool-worthy corned beef perfection sky high.
- Carnegie Deli Pastrami
It’s the recipe that made the Carnegie Deli famous. Our pastrami is brined, seasoned and smoked with our secret family recipe.
Daily Soups
Drinks
- Coffee$2.29
- Blackout Iced Coffee Can
Indulge in the smooth, rich taste of our Ready-to-Drink Coffee Latte. Perfect for on-the-go enjoyment, anytime, anywhere.
$4.29 - Orchid Island OJ$4.25
- Chocolate Milk$2.89
- Pint Milk$2.79
- Fountain Drink$2.69
- Martinellis Apple Juice
10 fl. oz. glass bottle contains 100% juice from U.S. grown fresh apples. It contains no chemical additives and is not from concentrate. Just premium apple juice.
$3.99 - Dr Browns$2.79
- Manhattan Specials$3.99
- JOES Teas$3.99
- OLDE Brooklyn Sodas$2.79
- Bottle Water$1.89
- Box of Joe regular (10 Cups)$19.99
- Box of Joe flavor (10 Cups)$21.99
NEW STORE MENU (3PD)
NEW!!! Original Philly Cheesesteak
SECRET Old School Menu ( Available for Pick Up & Delivery )
- Bourbon Street
Grilled Blackened Chicken / Smoked Bacon / Melted Cheddar / Baby Spinach / Sauteed Onions / Cajun Mayo / Sliced Ciabatta
$10.44 - Smokehouse
Smoked Turkey, Sliced Cheddar Cheese, Crispy Bacon and our Housemade BBQ Mayo
$10.75 - Healthy Croissant
Our Homemade Chicken Salad, grapes, celery, walnuts & mixed greens on a fresh baked Croissant.
$11.00 - Cracked Russian
Boar's Head Cracked Pepper Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, topped with Russian Dressing on a Kaiser Roll or Bagel of your choice.
$11.99 - Toasted Chicken Muenster
Boar's Head sliced Chicken, Muenster Cheese, Spinach, Tomatoes, House made Chipotle Sauce on a toasted Panini
$11.99
NEW! Breakfast Burritos
- Huevorito
Burrito with 3 scrambled eggs, smashed tots, sautéed peppers & onions, house made Pico de Gallo & shredded Cheddar Jack Cheese and our Signature Bros Sauce.
$11.29 - SpicyRito
Burrito with 3 scrambled eggs, smashed tots, sausage, pickled jalapeños & shredded Cheddar Jack Cheese, topped with our Signature Bros Sauce.
$11.29 - CaliforniaRito
Burrito with Sauteed peppers & onions, 3 scrambled eggs, shredded Cheddar Jack Cheese, our smashed avocado spread, topped with our Signature Bros Sauce.
$11.29 - PastramiRito
Burrito with Carnegie Deli Pastrami, 3 scrambled eggs, shredded Cheddar Jack Cheese, smashed tots and our Signature Bros Sauce.
$11.29
NEW! Crispy Chicken Sandwiches
- Nashville Hot Chicken
Our Crispy Chicken, tossed in our Nashville sauce, sliced pickles, topped with our house made creamy Cole Slaw.
$13.99 - Crispy Cordon Bleu
Crispy Chicken, Boar's Head sliced Ham, Melted Swiss Cheese & Boar's Head Honey Mustard.
$13.99 - Spicy Chipotle
Crispy Chicken, melted Pepper Jack Cheese, sliced pickled jalapenos and our house made chipotle sauce.
$13.99 - Crispy Avocado Ranch
Our Crispy Chicken, avocado mash, bacon, melted Cheddar Cheese and ranch dressing.
