El Maguey - Salem
No reviews yet
28 public square
Salem, IN 47167
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Entree_Maguey Menu
Appetizers
- Chile Rellenos (2)$11.99
- Wings$9.99
(boneless or bone-in) Ten fresh chicken wingsfried and glazed with your choice of sauce. Servedwith celery sticks and ranch dressing. Pick yourfavorite sauce: mild Buffalo or BBQ
- Totchos$16.99
Boneless Buffalo chicken wings, tater tots, bacon, crispy tortilla chips, topped with four cheese blend, crispy onion strings, green onions, drizzled with queso, smoked onion ranch and Buffalo sauce
- Loaded Fries$13.99
Golden fries loaded with melted cheese and ground beef
- Lions Platter$14.99
Bed of rice and French fries covered with melted cheese and grilled chicken
- Tamales (4)$14.99
- Esquites$8.99
Four seasonal Indiana corn cobbettes covered in butter, crema sauce, Cotija cheese, lime juice, ancho chili, cilantro and special sauce
- SHRIMP COCKTAIL$16.99
Fresh shrimp cooked with our cocktail sauce with onions, tomatoes, avocado, cilantro and lime
- TAQUITOS MEXICANOS$12.99
Four tightly rolled corn tortillas – two shreddedchicken and two seasoned shredded beef,stuffed and deep-fried. Served with El Paso4 Cheese & Bean Dip and sour cream
- Nacho Bowl$12.99
- Street corn$8.99
- Maguey fries$16.99
- Shrimp loaded fries$15.99
Dips
- Choriqueso Fundido$11.99
Warm original white cheese dip with chorizo
- Maguey dip$7.99
Our original cheese dip with pico de gallo and ground beef
- Choriqueso dip$9.99
- Crab dip$9.99
Crab with special yellow queso and mixed with pico de gallo
- Guacamole large$8.99
Fresh made with avocado, lime mixed with pico de gallo and salt
- Queso dip small$4.99
Maguey’s own original secret recipe
- Salsa. Maguey$1.99+
- Queso dip large$8.99
- Small guacamole$4.99
- Small tomatillo$2.99
- Large tomatillo 16 oz$7.99
- Small pico$1.99
- Bean dip$8.99
Nachos
Salads & Soups
- Salad. Santa Fe$15.99
Seasoned grilled strips of chicken breast or steak atop organic spring mix topped with our black bean corn salsa and crispy tortilla strips. Served with sour cream, guacamole and pico de gallo
- Taco Salad$13.99
A crisp tortilla shell loaded with your choice of seasoned ground beef or shredded chicken, smothered with cheese sauce, organic spring mix, tomatoes, shredded cheese and sour cream
- Salad. Fajita Taco$13.99
Crisp flour tortilla shell filled with your choice of steak or chicken cooked with bell peppers, tomatoes and onions, topped with cheese, organic spring mix, more tomatoes and sour cream
- Soup. Chicken Tortilla$9.99
A zesty soup with chicken breast, tomatoes, onion, garlic, carrots, cheese, Mexican spices, tortilla chips topped with sour cream and fresh avocado slices
- WEST COAST SALAD$10.99
Arugula,organic spring mix with cucumber, bacon, pico de gallo, parmesan cheese, avocado, black beans, roasted corn and avocado balsamic vinaigrette
- WEDGE SALAD$10.99
- CEASAR SALAD$10.99
- Shrimp Soup$14.00
El Maguey's Favorites
- ARROZ CON CAMARON$16.99
A bed of rice with 12 grilled shrimp smothered in queso
- Arroz Con Pollo (ACP)$14.99
Sauteed sliced chicken breast prepared with onions, bell peppers, tomatoes, served on a bed of rice and smothered with melted cheese sauce. Served with flour tortillas
- CARNITAS$17.99
