- Home
- /
- Shrewsbury
- /
- Sandwiches
- /
- Bagelmasters
Bagelmasters
946 Reviews
$
661 Broad St
Shrewsbury, NJ 07702
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
BAGELS
- One Bagel$1.20
- 6 Bagels$7.20
- Dozen Bagels$14.40
LIMIT OF 2 DOZEN FOR ONLINE ORDERING
- Bagel w/ Cream Cheese$2.95
- Bagel w/ Butter$2.35
- Bagel w/ Specialty Spread$3.95
Choose from a variety of our homemade spreads
- Bagel w/ Lox Spread$4.20
- Bagel w/ Lowfat Cream Cheese$3.20Out of stock
- Bagel with Cream Cheese and Butter$2.95
- Bagel w/ Vegan Plain Cream Cheese$5.30
An almond base is what makes this spread so good
- Bagel w/ Vegan Vegetable Cream Cheese$7.00
- Bagel w/ Peanut Butter$2.65
- Bagel w/ Peanut Butter & Jelly$2.85
- Bagel w/ Cream Cheese & Jelly$3.10
- Bagel w/ Peanut Butter & Butter$2.65
- Bagel w/Butter & Jelly$2.40
- Bagel w/Jelly$1.95
- Bagel w/ Cheese$2.40
MINI BAGELS
Mini Bagel
- One Mini Bagel$0.80
- 6 Mini Bagels$4.80
- Dozen Mini Bagels$9.60
- Mini Bagel With Cream Cheese$1.75
- Mini Bagel w/ Butter$1.30
- Mini Bagel w/ Lowfat Cream Cheese$1.80
- Mini Bagel w/ Cream Cheese & Jelly$1.90
- Mini Bagel w/ Peanut Butter$1.35
- Mini Bagel w/ Lox Spread$2.95
- Mini Bagel w/ Peanut Butter & Jelly$1.45
- Mini Bagel w/ Specialty Spread$2.75
- Mini Bagel w/ Vegan Plain Cream Cheese$2.25
- Mini Bagel w/ Vegan Vegetable Cream Cheese$3.15
- Mini Bagel w/ Butter & Jelly$1.15
- Mini Bagel w/ Cheese$2.10
- Mini Bagel w/ Cream Cheese and Butter$1.15
- Mini W/PB & But$1.35
- Mini Bagel w/ Jelly$1.55
BREAKFAST
Breakfast
- Nova Lox & Cream Cheese Sandwich$10.25
- Avocado Toast$3.75
- Bacon Egg & Cheese$6.55
- Bacon & Egg Sandwich$5.60
- Bacon & Cheese Sandwich$5.00
- Bacon Sandwich$4.35
- Pork Roll Egg & Cheese$6.55
- Pork Roll & Egg Sandwich$5.60
- Pork Roll & Cheese Sandwich$5.00
- Pork Roll Sandwich$4.35
- Sausage Egg & Cheese$6.55
- Sausage & Egg Sandwich$5.60
- Sausage & Cheese Sandwich$5.00
- Sausage Sandwich$4.35
- Egg Sandwich$3.55
- Egg & Cheese Sandwich$4.50
- Turkey Bacon Egg & Cheese Sandwich$7.30
- Turkey Bacon & Egg Sandwich$6.35
- Turkey Bacon & Cheese Sandwich$5.75
- Turkey Bacon Sandwich$5.10
- Ham Egg & Cheese$8.90
- Ham & Egg Sandwich$6.95
- Hot Deli Ham/Cheese$6.75
- Roast Beef Egg & Cheese$9.45
- BLT Sandwich$6.05
- Turkey Egg & Cheese$9.55
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich$5.20
- Avocado Sandwich$5.00
- Turkey & Egg Sandwich$7.60
- Hot Turkey/Cheese$7.40
Breakfast Wraps
- Power Wrap$9.20
Turkey, Three Egg Whites and American Cheese
- Featherweight Wrap$6.75
Three Egg Whites, with Red & Green Peppers, Tomatoes, Onions and American Cheese
- Western Wrap$10.05
Ham, Three Eggs Scrambled, Red & Green Peppers and Onions
- Patron Wrap$7.15
Three Egg Whites, Fresh Spinach and Vermont Cheddar Cheese
- RPM Wrap$8.35
Three Eggs, Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Spinach and Mozzarella
Mini Bagel Breakfast
- Mini Bagel Turkey & Egg$6.90
- Mini Bagel Hot Turkey & Cheese$6.70
- Mini Bagel Turkey, Egg & Cheese$8.85
- Mini Bagel w/ Nova Lox$5.25
- Mini Bagel Turkey Bacon Egg & Cheese Sandwich$6.60
- Mini Bagel Turkey Bacon & Egg Sandwich$5.65
- Mini Bagel Pork Roll Egg & Cheese$5.85
- Mini Bagel Sausage Egg & Cheese Sandwich$5.85
- Mini Bagel Bacon Egg & Cheese Sandwich$5.85
- Mini Bagel Egg & Cheese$3.30
- Mini Bagel Pork Roll & Egg Sandwich$4.90
- Mini Bagel Egg Sandwich$2.35
- Mini Bagel Sausage & Egg Sandwich$4.90
- Mini Bagel Sausage Sandwich$3.25
- Mini Bagel Nova Lox & Cream Cheese Sandwich$6.25
- Mini Bagel Bacon & Egg Sandwich$4.90
- Mini Bagel Pork Roll & Cheese Sandwich$3.35
SIDES
DRINKS
Cold Beverages
Joe's Iced Tea
Jarritos Soda
Snapple
Gatorade & Energy Drinks
Hot Beverages