$13.99
Freshly Baked Bagels
Spreads by the Pound
- NEW! Nutella$3.50
- Plain Cream Cheese$2.99
- Vegetable Cream Cheese$2.99
- Chopped Scallion Cream Cheese$2.99
- Bacon Scallion Cream Cheese$3.12
- LOX Spread Cream Cheese$3.50
- Butter$1.04
- Honey Butter$1.04
- Cinnamon Raisin Cream Cheese$2.99
- Cinnamon Sugar Cream Cheese$2.99
- Blueberry Cream Cheese$2.61OUT OF STOCK
- Honey Walnut Cream Cheese$2.99
- Olive Pimento Cream Cheese$2.99
- Caramelized Onion$2.61OUT OF STOCK
Classic Breakfast
- Belgian Waffle
Belgian Waffle / Maple syrup/ add breakfast potatoes/sausage or bacon
$9.90 - The Classic Platter
Two eggs your way/ bacon or sausage/ breakfast potatoes/ bagel
$10.50 - Challah French Toast
Two thick cu challah slices/ powdered sugar/ breakfast potatoes/ bacon or sausage
$10.50 - Home Fries$3.50
- Side of Bacon$2.75
- Side of Sausage$2.75
Omelettes
- Garden Veggie
Cherry Tomatoes, Bell Peppers, Baby Spinach, Sliced Mushrooms, Scallions, Diced Onions.
$10.50 - Spinach Florentine
Baby Spinach, Melted Pepper Jack Cheese, Diced Tomatoes.
$11.25 - Classic Western
Bell Peppers, Spanish Onions, Sliced Mushrooms, Diced Ham, Diced Tomatoes.
$11.50 - Original Leo
Acme Chopped Nova, Diced fresh onions.
$11.75 - Build Your Own Omelette$11.75
Weekly Specials
- Matzo Ball Soup
House Made Daily! Available in grab and go, take home and heat up....mmmmm
$5.29 - French Dipper
Thin sliced beef, melted provolone cheese, caramelized onions on a fresh baked hero, served with our house made Au jus.
$11.59 - Carnegie Pastrami Egg & Cheese
Carnegie Deli Pastrami sliced thin & grilled, 2 eggs and Swiss Cheese on your choice of Bagel.
$9.29 - Eggplant Special (Friday Only)
Fried Eggplant, Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Sliced Mozzarella, Honey pesto Mayo on our Kalamata Olive Bread.
$11.99OUT OF STOCK - Panni Perfection
Breaded Chicken Cutlet / Sauteed Spinach / Red Peppers / Homemade Mozzarella / Honey Pesto Mayo
$10.99 - Bourbon Street
Bagel Brothers Original - Grilled Blackened Chicken, Smoked Bacon, Melted Pepper Jack Cheese, Baby Spinach, Sauteed Onions, Cajun Mayo on a pressed Ciabatta.
$10.96 - BB Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, Romaine, Croutons, Parmesan Cheese, Caesar Dressing, Wheat or Plain Wrap.
$11.29 - Italian Slam
Deluxe Ham, Genoa Salami, Capicola, Picante Provolone Cheese, Giardiniera, Red Onions, Tomato, Leaf Lettuce, Aioli, Pressed Gourmet Asiago Ciabatta.
$13.65
Avocado Toast
- Smoked Salmon
Acme Smoked Nova, Housemade Avocado Mash, Everything Bagel Seasoning, Herb Salad, Red Onions, Capers, Drizzled with EVOO, Sliced Multigrain Toast.
$14.16 - Caprese (NEW)
Housemade Avocado Mash, thin sliced tomatoes, Fresh sliced Mozzarella, Basil infused Olive Oil, drizzled with Balsamic Glaze on Multigrain Toast.
$13.11 - Grated Egg Avocado
Hard Boiled Eggs Grated, Housemade Avocado Mash, Kosher Salt & Pepper, Mayo, Light Siracha Sauce, Drizzled with EVOO, Multigrain Toast.
$13.11
Bakery
Panini - Wraps
- Thanksgiving Wrap (Seasonal)
Roasted Turkey, Stuffing, Cranberry Sauce, Gravy & Mashed Potatoes on a Plain Pressed Wrap.
$10.99OUT OF STOCK - Cheddar Steak Melt
Thinly Sliced Beef, Caramelized Onions, Melted Cheddar, Horseradish Mayo, Sliced Texas Toast.
$10.80 - The Cubano
Our Slow Roasted Pork, Ham, Swiss Cheese, Pickles, Mustard on a pressed Ciabatta.
