Pies in Buffalo
Buffalo restaurants that serve pies
PIZZA • CHICKEN WINGS
Mister Pizza - Elmwood
1065 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo
Key Lime Pie | $5.25 |
The Ridge West Seneca
555 Orchard Park Road, West Seneca
Peanut Butter Pie | $9.00 |
Pizza Plant Italian Pub
7770 TRANSIT ROAD, Williamsville
Hawaiian Pie Large | $30.89 |
A tropic blend of juicy pineapple, tender ham, mozzarella, & sauce | |
Hawaiian Pie Small | $13.59 |
A tropic blend of juicy pineapple, tender ham, mozzarella, & sauce | |
Hawaiian Pie Medium | $21.89 |
A tropic blend of juicy pineapple, tender ham, mozzarella, & sauce |
PIZZA • SANDWICHES • CHICKEN WINGS • HAMBURGERS • FRENCH FRIES
Wise Guys Pizza - 1965 Seneca Street - Buffalo NY 14210
1965 Seneca St., Buffalo
RUEBAN | $19.99 |
Please refer to Facebook for this weeks specialty pie. |
SANDWICHES • FRENCH FRIES
Elmwood Taco & Subs - 937 Elmwood Ave
937 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo
Becker Farms Apple Pie | $17.00 |
Sold Frozen- Bake at home! Enjoy! |
Hayes Seafood House
8900 Main Street, Williamsville
Key Lime Pie | $7.99 |
Homemade lime custard pie with a graham cracker crust. | |
Kentucky Bourbon Pecan Pie | $10.50 |
PASTA • SEAFOOD • SALADS • HAMBURGERS • FRENCH FRIES
Creekview Restaurant
5629 Main Street, Williamsville
SHEPHERDS PIE | $17.95 |
Seasoned ground beef, peas, carrots, onions, parmesan mashed potatoes, frizzled onions | |
Tollhouse Cookie Pie | $7.00 |
Key Lime Pie | $8.00 |
WRAPS • SOUPS • SALADS • SANDWICHES • FRENCH FRIES
Joe's Deli
1322 Hertel Ave, Buffalo
Lobster Pot Pie | $0.00 |
Creamy Lemon Chicken Rice Leeks | $0.00 |
Macy's Place Pizzeria
3348 Genesee St, Cheektowaga
Large Apple Pie Dessert Pizza | $25.99 |
Apple pie filling, caramel drizzle, sugar glazing, Cinnamon Toast Crunch and Graham Cracker Crumble, brown and cinnamon sugar crust | |
Apple Pie Dessert Skulls - 6 Pack | $20.99 |
6 Pack of Apple Pie Skulls | |
Small Apple Pie Dessert Pizza | $20.99 |
BreadHive Bakery & Cafe
402 Connecticut St, Buffalo
Hand Pie Ⓥ | $3.00 |
This 3" cherry hand pie is a vegan delight! |
Pesci's Pizza & Wings
8065 Main St, Williamsville
Oreo Mousse Pie! | $4.99 |
HAMBURGERS
Swan Street Diner
700 Swan St., Buffalo
(to go) Shepard's Pie | $12.00 |
ground beef, onion, carrot, corn, peas, savory gravy topped with mashed potatoes | |
(to go) Vegan Pot Pie | $12.00 |
curry, onion, carrot, potato, corn, tofu, puff pastry | |
(to go) Chicken Pot Pie | $12.00 |
Chicken, veggie, gravy, puff pastry |
BriteSmith Brewing
5611 Main Street, Williamsville
Irish Cottage Pie | $18.00 |
Pie-O-Mine - Tonawanda
1725 Sheridan Drive, Tonawanda
Pie-O-Cheese Bread | $6.99 |
7" Pita Bread, Garlic Spread, Shredded Mozzarella, Finished with Grated Parmesan Cheese & Oregano. Served with a Side of our House Made Classic Red Sauce | |
** 10" Spicy Meatball Marinara - August Special** | $11.79 |
Classic Red Sauce, Shredded Mozzarella, Ricotta Cheese, Red Onion, Sliced Hot Cherry Peppers, & Meatballs | |
**16" Pie-O-Pickle- June Special** | $21.79 |
Garlic Oil Base with Cheddar/Jack Cheese, Red Onion, Garlic, Bacon, & Pickles. Finished with Grated Parmesan Cheese and a Honey Siracha Drizzle |
Jack Rabbit - 1010 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222
1010 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222, Buffalo
Build a Pie | $15.00 |
house cheese blend, and your choice of fresh toppings. |
PIZZA • PASTA • CALZONES • PITAS • CHICKEN • HAMBURGERS
My Tomato Pie
3055 Niagara Falls Boulevard, Amherst
Kid's Teeny Tomato Pie | $8.50 |
Choice of cheese or cheese and pepperoni personal pizzas with a beverage in a take home kids cup. | |
Snickers Pie - Slice | $6.50 |
Slice of Snickers Pie |
FRENCH FRIES
Mike & Pop's Bistro & Tavern
3020 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, NY 14217, Kenmore
Momma's Chicken Pot Pie | $14.99 |
Your own personal sized puff pastry crust filled with a delicious creamy and chunky filling with chicken, peas, carrots, onion, and potatoes. | |
Shepherds Pie | $17.99 |
Allentown Pizza - 94 Elmwood Avenue
94 Elmwood Avenue, Buffalo
Apple Pie Logs | $7.75 |
BBQ • GRILL • FRENCH FRIES
Fat Bob's Smokehouse
41 Virginia Place, Buffalo
Caramel Apple Banana Pie | $6.00 |
Cranberry Chess Pie | $6.99 |
Brisket Shepherd's Pie | $19.99 |
Texas style smoked brisket and Cajun gravy served under Cajun corn and mashed potatoes topped with melted cheddar and crispy bacon. Served with grilled cornbread |
Mojo Market
3030 Delaware Avenue, Kenmore
Pecan Pie | $5.75 |
pecan pie syrup with toasted pecans, vanilla, and dates with espresso & steamed milk | |
Chicken Pot Pie | $15.00 |
Macy's Place Kenmore - 3100 Delaware Avenue
3100 Delaware Avenue, Kenmore
Small Apple Pie Dessert Pizza | $20.99 |
Large Apple Pie Dessert Pizza | $25.99 |
Apple pie filling, caramel drizzle, sugar glazing, Cinnamon Toast Crunch and Graham Cracker Crumble, brown and cinnamon sugar crust | |
Large Buffalina Square Pie | $21.99 |
Tray of Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza. Extra Pep, Red Sauce on Top, Parmigiana Well Seasoned |