Pennie's Bake Shop & Espresso Bar
670 Reviews
$
800 W New Castle Street
Butler, PA 16001
Orders through Toast are commission free and go directly to this restaurant
Featured Items
- Featured Cupcakes$15.00+
We offer six options daily in our showcase. Our three best sellers include the Wedding White, Salted Caramel and Chocolate Peanut Butter. We also offer 3 additional flavors that we rotate twice a month.
- 4" Round Cake$13.00
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer custom size, batter, filling, icing. and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
Breakfast
- Pizza Rolls$35.00
Breakfast, Lunch or Dinner our pizza rolls are enjoyable anytime of the day. Our pizza dough is topped with Grande cheese and savory meat or veggies. We roll them like a cinnamon roll for a light and fluffy dough texture.
- Cinnamon & Pecan Rolls$16.00+
Oh, cinnamon rolls from Pennie’s, how do we love thee? Let us count the ways: you’re light and fluffy, yet big and filling. Your buttercream frosting is laid on with a generous, loving hand, and you are equally good warmed up as at room temperature. You are delicious.
- Muffins & Scones$16.00+
Baked fresh every morning, we offer a variety of flavors perfect for your morning meeting or breakfast at home.
- Quiche - 8" Round$22.00
A pastry crust filled with our savory egg mixture, cheese, and hint of garlic. Fillings are listed below.
- Banana Bread Loaf$19.00
A classic favorite with a super moist texture and a buttery banana brown sugar flavor. Choose from our classic loaf or add walnuts, chocolate chips or coconut. A perfect blend of deliciousness.
- Sour Cream Crumb Coffee Cake$37.00+
A moist and buttery sour cream cake layered with crumb topping and drizzled with sweet glaze. Perfect for breakfast or brunch with a hot cup of coffee!
- Toasted Almond Coffee Cake$37.00+
A moist and buttery cake layered with cinnamon sugar toasted almonds topped with raspberry jam, strawberry jam, or sweet glaze. Perfect for breakfast or brunch with a hot cup of joe!
Cakes
- Featured Cakes$25.00+
Our two best sellers: The Wedding White features our wedding white cake with a raspberry filling and vanilla buttercream frosting. Our Black and White has a layer of chocolate cake and a layer of white cake filled with our fudge buttercream and vanilla buttercream frosting.
- 4" Round Cake$13.00
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer custom size, batter, filling, icing. and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- 6" Round Cake$25.00+
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer custom size, batter, filling, icing. and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- 8" Round Cake$36.00+
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer custom size, batter, filling, icing. and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- 10" Round Cake$63.00+
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer custom size, batter, filling, icing. and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- 1/4 Sheet Cake - 1 Layer$35.00
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer custom size, batter, icing. and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- 1/4 Sheet Cake - 2 Layer$62.00
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer custom size, batter, icing. and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- 1/2 Sheet Cake - 1 Layer$57.00
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer custom size, batter, icing. and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- 1/2 Sheet Cake - 2 Layer$104.00
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer custom size, batter, icing. and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- Angel Food Cake$22.00+
A beautiful golden brown crust with a light and airy texture. This cake is a true delight! Enjoy it with our fluffy whipped cream topping and fresh fruit when in season.
- Boston Cream Cake$15.00+
Layers of yellow cake filled with our vanilla custard and topped with a poured chocolate glaze.
- Carrot Cake$15.00+
An old-fashioned favorite made with fresh carrots and toasted pecans, filled and frosted with cream cheese buttercream and accented with chopped pecans.
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Torte$15.00+
Our chocolate peanut butter torte has our moist chocolate cake layered with a rich peanut butter cream filling, then topped with fudge buttercream icing. Accented with a chocolate glaze drip and a mini Reese's cup.
- Coconut Cream Pie Cake$15.00+
Our coconut cream pie cake features our wedding white cake with a coconut custard filling, vanilla buttercream frosting and covered in toasted coconut.