$10.80 - California Dreaming
Roasted Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Avocado, Sliced Tomato, Lemon Aioli, Pressed Ciabatta.
$10.80 - Bourbon Street
Bagel Brothers Original - Grilled Blackened Chicken, Smoked Bacon, Melted Pepper Jack Cheese, Baby Spinach, Sauteed Onions, Cajun Mayo on a pressed Ciabatta.
$10.96 - Italian Slam
Deluxe Ham, Genoa Salami, Capicola, Picante Provolone Cheese, Giardiniera, Red Onions, Tomato, Leaf Lettuce, Aioli, Pressed Gourmet Asiago Ciabatta.
$13.65 - BB Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, Romaine, Croutons, Parmesan Cheese, Caesar Dressing, Wheat or Plain Wrap.
$11.29 - Garden Delight Wrap
Sliced Avocado, Cucumber, Carrots, Tomatoes, Spinach, Lettuce, Brothers House Dressing, In a Wheat or Plain Wrap.
$11.29
Deli Salad Sandwiches
Carnegie Deli Classics
- The Carnegie Hot Pastrami
Half Pound of Carnegie World Famous Pastrami, Swiss and Carnegie Mustard on a Bagel or NY Rye Bread.
$14.69 - The Carnegie Hot Corned Beef
A Half Pound OF World Famous Carnegie Corned Beef, Carnegie Mustard or Russian Dressing on a Bagel or NY Rye Bread.
$14.69 - The Carnegie Reuben
A half Pound of World Famous Carnegie Deli Pastrami, with Carnegie Mustard, Swiss, Sauerkraut on a Bagel or NY Rye.
$14.69 - The Carnegie One Pounder
A half pound of Carnegie Corned Beef & World Famous Pastrami, Sauerkraut, Swiss and Carnegie Mustard on NY Rye Bread
$18.89
Signature Sandwiches 🥪
- Spicy Chipotle
Crispy Chicken, melted Pepper Jack Cheese, sliced pickled jalapenos and our house made chipotle sauce.
$13.99 - Panini Perfection
Breaded Chicken Cutlets, Sauteed Spinach, roasted red peppers, fresh made Mozzarella Cheese and our Honey Pesto Dressing.
$10.87 - French Dipper
Thin sliced beef, melted provolone cheese, caramelized onions on a fresh baked hero, served with our house made Au jus.
$11.12 - B.L.T
Smoked Bacon / Leaf Lettuce / Sliced Tomato / Herb Mayo / Buttery Brioche
$9.92 - Healthy Croissant
Our Homemade Chicken Salad, grapes, celery, walnuts & mixed greens on a fresh baked Croissant
$11.33 - The Donna
Navel Pastrami, Melted Swiss Cheese, Deli Mustard, Rye Bread.
$12.23 - Turkey Chipotle
Sliced Ovengold Turkey, Pepper Jack Cheese, Crisp Lettuce, Sliced Tomato, Smoked Bacon, Chipotle Mayo of Multigrain Bread.
$10.87 - Smokehouse
Smoked Turkey, Sliced Cheddar Cheese, Crispy Bacon and our Housemade BBQ Mayo
$11.29 - Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, croutons, Caesar dressing on a wrap
$11.13 - Grilled Cheese With Fries
Our thick sliced Challah Bread, melted cheese of your choice, served with our house cut seasoned fries.
$9.44 - Grilled Ham And Cheese With Fries
Our thick sliced Challah Bread, melted cheese of your choice, Boar's Head Sliced Ham, served with our house cut seasoned fries.
$10.49
Daily Soups
Deli by the pound
Drinks
- Blackout Drip Coffee
We source premium specialty grade green coffee beans which are graded at 80 points or above on a 100-point scale. Specialty coffees are grown at the perfect altitude, at the correct time of year, in the best soil, and then are harvested at just the right time. We work with local co-ops and farmers that grow this high-quality coffee and we adopt a strict adherence to small batch roasting our coffee.
$2.30 - Coca Cola Fountain Drink$2.61
- Martinellis Apple Juice
10 fl. oz. glass bottle contains 100% juice from U.S. grown fresh apples. It contains no chemical additives and is not from concentrate. Just premium apple juice.