SANDWICHES & WRAPS
Sandwiches
- The #3$10.75
Ham, Turkey, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Oil & Vinegar
- Farmhouse Club$10.50
Chicken Salad, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Cranberry Sauce
- Roast Beef Club$10.90
Deluxe Roast Beef, Lettuce, Tomato and Bacon
- Ham Club$9.90
Boiled Ham, Lettuce, Tomato and Bacon
- Corned Beef Reuben$11.70
Corned Beef, Swiss Cheese and Sauerkraut
- Triple Decker$10.35
Turkey, Corned Beef and Pastrami, with Cole Slaw and Russian
- Masters Melt$8.65
Solid White Tuna, Muenster Cheese and Tomato
- Pastrami Reuben$11.70
Pastrami, Swiss Cheese and Sauerkraut
- Pizza Bagel w/ Mozzarella$5.55
- Pizza Bagel w/ Mozzarella & Pepperoni$6.85
- Turkey Club$9.90
Oven Gold Turkey, Lettuce, Tomato and Bacon
- Turkey Melt$9.10
Oven Gold Turkey, Roasted Red Peppers and Swiss Cheese
- Masters Grill$10.00
Smoked Turkey, Muenster Cheese, Bacon and Russian Dressing
- Honey Combo$9.90
Honey Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Honey Mustard Dressing
- Cheesesteak$11.50
Deluxe Roast Beef, American Cheese, Red & Green Peppers
- Sloppy Joe$10.25
- Masters Choice$10.00
Cracked Peppermill Turkey, Havarti with Jalapeno Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato & Russian Dressing
Wraps
- The Brooklyn Wrap$9.00
Mozzarella, Tomato, Spinach, Olive Oil & Pesto
- Pollo Loco Wrap$11.30
Grilled Chicken, Onions, Peppers, Jalapenos, Avocado, Havarti, Chipotle Sauce
- All-American Wrap$9.55
Grilled Chicken Breast with Lettuce, Tomato and Crispy Bacon
- Caesar Wrap$9.55
Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Grated Parmesan Cheese and Caesar Dressing
- Veggie Wrap$6.25
Shredded Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, Red Peppers, Green Peppers, Cucmbers & Jalapenos with Ranch Dressing
- Wild Western Wrap$9.15
Buffalo Chicken Breast, Havarti w/Jalapeno Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Smothered with Blue Cheese Dressing
- Ultimate Wrap$9.75
Grilled Chicken Topped with Tomato, Melted Mozzarella and Balsamic Vinegar
- Delight Wrap$10.25
Roast Beef, Lettuce, Tomato and Vermont Cheddar Cheese covered with Russian Dressing
- Pollo Chipotle Wrap$9.95
Grilled Chicken with Avocado Topped with Homemade Cream Chipotle and Melted Mozzarella
- Yankee Wrap$10.15
Grilled Chicken, Roasted Red Peppers, Sundried Tomatoes, Melted Mozzarella and Balsamic Vinegar
BUILD IT
- Roasted Turkey Sandwich$8.90
- Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich$8.90
- Peppermill Turkey Sandwich$8.90
- Smoked Turkey Sandwich$8.90
- Roast Beef Sandwich$9.95
- Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich$8.75
- Boiled Ham Sandwich$8.25
- Genoa Salami Sandwich$7.75
- Bologna Sandwich$5.95
- Corned Beef Sandwich$11.00
- Pastrami Sandwich$11.00
- Egg Salad Sandwich$6.45
- Tuna Salad Sandwich$6.75
- Chicken Salad Sandwich$7.95
- Whitefish Salad Sandwich$8.75
- Buffalo Chicken Breast$8.45
Submarine Sandwiches
Mini Bagel BYO Sandwich
- Mini Bagel Roasted Turkey Sandwich$4.85
- Mini Bagel Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich$4.85
- Mini Bagel Peppermill Turkey Sandwich$4.85
- Mini Bagel Smoked Turkey Sandwich$4.85
- Mini Bagel Roast Beef Sandwich$5.50
- Mini Bagel Boiled Ham Sandwich$4.45
- Mini Bagel Egg Salad Sandwich$4.10
- Mini Bagel Tuna Salad Sandwich$4.35
- Mini Bagel Chicken Salad Sandwich$4.55
- Mini Bagel Whitefish Salad Sandwich$4.60
SPREADS
- 1/2 lb. Plain Cream Cheese$3.05
- 1/2 lb Salted Whipped Butter$4.05
- 1/2 lb. Scallion Cream Cheese$4.95
- 1/2 lb. Vegetable Cream Cheese$4.95
- 1/2 lb. Strawberry Cream Cheese$4.95
- 1/2 lb. Blueberry Cream Cheese$4.95
- 1/2 lb. Lox Spread Cream Cheese$5.10