Tender pork roast flash fried and served with pico de gallo, guacamole, lettuce, charro beans, Mexican rice and choice of warm corn or flour tortillas
- CHILE COLORADO$15.99
Grilled beef tips covered red sauce. Served with rice and a sope filled with black beans, lettuce, pico de gallo and sour cream
- CHILI VERDE$15.99
Tender carnitas simmered in green tomatillo sauce, onions, Mexican spices and cilantro. Served with rice and a sope filled with black beans, lettuce, pico de gallo and sour cream
- POLLO CON CHORIZO$17.99
Chicken breast topped with chorizo and cheese sauce. Served with charro beans, rice, warm tortillas, sour cream, lettuce and pico de gallo
- MAGUEY ARROZ$18.99
A combination of rice, shrimp, steak, chicken, bell peppers, onions and tomatoes all topped with queso dip
- POLLO ALA CREMA$16.99
Strips of chicken breast stuffed with onions, mushrooms and Mexican spices simmered in our sour cream sauce. Served with refried beans, rice, lettuce, sour cream and pico de gallo
- POLLO AZTECA$16.99
Grilled marinated chicken breast dressed with mushrooms and cheese sauce. Served over a bed of rice with black beans topped with lettuce, pico de gallo and sour cream in a skillet
- POLLO CHIPOTLE$14.99
Chicken dry rubbed with chipotle and a little honey for a sweet, smokey and spicy taste topped with cabbage and fresh orange bits and our famous taco orange sauce. Served with black beans and rice
- POLLO HAWAIANA$14.99
Grilled chicken breast topped with grilled pineapple. Served with rice, black beans, lettuce, sour cream and pico de gallo. Aloha!
- POLLO SOBROSO$16.99
Marinated grilled chicken breast with sauteed fajita style vegetables, tomato, squash, zucchini and mushrooms and with cheese dip. Served with Mexican rice, lettuce, pico de gallo and sour cream and black beans
- TIOS MEXICAN COMBO$16.99
THIS IS TIO’S ALL-TIME FAVORITE! Chicken burrito, enchilada and chimichanga with chili con queso topped with lettuce, sour cream and pico de gallo. Served with rice and black beans
- ARROZ CON CAMARON Y POLLO$17.99
- BROCCLI ALFREDO$17.99
- MAGUEY FRIES$16.99
ARROZ CON CAMARON
A bed of rice with 12 grilled shrimp smothered in queso
STREET TACOS
- CILANTRO LIME STEAK STREET TACOS (3)$15.99
Grilled steak, peppers, onion, glazed in lime juice, jalapeño, sour cream and cilantro with lime wedges dredged in chile lime salt
- STEAK & SHRIMP STREET TACOS (3)$16.99
Steak and shrimp glazed in lime juice, jalapeño with lime mayo, and pico de gallo
- MAHI MAHI STREET TACOS (3)$16.99
Grilled or Dos Equis battered crispy mahi mahi with lime mayo, guajillo slaw and jalapeño
- CHIPTOLE ORANGE CHICKEN STREET TACOS (3)$14.99
Grilled chicken dry rubbed with chipotle and a little honey for a sweet, smokey and spicy taste topped with cabbage, jalapeño, fresh orange bits and our famous taco orange sauce
- CARNITAS STREET TACOS (3)$15.99
- CHORI POLLO STREET TACOS (3)$15.99
Grilled chicken topped with chorizo with caramelized onions, avocado, jalapeño, lime mayo and cilantro 11.99
- BUFFALO SHRIMP TACOS (3)$16.99
- SUPREME STREET TACO (3)$11.99
- CLASSIC STREET TACOS (3)$10.99
- PASTOR STREET TACOS (3)$14.99
- ASADA (STEAK) STREET TACOS (3)$15.99
- GRILLED CHICKEN STREET TACOS (3)$14.99
Fajitas
Burrito y enchiladas
- Monster burrito$12.99
A large flour tortilla with your choice of ground beef or shredded chicken topped with red sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, shredded cheese, sour cream, rice and refried beans