$3.99 - Orchid Island OJ
Life is complicated enough. Natalie’s keeps it simple, which is why there are minimal ingredients in each juice. No preservatives. No artificial ingredients. No GMOs. Nothing to deter you from the optimal health that lives within each bottle of Natalie’s juice.
$4.25 - Pint Milk$2.78
- JOES Teas$3.99
- Dr Browns$2.78
- Bottle Water$1.98
- Mini Orchid OJ$3.15
- Iced Coffee$2.93
- Chocolate Milk$2.99
- Box of Joe flavor$20.99
- Box of Joe regular$20.99
Hot + Iced Drinks
*NEW* Acme Smoked Fish Grab & Go
- Acme Smoked Sliced Salmon 4oz Pkge
Our line of nova salmon packs are made from Atlantic salmon rich in omega-3 fatty acids. These hand cut fillets are cured using just the right blend of ingredients, and slowly smoked with real hardwood chips. These techniques have been in our family recipe for four generations.
$10.38 - Acme Everything Seasoned Sliced Salmon 4oz Pkge
Our blend of garlic, onion, sesame seeds, and poppy seeds seasons Acme's Premium Smoked Salmon, recreating everything you love about an everything bagel!
$11.18 - Acme Pre Packed Kippered Salmon 9oz Pkge
Acme’s hot smoked salmon is bursting with rich flavors steeped in tradition. Our Atlantic kippered salmon, also known as baked salmon, is ideally portioned to be the center of plate or the perfect complement to any recipe.
$17.69 - Acme Pre Packed White Fish 9oz Pkge
Acme’s hot smoked wild caught whitefish is bursting with rich flavors steeped in tradition. This golden, white-fleshed, fresh water fish from the Great Lakes provides a delectable smokey flavor that is perfect for any meal.
$11.54 - St. James Reserve Smoked Salmon Whiskey/Honey 4oz Pkge
A pairing of single malt scotch whisky and honey creates a refined and luxuriously smooth flavor. A bold oak smoke profile complements the peaty flavor from the whiskey. The honey creates a balance of sweet and salt enhancing the delicate Scottish salmon.
$9.96OUT OF STOCK - St. James Reserve Smoked Salmon Gravadlax 4oz Pkge
A twist on a classic Scottish delicacy, this premier smoked salmon is infused with blossom honey, mustard, and dill sauce to present aromatic, vibrant, and complex flavor that is sure to make your dishes stand out.
$9.96OUT OF STOCK
Kids Menu 🧒
Owner / Otter Menu
NEW!!! Original Philly Cheesesteak
NEW! Breakfast Burritos
- Huevorito
Burrito with 3 scrambled eggs, smashed tots, sautéed peppers & onions, house made Pico de Gallo & shredded Cheddar Jack Cheese and our Signature Bros Sauce.
$11.29 - SpicyRito
Burrito with 3 scrambled eggs, smashed tots, sausage, pickled jalapeños & shredded Cheddar Jack Cheese, topped with our Signature Bros Sauce.
$11.29 - CaliforniaRito
Burrito with Sauteed peppers & onions, 3 scrambled eggs, shredded Cheddar Jack Cheese, our smashed avocado spread, topped with our Signature Bros Sauce.
$11.29 - PastramiRito
Burrito with Carnegie Deli Pastrami, 3 scrambled eggs, shredded Cheddar Jack Cheese, smashed tots and our Signature Bros Sauce.
$11.29
NEW! Crispy Chicken Sandwiches
- Nashville Hot Chicken
Our Crispy Chicken, tossed in our Nashville sauce, sliced pickles, topped with our house made creamy Cole Slaw.
$12.99 - Crispy Cordon Bleu
Crispy Chicken, Boar's Head sliced Ham, Melted Swiss Cheese & Boar's Head Honey Mustard.
$10.99 - Spicy Chipotle
Crispy Chicken, melted Pepper Jack Cheese, sliced pickled jalapenos and our house made chipotle sauce.
$10.99 - Crispy Avocado Ranch
Our Crispy Chicken, avocado mash, bacon, melted Cheddar Cheese and ranch dressing.