- 1/2 lb. Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese$4.95
- 1/2 lb. Olive & Pimento Cream Cheese$4.95
- 1/2 lb. Apple Cinnamon Cream Cheese$4.95
- 1/2 lb. Sundried Tomato Cream Cheese$4.95
- 1/2 lb. Jalapeno Cheddar Cream Cheese$4.95
- 1/2 lb. Bacon Cheddar Cream Cheese$4.95
- 1/2 lb. Lowfat Plain Cream Cheese$3.25Out of stock
- 1/2 lb. Lowfat Scallion Cream Cheese$5.10Out of stock
- 1/2 lb. LowFat Vegetable Cream Cheese$5.10Out of stock
- 1/2 lb. Vegan Plain Cream Cheese$11.75
- 1/2 lb. Vegan Vegetable Cream Cheese$13.50Out of stock
- 1\2 LB Strawberry Jelly$3.75
BOARS HEAD BY THE 1/4 POUND
Meats
- Nova Lox (1/4 lb)$8.38
- Boiled Ham (1/4 lb)$2.49
- Roast Beef (1/4 lb)$3.98
- Corned Beef (1/4 lb)$5.00
- Roasted Turkey (1/4 lb)$3.05
- Cracked Peppermill Turkey (1/4 lb)$3.05
- Smoked Turkey (1/4 lb)$3.05
- Honey Maple Turkey (1/4 lb)$3.05
- Bologna (1/4 lb)$1.62
- Pastrami (1/4 lb)$5.00
- Trenton Pork Roll (1/4 lb)$2.15
- Genoa Salami (1/4 lb)$2.64
- Buffalo Chicken Breast (1/4 lb)$2.35
Salads
Cheese
RETAIL
Merchandise
- Unisex Vintage Grey Tee$23.00
- Unisex Vintage Navy Tee$23.00
- Unisex Vintage Black "Hole Foods" Tee$25.00
- Women's Flowy Crew$25.00
- Women's Pink & White$25.00
- Long Sleeve Crew Tie-Dye Tee$32.00
- North Face Lightweight Fleece Black$80.00
Bagelmasters Branded 3/4 Zip Lightweight North Face Fleece
- North Face Lightweight Fleece Grey$80.00
Bagelmasters Branded 3/4 Zip Lightweight North Face Fleece
- Black Vintage Hoodie$38.00
- Kid's Vintage Grey$18.00
- Toddler T-Shirt$21.00
- White/Black Trucker Hat$23.50
- Navy Canvas Snapback Hat$23.50
- Black Canvas Tote$10.00
- Natural Canvas Tote$10.00
- Unlimited Coffee Mug$125.00
Purchase our Baglemasters tumbler and receive free coffee through 2023
- Koozie$2.00
BY THE POUND
Meats
- Oven Roasted Turkey (lb)$12.45
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Cracked Peppermill Turkey (lb)$12.45
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Smoked Turkey (lb)$12.45
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Honey Maple Turkey (lb)$12.45
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Boiled Ham (lb)$9.95
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Roast Beef (lb)$15.95
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Corned Beef (lb)$19.95
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Bologna (lb)$6.50
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Pastrami (lb)$19.95
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Trenton Pork Roll (lb)$8.45
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Genoa Salami (lb)$10.55
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Buffalo Chicken Breast (lb)$9.95
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
Salads
- Chicken Salad (lb)$9.95
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Tuna Salad (lb)$9.85
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- White Fish Salad (lb)$14.99
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Egg Salad (lb)$9.65
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Cole Slaw (lb)$4.15
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Macaroni Salad (lb)$4.15
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
- Potato Salad (lb)$4.15
SORRY ONLY SOLD IN 1LB INCREMENTS ONLINE
Sunday | 5:45 am - 12:00 pm, 12:01 pm - 1:15 pm |
Monday | 5:45 am - 12:00 pm, 12:01 pm - 2:45 pm |
Tuesday | 5:45 am - 12:00 pm, 12:01 pm - 2:45 pm |
Wednesday | 5:45 am - 12:00 pm, 12:01 pm - 2:45 pm |
Thursday | 5:45 am - 12:00 pm, 12:01 pm - 2:45 pm |
Friday | 5:45 am - 12:00 pm, 12:01 pm - 2:45 pm |
Saturday | 5:45 am - 12:00 pm, 12:01 pm - 1:15 pm |
YOU KNEAD IT
661 Broad St, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702