- Burrito dos bandidos$15.99
Two burritos! One stuffed with steak, peppers and onions smothered in a green tomatillo sauce and the other filled with grilled chicken simmered in Chile Colorado sauce. Served with rice, black beans, lettuce and pico de gallo
- Burrito Lone Star$15.99
A 12
- Burrito Fajita$15.99
A big burrito stuffed with grilled chicken or steak with onions, tomatoes, bell peppers and beans smothered with cheese, red and green sauce. Served with rice,lettuce, pico de gallo and charro beans
- Burrito California$14.99
Grilled chicken, rice, black beans, avocado and pico de gallo wrapped in a flour tortilla topped with tomatillo salsa garnished with fresh grilled jalapeño. Served with lettuce, guacamole and pico de gallo, rice and beans
- Burrito Chile Colorado$15.99
Our original Chili Colorado recipe inside a flour tortilla covered with salsa ranchera. Served with rice and beans
- Burrito Wet$14.99
A flour tortilla filled with a rice, beans and taco seasoned beef. Topped with enchilada sauce, frijoles de chorizo and chile con queso. Served with pico de gallo and sliced jalapeños
- Maguey Burrito$12.99
- Burrito al Carbon$16.99
A big tortilla with steak, chicken, shrimp, chorizo and onions, peppers and tomatoes. Topped with salsa verde, red salsa and cheese sauce
- Burrito Del Mar$17.99
Crab meat, shrimp, onions, tomatoes, bell peppers and cheese inside a flour tortilla glazed with cheese sauce. Served with Mexican rice, lettuce, guacamole and pico del gallo
- FRIED BURRITO DELUXE$13.99
12” chicken burrito with lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream, guacamole, red sauce and cheese dip. Served with charro beans
- Enchi. Suizas$14.99
Three enchiladas filled with your choice steak or grilled chicken topped with cheese sauce and green sauce. Served with lettuce, sour cream, pico de gallo and Mexican rice
- Enchi. Camaron y Scallop$16.99
Three authentic corn enchiladas filled with fresh shrimp and scallops sauteed with tomatoes, onions and peppers. Topped with salsa verde, cheese dip and sour cream. Served with rice, lettuce, pico de gallo, sour cream and black beans
- Enchi. Tipicas$14.99
Your choice of two cheese or beef or chicken enchiladas topped with ranchera sauce and melted cheese. Served with refried beans, Mexican rice, lettuce, pico de gallo and sour cream
- Enchi. Suprema$13.99
Four rolled corn tortillas, one beef, one chicken, one cheese and one bean. Topped with enchilada sauce, lettuce, cheese, tomatoes and sour cream. Service with Mexican rice
- Enchi. Crema$13.99
Two chicken glazed with a creamy sour cream sauce and topped with melted cheese. Served with refried beans, Mexican rice, lettuce, pico de gallo and sour cream
- Enchi. Maguey$13.99
Three tender flash fried pork and cheese enchiladas covered in red, white and green sauce. Served with rice, pico de gallo, sour cream and charro beans
- TRIO DE MEXICANAS ENCHILADAS$12.99
One beef with roja sauce, one chicken with queso sauce and one carnitas with verde sauce enchilada. Served with lettuce, pico de gallo, sour cream and rice
- Speedy Gonzalez$10.99
- Burrito Roqueta$15.49
Chimi
Seaside
- Molca. Maguey$26.99