$10.99
Freshly Baked Bagels
Spreads by the Pound
- NEW! Nutella$3.50
- Plain Cream Cheese$2.99
- Vegetable Cream Cheese$2.99
- Chopped Scallion Cream Cheese$2.99
- Bacon Scallion Cream Cheese$3.12
- LOX Spread Cream Cheese$3.50
- Butter$1.04
- Honey Butter$1.04
- Cinnamon Raisin Cream Cheese$2.99
- Cinnamon Sugar Cream Cheese$2.99
- Blueberry Cream Cheese$2.61OUT OF STOCK
- Honey Walnut Cream Cheese$2.99
- Olive Pimento Cream Cheese$2.99
- Caramelized Onion$2.61OUT OF STOCK
Classic Breakfast
- Belgian Waffle
Belgian Waffle / Maple syrup/ add breakfast potatoes/sausage or bacon
$9.90 - The Classic Platter
Two eggs your way/ bacon or sausage/ breakfast potatoes/ bagel
$10.50 - Challah French Toast
Two thick cu challah slices/ powdered sugar/ breakfast potatoes/ bacon or sausage
$10.50 - Home Fries$3.50
- Side of Bacon$2.75
- Side of Sausage$2.75
Omelettes
- Garden Veggie
Cherry Tomatoes, Bell Peppers, Baby Spinach, Sliced Mushrooms, Scallions, Diced Onions.
$10.50 - Spinach Florentine
Baby Spinach, Melted Pepper Jack Cheese, Diced Tomatoes.
$11.25 - Original Leo
Acme Chopped Nova, Diced fresh onions.
$11.75 - Classic Western
Bell Peppers, Spanish Onions, Sliced Mushrooms, Diced Ham, Diced Tomatoes.
$11.50 - Build Your Own Omelette$11.75
Weekly Specials
- Brown Sugar & Spice Holiday Ham
Boar's Head Brown Sugar & Spiced Ham, Melty Vermont Cheddar Cheese, Honey sweet sugar glaze on pressed buttery multigrain ciabatta.
$11.99 - Matzo Ball Soup
House Made Daily! Available in grab and go, take home and heat up....mmmmm
$5.29 - French Dipper
Thin sliced beef, melted provolone cheese, caramelized onions on a fresh baked hero, served with our house made Au jus.
$11.59 - Carnegie Pastrami Egg & Cheese
Carnegie Deli Pastrami sliced thin & grilled, 2 eggs and Swiss Cheese on your choice of Bagel.
$9.29 - Eggplant Special (Friday Only)
Fried Eggplant, Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Sliced Mozzarella, Honey pesto Mayo on our Kalamata Olive Bread.
$11.79OUT OF STOCK - Panni Perfection
Breaded Chicken Cutlet / Sauteed Spinach / Red Peppers / Homemade Mozzarella / Honey Pesto Mayo
$10.99 - Bourbon Street
Bagel Brothers Original - Grilled Blackened Chicken, Smoked Bacon, Melted Pepper Jack Cheese, Baby Spinach, Sauteed Onions, Cajun Mayo on a pressed Ciabatta.
$10.44 - BB Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, Romaine, Croutons, Parmesan Cheese, Caesar Dressing, Wheat or Plain Wrap.
$10.75 - Italian Slam
Deluxe Ham, Genoa Salami, Capicola, Picante Provolone Cheese, Giardiniera, Red Onions, Tomato, Leaf Lettuce, Aioli, Pressed Gourmet Asiago Ciabatta.
$13.00
Avocado Toast
- Smoked Salmon
Acme Smoked Nova, Housemade Avocado Mash, Everything Bagel Seasoning, Herb Salad, Red Onions, Capers, Drizzled with EVOO, Sliced Multigrain Toast.
$13.49 - Caprese (NEW)
Housemade Avocado Mash, thin sliced tomatoes, Fresh sliced Mozzarella, Basil infused Olive Oil, drizzled with Balsamic Glaze on Multigrain Toast.
$12.99 - Grated Egg Avocado
Hard Boiled Eggs Grated, Housemade Avocado Mash, Kosher Salt & Pepper, Mayo, Light Siracha Sauce, Drizzled with EVOO, Multigrain Toast.