- Lemon Drop Torte$15.00+
Our lemon drop torte features layers of moist lemon cake, lemon curd filling, and cream cheese frosting. Accented with white chocolate curls and white chocolate drizzle on top.
- Maraschino Cherry Torte$15.00+
Maraschino cherry studded vanilla cake, with an almond buttercream filling and maraschino cherry almond buttercream frosting.
- Oreo Torte$15.00+
Our moist rich chocolate cake, layered and iced with an Oreo buttercream. Topped with a chocolate glaze and Oreo cookies.
- Plain Jane$15.00+
Our Plain Jane takes us back to our childhood home in Connoquenessing, where Pennie often made this cake for our family. Wedding white cake, filled and iced with vanilla buttercream. Finished with a white chocolate drip and edged in white chocolate curls.
- Red Velvet$15.00+
Red velvet cake is the sweet marriage of buttermilk and vanilla with a little cocoa for good measure. Finished with a cream cheese buttercream filling and frosting. Accented with red velvet crumbs.
- Toasted Almond Torte$15.00+
Our best selling specialty cake features layers of yellow cake, vanilla custard filling, almond buttercream frosting, and covered with toasted almonds.
- Triple Chocolate$15.00+
Layers of chocolate cake, filled with chocolate custard, chocolate buttercream frosting, accented with a poured chocolate glaze and chocolate curls.
- Unicorn Cake$34.00+
Our unicorn cakes are a fun and popular options for any occasion. Choose your cake batter, filling, and frosting and our decorators will do the rest.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake$32.00+
Our cookie cake are thick, chewy, and beyond amazing. Decorated with your choice of vanilla or fudge buttercream.
- Brownie Cake$13.00+
Choose our rich and thick brownie cake for your next occasion. Our brownie cakes are rich and dense with a moist intensely chocolatey interior. Topped with your choice of buttercream frosting.
Brownie Cake
Choose our rich and thick brownie cake for your next occasion. Our brownie cakes are rich and dense with a moist intensely chocolatey interior. Topped with your choice of buttercream frosting.
Cupcakes
- Featured Cupcakes$15.00+
We offer six options daily in our showcase. Our three best sellers include the Wedding White, Salted Caramel and Chocolate Peanut Butter. We also offer 3 additional flavors that we rotate twice a month.
- Create Your Own Cupcakes - Unfilled$10.00+
Create your own favorite by choosing a cake batter and frosting for these traditional cupcakes.
- Create Your Own Cupcakes - Filled$11.50+
Create your own favorite by choosing a cake batter, filling, and frosting for these filled cupcakes.
- Boston Cream Pie Cupcakes$13.00+
Our Boston cream pie cupcakes feature our yellow cake with vanilla custard filling, vanilla buttercream frosting and a poured chocolate glaze.
- Carrot Cake Cupcakes$13.00+
An old-fashioned favorite made with fresh carrots, pineapple, and toasted pecans. Filled and frosted with our classic cream cheese buttercream and accented with chopped pecans.
- Coconut Cream Pie Cupcakes$13.00+
Our coconut cream pie cupcakes feature our wedding white cake with a coconut custard filling, vanilla buttercream frosting and covered in toasted coconut.
- Oreo Cupcakes$13.00+
Our moist rich chocolate cake with an Oreo buttercream filling and frosting. Accented with an Oreo cookie.
- Maraschino Cherry Cupcakes$13.00+
Maraschino cherry studded vanilla cake, with a maraschino cherry almond buttercream filling and frosting.
- Red Velvet Cupcakes$13.00+
Red velvet cake is the sweet marriage of buttermilk and vanilla with a little cocoa for good measure. Finished with a cream cheese buttercream filling and frosting. Accented with red velvet crumbs.
- S'mores Cupcakes$13.00+
Chocolate cake, marshmallow buttercream filling, vanilla buttercream frosting with graham cracker crumbs, topped with mini marshmallows & chocolate drizzle.