Bursting hot lava rock filled with: grilled steak, chicken, shrimp, chorizo, ranchera salsa, cactus, onion, panela with rice and beans
- Molca. Seaside$26.99
This flavor profile will take you back to your favorite beach. A combination of mahi mahi and shrimp with pineapple and red bell pepper and a squeeze of orange juice. Served with lime wedges dredged in lime chili salt and beans and rice and our famous orange taco sauce on the side
- Molca. Surf & Turf Spicy$27.99
A wonderful tasting combination of steak, chicken, mahi mahi and shrimp in a spicy sauce with tomatoes, onion and Mexican spices and peppers topped with cilantro. Served with lime wedges dredged in lime chili salt and beans and rice
- Shrimp Fuego$20.99
Grilled shrimp, red peppers and jalapeño peppers sauteed with a spicy sauce and then sriracha is added for the final glaze to fire it up even more. Served with rice, small guacamole salad and warm tortillas
- Chimi del mar$16.99
Two flour tortillas stuffed with shrimp and crab meat topped with cheese sauce. Served with lettuce, pico de gallo, guacamole, sour cream, rice and your choice of refried or charro beans
- Mahi Mahi Grilled$23.99
Grilled salmon dry rubbed with chipotle and a little honey for a sweet, smokey and spicy taste topped with cabbage, Fresh orange and lime mayo with cabbage and fresh orange garnish. Served with black beans and rice with our famous orange taco sauce on the side
- Chipotle Shrimp$20.99
Tender shrimp sautéed with tomatoes simmered in our very special chipotle mango sauce. Served with sour cream, pico de gallo, rice and black beans
- Camarones al mojo de ajo$20.99
FROM THE GRILL
- CARNE ASADA$21.99
Cooked to your preferred temperature our marinated ribeye steak is a traditional Mexican steak meal. The steak is grilled with sliced onions. Served with refried beans, Mexican rice, guacamole salad and warm tortillas
- STEAK & SHRIMP$25.99
- RIB PLATTER$15.99+
Roll up your sleeves and get ready to enjoy! Our ribs are dry rubbed and then grilled with our BBQ and then glazed in our famous orange taco sauce. Served with your choice of two sides
- RIBS & SHRIMP$22.99
Our half rack dry rubbed rack combined with grilled, fried or coconut shrimp. Served with your choice of two sides
- RIBS & RIBEYE$24.99
Our half rack dry rubbed rack combined with our carne asada. Served with your choice of two sides
Quesadillas
- Ques. Fajita$15.99
flour tortilla stuffed with grilled steak or chicken cooked with onions, bell peppers and cheese on a layer of crisp lettuce. Served with sour cream, pico de gallo and rice
- Quesadilla Maguey$15.99
Filled quesadilla with flash fried carnitas. Served with lettuce, pico de gallo, sour cream and charro beans
- Ques. Indy$14.99
Two flour tortillas stuffed with chicken and cheese. Served with lettuce, sour cream and pico de gallo
- Ques. Crab & Shrimp$16.99
A flour tortilla stuffed with marinated shrimp, and crab, cheese melt with tropical fruit and red pepper garnish with a drizzle of honey, Served with rice and pico de gallo
- Ques. Hawaiian$15.99
A flour tortilla stuffed with chicken, pineapple and mushrooms. Served with pico de gallo, lettuce and sour cream
- PATRON QUESADILLA$13.99
Vegetarian
- Enchi. Veggie$12.99
- CALIFORNIA VEGGIE BURRITO$11.99
Rice, black beans, avocado and pico de gallo wrapped in a flour tortilla topped with tomatillo salsa garnished with fresh grilled jalapeño. Served with lettuce, guacamole and pico de gallo and rice & black beans