$12.49
Bakery
Panini - Wraps
- Thanksgiving Wrap (Seasonal)
Roasted Turkey, Stuffing, Cranberry Sauce, Gravy & Mashed Potatoes on a Plain Pressed Wrap.
$10.99OUT OF STOCK - Cheddar Steak Melt
Thinly Sliced Beef, Caramelized Onions, Melted Cheddar, Horseradish Mayo, Sliced Texas Toast.
$10.29 - The Cubano
Our Slow Roasted Pork, Ham, Swiss Cheese, Pickles, Mustard on a pressed Ciabatta.
$10.29 - California Dreaming
Roasted Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Avocado, Sliced Tomato, Lemon Aioli, Pressed Ciabatta.
$10.29 - Bourbon Street
Bagel Brothers Original - Grilled Blackened Chicken, Smoked Bacon, Melted Pepper Jack Cheese, Baby Spinach, Sauteed Onions, Cajun Mayo on a pressed Ciabatta.
$10.44 - Italian Slam
Deluxe Ham, Genoa Salami, Capicola, Picante Provolone Cheese, Giardiniera, Red Onions, Tomato, Leaf Lettuce, Aioli, Pressed Gourmet Asiago Ciabatta.
$13.00 - BB Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, Romaine, Croutons, Parmesan Cheese, Caesar Dressing, Wheat or Plain Wrap.
$10.75 - Garden Delight Wrap
Sliced Avocado, Cucumber, Carrots, Tomatoes, Spinach, Lettuce, Brothers House Dressing, In a Wheat or Plain Wrap.
$10.75
Deli Salad Sandwiches
Carnegie Deli Classics
- The Carnegie Hot Pastrami
Half Pound of Carnegie World Famous Pastrami, Swiss and Carnegie Mustard on a Bagel or NY Rye Bread.
$13.99 - The Carnegie Hot Corned Beef
A Half Pound OF World Famous Carnegie Corned Beef, Carnegie Mustard or Russian Dressing on a Bagel or NY Rye Bread.
$13.99 - The Carnegie Reuben
A half Pound of World Famous Carnegie Deli Pastrami, with Carnegie Mustard, Swiss, Sauerkraut on a Bagel or NY Rye.
$13.99 - The Carnegie One Pounder
A half pound of Carnegie Corned Beef & World Famous Pastrami, Sauerkraut, Swiss and Carnegie Mustard on NY Rye Bread
$17.99
Signature Sandwiches 🥪
- Spicy Chipotle
Crispy Chicken, melted Pepper Jack Cheese, sliced pickled jalapenos and our house made chipotle sauce.
$10.99 - Panini Perfection
Breaded Chicken Cutlets, Sauteed Spinach, roasted red peppers, fresh made Mozzarella Cheese and our Honey Pesto Dressing.
$10.35 - French Dipper
Thin sliced beef, melted provolone cheese, caramelized onions on a fresh baked hero, served with our house made Au jus.
$10.59 - B.L.T
Smoked Bacon / Leaf Lettuce / Sliced Tomato / Herb Mayo / Buttery Brioche
$9.45 - Healthy Croissant
Our Homemade Chicken Salad, grapes, celery, walnuts & mixed greens on a fresh baked Croissant
$10.79 - The Donna
Navel Pastrami, Melted Swiss Cheese, Deli Mustard, Rye Bread.
$11.65 - Turkey Chipotle
Sliced Ovengold Turkey, Pepper Jack Cheese, Crisp Lettuce, Sliced Tomato, Smoked Bacon, Chipotle Mayo of Multigrain Bread.
$10.35 - Smokehouse
Smoked Turkey, Sliced Cheddar Cheese, Crispy Bacon and our Housemade BBQ Mayo
$10.75 - Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken, romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, croutons, Caesar dressing on a wrap
$10.60 - Grilled Cheese With Fries
Our thick sliced Challah Bread, melted cheese of your choice, served with our house cut seasoned fries.