- Toasted Almond Torte Cupcakes$13.00+
Our best selling specialty cupcakes feature our yellow cake with a vanilla custard filling, almond buttercream frosting, and covered with toasted almonds.
- Triple Chocolate Cupcakes$13.00+
Chocolate cake with a chocolate custard filling and fudge buttercream frosting. Accented with chocolate glaze and chocolate curls.
Assorted Cookies
- Chocolate Chip Cookies$10.00+
Perfectly nostalgic and delicious, these cookies are loaded with chocolate chips and feature a crisp edge with a chewy center.
- Glazed Sugar Cookies$10.00+
An ultra-light cookie, ever so crispy around the edges, with a soft and chewy center. Brushed with glaze and accented with seasonal sprinkles. These cookies put all other sugar cookies to shame.
- Snickerdoodle Cookies$10.00+
- Molasses Cookies$10.00+
- Peanut Butter Cookies$10.00+
Specialty Cookies
- Coconut Macaroons$2.50+
The coconut macaroon, with its crispy outer layer and chewy middle is dipped in chocolate and naturally gluten free.
- Oatmeal Cream Pies$4.00+
The oatmeal cream pie is made with super soft and delicate oatmeal cookies. For the filling we blend our vanilla buttercream and Swiss buttercream resulting in pure magic.
- Drop Cookies$2.95+
Our drop cookies are a family tradition that started with Pennie's Grandmother. These cake-like cookies are moist, chewy and will take you back in time.
- Reese's Big Cup Cookies$4.00+
This 4" peanut butter cookie holds the precious Reese's Big Cup candy bar.
- Salted Caramel Pretzel Thumbprints$2.50+
A buttery shortbread pretzel cookie topped high with our salted caramel buttercream icing, caramel drizzle and sea salt!
Brownies & Bars
- Caramelita$20.00+
Gooey, chocolatey, buttery, caramely... Caramelita bars have an oatmeal crust base, then layered with chocolate chips, homemade caramel sauce, and topped with the remaining buttery oat mixture.
- Fudge Brownie$20.00+
Our fudge brownies are rich and dense with a moist intensely chocolatey interior– Topped with your choice of buttercream frosting.
Pies
- Apple Pie$24.00
This exceptional apple pie has a light and flaky crust with a flavorful filling of apples, butter, and cinnamon. Serve an all-American favorite that everyone will enjoy.
- Blueberry Pie$24.00
This Blueberry pie is bursting with fat little blueberries and lemon zest then wrapped in our signature pie crust.
- Cherry Pie$26.00
Tender tart cherries are piled into a bed of hand-rolled pie crust with your choice of a top crust or crumb topping.
- Coconut Cream Pie$26.00
Delicious, fluffy coconut custard cream topped with toasted meringue and toasted coconut.
- Fresh Fruit Tart$6.50+
Always impressive, our fruit tart is loaded with a lush assortment of seasonal berries and fruit. With a sweet pastry crust and smooth pastry cream filling, this fruit tart is simply elegant.
- Fresh Strawberry Pie$5.50+
Our fresh strawberry pie starts with a vanilla custard on top of our flaky pie crust. Piled high with fresh strawberries accented with fresh whipped cream.
- Mixed Berry Pie$25.00
Red raspberry, blueberry and blackberries on our light flaky crust
- Peach Pie$25.00
This Peach Pie brings together ripe peaches, mixed with cinnamon and sugar to create the perfect pie filling, with your choice of a flaky pie crust or crumb topping.
- Pecan Chocolate Chip Pie$30.00
Richly flavored, gooey dessert, intensely sweet with a baseline of vanilla and chocolate chips.
- Red Raspberry Pie$30.00
The beautiful, bright, zippy flavor of our raspberry pie simply can’t be beaten. Combined with whip cream or ice cream this pie is a real treat!
- Pumpkin Pie$21.00
Cheesecakes
- Oreo Cheesecake$20.00+
Our signature cheesecake loaded with Oreo cookie crumbs, on top an Oreo cookie crust. Accented with whipped cream and Oreo cookie crumbs.
- Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake$20.00+
Our signature cheesecake swirled with red raspberries on graham cracker crust
- Salted Caramel Pretzel Cheesecake$20.00+
Everyone’s favorite cookie as a cheesecake! This cheesecake combines the elegance of caramel and cheesecake with our best-selling pretzel thumbprint cookie as a crust. Topped with our salted caramel buttercream, crushed pretzels, caramel drizzle and coarse sea salt.
- Signature Cheesecake$20.00+
Our signature cheesecake combines a refined New York–style recipe with traditional touches like a crumbled graham cracker crust. This classic cheesecake has a silky texture and a rich, sweet flavor. Finished with a poured chocolate glaze and fresh whipped cream.
Gluten Friendly
- Muffins (GF)$26.00+
Our gluten friendly muffins are light and airy and filled with fruit, nuts, or chocolate.
- 4" Round Cake (GF)$17.50
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer our wedding white cake made without gluten. You choose your size, filling, icing, and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- 6" Round Cake (GF)$34.00
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer our wedding white cake made without gluten. You choose your size, filling, icing, and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- 8" Round Cake (GF)$51.00
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer our wedding white cake made without gluten. You choose your size, filling, icing, and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- 10" Round Cake (GF)$89.00
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer our wedding white cake made without gluten. You choose your size, filling, icing, and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- 1/4 Sheet Cake (GF)$52.00
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer our wedding white cake made without gluten. You choose your size, filling, icing, and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- 1/2 Sheet Cake (GF)$88.00
Pick your favorite flavors to create your own cake. We offer our wedding white cake made without gluten. You choose your size, filling, icing, and decoration. Please choose from the menu options.
- Specialty Cakes (GF)$20.50+
- Create Your Own Cupcakes - Unfilled (GF)$12.50+
Create your own favorite by choosing a frosting for these traditional gluten friendly cupcakes.
- Create Your Own Cupcakes - Filled (GF)$15.00+
Create your own favorite by choosing a filling and frosting for these gluten friendly filled cupcakes.
- Specialty Cupcakes (GF)$17.50+
- Assorted Cookies (GF)$13.75+
Mix and match your favorite gluten friendly cookies by the half dozen or dozen.
- Coconut Macaroons$2.50+
The coconut macaroon, with its crispy outer layer and chewy middle is dipped in chocolate and naturally gluten free.
- Fudge Brownie (GF)$4.75+
Our gluten friendly fudge brownies are rich and dense with a moist intensely chocolatey interior– Topped with your choice of buttercream frosting.
- Reese's Big Cup (GF)$4.75+
This 4" gluten friendly peanut butter cookie holds the precious Reese's Big Cup candy bar.
- Signature Cheesecake w/ 3 Nut Crust (GF)$26.00+
Our signature cheesecake combines a refined New York–style recipe with gluten friendly options like our three nut crust. This classic cheesecake has a silky texture and a rich, sweet flavor.
- Chocolate Chip Cheesecake (GF)$26.00+
Our signature cheesecake is studded with chocolate chips and sits on a chocolate chip cookie crust. This cheesecake has a silky texture and a rich, sweet flavor. Topped with whipped cream and cookie chunks.
- Snickerdoodle Cheesecake (GF)$26.00+
We start with our New York-style cheesecake and hand swirl our cinnamon roll filling. This fall favorite rests on a snickerdoodle cookie crust. Topped with whipped cream and chunks of snickerdoodle cookie.
Sunday | Closed |
Monday | 7:00 am - 1:00 pm |
Tuesday | 7:00 am - 1:00 pm |
Wednesday | 7:00 am - 1:00 pm |
Thursday | 7:00 am - 5:00 pm |
Friday | 7:00 am - 5:00 pm |
Saturday | 7:00 am - 1:00 pm |
We are one of Butler County's premiere bakeries. We look forward to seeing you in the shop, or helping you to create the perfect treats for your events! https://penniecake.com/
800 W New Castle Street, Butler, PA 16001