- GARDEN VEGTABLE FAJITAS$13.99+
A sizzling mix of veggies including onions, tomatoes and bell peppers. Served with rice refried beans, lettuce, guacamole, pico de gallo, sour cream and or choice of flour or corn tortillas
- VEGGIE BURRITO$12.99
- GARDEN QUESADILLA$10.29
Kids
EXTRA SAUCES&MEATS
- SALAD DRESSING$1.50
- SMALL TOMATILLO SALSA$3.99
- VERDE SALSA$3.99
- RANCHERO SALSA$3.99
- SIDE OF GRILLED CHICKEN$6.99
- SIDE OF STEAK$7.99
- SIDE OF SHRIMP$8.99
- SIDE OF CARNITAS$5.99
- SIDE OF PASTOR$5.99
- SIDE OF CRAB$4.99
- SIDE OF CHORIZO$3.99
- SIDE OF SHREEDED CHICKEN$3.99
- SIDE OF GROUND BEEF$3.99
- SIDE OF MAHI MAHI$8.99
- SIDE OF SCALLOPS$6.99
- SIDE OF NOPAL$4.99
- SIDE OF AVOCADO SLICES$3.99
LUNCH SPECIALS
Ala carte
- CLASSIC TACO (1)$3.25
- TACO SUPREME (1)$3.99
- STEAK TACO (1)$4.99
- SHRIMP TACO (1)$5.25
- ENCHILADA (1)$3.99
- CHILE RELLENO (1)$4.99
- TAMAL (1)$3.99
- BURRITO (1)$5.25
- QUESADILLA grill$6.99
- CALIFORNIA VEGGIES$3.99
- SOUR CREAM$1.99
- TORTILLAS$1.25
- Order bacon$3.99
- SIDE OF LETTUCE$1.99
- SIDE OF TOMATO$1.25
- SIDE OF ONIONS$1.25
- GILL BELL PEPPERS$3.25
- ORDER FAJ VEGGIES$3.25
- GUAC SALAD$5.99
- FAJ Plate salad$7.99
- RICE WITH CHEESE$6.99
- GRILLED CHICKEN TACO (1)$4.99
- SIDE OF CILANTRO$0.99
- RICE & BEAN COMBO$5.99
- Cheese Quesadilla$4.99
- Chips Togo$1.99
- Sweet potato fries$4.99
- Side grill shrimp (6)$6.99
- FRENCH FRIES$4.99
- Grill chicken$6.99
- Grill steak$7.99
- A LA carte chimi$5.99
- ALC chimi grill chicken$6.99
- ALC chimi gill steak$6.99
- Order rice$4.99
- Order fried beans$4.99
- Order Chiles toriados$4.99
- Grill jalapeños$4.99
- Pickled jalapeños$1.99
- Fresh jalapeño$1.99
- Grill onions$3.25
- Grill pineapple$3.25
- Order mushrooms$3.25
- Order black beans$4.99
- Order charro beans$4.99
- Order grill chicken and steak$9.99
- Slice avocado$3.35
- Cheese beans$5.99
- mash potato$4.99
- Quesa shredded chicken$5.99
- Shrimp quesadilla ala carte$8.99
- Tater tots$4.99
- Side shredded cheese$2.25
- Order of Shredded chicken$5.99
- Salsa verde$1.25
- Cheese fries$7.49
Sunday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Monday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Tuesday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Wednesday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Thursday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Friday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Saturday | 11:00 am - 11:00 pm |
Come in and enjoy the finest and freshest Southwestern, Tex-Mex and Mexican dishes! We are family owned and operated. Our goal is to be not only your go to place for a great meal but a great experience as well! Muchas Gracias!
![El Maguey - Salem image](https://toast-local-nyc3-production.nyc3.cdn.digitaloceanspaces.com/restaurants/69ceb1ba-f149-41bd-ac04-dfd1b58a2b17/el-maguey--salem-consumer-146020-293.webp)
![El Maguey - Salem image](https://toast-local-nyc3-production.nyc3.cdn.digitaloceanspaces.com/restaurants/69ceb1ba-f149-41bd-ac04-dfd1b58a2b17/el-maguey--salem-banner-146019-235.webp)
![El Maguey - Salem image](https://toast-local-nyc3-production.nyc3.cdn.digitaloceanspaces.com/restaurants/69ceb1ba-f149-41bd-ac04-dfd1b58a2b17/el-maguey--salem-main-146018-1452.webp)