$8.99 - Grilled Ham And Cheese With Fries
Our thick sliced Challah Bread, melted cheese of your choice, Boar's Head Sliced Ham, served with our house cut seasoned fries.
$9.99
Daily Soups
Deli by the pound
Drinks
- Blackout Drip Coffee
We source premium specialty grade green coffee beans which are graded at 80 points or above on a 100-point scale. Specialty coffees are grown at the perfect altitude, at the correct time of year, in the best soil, and then are harvested at just the right time. We work with local co-ops and farmers that grow this high-quality coffee and we adopt a strict adherence to small batch roasting our coffee.
$2.19 - Coca Cola Fountain Drink$2.49
- Martinellis Apple Juice
10 fl. oz. glass bottle contains 100% juice from U.S. grown fresh apples. It contains no chemical additives and is not from concentrate. Just premium apple juice.
$3.99 - Orchid Island OJ
Life is complicated enough. Natalie’s keeps it simple, which is why there are minimal ingredients in each juice. No preservatives. No artificial ingredients. No GMOs. Nothing to deter you from the optimal health that lives within each bottle of Natalie’s juice.
$4.25 - Pint Milk$2.65
- JOES Teas$3.99
- Dr Browns$2.65
- Bottle Water$1.89
- Mini Orchid OJ$3.00
- Iced Coffee$2.79
- Chocolate Milk$2.99
- Box of Joe flavor$19.99
- Box of Joe regular$19.99
Hot + Iced Drinks
*NEW* Acme Smoked Fish Grab & Go
- Acme Smoked Sliced Salmon 4oz Pkge
Our line of nova salmon packs are made from Atlantic salmon rich in omega-3 fatty acids. These hand cut fillets are cured using just the right blend of ingredients, and slowly smoked with real hardwood chips. These techniques have been in our family recipe for four generations.
$9.89 - Acme Everything Seasoned Sliced Salmon 4oz Pkge
Our blend of garlic, onion, sesame seeds, and poppy seeds seasons Acme's Premium Smoked Salmon, recreating everything you love about an everything bagel!
$10.65 - Acme Pre Packed Kippered Salmon 9oz Pkge
Acme’s hot smoked salmon is bursting with rich flavors steeped in tradition. Our Atlantic kippered salmon, also known as baked salmon, is ideally portioned to be the center of plate or the perfect complement to any recipe.
$16.85 - Acme Pre Packed White Fish 9oz Pkge
Acme’s hot smoked wild caught whitefish is bursting with rich flavors steeped in tradition. This golden, white-fleshed, fresh water fish from the Great Lakes provides a delectable smokey flavor that is perfect for any meal.
$10.99 - St. James Reserve Smoked Salmon Whiskey/Honey 4oz Pkge
A pairing of single malt scotch whisky and honey creates a refined and luxuriously smooth flavor. A bold oak smoke profile complements the peaty flavor from the whiskey. The honey creates a balance of sweet and salt enhancing the delicate Scottish salmon.
$9.49OUT OF STOCK - St. James Reserve Smoked Salmon Gravadlax 4oz Pkge
A twist on a classic Scottish delicacy, this premier smoked salmon is infused with blossom honey, mustard, and dill sauce to present aromatic, vibrant, and complex flavor that is sure to make your dishes stand out.
$9.49OUT OF STOCK
Sunday | 6:00 am - 3:00 pm |
Monday | 6:00 am - 3:00 pm |
Tuesday | 6:00 am - 3:00 pm |
Wednesday | 6:00 am - 3:00 pm |
Thursday | 6:00 am - 3:00 pm |
Friday | 6:00 am - 3:00 pm |
Saturday | 6:00 am - 3:00 pm |
“For 25 years, our experienced bakers have worked to produce daily-made small batches of bagels – so fresh you’ll feel like it’s the first time you’ve tried one.” Bread flour, water, and yeast are the simple, time-tested foundation of this true family recipe. Passed on and perfected, our bagel recipe has represented the satisfying route to natural, delicious eating for years. Our harvest is yours; become part of the wealth of fresh flavor that our bagels bring with every taste. - Joseph Carfino and Jason Dippolito, Co-Owners of Bagel Brothers of NY